Yankees Need Help on Offense at the Trade Deadline | Pinstripe Post

New York Post - Sports
11 followers
1 Video View·Jul 20, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe New York Yankees are navigating a critical period marked by a stagnant offense and injuries to stars Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton. While their pitching leads the league in ERA, the lack of run production puts immense pressure on the defense. The team must now decide whether to prioritize bullpen depth or acquire a powerhouse bat before the trade deadline to avoid a late-season collapse.
I think at some point you can say, well, we believe in the group and they'll hit.
It's been a long time.
They have scored more than five runs once in the last 27 games.
Once in the last 27 games, Ryan and Joel.
That is putting extreme pressure on that good pitching.
It's a drive by Debbie Dawson.
Charles Chisholm goes deep.
Hello. Welcome to the Pitch Straight Post.
We're back.
Joel was off for the all-star break, but we're back.
The Yankees play the start of their second half.
A three-game set against the Dodgers.
They lose two out of three to the Dodgers.
And we're excited to be talking baseball again.
Joel, I hope you got to enjoy some time off.
And as always on a Monday, how are you doing today, sir?
Good.
Up here at MLB Network, got a couple of shows this morning.
Then I'll be back at the Yankees tonight.
I was at the doubleheader yesterday.
So a lot of baseball in about a 48-hour period.
But I certainly wanted to see the marquee matchup of the Dodgers and Yankees.
And in a perverse way, I got two games that I wasn't expecting.
I was only expecting to cover the finale.
So I saw a lot of it.
And so let's dive into it.
It's obviously a moment where...
Why don't we dive into it instead of me soliloquying on it.
So what's on your mind?
Look, I think, Joel, there's a lot on Yankees fans' mind.
We're three weeks away from the trade deadline.
We know how the Yankees want to attack.
At least we think we do from all the reporting that you have done and others.
But before we get into the trade deadline stuff,
I want to talk about what we saw over the weekend.
I think fans like myself are really curious what you have to say
because I know everything has been so focused on the bullpen
and pitching and pitching and pitching of the Yankees.
They have strong pitching, but the bullpen needs to be fixed.
But I got to be honest with you, Joel.
With Judge, the news that we got before that series started
that there was some healing, but it's not fully healed
and he still has time to go before he can be cleared for baseball activity.
He's not anywhere close to returning.
I don't know when Stanton's coming back.
So the reinforcements you want for your lineup are not going to be there,
the big bats.
This lineup, as it's currently constructed, does not hit.
It just doesn't.
So I'm curious, do they need to be more aggressive
at that lineup?
And ultimately, what are you seeing right now from this lineup
from one through nine?
Yeah, Ryan, well there's a lot there.
I assume that we'd be tackling this a lot
because it's so clearly...
So let's start with a few things.
Number one, I think early on,
multiple shows early on in Judge's injury,
I kept saying to you,
don't expect him for a long time.
This idea of, like, oh, he has an injury.
It is much more a football injury than a baseball injury.
He's a very big guy who does things with great force.
You know my rule when it comes to injuries in general
and injuries with the Yankees,
who are a little squirrely, always about injuries,
is I'll believe a guy's playing when a guy's playing
as opposed to whatever your projected timeline is.
I have some real doubts about Stanton playing this year.
Again, just his injury history,
the fact he's re-injured himself,
the fact that he appears to me the second time through
doing very little.
When I see it, I'll believe it.
I will take the Yankees at face value
that Judge will play again this year,
but play again on August 15th, September 1st, September 15th.
They're going to have to win a lot of games without him,
even if the goal is to make sure he's upright for the playoffs.
First off, you have to make sure you get in the playoffs.
I understand that's still a 90% likelihood,
but it was a 90% likelihood of the Mets
at about this time last year also.
They kind of went into a nosedive
at about the same time the Yankees did,
and they couldn't quite pull themselves out.
The Yankees' run prevention, at least from the pitcher's mound,
is very good.
They lead the major leagues in ERA.
I want to repeat that.
The New York Yankees lead the major leagues in ERA.
They actually have formed,
for all the talk we've done about the bullpen,
they have formed a four-man unit,
Bednar, Cruz, Paul Blackburn, and Hedrick.
By the way, it's only five games,
but am I curious about Ángel Chivite?
I am.
He's been really good.
I expect we're doing this on Monday morning.
The Yankees had to use their A bullpen so much
to win a game in the second game
that if they need a guy tonight,
even though Chivite also pitched some extended yesterday,
that he's going to get the ball again tonight.
They're not in a great bullpen situation today
because of the doubleheader.
You simply can't give the ball to Camilo Duval
in any situation pretty much
except for up big or down big.
They got some stuff today.
I still think as a baseline, Ryan,
as of yesterday,
the Yankees very much are,
add at least one or two bullpen ons
and add a righty hitting catcher.
That is, I feel like, if you said,
I would say that's par.
Now, what else do they have to do?
I think at some point you can say,
well, we believe in the group and they'll hit.
It's been a long time.
They have scored more than five runs
once in the last 27 games.
Once in the last 27 games, Ryan.
That's insane, Joel.
That is putting extreme pressure
on that good pitching.
We saw it with Garrett Cole on Friday night
where it's like, Cole's best start
since coming back from Tommy John surgery.
We could talk about, should Buhnelk let them in?
Should Welch challenge the pitch?
Ultimately, they scored one run.
They scored one run on two errors.
It was an unearned run.
Could they have won a game?
Here's what I would say,
encouragingly from the weekend.
Cole pitched great and the Yankees
overall held the Dodgers to two runs.
