Ford F-150 Tremor vs. Ram 1500 Rebel vs. Chevy Silverado Trail Boss | Off-Road Comparison Test

Van & Truck Lab
86 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedEdmunds compares the Ford F-150 Tremor, Ram 1500 Rebel, and Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Trail Boss. While the Chevy offers the best value and the Ram excels in sand, the Ford F-150 Tremor is the overall winner due to its superior off-road capability, visibility, and technology across diverse terrains.
You want off-road pickups?
We've got off-road pickups.
This all-American showdown features the Ford F-150 Tremor,
Ram 1500 Rebel, and the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Trail Boss.
We've got three challenges for these vehicles
to be able to tell you which of these three trucks
is the best off-road, because here at Edmunds,
we test everything.
One thing to keep in mind throughout this comparison
is that there is a bit of a price gap
between these three vehicles.
Now, they're all full-size trucks with off-road packages,
but the Ford and the Ram are both gonna cost you
around $81,000, while here in the Chevy,
it only costs about $68,000,
and that's even with the optional diesel engine.
Now, the Chevy might not have all the features
that the Ford and the Ram do.
You're not gonna get ventilated seats,
and the interior in the other two trucks
is probably a little bit nicer,
but if your goal is to find some sort of value
in this comparison, the Chevy might be the choice by default.
For our first test, we have a pretty large hill climb.
Now, this hill climb is going to present
a pretty good challenge for these trucks
because it's pretty steep and it's pretty loose
and quite rocky, so what we're going to do
is we're actually going to start all the trucks
set up the same way in four high
in their off-road driving modes,
and then we'll see how far up they can get,
and as we need to, we'll layer in more stuff
like four low and lockers, things like that,
but I'm here in the Chevy, and it's gonna go first.
There are two things about the Chevy
that make it mechanically a bit different
from the other two trucks that we have here.
First one, of course, is under the hood
where it's got that turbo diesel
instead of a turbo six-cylinder
like we have in the other two trucks,
and the second one, which may come into play
here on this hill, is that it doesn't actually
have a rear locker, so just like our Colorado Z71,
there's no way for you to activate
that rear locker yourself.
It has what's called an auto locker,
so once it detects slippage,
it'll lock the rear automatically on its own.
I don't really like this.
I would rather have that control myself
to turn the locker on when I need it,
and this makes the name Trail Boss a bit ironic
because you're not really the boss
over the rear of the truck at all.
This hood, while it helps make the truck
look real burly and manly-like,
these two kind of bulges here,
they make it like a mini mountain range
that's right in front of your face,
and I really can't see anything out the front at all,
so I've got my handy camera here on the screen
for me to look down if I really need to.
The low-end torque from this diesel is great.
I can just keep my foot maybe 1 1⁄4 to 1⁄2 throttle,
and it just sort of takes me up pretty easily.
Huh, this thing did much better than I thought it would.
Now it's time to do it in the Ford,
and there's something that you should know
about the Tremor.
The Tremor comes with a pretty good amount
of off-road equipment right out of the box.
You get a rear locker.
You get off-road suspension.
You get some off-road driving modes as well,
but on top of that,
you can also add on something called the 402A package,
as this truck does,
and that costs you about $12,000,
and that adds on even more goodies,
so you get a bunch of stuff
that makes the interior a lot more luxurious,
and you also get the transfer case out of a Raptor,
which gives you a four-wheel-drive auto setting,
and so far, so good for the Ford,
just like it was in the Chevy.
The Tremor also has a larger tire than the Chevy does,
a 33.2-inch tire, about 31-inch tires on the Chevy.
The Ram has the bigger tires as well.
One thing to watch out for on the Tremor package, though,
is you get these steps that do make it easier
to get into the truck.
Metal pings might be those side steps,
but not the skid plates.
Okay.
This thing is just eating this hill up,
just like it was in the Chevy.
Throttle dexterity, quite good.
The low-end torque output from this engine
seems to be very even and very easy to modulate,
as I need to.
Now we're getting to the tough part of the hill here,
with the biggest ruts,
and we're still making it up.
Had to give it a little more throttle there.
It was kind of hard to tell in the Chevy
at which point the auto-locker
kind of grabbed the rear and helped it up,
but here in the Ford, I know it's completely unlocked,
and it's still climbing up with a pretty good amount of ease.
The suspension does feel a bit less bouncy
than it does in the Chevy.
