Why there were NO Muslim Colonies in the Americas?

Weird History
157 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores why major Muslim empires did not colonize the Americas despite their wealth and power. It analyzes the geographical, technological, and socio-political barriers that prevented Muslim states from pursuing transatlantic expansion, while highlighting a specific attempt by Morocco to establish a foothold in the New World.
Whether it was the Catholic conquistadors or Protestant pilgrims, religion was an important
part of the colonization of the Americas. Western European countries colonized, or at least
attempted to establish colonies, in the Americas. So where was Islam? Why was there no Muslim state
creating a colony there, even though at least one sultan seriously considered the idea at one point?
The obvious answer for why Muslims didn't colonize the Americas is that none of the
major Muslim empires were centered near the Atlantic. There were three major Muslim empires
in the world at the time of the colonization of the Americas, among the biggest and most
influential, alongside other Muslim-ruled states that were smaller or more regionally focused.
The Ottomans were the largest, controlling most of the eastern Mediterranean, including Anatolia,
the Levant, and Egypt, as well as parts of Europe and North Africa. They were extremely wealthy,
and had a powerful Mediterranean fleet. However, their power was primarily Mediterranean,
and while Ottoman-aligned corsairs could operate beyond the Strait of Gibraltar,
a serious colonizing expedition would have required running an expensive gauntlet through
contested waters. They were regularly at war with opponents in Spain and Italy, so any attempt to
outfit and sail a transatlantic expedition would have had to pass hostile choke points
under enemy pressure. The Safavids controlled Persia. They were engaged in trade in the Persian
Gulf and Indian Ocean, but did not build their power around long-distance oceanic expansion.
Not only were they a long way from the Atlantic, but they didn't even have access to the
Mediterranean. To reach the Americas, they would have needed to either push through heavily
contested routes towards the Atlantic, or to find a way around Africa into the Atlantic world,
dominated by Iberian naval power. Both long and difficult options.
This was also broadly true of the Muslim Mughal Empire of India. Their ports sat on the Indian
Ocean trade networks that connected Arabia, East Africa, India, and Southeast Asia. But building
and protecting a sustained trans-oceanic colonizing venture across to the Americas
was another task entirely. Access to the Atlantic was one reason then, but it had
knock-on effects. Crossing the Atlantic required specific ship designs and navigational routines
tailored to Atlantic conditions, and most Muslim powers did not prioritize those because their
strategic and commercial focus lay elsewhere. European vessels making the journey were
sail-driven and sturdy, strong enough to withstand the harsh waters of the Atlantic.
By contrast, many Ottoman naval forces in the 1500s still relied heavily on oared galleys
built for Mediterranean warfare, which weren't practical for a trans-Atlantic voyage.
Of course, Muslim societies also used sailing ships, including large Indian Ocean vessels,
but these were typically built for different wind systems, routes, and logistical assumptions
than the Atlantic crossings pioneered by Iberian powers.
Not being positioned for American conquest meant they weren't equipped for it either.
If Muslim powers did want American colonies, they would have had to build entirely new
long-range expedition systems, ships, supply chains, and Atlantic intelligence networks.
The Europeans weren't eager to share their designs with Muslims in the first place.
The European powers also closely guarded their maps, navigation charts,
and navigational techniques, often treating them as state secrets.
But why not try? If these wealthy and powerful empires really wanted American colonies,
they could have tried at least. So why didn't they?
To answer that, let's take a step back first.
Why did the Europeans go to America in the first place?
The first reason was to get to Asia. Columbus was famously seeking a new route to Asia
when he set out in 1492. With the fall of Constantinople in 1453, some European rulers
and merchants feared higher costs, instability, and dependence on powerful intermediaries along
eastern routes. So going west looked like a way to bypass competitors and secure direct
access to high-value trade. For obvious reasons, the Islamic world didn't have this problem in the
same way. Many of the trade routes Europeans wanted to bypass ran through Muslim-ruled or
Muslim-connected commercial networks. Trade with Asia continued through long-established routes,
and major empires were already plugged into Indian Ocean commerce. Therefore,
the particular motivation that pushed some Europeans into high-risk Atlantic experiments
simply didn't make much sense. Secondly, even if we ignore the
distance to the Americas for a moment, European powers wanted land that was hard to secure back
home. Europe was fragmented into many rival states and kingdoms, often locked in wars and
shifting alliances. If any European country wanted more land to exploit for resources or
to acquire more people, their only choice were costly wars that could backfire on them. The
Americas offered an entire new continent's worth of land for the taking. Meanwhile, just referring
to the three major Muslim powers, they had vast lands of their own and plenty of opportunities
to expand closer to home. The Ottomans didn't need America to find viable conquests,
they had the Balkans and North Africa. The Safavids had Central Asia to wrestle with,
and also fought conflicts with the Ottomans and other regional rivals on their borders.
