Understanding ICE-related data searches

Fox - Fox 9
44 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 20, 2026
Welcome back. Well, in a Star Tribune investigation published today, they found
that Minnesota license plate camera data was accessed by outside law enforcement agencies
for immigration-related searches. Here to talk about the privacy around these cameras,
most commonly referred to as flot cameras, Harry Moggins from Privacy Bee joins us now.
Harry, thanks for coming back on the show. Thank you.
So we've talked about this a lot here, these flot cameras. What's your biggest concern
when it comes to privacy? That's a very loaded question. So there's a lot of concerns, right?
At the end of the day, these cameras are, you know, you have tens of thousands, I think it's
60 or 80,000 cameras around the country capturing your license plate and details about your car.
There is a flock product called Flocknova, where they connect that car data to data broker
information to pull down your name, your address, your hobbies, all kinds of behavioral data about
what you're researching online, and a lot of other scary information. And obviously,
as it's breaking in the news right now, this camera surveillance network is being accessed by
ICE, and they're using it for immigration-related searches, which opens a whole can of worms of
privacy compliance. All right, so this Star Tribune report found that about 30 state, county,
and federal agencies here in Minnesota searched the license plate data in at least eight Twin
City suburbs for immigration enforcement just between November and March. Are they allowed to
do this? So if a city puts in flock cameras, is ICE allowed to access that information, and can
Yes and no. So Flock has a public stance. They do not work with ICE, and that is true on the surface
level. What they're not telling you is Flock works with all kinds of different police departments,
and when you have any kind of law enforcement contract with Flock, it gives them access to
that network. What it doesn't do is restrict their sharing with other jurisdictions or with
federal level in certain cases. So what we're seeing here with these audits is Flock is going
to the actual police station or the police departments, and then ICE's relationship with
that department is allowing them to lean on the department and say, hey, can you give us access
to do a search for this plate or this geospatial query, whatever it is they're trying to look up.
And once that information is retrieved by the local police, it's shared with ICE because of
data sharing agreements, and Flock can say, I had no knowledge of that. I just saw the police
department running a query. So they're kind of arm's length from it while still facilitating
what everybody's scared of. So is the issue here the storage of the data, the fact that they collect
the license plate data, and then they store it? Storage is a concern. The bigger concern is the
interconnected nature of this surveillance network. What's happening here is they're able
to tie together so many data points, and they're selling this data so freely without the guardrails
in place that they send it to a police precinct, and they're not saying you can't use it for
anything outside of crimes in your jurisdiction, or you can't share it with others. It's a private
company selling a contract to the police. So that's what's piqued the interest of lawmakers,
of finding ways to create these guardrails and restrict where the data is being used and how,
because the positive side, Flock is catching some criminals. There are some good case studies
coming out of it. But in my personal opinion, I don't believe it's worth the egregious privacy
violations that are accompanying this new technology. So Flock says it does not work
directly with ICE, and DHS says it doesn't have a contract with Flock. So how are they
getting this info? They're just doing it through the local police departments that do have accounts?
Exactly. So the police departments have the accounts with ICE, and there's so much data
sharing done between departments and between the local and the federal level. It's relatively
routine for the police departments to receive requests from ICE or from the FBI or from some
federal agency, and they regularly field these. In the audit that went through, a large percentage
of the local police-run searches were done through these local federal sharing agreements.
What's not being well-regulated is in these agreements, there's supposed to be a specific
anchor to an active investigation. The police departments aren't always checking to see if
active investigation is real, or if it's too vague of a request, or if it's just not there at all.
And they're doing it because it's what they're used to. If they get a request, they serve it.
So these are the guardrails we really need to solidify to understand the flow of information.
And while ICE is saying they don't work for Flock, they seem to find their way to get access to quite
a bit of Flock data. So there's a lot of concern that people's movements are being tracked
using this Flock data. Is that a violation of privacy?
I think it's a violation of human rights. Unfortunately, in the U.S., there is no national
privacy law, so it gets a little bit fuzzy and gray. The reality is it's not just tracking your
car and the position. They have so many cameras. Again, I believe it's 80,000 across the country,
with a high concentration in certain states. Minneapolis is a pretty high concentration
of these Flock cameras. When you have that many data points coming in,
Flock's able to piece together not just simple point-in-time data, like you're on this road at
12.03 p.m., but they can create a timeline. They can see what church you go to on Sunday.
They can see what friend's house you're driving to. They can see your work habits of when you
are coming home. They can map this out to create a pretty invasive dossier on your lifestyle and
your habits. Then when they combine that with Flock Nova, they know not just the car's habits,
but the person, the family, the household. They know immigration status in a lot of cases. They
know your sexual proclivities, your sexual orientation. They know what grocery store
you shop at, if it's Kroger or Publix or whatnot. They know so much about an individual.
If it's used in the pursuit of catching criminals, it's a great story. But the reality is the privacy
is completely unguarded. There is no guardrails right now at all. When you have that level of
exploitation and such a wild, wild west regulation of sharing the data, it does, again, question
that human rights of, is this too far? I believe it is. What do you say to the people who say,
the benefits outweigh the risk? This is resulting in a lot of bad criminals getting caught and
getting locked up. It outweighs the risk. I understand that perspective because I believe
catching criminals is a great thing. The technology has proven it is effective at that.
The conversation should not be, is it good at solving crime? The conversation should be,
is there sufficient guardrails to protect those not involved in the crime, to protect the innocent
individuals who have no connection to the active case they're working? Those guardrails are the
real question. That's where legislators really need to step up and enforce where the data can
be shared, how it can be shared. I think most importantly, the fact that it should just be the
data intended to be collected, like the vehicle data, it should not be connected to the data
broker ecosystem and building that complete profile of the individual beyond their car.
That's where it starts getting pretty aggressive in the privacy exploitation.
We do have a few communities here in Minnesota who have ended their contracts
with Flock due to these privacy concerns, including Brooklyn Park and Columbia Heights.
Harry Moggins, cybersecurity expert and CEO of Privacy Bee, thanks for joining us.
Thank you so much.
