To make this second film about Afghanistan, reporter Sandy Gall returned there in the summer of 1984 to find out who, if anyone, is winning the war which began five years previously when Soviet forces invaded the country. Sandy and a small camera crew spent two months with the Afghan rebels and travelled more than 400 miles in the south-east of the country filming the fighting. His report includes some remarkable footage of the attempted ambush of a Russian convoy and contains interviews with defecting Russian soldiers who tell of the horrors they have seen and describe the low morale of the Soviet troops.
A journalist's report from five years into the Soviet-Afghan War reveals a grueling war of attrition. While the Mujahideen exhibit high morale and increasing armament, they face a catastrophic humanitarian crisis and a lethal disadvantage against Soviet air power. The conflict is framed as a spiritual struggle, with the resistance's survival heavily dependent on external military aid.
This Christmas it will be five years since the start of the war between the Afghan resistance,
the Mujahideen, and the Russian army in Afghanistan. After an interval of two years,
I recently made my second visit to the country to see what effect the war is having and to
discover who, if anyone, is winning. With an ITN cameraman, Paul Carlton, and a sound recordist,
John Hunt, I spent a month with the Mujahideen in an area where the Russians are trying to cut
off the flow of men and weapons from across the Pakistani border. But that border is 1,500 miles
long, the mountain trails are myriad, and the flow of men and arms is heavier and better organised
than two years ago. We travelled through a virtually deserted landscape. The people who
lived here are now nearly all refugees in Pakistan. Every so often we'd stop at a tea house
to rest and drink cups of sweet green tea, a great reviver on this march which took us over
9,000 foot passes in blazing sunshine. I became a green tea addict.
The Mujahideen are tireless, but Westerners like myself find it hard to resist
asking repeatedly and plaintively how much further there is to go.
Do we have a long way to go today? Do we have much further to go today?
Nearly there. These Mujahideen, most in their teens or early 20s, have left their families
in Pakistan to come back and fight the jihad, the holy war against the infidel.
For them the jihad is an obligation, unpaid, but also an honour, a chance for glory.
Everybody is caught up in it, even the children. Compared to two years ago, I found the Mujahideen
much better armed. Some groups even have anti-aircraft missiles like these SAMs,
although it's doubtful if the international symbols this way up,
fragile and keep dry, mean much to the Afghans,
especially when everything has to be brought in over the mountains by pack-horses.
The logistical difficulties, especially for the groups in the deep interior, are horrendous. It
may take a month or more to get in a fresh supply of desperately needed ammunition.
This more than anything hampers the resistance and slows down their war effort.
Each of these boxes contains two SAM-7s, a Russian missile,
although the Chinese also make them. Each missile is said to cost a quarter of a million dollars,
so this horse is carrying one million dollars worth of weaponry on its back.
Our camera equipment, equally delicate but less expensive, had to be carried in the same way.
From the border, we headed north and east towards the Kabul River,
where our group planned to ambush a Russian convoy, then back in a circle to Hisarak
to try and capture a government fort, a journey of three to four hundred miles.
Recently, the Russians have tried hard to block the guerrilla's infiltration routes
in this key area, both along the border and also deeper in. The guerrilla's response has
been to attack Russian convoys and outposts and blow up the power lines to Kabul.
Two years ago, practically all these villages were inhabited. Today, they're deserted. It's
estimated that 95% of the population of these border provinces has fled. Nangarhar was once
one of the most heavily populated parts of Afghanistan, the Patan or Pashto heartland.
Often, the only occupants are the Mujahideen themselves. The villages are their staging
posts, their field kitchens, where they butcher and prepare the tough meat, mainly goat,
on which their army marches. On the wall behind, a Chinese poster shows a Russian
being chased out of Afghanistan by President Reagan.
Traditionally, in an Afghan village, the women always did the cooking.
Now, with no women about, the Mujahideen have had to learn to do their own.
Some of them are very young, mere boys like 12-year-old Rais Khan,
youngest of 13 brothers, all Mujahideen. How long has he been fighting?
And does he like being a Mujahideen? Would he not rather be at school?
Would he not rather be at school?
Has he ever been involved in any fighting?
Where and when?
A Mujahideen's day, even on the march, is punctuated by prayers, beginning before dawn
and ending late at night. Their Islamic faith burns as brightly as it ever did,
and appears indestructible. Most Westerners fall far short of Afghan standards of godliness,
preferring cleanliness instead, although it's an almost unattainable ideal in Afghanistan.