In game one yesterday,
while Schlittler was really,
we saw why the Dodger lineup
is so much better than the Yankee lineup,
is they forced a really good pitcher
with good stuff yesterday.
Schlittler had good stuff.
I mean, Pahez fouled off
eight two-strike pitches
in his first two at-bats yesterday.
The Dodgers fouled off 15 two-strike pitches
in the first three innings.
They just worked the hell out of Schlittler
and got him out of the game.
Having said that,
until the ball got to Jake Byrd
and Camilo Duval,
it's a 3-1 game through seven innings
of guys who you expect to be on a
postseason pitching staff,
and Byrd isn't on the pitching staff anymore,
and I'd be surprised if you see him
the rest of the year
unless there's dramatic injury.
I assume Duval will not be
on the pitching staff on August 4th
when this is all said and done.
So they held him three,
and then they held him to one run
with a really, you know,
like Boone decided,
and this says something about his offense,
the Yankees are down 3-1
going to the top of the eighth yesterday.
And Boone decided not to chase him
with his offense
and go to any of his A relievers
with a second game to go.
And he was hoping and praying
that Byrd and Duval could do something
for him to the finish line
to keep them close
so if somebody bops a two-run homer,
you got a shot.
And then all of a sudden,
like I think if they did,
then all of a sudden you'd see
Cruz and Bednar, etc.
The next game,
that is really,
I know a lot of Yankee fans
spent a lot of time early this season
talking about why Ryan Yarborough
and Paul Blackburn are on the team.
But Paul Blackburn has been
one of the 15 best relievers
in the American League this year.
It's been a revelation, Joel.
And Ryan Yarborough gives them
major league extended depth
when it's needed.
Like, is it perfect?
Again, do I think Ryan Yarborough
has at best a 50-50 chance
of being on the roster on August 4th?
Yeah, I think that's it.
But Blackburn has become Luke Weaver.
He's a guy who was a starter
who they brought into the bullpen
and has been really good.
And the Yankees held the Dodgers
for one run.
So it's two runs on Friday night
for a really good Dodger lineup.
Three runs until you bring in two guys
who aren't going to be part of the staff
on August 4th.
And one run yesterday
with the best of your relief group.
And Ryan Yarborough really doing a good job
to get into the third inning
and stay away from having to bring
Elmer Rodriguez into the game
for length, which was the plan
if Yarborough can do it.
So the optimistic view of the weekend
is, hey,
the Dodgers are kind of like
the elite team in the sport
and the Yankees'
better pitchers, not named DeVollenberg,
held them down all weekend.
They did a great job.
Now the bad news is
the Dodger pitching
held the Yankees down to a higher level
even.
And usually I would say,
well, the Dodgers are really good pitching staff
except for, again, they have scored
more than five runs once in the last 27 games
against all different kinds of pitching.
And so, like,
I don't see it as, hey, a weekend
problem or a Dodger problem
or a short-term problem.
They...
Now, I don't know what...
There is no magic potion out there
if Cody Bellinger isn't going to hit.
Cody Bellinger's in a period where he had
more RBIs in the All-Star game
than he has in the last three weeks.
Right? And so his at-bats
were a little better yesterday, I thought.
And so is he
coming out of it?
Has Paul Goldschmidt
been played into
oblivion at 37 because
they needed him too much?
You know,
Jas Chisholm literally said after the second game
yesterday, I've sucked the sheep.
And so, to me,
can I talk about this
in a larger way, Ryan?
Paul O'Neill
once said something during the
great Yankee run.
He said, when you win a championship, everybody
had a good year.
And what he meant by that is when you win,
you go back and you're like,
hey, remember that night that Jas
hit the homer and kind
of stopped us from being swept
by the... In other words, you'll
find the reason to say Jas Chisholm had a good
year. I do feel
some of these Yankees, if it is
capable, they're capable of doing it.
Chisholm. Austin
Wells.
Caballero.
Ryan
McNair. Like, you've got
to in some way brainwash yourself. The
season starts today. There's
no way to pretty up some of these numbers.
Like, Jas was talking 50-50.
He can't get to 30-30.
But you know what? What's it matter?
If you... If we
remember that post-All-Star game
for the other four to five
or six weeks they played without Judge,
that Chisholm got hopped,
or that Bellinger got
hopped, or that Goldschmidt
refound himself, or Austin Wells remembered
he's allowed a hit in the major leagues,
or Caballero, you know,
started having better at-bats, or
Anthony Volpe, or fill in the blank.
They have two guys. An opposing
coach said something recently to me that
really stuck out. He said, when we face the Yankee
lineup, this version of it, he said,
besides Trent Grisham and Ben Rice,
nobody drags an at-bat deep
and makes us, forces us into the zone,
and we feel we could win
in the zone against the other guys.
Like, those are the two hard at-bats
in the lineup right now. Well, you're not
going to win if your two hard at-bats
are Ben Rice and Trent Grisham
exclusively. You've
got to get more than that.
I still believe that Bellinger
will be part of that. That
would get you to three. Can you get to five
or six? I'm not sure with this group.
I don't think you can, so I think
the expanded thing that you're saying right
here, Joel, sorry to interrupt, but
the thing that you're saying here
is all pointing to where I'm
trying to point this discussion a little bit, like
I got you. The two relievers
that they need to get at the deadline and a right-handed
catcher makes sense, but should they
be prioritizing a big-time
bat? And I don't know who it is. I don't.
I know I'm being
like that Yankees fan,
Ryan, go find that big bat on the store.