You get a bit more, it just feels a bit more pliant,
and so I am feeling these ruts and things,
but I think in the Chevy,
I was definitely getting tossed around a bit more.
One advantage I think the Ford does have over the Chevy
is that the visibility to the front is a lot better.
You don't have those big bulges on the hood here,
so I'm actually sort of able to have
a much better sense of where the nose is,
and the visibility overall in the F-150 is just superb.
Oh.
Oh, there was a step.
Those steps did come into play a little bit on the way down,
but on the way up, it was a clean run.
And now finally, we have the Ram,
and let's see if it can make light work of this hill,
just like the other two trucks.
Now, the Ram has a similar powertrain to the Ford
in that they're both turbo sixes,
but this one is inline instead of a V6,
and what the Ram has different is an air suspension,
and it's actually right now raised in its highest setting,
which is off-road mode,
but it still has less ground clearance than the Chevy.
And here we go, let's see if we can get up this hill.
It's struggling for grip a little bit more, it seems,
than the other two here.
Yeah, definitely scrabbling a lot more
over this loose surface.
It's really trying to keep the momentum, but we're, nope.
So this is our first truck to not make it up
four high without the rear lock,
so what I'm going to do now is I'm going to lock the axle,
and we're going to see if we can back down a little bit,
get a little bit of momentum, and make it through this.
Rear locked, and yeah, that's definitely better.
So with the locker on,
the Ram made it up that first part of the hill pretty easily,
but that's not as good as the Ford,
which made it up with the rear locker off.
In the Chevy, it's a bit hard to say,
because auto locker,
so I don't quite know when it was turning on and off,
but yeah, so far, advantage Ford.
One of the things about the air suspension
is that when it's fully extended up,
you do lose some articulation,
and it can make the ride a bit more harsh,
so that's one of the things I'm going to be watching out for
as we continue to go up this hill,
to see if it's as comfortable as it is in the other trucks.
This thing is definitely still fighting for grip,
even with the rear locked,
more than the other trucks were.
And the Ram does have a decent size hood bulge,
but visibility-wise, it's probably closer still to the Ford
than the Chevy with that mountain range in front of you.
This is definitely a lot more of a struggle here in the Ram.
Wow, and we are stuck again.
Okay, so we're now in four low with the locker on,
which means that basically everything here in the Ram
is turned on as much as it can be.
Now we're going to see if we can make it
out of the rest of the hill.
And with the four low turned on,
we are moving once again.
The Ram is going to make it out of this hill,
but it was a lot more work than it was
in the other two trucks.
Woo, oh, that was not nearly as fun.
On the hill climb, it was a very clear win for the Ford
as it made it up the hill with ease,
and it was the most comfortable from behind the wheel.
In second place was the Chevy,
which also had no problems with the ascent,
but its suspension was less pliant
and visibility was very compromised by its giant hood.
In last place was the Ram.
It was the only truck that needed to go into four low
to complete the obstacle,
and with its air suspension stretched all the way up,
it made things very uncomfortable
both going up and down the hill.
Now this is an off-road test,
so we're not going to get too far
into these truck interiors
and what they're sort of like to live with day to day,
but it is worth noting that both the Ram and the Ford
are significantly updated for 2025.
The Ram especially, where it got
all those brand new powertrains,
including the one under the hood of the Rebel
that we're testing.
And if you want to know more details
about either the Ram or the Ford,
be sure to check out our big two truck comparison
that we did on these two earlier in the year.
Now the Chevy hasn't been updated in a few years,
so it definitely feels older
than both the Ford and the Ram,
and that's something that you'll have to keep in mind
if you do want to pick up a Silverado.
Up next, we're going to test out the articulation
and approach angles of each of these trucks,
and even though we don't have a ziggurat of integrity
out here to do it with, we do have this rock.
Now those two measures are very important for every truck
because they kind of tell you what you're able to get
on and over in terms of obstacles.
And while these trucks are up here,
we're going to get a chance to look at the underside
to see what kind of protection they have,
because no matter how careful you are off-road,
you might always hit something.
So we'll load in each of the trucks
and we'll drive them as far up the rock as they can go
until that rear tire comes off the ground,
and once it does, we stop.
So this is how far our Ram made it up the rock of integrity,
and while it was up here,
we got to get a pretty good look underneath,
and the underbody shielding is quite good.
All the things that you'd want to be covered are.
There are skid plates right behind the front bumper
and ones covering the transfer case and the fuel tank,
but if you want something like
full underbody belly protection,
you'll have to wait for the Ram RHO for that.