Even in the villages, baths don't exist, and the travellers only hope there's a
convenient stream. And in order not to offend against local standards of decency,
you're required to keep your underpants on throughout. But with no women about to give
offence to, we were able to expose more of ourselves than would have been possible two
years ago. We managed to have three open-air baths in four weeks marching, which is bordering
on luxury for Afghanistan. Oh, great, wonderful, I can recommend it. In the last five years,
the flood of Afghans leaving the country to escape the Russians has created the biggest
refugee problem in the world. Three million in Pakistan, another million in Iran. Four million
in all, one quarter of the population. Plus another half million internal refugees, people
who fled their homes but are still in Afghanistan.
When this little girl's donkey refused to budge, the Mujahideen were quick to help.
We met this party of refugees three days in from the border.
The temperature was in the 90s and there was no shade for miles.
Among them were four young women we weren't allowed to film, but they told one of our escorts
they'd all been raped by Russian soldiers, all were pregnant, and one was very close to giving
birth. We were told there had been similar cases before, but the women had always killed themselves.
You're a refugee? Yes. Where have you come from? I came from Kabul.
Last Wednesday, because there was a lot of... Life is dangerous in Afghanistan. I have to
escape from Afghanistan. Our lovely country to go to Pakistan to join with our brother
and Muslim brother and help, get help from Pakistan. What made you leave Kabul now at this
time? Yeah, at this time I'm an engineer. Sometimes they force it on me to come join with us,
otherwise we will put you to jail. You mean to work for the government? Yes. And my daughters,
I have two daughters, one of them is studying in the Faculty of Law in the fifth semester,
and the other is in the Faculty of Medicine, and they force it on them to come join with us,
but we are Muslim, we don't like the Russian government, and they always attack all of us,
and just we leave this country to go until we are in Pakistan to our friends, our brothers,
all the Communist Party attack on me and always trying to put me on the jail. This is my
uncle's son. They put them for two years in the jail. He was... You were in jail? Yes, because
he has to help with the Afghan people, Muslim, not working with the Russian government.
They caught him and put him in the jail for two years. After two years, he came back. Now,
if he stays in Kabul, they put him again to the police and maybe kill him. Yeah. What exactly
were they trying to make you do? Actually, the Communist Party find our mind to what we have
in our mind. Now, they found we are not with them. Just we want to our country free from Russian.
We don't want Russian to stay here, to come to Afghanistan. Now, they found us the same.
They want to make a trick on us to put in the jail. After a few weeks, they will kill us.
Later that day, we pushed on into the mountains. In the evening, we reached one of the group's
main logistics bases that has been bombed several times by the Russians but survived
thanks to its natural defenses. The armory is tunneled into the side of the mountain
and contains a whole array of weapons, all Russian or Chinese, heavy and light machine guns
like this Goryunov, which fires 650 rounds a minute. Chinese-made RPG-7 rocket launchers,
a devastating anti-tank weapon at close range and now in apparently plentiful supply with
Mujahideen groups throughout the country. Such is the penetrating power of the nose cone
that it can pierce armor plating and is deadly against soft-skinned vehicles.
Hundreds of boxes of ammunition for the Zhigoyak heavy machine gun,
82-millimeter recoilless rifle ammunition,
and the weapon itself, Chinese-made and extremely effective.
Next day, we met three young Russian defectors.
Sergei Buzov is 20 and comes from Perm, east of Moscow.
He trained as an armored personnel carrier driver and was posted to Bagram Air Base near Kabul.
He says he deserted from the army because he was constantly beaten up,
once by an officer and regularly by NCOs. This, he says, is a tradition in the Soviet army,
but he deserted when he couldn't endure it any longer. Like the others, he's become a Muslim,
possibly there was little choice, but he and the others seem to be completely accepted
by the Mujahideen. Vladislav Naumov is 21 and comes from Volgograd, the old Stalingrad.
He trained as a tank mechanic and a paratrooper and was posted to an army base near Jalalabad.
He says he defected because when he and some other soldiers protested about bad food,
he was arrested and imprisoned by the KGB. He managed to escape and made contact with the
Mujahideen. Naumov says all of them were opposed to the Soviet system at home, where there was no
freedom of the press, no freedom of speech, no political freedom. Although they're all European
Russians, they seem very much at home in their new surroundings.