As for the Mughals, it took until around 1700 for them to consolidate much of the Deccan,
and even then, large parts of the far south remained outside firm Mughal control.
So the governments and merchants of the Muslim world did not have the same motivation to colonize
the Americas. But what about other people? European colonization was often driven by
the nobility. European nobility was based on inheritance and land ownership, but with spare
land in short supply, Europe's nobility were running out of options to gain power and status.
American colonies offered the chance at glory and power that the disaffected nobles of Europe
couldn't find at home. This is what drove Hernan Cortes, the son of a lesser noble who had failed
to secure a profitable legal career to venture to the New World and eventually conquer Mexico.
Similarly, Peru was conquered at the command of Francisco Pizarro, the poor son of a colonel who
had no real prospects at home. Muslim nobility was quite different. While European nobles
inherited titles and land, Muslim nobility was often appointed by the sultan directly,
and were not granted land per se, but tax collection rights over that land,
such as in the Ottoman Timur system. This made nobles easier to control from the center.
It meant no regional power bases or independent tax revenues that could be the basis of rebellion,
and so Muslim nobility was almost entirely dependent on the favor of the ruler.
There was not a massive disaffected class of nobles wandering about with no prospects like
in Europe. And even if they did get it in their heads to go to these lands,
they wouldn't have expected to receive land and power in the same way. Yet, despite this,
there were still Muslim powers who were interested in colonizing the Americas.
Morocco
The Muslim power that left unusually clear written evidence of Atlantic, even New World,
ambitions was Morocco. The Sultanate, on the northwest coast of Africa, had direct
access to the Atlantic as well as the Mediterranean, just like Spain did. Therefore,
it had the location to think about such a venture. It was not a big empire like the Ottomans or
Safavids, but it was a reasonably wealthy kingdom of its own, with a long-established talent for
sailing and trading. Morocco was also quick to adopt new technological developments like
gunpowder weaponry, as were its European rivals, and by the late 16th century it could field
substantial forces and compete in a dangerous Atlantic world. True, they didn't have the same
ocean-going imperial infrastructure that Spain and Portugal built, and adopting it was not easy
once Iberian powers dominated Atlantic routes with fortified ports, experienced crews, and
tight control of strategic information. There were a few reasons why this couldn't happen
easily. First, Morocco was under the rule of the Wattasid dynasty for most of the early 16th
century, who were too focused on protecting themselves from Portuguese and Spanish opponents
than funding expeditions to the New World. After a brief civil war, they were replaced by the
Saadi. It was one of the Saadi sultans, Ahmad al-Mansur, who realized that Morocco might have
an opportunity to claim its stake across the Atlantic. In August 1600, a Moroccan embassy
arrived at the court of Queen Elizabeth I of England. The two countries shared a common enemy
in Spain, and Sultan Ahmad al-Mansur sent his people with a proposal to weaken Spain permanently.
Serious discussions about coordinated action against Spanish power, ideas that could even
extend to Spain's overseas empire. He suggested launching an expedition from a Moroccan port
to capture the colonies, some of which would then be repopulated with Moroccan settlers,
creating the first Muslim-American colonies. The sultan was clearly interested in America.
While in Britain, his ambassadors sought maps, intelligence, and practical know-how about
Atlantic navigation and the wealth flowing from the New World. While Queen Elizabeth was cautious
and non-committal about any direct attack on Spain's colonies, she did begin discussions
about cooperation against Spanish shipping and broader alliance building. However,
Elizabeth and al-Mansur both died in 1603 before any lasting agreement could be secured.
Morocco fell into civil war after his death, and the Atlantic remained dominated by the Spanish,
Portuguese, and others. So Morocco was no longer in a position to entertain the idea of American
colonies, not when European fleets could raid their coasts and seize their ships.
Overall, there was no Muslim colonies in the New World because most of the major Muslim
powers did not have the geography, ships, or strategic incentives needed to create and hold
them. With deep integration into Afro-Eurasian trade and different political and social
structures than those powering European settler colonialism, Muslim powers had little reason to
pursue the idea of creating colonies. If you'd like to help us keep creating
and get early access to our videos, behind-the-scenes content, and other perks,
consider becoming a member right here on YouTube or joining us on Patreon.
Every bit of support helps, and as always, thank you so much for watching!
