Scientists Dropped This Plant 1000 Times

Explore trees and flowers
58 followers
Professor Stefano Mancuso has studied plant intelligence and consciousness for over 3 decades. His research found that plants are able to sense their surroundings, learn new things and even seem to have some form of consciousness. He has pioneered the field of plant neurobiology.
In this video, we look at how he came to these conclusions and what his work might reveal about intelligence itself.
#research #science #nature #plants #plantintelligence
AI Generated·May contain errors
This is Professor Stefano Mancuso. For over 30 years he has been studying plant behavior
and much of his work is centered around what he calls plant intelligence. When you first hear this
you're probably thinking that this sounds absurd. After all, plants don't even have brains or
anything that even resembles a nervous system. So how could they possibly have any form of
intelligence? Yet through decades of experiments he has found that plants are able to actively
sense their surroundings and adjust their behavior depending on what information they receive. He has
even found evidence for their capacity to learn. Now at this point most people would probably be
quite skeptical because how do you even go about proving any of this? Well let's take a look
together at how all of this first began. For as far as Stefano could remember he grew up in a
world full of plants and not just full in the conventional sense but rather his entire house
was flooded with plants where space for everything else was very limited. This was largely thanks to
his mother who absolutely loved plants and growing up in this weird world he slowly began developing
an interest for them too. At school when teachers show photos of different animals other kids would
ask about lions or elephants but he was always curious about the walls and walls of plants
in every photo. The plants that no one else seemed to see. This fascination stayed with him into
college where he began to study plants seriously and the more he studied them the more he was
fascinated by how they lived alongside us yet seemed to exist in a completely different world.
And as he was studying for his doctorate Stefano came across descriptions of how plant roots were
said to navigate obstacles underground. The literature at the time mentioned that a root
would first run into an obstacle then slowly feel its way around it in a series of little jumps.
This may not seem fascinating to others but it absolutely captivated him and he wanted to set up
an experiment to study this phenomenon. Little did he know this experiment would change his
perspective on plants forever. So next let's take a look together at what he found. Stefano's
experiment began with a very simple design. He would first place a large obstacle in the soil
before planting the seed of a bean plant directly on top. Next he would wait for the roots to grow
while taking notes on what he saw. As the days passed the roots grew closer and closer to the
barrier and just as he thought he was about to see them come into contact something unexpected
happened. The roots started growing sideways long before they encountered any kind of physical
resistance and this made him very angry because he wanted to observe the little jumps and he
couldn't figure out what he had done wrong and so he repeated the experiment again and again
and again. Over hundreds of experiments he tried different materials, different depths and yet
the roots always seemed to avoid the obstacle before ever encountering it. Until one day
it occurred to him that maybe he had been thinking about this all wrong.
It was in this moment that he truly fell in love with plants and he couldn't help but wonder if there was more to what plants were capable of than we gave them credit for.
Over the next several years Stefano spent long stretches in the lab running experiment after
experiment watching and learning how plants responded to the world around them and the more
he studied them the harder it became to see them as just passive things. He found that plants could
detect pathogens and pick up signals from their environment in ways we barely notice. Then one day
whilst he was observing a parasitic plant called the Cuscuta slowly reach for its host he saw
something that felt strangely familiar. The plant seemed to move as though it already had some sense
of where the host was even before making contact and that brought him back to the same mystery from
his doctoral work. How could a plant know what was around it without any of the senses we normally rely
on like sight or touch? This time he decided to pursue this further and see how far it really went.
See in previous situations one could argue that perhaps the host plant was giving off chemical
signals or that the roots were simply responding to conditions in the soil. So what happens when
you remove both those possibilities? He began by placing the seed of a bean plant in a small pot
at the center of his lab. Next he would place a metal support a few meters away. If the plant had
no idea of its surroundings then it should search randomly around the room. But let's take a look
together at what he found. This is footage from Stefano's lab. The footage is sped up over several
days but you can see that rather than searching randomly the bean plant seems to have a very good
idea of where the support is. And if you look closely the tip of the bean shoot has also
preemptively formed into a hook-like shape and all of this has happened before ever making physical
contact. Another try and it's not enough and you can almost feel the effort
and look at the leaves now that they reach the support how is much much
quiet, calm. Anyway so we know that the bean is aware of the pole.