Naumov is writing a book about the war which will describe, he says, the behaviour of the Soviet
army in Afghanistan and the atrocities. How, for example, at the end of May 1983,
a totally innocent Afghan, in his words, was held in front of a tank gun and blown to pieces.
They defected separately, Naumov says, basically because they all opposed the war in Afghanistan
on moral grounds. They met later and have been together for almost a year. The youngest of the
three, Vadim Plotnikov on the left, is 19. He defected after only one week in the army in
Afghanistan. I talked to them through an Afghan interpreter and then Naumov gave their views on
the war in Russian.
The idea was to create a small Afghanistan, a territory of Uzbekistan, where Soviet builders,
I think even under the leadership of Afghan communists, built large villages, like the ones
in Afghanistan. And it was on these villages that we learned to fight in Afghanistan.
What difficulties does a Soviet soldier face in Afghanistan? First, of course, I will not
talk about the living conditions. Of course, the living conditions here are very difficult,
very terrible. First, the relief of this country does not correspond to the relief of our country.
It is very difficult to fight here in terms of training. The Afghans, of course, know what
they are fighting for. In general, they are fighting for the freedom of their country. And the Soviet
soldiers, what do they need in Afghanistan? They don't know why they came. Nobody really
knows why they came to Afghanistan and what they need to do here. That's why they treat
it coldly. Why do they treat the military actions coldly? Because they are afraid of death.
Every soldier wants to go home. In general, his family or relatives are waiting for him at home.
Therefore, the Soviet soldiers are doing very badly here. Also, the Soviet command is very
dissatisfied with the conduct of war in Afghanistan, as the Soviet soldiers conduct war in Afghanistan.
Wednesday, August 1, Hussein Pacha, the local commander, starts mustering his men for an
ambush on the Kabul road, calling the roll and distributing ammunition. Altogether, about
200 men had been called up, a big group by local standards, but only 120 or so would
take part in the operation. The rest would be in support, making sure the main force
received supplies of food and ammunition.
First, each man received a handout of 9mm ammunition for his Kalashnikov rifle.
Many Mujahideen groups have been penetrated by the HUD, the local equivalent of the KGB,
and so each Mujahideen now carries an identity card with his photograph.
What is it?
Basir Khan and Hamdallah?
Basir and Hamdallah?
Babrik and Malajan?
Mala Khalil and Aftagul?
What happened to Mala Khalil?
One of the problems the Mujahideen face is finding men skilled enough to be SAM operators.
Few Mujahideen have any military training, although they all have a natural attitude
for arms, and few have much formal education.
Our group took in six SAM-7s, representing an investment of one and a half million dollars.
This is the SAM-7B, the latest version, a heat-seeking missile designed to lock onto
an aircraft's exhaust. It has a range of three miles and a speed of 1250 miles an hour.
Chinese pressure mines, made of plastic, so they're hard to detect.
By removing the detonator, in blue, so that they no longer act as pressure mines,
packing them with extra explosive, and then wiring them up in batches,
the Mujahideen hope to pull off a spectacular ambush.
There were generous supplies of C3, blasting gelignite, which is remarkably stable to handle.
Looks and smells like marzipan, and can give you a nasty headache if you inhale the fumes for too long.
Pound for pound, it's probably the most powerful explosive in everyday use.
The plan here was to set off the mines in batches of 16 by remote control.
It was an ambitious plan, perhaps too ambitious, and meant that each batch had to be wired together,
and then wired separately to a remote control exploder.
I found myself reflecting, as on my trip two years ago, that although they may lack conventional
military skills, the Afghans have a lot of ingenuity, and are remarkably good at improvising.
Well, the ambush site has finally been chosen, and this group of mine layers is setting off now
to plant 80 mines on the main road, which is just over that hill, down at the bottom of a steep gorge.
It's the main road from Kabul, the capital, to the important provincial city of Jalalabad,
and along it run big Russian convoys regularly, up to 250 or 300 vehicles,
some of them carrying ammunition, petrol, and troops.
Now today, a big convoy went along that road, but the guerrillas weren't ready,
so they're hoping there'll be another convoy tomorrow, or the next day.
A group of young boys carries the last of the mines up the hillside.
The rest of the force camps out at the foot of the mountain, and prays for victory in the coming battle,
buoyed up by the belief that a place in heaven awaits the martyrs of the jihad.