Now also, now that it's up here,
we can kind of get a look at the suspension,
and that is something that makes the Ram unique
among this set of competitors.
It's the only truck here with an air suspension.
We actually put this in its off-road mode,
which raises it up by an inch,
and that was the only way that we could actually
get the nose just high enough to get it onto this rock.
So now we've got the Ford up here,
and not only was it easier to load in,
it also went significantly further up than the Ram did.
Now, while it's up here,
we took a look underneath this one as well.
Skid plates in all of about the same places,
all the same things are covered.
Another thing that we really noticed,
the rear articulation on this truck
is so much greater than it was on the Ram.
This is a big part of why it was able to go up further.
As you can see, the travel that you get
out of this rear wheel is just so much more.
Now, a big reason for that is that the Ram,
that suspension, it might make it more comfortable
on the street, but it is less flexible.
This, with the traditional leaf springs,
you're getting a ton of flexibility,
and that's the reason that the Ford went as far as it did.
We've loaded in the Chevy,
and the results were a bit surprising,
because if you'd asked me before this,
I would have thought that it would have gotten
a bit further than the Ram,
somewhere between the Ram and the Ford,
because like the Ford,
it has that more traditional rear suspension
that should give it more flexibility.
But the Chevy is missing that lockable rear differential,
and as such, it sort of like lost traction.
This is as far as we were able to get it up,
just behind the Ram.
Now, underneath as well,
you're still gonna get a pretty good skid plate front,
and another one over the transfer case,
but the fuel tank protection
is missing a bit on this Chevy.
One other point, this vehicle,
we don't know if it has more rear articulation in it,
again, because it could be more flexible,
but we're just losing traction.
We couldn't get it up any higher to C,
and those are things that you're gonna have to watch out for
when you're driving off-road.
So that wraps things up for us here at the rock test,
and third was the Chevy,
and just beyond that was the Ram,
but this was a very clear and decisive win for the Ford.
Now, all three of these trucks
possess plenty of technology
that's going to help you drive off-road,
including surround view cameras,
but not all surround view cameras are created equal.
In the Ram, with its vertically oriented touchscreen,
the surround view camera
only takes up about the top third of it,
and the picture is pretty grainy,
but here in the Ford and in the Chevy,
that view takes up the whole screen and looks quite nice.
Now, there are two reasons
why I prefer the Ford's camera to the Chevy.
The first one is the front view in the Ford is much better.
It seems to be a bit higher resolution,
and it's got great guidelines
to show you exactly where those front tires
are going to be placed,
and the second reason is that the Ford
also comes with a dedicated camera button
right here above the screen,
so if you ever want to do get to that camera view,
it's really easy to do so.
Now, we've come to our final test,
and it's one of my favorites,
a quick run through a sandy wash,
and this will provide a stern challenge
for each of these trucks' power delivery,
suspensions, and traction control.
Now, the Ram, big change for 2025,
no more V8s,
and the optional engine for this truck
is now a pair of twin turbo straight sixes.
Now, here in the Rebel,
it's got the normal output version of that engine,
but there's nothing really normal about it.
Now, this is not my first rodeo with this new engine,
and in the previous times,
I've had nothing but good things to say about it.
It's just a great truck to drive around on the street.
Seeing that amount of metal
just flying down the straight,
really, really impressive,
and a huge endorsement of these new engines.
Immediately, I haven't even had to lock it
into any sort of gear,
just as soon as you put your foot into the throttle,
you're just met instantaneously with tons of power,
tons of torque.
The sand here is pretty soft and pretty deep,
so it would be easy for these things
to kind of get bogged down,
but this thing, no such problems at all,
and I never feel like the power's
really gonna run out either.
The sandy wash is pretty bumpy, though,
and I have to say that the suspension
is doing much better here
than it was on the hill climb.
I'm running it right now in normal mode,
because we don't really need all the clearance,
but I also ran it in off-road,
and in both settings,
it seems to be a lot more happy
in this sort of sandy running environment
than it does on a really rutted out, steep hill.
When the Ram really gets to let its powertrain shine,
that is when it is at its absolute best,
and, oh man,
this is just making me even more and more excited
for that Ram R8 show to come out,
because that's going to have
the even more powerful version of this engine,
and that thing is going to rip.
It's an absolute blast.
The Ram, it might have struggled
on those other two tests,
but here, here's where the Ram strikes back.