I got it, but at the end of the day,
what you're saying right now and
everything that's happening, the evidence that we're
seeing, they don't have enough in the lineup
to win, and I don't know even if with
a banged-up judge that you don't know what he's going to
be when he comes back and who the hell knows what
Stanton's going to be when he comes back. They don't
have enough in this lineup to actually
win. Does that make
sense, Joel? Should they be prioritizing
a big-time bat? I hear what you're saying.
So, Ryan, let's take that into two seconds.
Yeah. If Aaron Judge
does not come back and come back well,
the Yankees are not winning the World Series.
100%. Okay, like
they can do, they can have the greatest
deadline in the history of baseball.
Like, they need
Aaron Judge. They, everything
feels different. If you've noticed,
they've been unplugged in the first inning
for like two months. They used
to be a first-inning, take-the-lead thing.
They go down 1, 2, 3, and 10 pitches
now almost every game.
And, you know, we're talking about a guy, Judge,
has a career. He had
over 90 homers in the first inning. He has
over a 400 on-base
percentage in the first inning. So, like,
you hardly ever got a 1, 2, 3
first inning against the Yankees to
open. Like, they always put some
duress on the pitcher, and
Judge could put points on the board right away.
And I thought one of the
real
positives about Trent Grisham is
Trent Grisham's eye is so good,
he would draw walks in front of
Judge. Like, leading
off a game. And I'm like,
if I'm an opposing pitcher, I don't care
if I have to throw an underhand to Trent Grisham.
I don't want to put a guy on base in front
of Judge to open the game.
Like, and possibly be down
to nothing before I even really breathe.
So I always thought that was a real positive about
Grisham. And so, that
So let's deal
If the Yankees trade a lot at this
deadline to try to win,
I would really then believe Judge
is coming back, and they believe Judge is coming
back in full. Because I've got to think they
believe that if they don't get Judge
back, nothing they do in the
next two and a half weeks, two weeks or so
to the deadline is
really going to matter on a championship
level. So, like, let's take that. They need
Judge. Having said that,
I think that
you know, like,
Ryan Jeffers' name has been thrown around
a lot. Our
colleague John Heyman
recently wrote that the A's would at least talk
about Shea Langeleers.
Like, they've got to get more
production out of catcher.
And I thought that Austin
Wells caught a
genius game in the second game of the
doubleheader yesterday. When you want to say
what is his value, like
the five different pitchers
he had an umpire behind the plate.
I've seen Jordan Baker umpire a few times
this year. He misses a lot of calls,
so you've got to have a catcher who's really
on top of it, and he stole
a lot of strikes for the Yankees, Austin
Wells, by challenging some real borderline
stuff and turning some counts
around. I thought he did
great. It's what he's one of the better defensive
catchers in the league.
He had a couple of homers before the break.
He hadn't been
when you and I talk positively about him
in years past as an offensive player,
it was because he was constantly getting
into good counts, among other things.
Do I say, like
he hadn't walked in like three
weeks before he drew two walks
yesterday. So,
are the homers and the two
walks breadcrumbs that,
because again, Ryan, there's no
way for that guy to make the final numbers
on his season look good this year.
But from second half
forward, can he
have a 720
OPS? 720?
That would only bring him to probably like
600 for the season.
But a 720 OPS where he pulls
a couple of balls into the seats and draws
some walk and lengthens innings
and puts the rest on the other.
The term Boone kept using
yesterday is we're not having heavy at-bats.
And heavy at-bats mean to me like
even if you make an out, you drag the
count to three and two, you hit the ball
hard, which all of that
messages to the next at-bat.
It puts work on it.
The Yankees are being too
easy at the plate. They're not scoring runs
and they're making it, it's like the
fifth inning and you look up and you go, wow,
the Yankees have one base runner in five
innings. The opposing pitcher's thrown
47 pitches. It's
too easy. And so
like from here
forward, can some of their more talented
players, and I do think Chisholm
and Wells stand out because I think
they're talented. I think
Chisholm is super talented.
I don't know that he can
concentrate fully for long periods of
time. I don't know that he
kind of like can do it, but he
has so much at stake with free agency
coming up and whatever will be
remembered about him as a Yankee.
And I don't think he's afraid of the moment because
he's had a lot of big moments this year within
a bad year. He's had big
hits for that. And so
I just think they need a couple
of these guys.
And while I agree with you,
I think they have to find a bat.
I think it's really tricky. I think
every team is looking for it.
I think that the
jumble of teams that are
close in the American League
is making it more problematic
to find it.
The Astros are doing a lot of losing
now. With the
Astros, again,
their history, their owner has
said we'll never trade.
We'll never trade at the deadline.
We're not a seller.
They're really bad right now
and they just might be really bad.
And they just traded McCullers too?
Well, McCullers was a salary dump for them
because they included somebody
who the other team liked.
That's a salary dump. They think
addition by subtraction because it was hard
to disrespect the guy who had won a
couple of championships with them. He hadn't
been pitching well and Milwaukee wanted
the other guy,
Gordon, and the price was to take on
$2 million on McCullers.
That was salary dump and something
else there. But would Jeremy
Pena ever get in the market?
I think the Yankees would have to think
seriously about it if he did. Would
Houston even deal with the Yankees?
How many teams would do it?
I think a lot of the other stuff is pie
in the sky. I don't think the
Yankees and Mets can make a big trade.
I don't think Francisco Lindor
is getting traded at the deadline.
I know there's
a lot of Rafael Devers stuff.