Okay over the next few weeks Stefano repeated the experiment time and time again. He'll try
moving the support to different locations in the room but each time the bean plants always seem
to know where the support was. And before long a more complex question began to take shape
in his mind. Were the plants only detecting where the nearest support was or were they perhaps
capable of even more? See in the wild plants are rarely alone so would their behavior change if
there were other plants nearby? So for his next experiment he decided to place two plants side by
side with a support beam in between. If the plants were just detecting the nearest support they could
find then they should both grab onto the beam. But let's take a look at what Stefano found.
The first phase is what Stefano calls the sensing phase where they begin to detect what's in their
surroundings. Once they realize there's a pole they quickly try to move towards it but pay very
close attention to what happens when the first plant reaches the pole. Rather than latching on
the second plant suddenly changes direction instead. This you can repeat this experiment
100 times and 100 times you will have you will get the same result. So this means that the second
plant is not just aware of the support is also aware of another plant and is aware of what the
other plant is able to do. He would later repeat this experiment with plants that were either
related or unrelated and what he found was that when the plants weren't related the one that lost
would typically search for alternatives before giving up eventually. But if they were related
the two plants would instead share the support beam together. This type of kinship behavior has
also been found in similar studies across different plants by other scientists. This suggests that
they are not only aware of what's in their surroundings but are actively altering their
behavior based on the broader context of the situation itself. Now this is pretty amazing right?
And when Stefano realized this he started to think about what all of this really meant. Because if
plants were altering their behavior based on complex contextual information is it possible
that they may even have some form of intelligence? As the days went by this question kept coming up
in Stefano's mind. And one day as he was thinking about what intelligence really meant he came across
a talk by theoretical physicist Michio Kaku who described learning as one of the clearest signs
of intelligence. And that's when he had an idea. He wanted to try and teach a plant something new.
For this experiment he decided to use a plant called mimosa pedica. These plants have a very
unique defense mechanism. When physically disturbed they'll rapidly close their leaves in response.
So Stefano wanted to see if he could get the mimosa pedica plants to stop reacting to a
stimulus that had previously considered to be dangerous. To test this the plants were first
placed in small containers mounted on the vertical rail. They would then be lifted to a height of
around 15 centimeters which was a distance that had already been shown to reliably trigger leaf
closure without actually harming the plant. Next he would drop the plants from this height and
observe their behavior. And sure enough the plants would quickly close their leaves as expected.
He would then wait for the plant to reopen its leaves before repeating this again. By around the
fifth or sixth time he already started noticing a change in how the plants would respond with some
plants beginning to reopen their leaves more quickly. And the more he did this the more the
response from the plants weakened and eventually they stopped closing their leaves altogether.
Now those of you who are
perceptive might think well maybe the plants were just exhausted from closing their leaves so many
times. Stefano thought the same thing. So after dropping them hundreds of times he immediately
introduced them to a second slightly different stimulus. Instead of dropping them he would shake
the container lightly instead and this time the plants immediately closed their leaves. Stefano
believed that the reason why they're able to learn so quickly is because closing their leaves not
only takes a lot of energy it also reduces the amount of light they're able to absorb. So being
able to learn and differentiate between how dangerous different stimuli are would give them
a clear survival advantage in nature. But this raised a bigger question. If the reason for their
behavior is based on their need for light would their ability to learn vary if they were raised
in different environments? So for his next experiment Stefano would raise one group of
plants in a low light setting and the other with bright light. He would then put them through the
same training and what he found was very interesting. The group that was raised in the low
light environment would learn to reopen their leaves much quicker than those in the high light
environment. This suggests that in environments where resources are scarce the cost of closing
the leaves becomes much higher making it more critical to be able to quickly differentiate
when a stimulus was actually harmless. He would later switch the environments for the two groups
and let them sit for a while before testing them again. He suspected that the plants would be able
to quickly adapt to their new environment and exhibit the behaviors that the previous group did.
