Archaeologists Uncover The Most Controversial 3,000-Year-Old Biblical Site In Israel

Relic Archives
18 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 23, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines the tension between the biblical account of the Israelite conquest of Canaan and modern archaeological findings. While scripture describes a swift military victory, evidence suggests a more gradual process, proposing theories that the Israelites were either peaceful migrants or indigenous Canaanites who evolved into a distinct culture during a regional societal collapse.
Armed with trumpets and ark and faith, the tribes of Israel are said to have swept triumphant into
the promised land. But did they? Sifting through Iron Age ruins for the tumbled walls of scripture,
archaeologists find instead what some might call heresy. I'm John Rhys-Davis,
join me as we search for the elusive tribes of Israel, next on Archaeology.
The story of the Israelites' conquest of the promised land has long been an article of faith
for Jews and Christians alike. The Bible tells us how, led by Joshua, they crossed the Jordan
and tumbled the walls of Jericho with mighty trumpet blasts. In quick succession, the pagan
cities of Canaan fell before their righteous assaults. And all the cities of all the kings
of them did Joshua take and smoke them with the edge of the sword, and he utterly destroyed them
as Moses, the servant of the Lord, commanded. So goes the scriptural account. But today,
a number of archaeologists challenge the historical accuracy of that biblical narrative.
Their findings suggest that the Canaanite cities may have been destroyed decades before the first
Israelite settlements, that they settled peacefully and gradually, and that heresy of heresies,
that the Israelites were themselves Canaanite peasants. Is it possible then that the
Israelite conquest of the promised land simply never happened? When Jesus of Nazareth was spreading
the gospel of the New Testament through the Holy Land, these ruins were already a thousand years old.
This is the kingdom of Hazor, all that remains of a mighty empire that two millennia before the
birth of Christ reigned in the Middle East. To the ancient world, it was known as the land of Canaan.
But to the Hebrews of the Old Testament, it was the promised land. Hazor has lured archaeologist
Amnon ben Tor in search of clues to an age-old question, rather a series of questions.
Who were the Israelites? Where did they come from? Did Joshua lead an army across the Jordan River
to conquer Canaan, as the Bible says? I don't know if there was a Joshua, but I hope to find,
I look to find the period described in Joshua, 11th century, 12th century. Somewhere here,
this is where they are. These bricks here, that's Canaanite. These stones here, this is Israelite,
but of the time of the monarchy. What's missing in here, that's Joshua, or the time of Joshua.
Ben Tor hopes that the answer may be found here, in the great Canaanite palace at Hazor.
This is Canaanite Hazor, the head of all those kingdoms. There is no building like it
anywhere in Hazor, and I don't think in the entire country. It's really big. So, and it lies
all under where we are standing. This is Canaanite, look there. This is Ahab, or the 9th century.
Over there, that's Solomon, 10th century. Over there, 8th century, the period of the kings.
Okay, so Joshua, judges, kings, one on top of the other. The only one that is missing
is in between. Israelites under Joshua, that's what we are looking for.
Up there, those are the Golan Heights. Very controversial, no?
Why? I thought we were talking about Joshua.
But in Israel, the story of Joshua is never far from present-day controversy.
The archaeology at Hazor, within sight of those embattled heights, has political overtones in a
country where historical claim to the land is a matter of war and peace. For it was here that
Joshua and the Israelites finished their righteous conquest of the Holy Land, according to the Old
Testament. They put to the sword all who were in it, utterly destroying them. There were none left
that breathed, and he burned Hazor with fire. This, look how dark it is, how black it is. Look
at all those fallen mud brick. This is the real end of Hazor. Look at the ashes. A half, well,
almost a meter and a half of debris, of ashes, of wooden beams, of pottery, of all kinds of finds,
and we are not yet down to the actual floor. So this is going to be a real big thing.
Was it the Israelites who destroyed Hazor, fulfilling their destiny as foretold in the Bible?
Now, this is Hazor, and this is the Bible. The question is, do they indeed correlate? Does it
really mean that, as it is written in the Bible, this is how it happened? This is still an open
question. We don't know, because it says so in the Bible doesn't necessarily mean that it is wrong,
okay? It may very well be so, but it is for us to prove. It may very well be that somebody else
destroyed Hazor, and in the book of Joshua, whoever wrote the book of Joshua, attributed
the story to the Israelites. For now, the answer remains hidden in the rubble of Hazor. Unknown
Ben-Tor and his team are continuing their search for the missing chapter from the time of Joshua.
Although their efforts are not always rewarded, today they have made a new find.
So it's just like a little scarf. You see the head here, and the wings and everything. Nice.
Very nice. Okay. This is about 8th century, something like this, 9th century. It's about
2,800 years old, maybe something like this. I don't know. We have to study it.
We are very young. Yesterday, we have to study it. It's the period of the kings of Israel.