The Yankees
I don't think want to
lock up the
DH spot in that way
because I think it's
a Ben Rice, Stanton,
whatever. You've got to be careful
about adding too many used players.
Plus, you don't know what the financial
rules are moving forward.
The financial reasons I would understand
what you're saying there for the Devers.
The part I would argue back with you is that
I know Ben Rice is the worst defensive
player compared to Goldschmidt, but Goldschmidt
has given you absolutely nothing offensively
the last couple weeks. And who knows?
He might have had his little spurt.
But you have to add, for Paul Goldschmidt
not, forgive me because I don't have it in front
of me, but I think that Devers has roughly
eight years left at about $250 million.
Like a lot of money.
He has proved to be
a problematic player
in two places who
once the season was over for the
Giants this year, now he's hidden.
And I just think
that this is the moment where
we make bad decisions in
relationships all the time, including our
baseball relationships.
Rafael Devers is as distressing
asset as there is in the sport.
There's a lot
of years left for a non-
who does the opposite of help you
in a clubhouse, who
has battled weight issues
and to solve a short-term problem
for the rest of the season.
I could, like Ryan, if you're
really sitting in a front office, can
you really turn to your owner
and general manager and say, I recommend
this player who for most
of the last three years,
since he got his money, has been
mostly a disaster, but
is so talented that he's going to hit
some. This year he started
hitting once the season was over.
I just can't
recommend that. If Rafael Devers
was a free agent at the end of the season,
I would say hold your nose
and go do it.
But you've got to live with him for
seven more years. You're just going to
repeat whatever the back end of
A-Rod was, whatever the back end of
Stanton is. You're just going to do that
because this second you're uncomfortable.
And you're going to lock
up DH for a long time
when the reality is, watching
Ben Rice play first bases, he's
probably got to be the DH a lot.
And there's going to be
the fact that every time Judge gets hurt
in right field, you say, shouldn't there be
50 DH games a year for Judge,
especially once Stanton is gone?
And so I am not
going to create a 2027
to 2033 problem
just because
I have an itch today. That is not
how I would do it.
Again, if he was
a free agent at the end of the year, that's a
different situation.
But he's one of the
most distressed assets in the sport.
Again, I'm not sitting
with his contract in front of me, but
I'm guessing right. It's 1, 2,
3, 4, 5, 6, 7.
He's got seven years after this.
Okay, seven
and 7,
like, let's say,
$210 million. Does he make $30 million a year?
He makes $33 million a year
for the next four years
after this, and then it goes to $31
to two years after that.
So it's seven years
of $32 million, so it's roughly
$7 to $220 million.
If Rafael Devers was a free agent after
this season, what would he get? He wouldn't get
that.
He wouldn't get in that ball.
We don't know the financial
rules, but let's say the financial rules
are roughly the same. He might
get, like, four years
at one time, considering
what Blake has done to him.
So his contract is under water
by over $100 million.
Can you really turn to your owner
in good conscience and say,
hey, I have an itch that needs
to be scratched today. Can you take on
$100 million in
dead money, understanding
what you had to deal with on the back
end of A-Rod, what you had to deal with on the back end
of Seth. By the way, after
A-Rod, Yankee officials
said, we'll never do a 10-year contract.
We'll never do a contract like that again.
It took them less than a year
to go get Stan.
And now they're sitting and
probably saying, man, there were a lot
of opportunity costs.
Think about the things,
and hopefully we're doing
this show in 2027, 2028,
2029. We go, yeah,
we'd love for the Yanks to be able to spend the money
to do this, but
maybe there's a salary cap. And you have
Rafael Devers on your books.
Ryan, I
get how sexy the name is,
but that guy has been a problem
for two franchises
now, and he just started
hitting when the games didn't matter,
he's not
in shape constantly. He's
zero benefit to a
clubhouse. In fact, the other way, I just
can't imagine
that
are the
Giants going to eat $100 million?
Probably not.
What about his teammate
Luis Arias?
Oh, well, yes.
He's a free agent at the end of the year.
If you do a rise, you do
have to give up Chism.
Unless you're putting a rise
at first base, which he said he desperately
doesn't want to do,
would he do it in a
pennant race? Maybe, and you're
playing a rise at first, rises
your DH. If you
make that move,
and I would seriously
consider that one,
I would seriously consider that one, especially
if you can make multiple moves
where Jazz is moving out and a rise
is the second baseman. I think the Yankees
are better that way. But
even if a rise becomes your first
baseman in that situation, you
are committing, and I think this is fine
because the mystery around Stanton
is the mystery around Stanton, that Stanton
is no longer playing for you,
at least this year. Because Rice
has to be the DH.
Rice has to be the DH. He's
earned at-bats every day.
So if you lock yourself,
that's why I would probably try to stay
away from the first base one
just on, because I
want to, I know I could
always DH Rice and feel comfortable.
I think there might have,
what if part of the judge
thing is there has to be some DH?
Sure. Yeah, makes sense.
You know, like,
so I would like to solve
this second, short,
third,
like, can I find a player there
who's offensive? That's why I keep bringing up
Pena, because I get the best of both worlds.
He's an exceptional
defender. Exceptional
defender. He's a
very good base runner, though he's had leg injuries
this year. He's had multiple injuries. It would
scare me. You've got to do a real deep dive
on if you think he's going to be healthy
from here through October
if you're a contending team.
And I know he's not a
great hitter, but he's an above-average
hitter who has performed in the postseason.
