Comanche archer were the only archers in history who could easily defeat firearms, but how did they do archery? Joe Rogan Experience suggested they did archery like me, but this is wrong! Comanche archery is a completely different and partially forgotten method.
There are many descriptions that they were incredibly good and very very fast, but no known method with the arrow on the left and arrows held in bow hand, is as fast as the Arabic method I usually use, where I only use one movement for each arrow.
So something was missing? Along with Dave Mead I started researching and testing. Eric Smith has been kind to tell his great-grandfather's experience of actually being shot after with arrows by Comanche which are written down and therefore confirm that they actually had 5 arrows in the air at the same time, when they were at war, and not just as games or the like. And a number of other descriptions are known of how extremely fast they shot arrows.
It is 150 years since this extreme horse archery war method was used in reality, so much knowledge has been lost
We talked to a lot of people including Comanche people for trying to recreate this archery.
With many experiments with all sorts of variation, no one was near fast enough because there were several movements needed for each arrow. I ended up, if the arrow is placed horizontally in the bow hand before or while shooting then you can shoot in one motion and it works really well and also on horseback. And if you do not use the arrows, they can easily be brought back in front of the bow in one movement
Of course, it is not possible to know whether this method is the real Comanche method but it works well and fits with equipment and works well on horseback and can do everything described in historical sources.
It is also impossible to know if there is only one Comanche archery method, or several different. Eric Smith told me he thinks so good archers they could both shot right and left around the bow and could use several methods, and this I think too.
But regardless of history, it's a really cool and fun way to do archery as other archers should try too and it is very easy to learn!!
Sincerely Lars Andersen
AI Generated·May contain errors
Our story starts in the middle of the last millennium where, over the course of a couple
of centuries, guns replaced bows. But there was an exception. One warrior culture had archers that
were so good that they defeated enemies with guns again and again. Their horse archers were one of
the main reasons the Spanish never conquered North America. The same Spanish conquistadors
who had defeated nation after nation had no chance against these fast-shooting warriors.
They kept the Spanish and Americans at bay until the second half of the 19th century,
where the development of the six-shooter pistol allowed the legendary Texas Rangers to come close
to matching their shooting speed. In fact, the revolver, as the six-shooter was called,
was developed because of these legendary horse archers. They were the Comanche.
Now, Lars Anderson looks at recreating their way of archery.
It all began with an episode of the Joe Rogan podcast.
Both the guest and Rogan were referencing Lars' system of shooting,
which was developed with inspiration from ancient Arabic and Asian sources,
and it's quite easy to come to the conclusion that the Comanche used the bow and arrow in the
same way. The two are not the same, however. As the Comanche hold their bows in the bow hand,
not the shooting hand, they also shoot left around the bow, and not right as Lars does.
Lars was arguably the first modern archer who discovered, or rediscovered, actually,
a way to shoot three arrows in 1.5 seconds, a way using just one movement instead of several.
No modern system of archery allows for the speed and accuracy we know the Comanches had while
simultaneously obeying the two premises of arrows in the bow hand and shooting left around the bow.
So, what did Lars do? To start out with, he teamed up with Dave Mead, who's half Native American,
and shares his passion for archery history. Dave did some tests of his own using Lars' theories
and came to similar conclusions, conclusions matched by the word of author and teacher Eric
Smith and notes taken by his grandfather. A distance of 300 feet, a Comanche could hit you
with an arrow if you stood still. But since you could see the arrow coming, you had time to get
out of the way. The only catch, you had to watch for the other three or four arrows that would be
following the first. And what my great-great-grandfather is saying there is that a Comanche warrior,
by the time he shot one arrow, he could have three or four more in the air before that first arrow
hit. I myself have not been able to replicate that, but as you will see in this video,
Lars, being a master archer, has practiced and will show you that this can be done.
Four or even five arrows hanging in the air, flying against an enemy, this is really fast.
And we have other similar descriptions, but we don't know any method with the arrows in a bow hand
and arrows on the left, who's nearly fast enough to do that. They needed to find a system that
will allow them to recreate Comanche horse archery. Now, Lars is no horseman, but since
the Comanche were probably the best light cavalry in history, he also needed to test what it would
be like to shoot from horseback. In other words, he needed a horse, but more on that in a moment.
As for the Comanche, they had gotten horses from the Spanish around 1650 and had quickly perfected
the art of riding and fast shooting, making them feared by both Spanish and indigenous tribes
alike. We know that their two main weapons were 14-foot spears and superb quality bows and arrows.
So Dave Meade built copies of historical weapons for Lars, and while they may look privative,
these Osage orange wood bows are both powerful and precise. They were originally meant for bison
hunting. Unlike modern arrows, which are standardized in length, the Comanche had
arrows of various sizes and draw lengths. They held their bows low using a short draw.
The Comanche held the bow with a thumbs-up grip and with a three-finger pinch grip,
sometimes while hanging from their saddles and using the horse as a shield.
This created a problem. Neither Dave nor Lars were aware of a method that would fit the facts
and allow for the ultra-fast shooting and for the occasional hanging from the side of a horse
that the Comanche practiced. There is a method that allows the archer to take the arrow around
the bow. This doesn't work while hanging from a horse, though, and also fails to produce the
needed speed. There's also another method, popular amongst horse archers, where you put the arrow
through the bow, so to speak, but this is extremely dangerous when done with sharp arrows,
and it also ends up being too slow. So while these two were both interesting,
they were obviously not the answer. Lars then started doing what he does best, experimenting.
It took many tests on his dummy horse, and even some on a real horse, before he found a method
that actually worked. It turns out that if you pre-load the arrows, not only can you achieve
the appropriate speed of shooting, you can also hang behind the horse with your draw hand free,
and if you end up not shooting your arrow, you can put them back in your bow hand.
This works well on horseback, and with the three-finger pinch grip, you do not have to
grip from either the left or right, but can grasp the arrow directly above the bowstring.
This meant that Lars could draw and release in one movement, thus allowing for more or less
the same level of speed shooting as he'd achieved with his own draw hand system.
The next step was clear, recreating Comanche feats of archery using this newfound system.
Here, history books came in handy, providing Lars with some goals to aim for.
For example, we know from history books that as boys, the Comanches shot coins out of the air,
three arrows in 1.5 seconds, and birds out of the sky. They were even known to be able to hit
insects. No wonder they became terrifying as adults. Obviously, you can't say this is the
real Comanche system, but it fits all the historical description and the equipment.
But perhaps most surprising to Lars himself was the fact that it's relatively easy to teach
newcomers to archery to shoot in this way. It turns out that this method of preloading and
drawing and shooting in one movement is something almost anyone can learn, and if that is truly the
case, that just makes the Comanche dedication to perfecting the style even more impressive.
Thanks for watching, and please like and subscribe.