That's the Israelites, no question. But it was Joshua, definitely. Unfortunately, not Joshua.
So Moses commanded, so Joshua did. According to scripture, the conquest of Canaan was the last
act in a drama that began with the triumphant exodus of the Israelites from Egypt. Moses led
the 12 tribes of Israel into the wilderness. When they came upon Mount Sinai, Moses went up to the
mountain to receive the Ten Commandments. Moses died before reaching the promised land.
His servant Joshua would lead the Israelites across the Jordan River. At Jericho, the Lord
commanded them to march around the city for six days. On the seventh, trumpets were sounded,
the people shouted, and the walls came crashing down. For over a century, archaeologists have
sought to verify the conquest as related in the book of Joshua. Today, a new generation
of Israeli archaeologists is challenging the validity of the Old Testament as a historical
document. Israel Finkelstein has surveyed hundreds of ancient settlements throughout Israel.
He thinks the Battle of Jericho never happened. The conquest theory in Jericho
was really disproved years ago. I think that it's a process of maybe 30 or 50 years
of excavations. Excavations in the sites which are mentioned in the Bible in the conquest narrative
reveal that either the sites were not at all inhabited at the time, or that the destruction
of the Canaanites was a gradual and long process which took 150 years. Simply,
this was not done by a group of people in one year or in several years or in a short period of time.
If Joshua's conquest of Canaan is a myth, then how did the Israelites reach the promised land?
Over the past decade, Adam Zertal has also uncovered dozens of new sites.
He believes they migrated peacefully into Canaan.
We're looking now backward on Wadi Farah. I believe that along this road, the Israelites
have entered from the Jordan that we can see on the opening, and gradually entered and penetrated
into the sedentary life, into the land of the promised land. Now, we know that these Israelites
were half nomads, and they moved gradually into sedentary, settled life. Zertal is convinced
that the Israelites were originally nomads who came across the Jordan River and settled around
Wadi Farah, the only perennial source of water in the region. Here, they could live on the land
and graze their flocks year round. Eventually, they gave up their traditional nomadic tents
for more permanent structures, like these crude mud huts unique to Wadi Farah. I think,
in a very firm way, that they were foreigners who came from the other side of the Jordan.
They were not Canaanites since they were not directed from the Canaanite city-states to this
land, but vice versa. Although Zertal has discarded the conquest theory in favor of his peaceful
migration theory, he is equally passionate about a new discovery. We were digging here without
understanding what it was. We didn't even dare to dream that we deal here with Joshua's altar.
He believes he has found the altar built by Joshua at Mount Ebal, after the Israelites
reached the promised land. That was a moment I'll never forget until the last day of my life.
We couldn't sleep for a couple of nights because then it was a very good proof that we deal here
with a real first Israelite altar, where our people have started the real roots of everything,
not only of the Jewish culture, but probably of all the Western civilization. I still can remember
this enthusiasm and this excitement, I think, never to be repeated in my lifetime. However,
not everyone agrees with Zertal. Well, Mount Ebal may be a cult site, but the altar,
as far as I'm concerned, is Zertal's sheer imagination. Israel Finkelstein has proposed
yet another new theory for the origin of the Israelites. Convinced that they were not immigrants,
Finkelstein argues that many were probably Canaanites, as were their fathers and their
fathers before them. I think that the Israelites were probably local people who were probably
sedentary people in the middle of the second millennium. Then there was a collapse of the
urban culture, there was a process of nomadization, and after a few centuries, resedentarization.
They were, in a way, they were Canaanites because they lived in Canaan of the second millennium BC.
And for Amihai Mazar, clues that the Israelites emerged from Canaan sometimes come from
unsuspected sources. This little bronze bull was found by me in a kibbutz, an antiquities collection.
It was found by a soldier training in the northern Samaria mountains, not far from Shechem, north of
Shechem, biblical Shechem. It was found on a remote mountain, and I was shown the place exactly where
it was found. We excavated there, and we could date it to this time, the 12th century BC, the
period of the Israelite settlement. And we believe that the place where this bull was found was a
high place. That means it was a sanctuary, an open-air sanctuary, utilized by those Israelites
in the early phase of their settlement there. Now this is a very interesting find because we know
that the Canaanites, much earlier, also used or had in their sanctuaries bronze bulls
made in a very similar fashion. So we can claim that this little bull illustrates Canaanite
traditions and inspiration on the early Israelite religion and cult. If the Israelites were
Canaanites all along, when did they emerge as a unified people with a cultural identity?
You cannot just ask, who are the Israelites? Because you must also be specific about a time
in history. Under Joshua, or in the period described in the book of Joshua, did they know
that they were Israelites? We don't know. We don't have enough historical evidence for this. But
obviously many people who joined in this new force were local or were from here, and it was
a mixture of people. Whether or not they identify themselves as Israelites, this mixture of people
was somehow different. In the archaeological layers of Hazor, the settlement after the Great
Fire is quite distinct from its Canaanite predecessors. So we have something different.