I wrote in my diary, their spirits seem very high, no sign of nerves.
They despise the Russians as soldiers, the only thing they fear is their air power.
Dawn, Friday, August the 3rd.
In the middle of the picture, a Russian post guards the road to Kabul with tanks and a garrison.
Well, the ambush plans seem to have gone wrong.
We think the Russians know we're here, and that the road is mined,
because last night apparently the guerrillas made a lot of noise planting the mines,
and the Russians opened fire, although haphazardly, the guerrillas say.
What we do know is that the Russians have now blocked all civilian traffic on the road in both directions,
and we're now waiting to see what happens next.
What happened next was that the Russians started to mortar the mountaintop where we were.
Well, the Russians have got us pinned down on the side of the mountain at the moment,
and they're lobbing mortars, that's one just gone off on the top, just over the top here,
and down below us on the road there are five Russian tanks, we can't see them because the gorge is very steep.
They're shooting back up at the mujahideen positions.
With tank guns, the main gun, and also with machine guns.
And the mujahideen are shooting back at them with RPG-7s, rockets, propelled grenades, and machine guns.
And we're waiting to see whether the Russians are going to put in an airstrike.
It came at noon. Two MI-24 helicopter gunships armed with rockets and cannon, flying too high for the SAMs.
When the first gunship opened fire, the rockets went right over our heads.
Then the second gunship lined up and fired.
The rockets smashing into the hillside above us.
So the element of surprise having been lost, and the ambush obviously not going to take place now,
the guerrilla commander has ordered his troops, who've been down there in the gorge all day, to pull out tonight.
It just shows you today's action, how easy it is for the Russians to keep a grip on this road.
They've got strong posts all along it, about two miles apart, from which they can rake the mountainside with heavy mortars and tank fire.
But it also shows just how easy it is for the guerrillas, the mujahideen, to cut the road at any time.
Today they've stopped all traffic for the whole day, and we don't know when it's going to start again.
It shows you that they are in a very strong position to cut the road whenever they want to.
And today, in fact, they have knocked out two tanks.
But the hard fact is that due to lack of professionalism, what might have been a famous victory for the mujahideen ended as just another skirmish.
Surprisingly, casualties were very light, only two wounded.
Looking after wounded mujahideen is one of the things the Russian defectors do voluntarily.
They have some first aid training. In Naumov's case, it runs in the family.
His mother was a doctor, his brother is a dentist.
This man was wounded by pieces of shrapnel from a mortar.
The mujahideen have almost nothing in the way of medical supplies.
A serious wound usually means gangrene and death.
By showing they care, the Russians are no doubt making their own act of atonement for the behavior of their fellow countrymen.
But for Naumov especially, their defection to the mujahideen is much more than a personal protest.
In the future, of course, we will try to expand our activities in Afghanistan.
So far we have three, but as they say, one in the field is not a warrior, but three are already warriors.
Therefore, we release leaflets in Russian.
We recorded a program for people living in the Soviet Union.
We told the truth about Afghanistan.
And a lot of other work.
We wrote a letter to Chernenko.
We did a lot of work in Afghanistan.
You can give a lot of examples of the cruelty that is happening in Afghanistan.
How Soviet soldiers, having smoked a lot of drugs, go into battle without realizing what they are doing.
They are doing incredibly terrible things in Afghanistan.
But practically no one from the military leadership is following the use of drugs in Afghanistan.
Because it plays to some extent into the hands of the Soviet government.
This village was bombed by the Russians last winter.
Two people were killed.
The remaining 11 families fled as refugees, except for one man, Gul Mahmud.
His family are all now in Pakistan, but he came back alone to work the land and to help the mujahideen.
Just below the village were two unexploded Russian bombs.
Plotnikov, who comes from Moscow, was trained as an engineer in bomb disposal and he offered to help get rid of them.
A lump of gelignite is shaped and placed against the casing of the 500 pounder.
The detonator is pushed home into the gelignite and the fuse wire attached.
Plotnikov lights it and runs. He has a minute to get clear.
Thursday, August the 9th.
Great excitement in camp at the news that the leader of the group, Yunus Halis himself, was approaching.
Red bearded and sprightly for a man of 67, Yunus Halis is the only senior resistance leader with headquarters in Pakistan
who crosses regularly into Afghanistan to visit his men in the field.
He recently married a young wife and had a son, which his followers see as a commendable sign of his virility.