But what he found was even more interesting. Because while this was the case for the group
that was raised in bright light this wasn't the case for the low light group who instead retained
And this is fascinating because their learned behavior still proves to be especially useful
in the new environment because it now affords maximum foraging opportunity and it suggests
that the plants were able to distinguish between which learned behaviors would continue to be
useful. And not just that they were able to retain these learnings for almost two months.
Stefano's research showed that plants not only have some form of memory
but are even able to learn and quickly adapt their behavior to different stimuli.
But here's the thing plants don't have brains. So what exactly was making this possible?
And as Stefano pondered this question he wondered if they may have some kind of internal system
similar to our own that was allowing them to perform these complex behaviors.
All his life Stefano had been told that plants were just responding reactively to the world
around them. Yet his research findings over the years had shown him something very different.
From their ability to detect and change their actions based on what was around them
and even their ability to learn all of it pointed to the idea that there was something
far more complex inside these organisms. And that's when he had a crazy idea. In animals
anaesthetic can temporarily shut down the processes that allow an organism to perceive
and respond to its surroundings. So what happens if you give anaesthetic to a plant?
For this experiment he needed plants that would give off a clear visual signal
in response to stimuli and he chose five different plants. We will mainly focus on
our friend the mimosa pedica and the venus flytrap but all the plants ended up having
similar results. Let's first take a look at how the plants respond before any anaesthetic is applied.
This is the actual footage from the experiment that Stefano ran and you can see that both the
mimosa pedica and the venus flytrap respond almost immediately when they're touched. Next he would
create an anaesthetic solution and have this slowly evaporate and be absorbed by the plants
in a gas container. And then came the most important part. If the way plants worked was
anything like animals then they should no longer respond to stimuli. And when he tested this that's
exactly what he found. In this instance despite being touched repeatedly the plants don't have
any response. Finally he would remove the gas container and leave the plants alone to see if
they would recover over time. And it turns out that different plants would take different amounts of
time to fully recover. He later finds that their speed of recovery seems to be directly correlated
to their ability to produce action potentials which are brief electrical signals that cells
use to transmit information. The same type of signals that animals use to transmit information
through the nervous system. This suggests that how plants function may be far more similar to us
and other animals as Stefano believes that they may even have some form of consciousness itself.
Stefano has often wondered if we're too narrow-minded about how we perceive
intelligence. For a very long time we have tended to associate intelligence with things that feel
familiar to us. We try to look for a brain or the ability to make choices that look visible
and immediate. And in doing so we assume that if something is truly intelligent then it must act
in ways that resemble us. But plants suggest another possibility. That life can solve problems
in slower quieter ways. They don't display traditional signs of intelligence like birds
or dolphins and yet they've survived on this planet for hundreds of millions of years.
They've helped build the very atmosphere we breathe. They've even learned to harvest light
and have cooperated with fungi and bacteria to turn a once hostile world into one that could
sustain life like ours. To Stefano that is hard to describe as anything less than intelligence.
And over time he came to feel that this was too important to remain locked away in scientific
papers read only by other specialists. He wanted to bring this hidden world of plants into public
view which is why he began writing and speaking more publicly about his research. He has even
helped build and popularize the field of plant neurobiology and in doing so has become one of
the most outspoken and controversial public voices. Some critics felt he was going too far,
that his language was too provocative and too willing to blur the line between plants and
animals. But perhaps Stefano's point was never really about whether plants were intelligent
in the way that animals are but rather if we had made ourselves incapable of seeing intelligence
in any form that did not resemble our own. Because when Stefano looks out into the forest he sees a
vast quiet intelligence at work. A world that has been sensing and evolving all around us for far
longer than we have been here to notice it. And that is part of why Stefano believes we would be
Because if one day we hope to build a more sustainable future whether here on earth or
somewhere far beyond it then perhaps we should pay more attention to the very organisms that
have already spent hundreds of millions of years learning how to survive in even the most difficult
places. So the next time you walk through a forest or a garden or even just watering your own plants
It may be worth looking a little more closely
because the world around us may be far more active and alive than we were ever taught to see.