You know, he was
the LCS and World Series
MVP at one point. So,
I
would think about that
one. Like, I think
about guys whose contracts run out
this year or next year
more than, like,
the Corey Seager, Francisco Lindor,
Rafael Devers, when I don't know what the financial
situation is for the league
moving forward, and
you know, it's going to landlock
me in other ways, and I have some questions
about some of those guys
like, you know, clubhouse
stuff, and I just
got an itch right now. I've
got to improve my offense, and I have to
in my heart believe Judge is coming back
to really improve the offense
because no matter what I do, if Judge
doesn't come back, I'm not going to
win. So, like, part of this
has to be how do I
thrive and survive
for another 30 days,
40, whatever it is for Judge,
but I,
Ryan, I just believe they need Judge
because
Judge makes them ping around the
team a little bit.
I also just think Judge's presence
is
menacing
to the other team. Like, they make, like
it's the Grisham walks always
make me feel that, which is, like,
there's something unnerving about
Judge in the on-deck circle
that creates
confidence for
his team, and something
where the other team doesn't
pitch quite as well, like,
again, the ease
with which teams are going through the Yankee
lineup right now is
startling
and worrisome,
and the Yankees either become,
and, Ryan,
I am agreeing that they need to find
at least a singular,
if not a plural, bat
in this marketplace.
One of them must come a catcher.
This can't be it.
So you wrote over the weekend some names.
Can you talk about the names that you
mentioned over the weekend about those
potential options, what they could be for Yankees
to look at for a catcher to target?
Yeah, I mean, I think
there's several, and
the one they're most associated with and makes the most
sense is Jeffers.
If Langeliers
is really available, I think you've
got to do that.
I,
you know, like, there's some,
I would not do Francisco Alvarez
if I were the Yankees. I don't think the Yankees are real
interested there either, and as much
as I like Luis Torrens, and I think Luis
Torrens is a winning baseball player,
I think the Yankees need a little more offense
in that position than
Torrens, though I think Torrens
is kind of like a big moment hitter. Like, he's
not afraid of a moment,
and I really love the player,
and I mean, he's just great in the
clubhouse. He's
a, you know, like, you can't run
against him,
you know, and the Yankees obviously have a lot of familiarity
with the player.
Yeah, I'm going to hold
on to one name because I'm going to write about him today.
Okay.
Plus tomorrow, that hasn't
really come up. That's fine.
I'm going to hold you back on that. What about the guy
in Colorado, Hunter Goodman?
So, Goodman
is, I think that,
see, I think Goodman and Langelaers
are available in this way, Ryan.
It's just, this is my experience,
and I called a couple of other teams
to ask, and they said, yeah,
I think you're right, which is
the A's and the Rockies
are saying, sure, make us an offer.
Like, there is that difference between
out-and-out shopping a guy.
Like, Luis Arias must be shopped.
He's a free agent at the end of the day.
Right? And then there are
even guys who have some control
years, but teams are like,
we know now we're not signing them long-term.
And then there's guys
like Langelaers and
Goodman, who I think
the Rockies and the A's would say,
well, I haven't hung up yet.
But I'm not telling
you what I want. You've got to make
the initial, if this is
poker, you've got to throw something in the middle of the
table so I can judge your level
of seriousness before I
counter it. And understand
the amount of pain.
Catching is
terrible in the major leagues.
Offensive catching is
incredibly difficult to find.
And so
you've got, like, tell me
the thing that is going to pain you greatly.
And then we
can discuss if
these players actually could be moved.
So I think that's where
I don't think
David Forse with the
A's, I don't think Paul
Depedesta and Josh Burns with the Rockies
are hanging up a phone.
But they're not saying
it's going to take A, B, C, and D.
They're saying, you
go. You go.
Those are players
whose value does not change an iota
in the offseason.
Or by next July.
So to move them today
when both have, especially Goodman,
a lot of control,
you're going to have to say to me,
what?
What's going to make me hurt as the Yankees
to give up?
And if the Yankees begin with, well,
we're not going to put this guy and this guy in it,
they're going to go, okay, click.
Like, I'm about to trade you
somebody you can't
replicate on the open market.
An offensive catcher.
Stop telling me who you won't give me.
And so...
Go ahead.
I was going to say, I'm curious, your thoughts,
because you've mentioned so much about
how difficult it is to transition
from one team to another, especially as a catcher,
about learning the signs,
learning how they're going to call a game,
how each pitcher responds,
how hard that transition would be.
I know Jeffers would be an easier one because of the
familiarity with the system, but for a guy
like Goodman, or maybe even Langeliers,
how difficult that transition would be
to come to the Yankees' offense,
be an impact bat,
and at the same time, you have to call a game really well
for one of the best pitching staffs in baseball, you would think.
Yeah, very difficult.
I wrote over the weekend,
I think it's possible Brian Cashman
has made more trade deadline trades
than anyone in the history of the game.
Depending on how you count them,
it's about 130
of them since he
became the general manager in
1998, and you can find pretty much
all shapes and sizes.
He only acquired a veteran
catcher once. It was Pudge Rodriguez
about 20 years ago,
a future Hall of Famer,
for Kyle Farnsworth.
He
was ultimately
left that trade thinking,
I never want to do this again.
This was 20, 25
years ago when there was not as
much game planning,
individualized game planning, when the stuff
wasn't like the stuff is differentiated
and powerful and moving
with all the different
pitchers.
When there was no
how do you handle ABS
and all this.
I think the last
thing that Brian Cashman would want to do
is acquire a catcher. I know he left
that trade deadline. I've talked to him about it
shortly after that season. He said,
man, I never want to get a catcher during
the regular season again.
Yet, he knows
that this is not good enough.
