Juan de Zurbarán's still life, lemons, and Spanish pride | National Gallery

Antique Masterpieces
23 followers
5 Video Views·Jul 21, 2026
What is the meaning behind this basket of citrus fruits? ‘Still Life with Lemons in a Wicker Basket’ by Juan de Zurbarán may look like a beautiful arrangement, but these everyday objects also have symbolic meaning. In this 10-minute film, art historian Siân Walters takes a closer look.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores Juan de Sorbarán's \"Still Life with Lemons in a Wicker Basket,\" analyzing its botanical details, religious symbolism, and technical execution. The presenter discusses the artist's life in Seville, his use of tenebrism, and the painting's journey from a private collection to the National Gallery.
This beautiful still life seems quite straightforward,
and yet it's a painting which raises some intriguing questions.
We don't know where it originally hung, nor who originally owned it.
The objects were clearly designed to be admired,
but also even possibly revered, like a religious icon.
Indeed, it's very likely that there are hidden depths of meaning to this masterpiece.
My name is Sian, and today we're going to be exploring
Juan de Sorbarán's still life with lemons in a wicker basket.
A large wicker basket weighs heavy with freshly picked lemons.
You'll see some of the branches, and glossy leaves are still attached.
These fruits were, and indeed still are, abundant in the city of Seville,
where Juan de Sorbarán lived from about the age of nine.
His father, the well-known painter Francisco de Sorbarán,
had moved from the region now known as Extremadura.
The warm climate of the south was perfect for the cultivation of lemons
and other citrus fruits, which had been introduced to the Iberian Peninsula
during Islamic rule.
The Muslim inhabitants of Islamic Spain had been present from the early 700s
until the late 1400s, leaving an incredibly important legacy,
which defines much of Spanish culture still today,
from science and literature to architecture and language and music and horticulture.
Lemons were prized as culinary delicacies
for the beauty and fragrance that they brought to gardens
and also for medicinal purposes.
There's something very meditative about this painting.
It's very calm, very still.
Everything seems to have been very carefully placed and arranged.
It's very balanced.
The arrangement is punctuated by two white roses,
a few red carnations and some sprigs of white lemon blossom
that we find here in the centre.
We can also see some blue delphiniums on the left
and then some orange day lilies
and just a single tulip which juts out from the top left-hand corner of the composition.
A branch of lemons has been placed to the right of the basket,
whilst on the left, a goldfinch perches gently on the edge of a porcelain bowl,
looking towards a single day lily flower,
whose petals are reflected in the smooth surface of the metal plate below.
There's only the tiniest suggestion of movement,
or I might say almost suspension of movement,
with a very, very small droplet of water on the tulip at the top.
And indeed, every time you look at the painting,
you'll notice another of these exquisite details,
like the pattern of deer with its head twisted on the porcelain cup
or the tiny, delicate feet of the goldfinch perched on the cup's edge.
So, how would this painting have been understood at the time?
Sorbaran Spain was a deeply devout Catholic country
and people would have been brought up with a well-established language of sacred symbolism.
So, for example, they would have understood
that the inclusion of the lily and the rose were symbols of the Virgin Mary.
Now, the lily that Sorbaran is actually showing us is a day lily,
or Hemerocallis fulve in Latin.
It was native to Asia but brought to Europe in the 1500s.
And it's called a day lily because its flowers just last for a single day,
so not only would this have been considered something very expensive,
but also we might interpret it as a vanitas,
in other words, something that reminds us of the brevity of life
and the inevitable passing of time.
Red carnations, well, they can symbolise love,
but they can also symbolise Christ's passion
because their colour was associated with Christ's blood.
The blue flower, that's called a larkspur in English,
but delphinium in Latin, coming from the word dolphin
because its flowers look like little fish.
So we could say that this could connect it
to the well-known Christian symbol of the fish.
For example, the flower appears in a famous manuscript
called the Très Rigeur around a miniature
which depicts the narrative of Christ feeding the 5,000.
We should probably add, however,
that Juan most likely didn't have all these flowers in his studio at the same time
because roses and carnations would bloom in summer
as opposed to the tulip, which is a spring flower.
So probably he would have modelled at least part of the composition using sketches.
And finally, on the subject of symbolism,
the little goldfinch, which can be identified by its distinctive red head,
is often seen as a symbol of Christ's passion.
Legend has it that a goldfinch flew down
to remove a thorn from Christ's crown
and was splashed with his blood, leaving a red spot on its plumage.
The cup of water is associated with the purity of the Virgin Mary
and the lemon blossom in the centre has five petals
so we could perhaps say that this symbolises the five wounds of Christ.
But I think the work also reflects or symbolises great national pride.
Lemons and other citrus fruits were grown locally
but then proudly exported and thought of abroad as items of very great luxury.