Is this something different, Israelite or not? For the time being, I think it is. But for the
time being, we don't have an absolute proof. We need something else, which I don't know if we
will ever find. Maybe we need a lot more of the same. But I think these are the Israelites, and
it's a different page in a different story. The Old Testament contains a second version
of the conquest that contradicts the book of Joshua. In the book of Judges, the Israelites
dwelled side by side with the Canaanites until a crisis threatened to overwhelm them.
The world was turned upside down. Around 1200 BC, a crisis burst throughout the ancient Near East.
Many cities collapsed. The empires collapsed. The Hittite Empire, the Egyptian Empire. After 1150 BC,
the Egyptian Empire did not survive anymore. And many of those Canaanite city-states,
Canaanite cities, for example, the largest, the most well-known one is Hazor in the Galilee,
disappeared. They just ceased to exist. In fact, the world as they knew it ceased to exist.
A golden age of trade and prosperity had linked Canaan to the empires of the Mediterranean and
the Aegean. When they collapsed, the social, economic, and political fabric of the Canaanite
city-states collapsed with them. Today, most archaeologists agree that against this backdrop
of turmoil and unrest, small groups of shepherds and herders, now politically independent and
economically self-reliant, wandered into the isolated hills of Canaan to begin the new life.
Out of their experience slowly emerged a new culture and a new identity.
In time, they would become known as the Israelites. Does this new theory, based on decades of
archaeological research, mean the Bible is wrong? Does it diminish the legend that has sustained
Israel for centuries? Perhaps it puts it in perspective. We have to understand that the
Bible is not a source for describing the origin of Israel, for the simple reason that the biblical
narrative was compiled at least, or even written in Jerusalem in the 7th century BC. And in many
ways it reflects the ideas, the ideology, the economic affairs, the political affairs of the
people of Jerusalem in the 7th century, which means five centuries after the supposed events
took place. It's a question of how you look on the Bible. There are many points of view
on the Bible. Of course, fundamentalists, both Christians and Orthodox Jews, believe in the
On the other hand, we have ultra-critical scholars, starting in the late 8th-19th century
and up to our own days, who claim that much of the biblical narrative is just literary fiction.
Archaeology is not here to prove or disprove the Bible. I mean, the Bible, as a book written in
divine inspiration, needs no proof. Professor Avram Beran is a veteran archaeologist who began
excavating in Israel before it became a state. He now teaches biblical archaeology at Hebrew
Union College in Jerusalem. Take Jericho. How many articles and books have been written?
Were there, did the walls of Jericho came falling down? Now, I don't know if it really matters.
There must have been some kind of a historical element in the story, but we don't know which of
the layers of occupation of Jericho can be ascribed to it. We don't know when it took place exactly.
But to me, the myth of Jericho, if you like, has sustained the Israelites and the Jewish people
for thousands of years. But for Adam Zertal, each chapter and verse of the Old Testament
is incontestably etched in these stones. The debate cannot be whether the Israelites were
Israelites, because the Israelite entity here is quite clear by, as I said, the similarity
with the Bible and the later Jewish temple in Jerusalem. In the Holy Land, biblical archaeology
often reflects modern longings as much as ancient truths. How does archaeology, how does material
culture relate to the biblical narratives? And here, this is a question of what's important.
You cannot answer it in general. You have to say for whom. There are some people who need,
for one reason or another, to have 100% correlation between archaeology and the biblical narrative
in order to prove or to give them confidence or to give them a sense of identity,
to give them roots in history. For a dozen different reasons, people need to have 100%
correlation. Others, I'd say, like me, I don't need 100% correlation. I don't need to read
a chapter in the Bible and then run to the field and see, can I find something which relates to
this or not? My identity as an Israeli, I don't think it has anything to do with one theory or
another in the book of Joshua. For some, it is important. For others, it's not. And in the larger
perspective, archaeology perhaps serves the needs of a nation over time. When I was brought up 30
years ago in the education system in Israel, I was brought up on the narrative of the conquest of
Canaan and destroying the local people and so on. And I'm not sure that this is the way that we have
to look at things today. It's important for us, I think, in Israel, for the way that we shape our
culture and our identity today in the sense that it teaches us, I think, to find a way to live
with our neighbors. In the present-day turmoil of the Middle East, archaeology has shed new light
on this ancient landscape. Far from shattering a myth, it has enriched an epic tale of struggle
and survival that continues to rock the political landscape of Israel today. In an earlier time,
the suggestion that the Israelites were themselves Canaanites would have earned its author a public
stoning. Yet in the timeless interplay of science and religion, one era's heresy is often another's
article of faith. Perhaps tomorrow, the idea of the Israelites as Canaanites will be no more
earth-shaking than the theory of evolution. Well, here we have maybe an unholy trinity.
Okay, there's archaeology, there is Bible, there is politics.