They can't,
they probably can't,
they had a lot of faith.
By the way, Brian, this is
something that I feel like
I should say. Sure.
If you
brought on five executives
randomly, and you
literally picked, let's pick one from the NL West,
the NL East, the NL Central,
AOS, whatever.
And said,
what did you have on Austin
Wells?
I'm telling you,
few things are 100%. At about
85-95%, all of them
would say, they are shocked
he's not here.
I keep asking that question.
You and I, I feel like he can't.
I thought he was going to have problems catching.
The Yankees, I think,
doubled down and tripled down on a player
that the industry
also thought, come on, man,
he's going to hit. This is his
profile is the hit.
And I think
that now enough plate appearances
have gone by where they're like,
maybe there's still a
50-50 chance he'll hit, a 40-60,
a 30-70, but
we're trying to win a championship and we just,
we've got to get somebody else here
who can do at least
half the catching
and bring a little
more offense than
is being produced here.
And I think the Yankees probably have
an A tier
that's the Jeffers,
Langoliers,
Goodman, and let's see what
happens in the marketplace, and I bet
you they have the
August 2nd and 3rd
we've got to do this group
that's another
step down that's like
it's better than
Mally Sanchez and
a guy who we think can start a playoff game
and could hit a little better
and could have a 700 OPS because
man, that would be 200 points over what
we're getting. Yeah.
Joel, it's so funny where this team
has positioned itself
and again, I go back to what you're talking
about. You're encouraged by what you saw from
the bullpen and the
four men that they're going to.
I'm encouraged by what I'm seeing from the rotation.
Max Freed had his
first rehab start. It went well
from what we've read.
He's going to have another one, so he should be coming back soon.
I know Rodon is working his way back.
Clark Schmidt's working his way back.
They have, I think, what is potentially a
World Series winning starting rotation
and the bullpen, for all intents and purposes
besides Duvall and Bird, they have
the second best ERA in the sport.
The Red Sox have caught up, now number one
after winning 13 straight, which is crazy to think
about, but
for me as a fan,
after more and more I'm seeing of this
offense just faltering and faltering
and not producing, I know it's tough.
It's tough to find that
impact bat and I know it's all going to come
down to Aaron Judge. I guess, am I crazy
to think about? I keep going back to
2018 when the Braves lost
Ronald Acuna Jr. to a torn ACL.
They went on to win a World Series and I know
it was a collection of
a lot of players, but I just wonder
is there something there where the
Yankees can find some more offense
and find impact bats?
Is it just the internal
you gotta have to have better things
returns from the guys like Jason Dominguez
and the guys you mentioned in Austin Wells?
Can Ryan McMahon turn into a nice player?
I don't know, Joel. That's
where I'm starting to get a little
frustrated as a fan.
So Ryan, I think the answer is
yes.
They need Judge back.
They need the internal guys to do
better and they need an outside
influence or two
to create this.
And what the Braves did
that year was magical
and is like, in a
way, getting a four of a kind
in poke. They got four
supplementary players.
The idea that anyone is going to do
and by the way, I think if you had Alex
Anthopoulos on, who is an
exceptional baseball executive,
but he's also an incredibly honest
guy and said,
could you replicate that?
He'd say, not in a million years.
All four guys who
are supplementary players are going
to all perform at this very high
level and create
multiple players
and looks, righty lefty,
batting average, on base percentage, power.
Some of those guys never
it got Jorge Soler money
Jorge Soler never got close to that again
as that kind of
player. Eddie Rosario never got
close to that again as that kind of player.
And so I think that
there was a little magic there
and if you're going to win a championship, we just saw this with the
Knicks, you're always going to need a little
magic along the way
like where stuff goes right.
The Yankees are going to need a
so I think they've got to win in the three
buckets. They've got to get it right.
They've got to be honest. The judge is
going to come back in full even if it's for the last
30 games. Like they're
going to need it, right?
And they're going to need a better version of
you know, pick three
Wells, Dominguez,
Chisholm, Caballero,
Volpe,
Bellinger around Rice
and I think Grisham is playing well.
How he ran on Friday night
we can have a conversation about
but
I think he's a tough at bat right now.
It's it there's lots of walks and
I think over the last two years you could put him up
with certainly anyone on the Yankees and many in
the league. He's had as many big hits
as just about anybody. So like
those guys are doing
fine. They need more
and they need to
win a trade or two
beyond the
probably needing to relief. Yeah.
Well, so
they're going to get they're going
to have to get a catcher, right? Yeah, and
I think I think
they might not
think but I think they need
another bat like like
if they left this trade
deadline with Ryan Jefferson
Louie's arise. I
would go. Yes, it
would make sense, right? Like, you know, like
with that kind of thing, you
know, just just you're trying
to make it tougher like think about
the Dodger lineup yesterday in that first
game against Hitler Tommy Edmonds hitting
345 and batting ninth
Tommy Edmonds comes off the bench in game
two and hits a homer like they've just
got a lot of length and
and having said that again, the Yankee pitching did
really well against them. Yeah, aside
from the two guys who aren't going to be on the
team in two weeks
and one of them isn't on the team now. So
like like the Yankee pitching is in a
good spot. Joel David Bednar has been
an incredible closer for us like that.
That's another thing you talked about. You're like
can this guy be a version
of forgive me. I'm
now blanking on the name in the 90s.
Wetland is he John Wetland and
he's been incredible for them
as a closer. Yes, he's been really
like like he's been good.