This can be seen in other paintings in the National Gallery.
For example, the much earlier Arnolfini portrait by Jan van Eyck
includes a wealthy married couple living in Bruges
and if you look closely you'll see just a few oranges on the chest
and the window ledge on the left-hand side
which were symbolic of the couple's great wealth.
Juan de Sorbarán's painting, on the other hand, is overflowing with them.
Now, Seville was an incredibly important centre of trade and commerce
so it would have imported luxury items as well
and the cup that we see here is a very, very beautiful example
of Chinese porcelain from the Ming Dynasty's Wanli period
and there's actually an example of this bowl in the Museo Naval in Madrid.
It's very likely that the Sorbarán family had one in their workshop
because a very, very similar example appears in a painting
attributed to Juan's father, Francisco.
The single tulip is also a symbol of great affluence
and would have been considered very much a luxury item.
In fact, in Juan's day in the Dutch Republic
we know that a single tulip bulb exchanged hands for the same cost as a house.
Still lifes, much like landscapes, were very popular with collectors
and they allowed artists like Juan de Sorbarán
a chance to test their observational skills
exploring how contrasts of light and shadow define form
or how they create different textures
from the knobbly pith of the lemon
to the beautiful smooth surface of the metal plate underneath.
They were also a chance for an artist to experiment with how objects were lit
Balance and structure and depth could be controlled
through the manipulation of light or composition
breathing life into otherwise still objects.
Here Sorbarán sets everything against a very, very plain, dark, rich background
with a very brilliantly lit foreground
making all the flowers and fruits stand out
almost with a sculptural clarity or hyper-realistic presence.
This technique is known as tenebrism
coming from the Italian word tenebroso meaning dark or gloomy
which gives the painting a really dramatic clarity
so the objects almost, you might say, feel like actors on a stage
spot-lit very brilliantly and effectively.
In this case, the light is coming from the front left
casting shadows from left to right.
Now, tenebrism is certainly a technique that he would have learnt
from his father Francisco who applied it to his religious compositions
like this image of St Francis in meditation
in which the saint is plunged into darkness
or also his still lifes like this cup of water and a rose.
And the cup of water and a rose has a lot in common
with the left-hand section of the painting that we're looking at today
a cup filled with water
the reflection of a single flower in a metal surface
and also this great sense of stillness and quiet intimacy.
I think it's also interesting to know that the cup of water and a rose
has a really beautiful authentic period frame
which the head of framing at the National Gallery, Peter Schade
used as the basis for creating a new frame
for the Juan de Sorberán painting when it came to the collection.
However, although there are similarities between these paintings by father and son
there's also a key difference.
The younger Sorberán has created a painting which is much larger than life
in fact it measures over a metre in width.
Although we don't know who originally owned the painting
we can imagine it having an incredibly impressive impact
on the wall of the home of a wealthy collector
perhaps with the source of light coming from a window on the left-hand side
mirroring the source of light in the painting.
And its size alone tells us that it would have been very expensive to buy.
Juan de Sorberán was very well off by the time he painted it
in part thanks to marrying spectacularly well.
His wife was a wealthy young woman from Seville called Marianne de Cuadros.
Juan seems to have enjoyed the finer things in life.
We know that he learnt how to dance for example
now dancing was an aristocratic or courtly pursuit
so associated with the nobility.
And he even wrote a sonnet in honour of a man called Juan de Esquivel Navarro
who wrote a famous treatise on dance called Discourses on the Art of Dancing.
And published in 1642 part of this treatise says
let him who is of good taste dance
for it is neither right nor fair that he who is noble born
should in this skill be contrary
for the knight seems but a squire if he is not inclined to dance.
Unfortunately Juan seems to have squandered most of his large wedding dowry
because in his father-in-law's last will and testament
written just a few years later
he mentions that Juan had already spent most of it.
Sadly the painter's career was cut short when he lost his life
during a devastating outbreak of bubonic plague
that struck Seville in June 1649.
The pandemic claimed about half of the city's population
and this is one of the reasons that we have so few works by him.
And another reason is that his work was actually also later overshadowed
by that of his father.
Indeed some of Juan's own paintings were later attributed to Francisco.
And interestingly Juan was only rediscovered in 1938
when a painting in Kiev previously considered a work by his father
was cleaned and it was found to have Juan's signature.
Since then a small body of his work has been established
and this painting was rediscovered in 2015 in a Spanish private collection
before being acquired by the National Gallery in 2017.
We're so fortunate to have this jewel of a painting in the National Gallery collection.
It's the only known work by Juan de Sorberán in a British public collection
and one of just a handful of fully attributed works by the artist.
But watch this space as I'm sure that more will be discovered in years to come.