He says it's the duty of every Afghan to refuse to submit to oppression.
Yunus Halis is not a soldier, but a mullah, a man of God, deeply versed in the teaching of the prophet and in the words of the Koran.
The struggle between good and evil is still going on, he says, and is symbolised by today's war against the Russians.
Now you're getting a lot more arms than when I was here two years ago, but is it enough?
If we don't have enough weapons, we won't be able to fight.
But we have been fighting for years.
We don't have any concerns about the weakness of our weapons.
In the past few weeks we've been travelling through virtually depopulated country.
Isn't this a sign of victory for the Russians?
It's a sign of victory for the Russians.
It's also a sign of victory for the Mujahideen.
We know that the Mujahideen are strong in the face of oppression.
The reason for our death is because our soldiers are fighting within the control of the enemy.
We know that this is not good for us.
Next day, we went to inspect a nearby government fort, which the Mujahideen were besieging.
The first rounds fell short.
Then they got the range.
Two to three hundred Afghan soldiers garrisoned the fort at Hisarak, which can only be resupplied
by air or by heavily armed convoy.
The Mujahideen brought up a recoilless rifle.
At the suggestion of the Mujahideen, the Russians fired a Goryunov light machine gun at a corner
of the fort.
In the afternoon, the helicopter gunships arrived to pound the Mujahideen positions,
first dropping flares to decoy any SAMs, and then firing rockets.
The SAM is switched on, the battery has a life of only 60 seconds, in which time the
operator must get lock-on to the target, otherwise he cannot fire.
He does fire, but without lock-on, nothing happens.
An MI-24, heavily armour-plated, but still cautious enough to drop decoy flares.
A second SAM is made ready, but again, possibly because the gunships stayed so high as to
be out of range, he did not get lock-on.
That just goes to show how very difficult it is to use this weapon, the SA-7.
Even the Russian makers claim a success ratio of one in four, that's under ideal conditions.
But in combat conditions such as these, the real kill ratio is probably much more like
one in ten.
A few days later, the Russians resupplied the fort by air.
On their way back, an MI-8 flew right past us, very low.
The Mujahideen took position with one RPG and one SAM.
The RPG fired first, you can just hear it, but missed.
Then the SAM lined up on the first MI-24, but without success.
This shows you once more just how difficult it is to use the SA-7 against Russian helicopters.
In this case, the Mujahideen fired at a helicopter which was flying at about 500 feet.
It should have been an easy target.
In effect, the SAM misfired, the seeker here did leave the tube, but the missile didn't.
So although he might well have thought that he had an easy target and a certain kill,
he failed.
Or rather, the SAM failed.
Indeed, Western experts rate the SAM as a poor weapon by today's standards.
The last time we met the Russians, they talked about the future.
I won't go in America.
And you've got an uncle there?
Yes.
New York, Washington.
Stay in New York?
Yes.
New York, very good.
Brave and civilized words by Vladislav Naumov, end the war and stop the bloodshed.
But there's no sign that the Russians have any thought of withdrawing from Afghanistan.
In fact, just the opposite.
They're intensifying the war, trying to block the arms routes and bombing the population
into the refugee camps.
As I watched Juma Khan, wounded by a mortar in the unsuccessful siege of the fort at Hisarak,
preparing for the long trek out over the mountains to Pakistan, I came to two conclusions.
First, that Afghan courage and morale are still enormously high.
But second, unless they can find an answer to the Russians' helicopter gunships,
and the SAM isn't one, their morale may begin to crack eventually.
Five years is a long time for a small nation of 16 million to fight a superpower of 273 million.
The Mujahideen can be criticized for being undisciplined tribesmen.
They say, who else could have fought the Russians virtually single-handed for five years
and still be fighting?
In the end, the fate of the Mujahideen will be decided by how much more aid they get
from Pakistan, China and the West, and whether that will include a more effective
anti-aircraft missile.
That means a Western missile, and at the moment, Pakistan is too afraid of the Russians
to let them through.
So what will the next five years bring?
The war will almost certainly go grinding on, because the Afghans don't give up easily.
It will mean more of this.
No one knows the toll among the Afghans, there are no statistics.
But the number of dead and wounded must run in to scores of thousands,
many of them children.
These are the lucky ones.
They reached Pakistan and hospital.
They at least have some sort of future.
For many others inside Afghanistan, there may be no future.