I think he jerks right up there with among
the best lefty relievers in the sport
this year. I
think that Paul Blackburn
has been, you know, Paul
Blackburn's been
Jonathan Lewis. It goes best
version. That's a good call
the balls on the ground
all the time like
like he's and he's shown to be
somewhat durable doing this after
he's had so he had a lot of injuries with the Mets
and he's been durable doing this
so like it's been he's been really
good cruises
always worries me because I just hate guys who
walk a lot coming out of the bullpen and he's
always going to do that. On the other hand
he was beat yesterday. He hadn't given up a homer since
April 24th. It's been
about a hundred and forty batters.
So like every once in a while, especially
Yankee Stadium, a lefty is going to pop you
but you know, essentially
those been those guys have been good
Tim Hill hasn't been as good as the best
version of him, but I still
think he's somewhat trustworthy because he's
not going to be afraid if he's like
your 13th guy
on a staff, you're fine
but like if they can improve on that they'll
they should try to improve it. I would give
the ball for the next two weeks to
should be he I hope I'm pronouncing his
name, right? It maybe it's
maybe it's five games
and he's a pumpkin
but wow, when he
the thing of the question on him was
one, could he throw enough strikes
these five games he has thrown a lot of strikes
and number two
can he win with his fastball
because the thing was he needed to get to his
changeup and for some reason even though he threw
in the high 90s his fastball got hit
a lot in
in Colorado
he was throwing fastballs
by good Dodger hitters yesterday
I mean throwing it by them
so he's
it's too small of a sample
to say hey that guy should be part of a
championship bullpen but
again you need a little magic along the way
and I would give him a lot
of chances for the next 10-12 days
just to see it
because if it's real
I mean the stuff the fastball changeup
is real
now
the league is going to go to school on him
because it's real
and the Yankees are going to use him
and we'll see and that's why I would use him
just to see like hey
everyone's going to set up their traject machine
to have a little of him in it
and let's see what that looks like after a while
but
for the area
that we probably spent the most time saying
they gotta fix, they gotta fix, they gotta fix
it's possible
again I think they'll make at least
one trade for a reliever if not two
but like if Shafeehi
is real, if they get Clark
Schmidt back, if they get all their starters
back and they put either Weathers or
Warren into the bullpen
they can self-improve
in this area
in a way that they can't on offense
it's gotta be the current group
plus judge
plus at least a catcher
and I would bring in
a Jeremy Pena, an Arise
like somebody, by the way
like Jeremy Pena helped me on both sides of the ball
this version of Luis Arise
like I don't know what to make of it, has played great
at second base, like Jazz's
second base play has not, that's the other thing
it's like it isn't that Jazz
has just failed on offense this year
he isn't playing well, he's not
playing well as a player
his concentration comes and goes
I just, is it just
who he is, is free agency weighing
on him, like at some point that all has
to go into the garbage and
it's gotta be coming about a championship and
again, I go back to the Polonio thing
if you win, everyone
had a good year, so like
what you've got to do is play a mind
game with yourself
Jazz Chisholm is talented
enough to have a really good
two months
he's really talented
do I think he will do it? I
don't. I think he's got
a concentration issue
you know, I think he's got a
sometimes a style over substance issue
but if you just
said on pure, could he go
off and hit 15 homers
the rest of the year, steal
20 bases the rest of the year, have an
800 OPS the rest of the year, that is
not outrageous for his skill level
it's in there, it's in there
Joel, my last
thing for you Joel, is Mason Miller
any of that real?
like I saw those rumors over the weekend
I think it's the right
Ryan, I think it's the right question, so I think
the Padres are in a
if you started ranking, who are the
fascinating teams 1-30
in the majors
I don't know if the Padres are one but
they're damn close to one, right
so consider some of the factors
for them
they are drawing fans
at a way they never have
before because they've gone for it
and they're the only of the
four major historical sports
they're the only game in town once the charge is left
so like
what this new fan base has
experienced is contention
and big names
go for it, build a pair
so you have that, so it's
hard to turn around and say
you know what we're going to do, we're going to trade it
even though they did it one
time but it was in the off season with Soto
to the Yankees, right, where they
were willing to do something like that
so there's that, there's new ownership
has taken over there
does the first thing new ownership
wants to do be to
piss off the fans by
selling, now I would argue
the best thing the Padres can do
for their fans is sell
the Padres are like 27
in like offense
they're starting pitching and their offense is so
bad, that's like one of the things is every once in a while
we use the word, I use the word here myopic
when it comes to the Yankees
like ultimately the Yankees have the second best record in the American
League and about a 96%
chance of making the playoffs and still
probably a better than a 50% chance of winning
the division and like you do
every once in a while have to say
if the Yankees have a lot of problems, imagine what
everybody else has, so the Padres
who have a gigantic payroll especially
for them and their market
and real problems coming
because they're into Manny Machado
forever, they're into Xander
Bogart forever, if Jackson Merrill
and Fernando Tatis don't start playing
better, they're into them forever and they're
just good but not the great players
they thought they signed
and they've used so much
of their farm system to go for it
I would argue
if you level with your fans
and say, look
I think as you and I are talking
they're like 49 and 50, they're a game
under 500, I think fan graph gives
them about a 9% chance of making
the playoffs this year, just making the playoffs
because the Dodgers are playing
162 game preseason, they've already
clinched the NL West, whatever
so you've got to be one of the three wild card teams
if you're somebody else in the NL West
I would say the most fan friendly thing they
could do is say, we're going for it next
year and one of the ways we're going for it
is we've got to restock a little
bit, we're really short in a lot of areas