And now we have the Chevy with its diesel.
Now, the diesel,
it might have a bit more trouble
in this environment than the other two engines,
because while these diesels
provide great low-end torque,
when you get them up to speed sometimes,
they have trouble sort of maintaining the power.
Interestingly enough, though,
even though this is a diesel,
this doesn't have the most torque
of any truck in our test.
Its 495 pounds-feet comes in just behind the Ford,
which we're going to hop into next.
It's mated to a 10-speed automatic transmission,
and let's see if we're able to sort of
get that consistent hour output
that we're looking for to get through this sand.
The power output actually seems to be pretty consistent.
It's not really running out of breath.
I'm able to get enough power and torque
down to hang the tail out easily when I need to.
It's not quite as responsive
as what we had in the Ram.
That engine just kind of loved to rev
and get up really quickly.
This one, you kind of have to plan out
a little bit more,
but if you give it enough advanced warning
with the throttle,
the power delivery is pretty smooth.
Now, I will say this,
this suspension,
not as good as what we had in the Ram there.
Both of those trucks really bumped me around
a lot on the hill climb,
and I would say that here, though,
on the wash,
the Ram really sort of found itself,
and the Chevy,
it's still really, really bumpy,
and that's sort of the limiting factor here.
All of these bumps,
I do have to sort of lift or brakes to slow down for.
Otherwise, the impacts would be really,
really upsetting to the balance of the truck.
This diesel is quite good, I feel like,
for a diesel,
but still a diesel.
This thing is bouncy.
All right.
Now it's time to get the Ford to go,
which has done really, really well
in our last two tests.
Now, this F-150 Tremor
has the twin turbo 3.5 liter V6 under its hood.
There is a part of me that wishes
that it had that 5 liter V8,
because that 5 liter V8 sounds incredible,
but this engine doesn't cost you any more,
and even though it offers the same 400 horsepower,
it offers more torque.
So 510 pounds feet of torque,
and that's even more than that diesel engine
in the Silverado 1500 is making.
Oh, my goodness.
This thing.
Oh, man.
Even though this thing
shares that transfer case with the Raptor,
it did not adopt all of the Raptor's drive modes.
So unfortunately,
there's no Baja mode for me
to really send this thing through the sand.
However, even though there's no Baja mode,
this thing still seems like it really
likes to run through the sand.
The throttle response,
not quite as good as the Ram.
That thing is really,
has the best,
most engaging sort of throttle feel to it
out of all these trucks.
But I will say,
once this thing does get up and revving a bit,
it will really, really shoot you out of the corner,
and it's the most tail happy of the three.
I can really hang the back end out
if I want to with a lot of ease.
Now, given how well the Ford suspension did
on the hill climb
and the articulation and flexibility it showed
on the rock,
I had admittedly higher hopes for it
out here in the wash.
I do think that the Ram's ride
in this environment is actually still
a touch more composed than that of the Ford.
But I will say that the Ford is definitely
better than the Chevy in that regard.
Man, good job brakes.
Not quite as good at handling those impacts
as the Ram is.
I would say that here in the wash,
even though the Ford
proven itself to be pretty capable,
I think that first place in this exercise
definitely goes to the Ram
with the Ford in second,
and the Chevy bringing up the rear.
So after a long, windy day of testing,
we are here with the results,
and this was a very dominating performance
from the Blue Oval.
The Ford won two of our tests,
while the Ram took home the third test,
and the Chevy took home zero tests.
However, there's still plenty of things
to like about that Silverado.
It offers a value proposition
that the other two can't match,
and with that diesel powertrain,
you get plenty of torque
and also much greater fuel economy.
The Ram, the highlight of that truck
is that engine.
Now it struggled mightily on the hill climb,
but once it got into the wash,
where it was able to let its engine
off the leash a little bit,
the power delivery
and the throttle response,
the Ram really shone there.
But for me, the one that I would take home
and the one that performed the best out here
in the most environments,
is the Ford.
It has the best technology,
its powertrain is great,
and that suspension did a pretty good job
on the hill climb,
and it showed great flexibility on our rock.
Now each of these full-size trucks
proved to be pretty capable off-road,
but the fun part is,
each of them has a big brother,
which should be able to do even more.
So please like and subscribe
so you don't miss out
when we get the real big boys out here
to do all these tests all over again.
Thanks for watching.
We all done? We done?
Cool.
Who's going to get the trucks now?
Yeah, I guess it's me.
