The Worst Kinds of College Essays

Academy: stories and events
54 followers
1 Video View·Jul 22, 2026
College essays are tough. Here are a few topics you should avoid this admissions season.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Here are the worst kinds of college essays and how to fix them. So five years ago,
I was sitting in my room, hunched over my desk, trying to think of the perfect college essay idea.
Now you might have heard the advice that anything can be a good topic, all that matters is how you
write it. And while I agree for the most part, here are some topics and storylines that you
should simply avoid. And before we jump in, if you're a rising senior who needs help with their
college essay, I'm editing essays over at Next Admit. We have a team of consultants from the
nation's top schools such as Harvard, MIT, and Stanford, and we've looked at thousands of essays
over the past year. First up, we have the aggrieved athlete. I twisted my pinky on the day of the big
game. I struggled to let coach know. I have a booboo. He kicked me off the team. Beautiful.
So here we have the classic sports injury essay. In my opinion, the problem with these sorts of
essays is that they are way too predictable. The intro always starts off with the injury,
sometimes it's a bit exaggerated, the body talks about the recovery process,
and the conclusion usually talks about winning the big game, or it has a line about hard work
and resilience. My number one piece of advice for these sorts of essays is to add some variety.
Maybe the essay doesn't end on a note of happily ever after. Maybe you're still recovering. Or maybe
you don't have to talk about hard work or resilience at all. You can give this essay an academic twist.
Maybe your injury prompted your interest in sports medicine. Maybe you took on a research
project to further investigate your own condition. Okay, so for the next essay, we have the pseudo
intellectual. Ah yes, I awoke from my slumber in the midst of dawn, for I could not bear the sun's
ethereal glow upon my eyelids. So I understand why some students take this approach. They want
to impress their dream schools, and they want to show them how they're super smart and intellectual.
But the problem here is that it's clear that you're trying too hard. More importantly,
most admissions officers can tell you don't actually speak like that. Your college essay
should be a reflection of your true voice, and if you're using big words and trying to sound fancy,
you're not giving admissions officers insight into who you really are. Yes, you can and even
should write about intellectual things, but don't try to sound fancier than you actually are.
Next up, we have the philosopher. We're all like a bag of chips. Half of our existence is filled
with substance, and the other an insufferable swallowing void. The issue here is that some
students try too hard to sound deep, and being deep in your essays isn't bad, but it makes your
essay more generic and sometimes even pretentious. By grounding yourself in reality and writing about
something you know about, your sentences can go from this to something more like this. Notice how
the second example sounds so much more rich and authentic, and for that reason, it's a lot more
memorable. Alright, next up, we have the misfit. I struggled as the new kid. Sitting at the lunch
table, I pulled out the chicken briyani my mom packed. What's that horrid stench, someone yelled.
Probably your mother's musty casserole, I retorted. So these sorts of cultural essays are overdone,
and that doesn't mean your experiences aren't valid. They are, and you should be proud of who
you are, but let's think from the college's perspective for a minute. They're trying to
A cultural essay like this, while personal, is overdone. It reflects an experience that's
probably applicable to thousands of other students. If you do choose to write about your culture,
don't write about it as a whole. Addressing your experiences broadly will make it incredibly
generic. Focus on a particular dish, event, experience, or person from your culture that
has helped you grow as a person. Now, it's impossible to be 100% unique, but try to tell
your story from an angle you think others haven't taken. Maybe you can combine one aspect of your
culture with something intellectual. For example, maybe you're so fascinated with one part of your
heritage that you do an independent research project about it. After having reviewed hundreds
of essays myself, I can tell you this is an angle I haven't seen yet. Next up, we have the
sanctimonious savior. My service trip abroad was humbling. Do you have the Wendy's 444,
I asked the children. Who's Wendy, they asked. I was taken aback by my life of privilege.
Okay, so the problem with these mission trip essays is that they can come across as classist,
tone deaf, and condescending. When you try to paint yourself as the hero and the people you're
helping as poor or helpless, you give this impression that you think too highly of yourself
and lowly of others. The main way to fix these sorts of essays is to remove any condescending
language. Well, I hope that helps. If you want a part two, let me know in the comments, and if you
need more help with your college essays, check out nextadmin.com.