and the best way to do that
would be to trade Mason Miller
would be to trade Adrian Morihan
and if he could get healthy in this
short period and he's on a rehab assignment
Jeremy Estrada
and if he gets healthy in this short period, I don't think
he will, Jason Adams
because I think all four of those relievers
if healthy, get you a ton
back in this marketplace
because the one thing the Padres have is a good bullpen
and I would just say, I'm going to try to rebuild
my bullpen in the offseason
but I'm going to rebuild it with these new 12
prospects, like we went from
one of the worst farm systems to one of the better
ones, we became more cost efficient
I think
the worst thing you do, never lie to your family
say, we do not think we're good
enough this year, but what we've
tried to show you these last few years is we always
go for it, we have a very aggressive general
manager and we're going to
the second the season ends
we're on the pursuit again of trying
to be the best team possible in 2027
our payroll is not going down
but we needed a better
base, and I think if they went
out with especially Miller
they could recreate a lot of that
to trade Miller
Leo DeVries was in the trade
to the A's, Leo DeVries
today is MLB.com's number two
prospect in the major leagues
so that was the cost
and Mason Miller was probably worth
it, you could argue he's the best relief pitcher
since August 1st of last year
him or probably Yoan Duran who also
got traded
and David Bednar
is probably in the top 10
and Louis Varlin is probably in the top 10
all four of those guys got traded last year and they've all
been great for their team since they got
there, so I would just say
to the San Diego Padres
that's best
from 20,000 feet
and some of your fans are always going to be
upset if you give up
but you should give up
because the team isn't good enough
if your aspiration is championship
you just don't have
enough starting pitching and offense
you know
you don't like the Yankee offense
go check that out
and
so to me I think that's
the most fan friendly thing they could do actually
because you're thinking about your
fans for the next five years not just
the next 50 days
and so will the Padres
come to that
I think it's in play, I think that's why
they're so fascinating, I think it's in play
and I think if it's in play
the Yankees will be one of those
teams that's standing there
and if it's not for Miller and I think
they'll be in for Miller, it will be
Morahan who's a power
lefty who's a free agent at the end of the year
if it's not Morahan and they're healthy
either Adam or Estrada
I think the Yankees will be in play
for sure, so I think the Padres
are one of those teams
that if I were a Yankee fan I'd be going
I hope the Yankees
win today and the Padres lose
because you want
them in the market
yeah, it would create
definitely more resources for them or
more opportunities to potentially go
after, again I wonder what that cost
would be like you said Joel, it is
a hefty price for someone like Mason
it will be
it will be like
look again, DeVries is the
number two prospect in the sport, I think it's
hard to tell the Padres
you can't have Lombard
even though you're hoping Lombard can somewhat
be your shortstop maybe later in the season
right, you would have hoped DeVries
was going to be your shortstop
is like
so again, if you're a Yankee
fan, this is one of the things I always do also
don't be the general manager
for your team, act like
you're the Padres
if you were the Padres and you were trading
Mason Miller, and by the way
the Rays with a better farm system
than the Yankees will be in for Mason Miller
the Brewers with a better farm system
the Reds
like the Dodgers
why would the Dodgers stop?
can you imagine having Miller and Edwin Diaz
for the last six outs of the game
so there's going to be
great, and that's again why I would do it if I was
San Diego, I'm not going to lack
for people
because Miller, proof of purchase
has been shown with Miller
if you have him
if you have him, there's few things
more valuable for
162 games or trying to
win what you have to win the October than when
you should win, you do win
and Miller
and Duran are
two of those guys that got traded at the deadline
last year, and so
I think the Yankees
might line up, and they might even say
take three of what you want
and still not win
it's a fascinating time, like we said
three weeks from today, we're at
the deadline, and I know
the Yankees got to get through these baseball games and figure out
more if they internally can get better offensively
I think, and I think you would
agree Joel, they have the pitching, hopefully
to get them where they need to be
reinforcements are even coming to that pitching
staff you would hope, if everyone stays healthy
but still baseball to be played
we appreciate you as always Joel, hopping on
you're giving us all your Yankees insight
and opinion man, and we're
looking forward to catching up with you next week
no doubt about it, I'll just end with this
I do wonder if the lingering
item from the weekend
against the Dodgers
this would be the best outcome for the Yankees
and I think it's a possibility
is it was the beginning of a
run by Cole
that would be something man, because he was lights out
because I thought the stuff
was so good on Friday
you could convince me that was Gary Cole
pitching, on Friday night
when I was watching it, and
it was a
aggravating loss for the Yankees
because it was about Grisham's running, it was about
Boone's decision, it was about only one run
scored on an unearned run
and it got
lost because ultimately
Cole ended up losing pitcher, he gives up
throws a cement mixer
to Muncie and
to Homer, if that was the
if that was the beginning of a run
which I think it could
possibly be, where it's
like oh, Cole has now finally figured out
what he's got, in this version
post Tommy John
I think
that no Yankee fan is
going to like that they lost 2 out of 3 to the Dodgers
but that's the kind of guy
who could then again pitch against the Dodgers
in the biggest games of the year
or against whoever they have to pitch against
where suddenly you're saying, I could start
him, I could start Schlittler, I could start
Fried, and really
it was the strength of the team
in March, it's the strength of
the team now, if they get to that point
on October 1st, it is a way
with even just
a little better offense to get
through. I agree, that's what
that's what's so frustrating
about seeing this team offensively go through
what they're going through right now, Joel we
appreciate you man, can't wait to catch up with you next week
appreciate you. Alright Ryan
all the best, thanks everyone for watching
Outro
