Immigration CRISIS | Ben Leo hilariously DESTROYS lefties over chaos in Britain

WAN NEWS
12 followers
Go to https://piavpn.com/GBNews to get 83% off Private Internet Access with 4 months free! #ad
'Have you got any source for that?!'
Ben Leo presses Mathew Hulbert on his evidence amid a debate on whether immigration benefits Britain.
#immigration #migrantcrisis #migration #uknews #ukpolitics #gba
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video examines the contentious debate over UK immigration and the political transition under Andy Burnham's premiership. It contrasts claims of civil service failure against the economic necessity of migrant labor and analyzes the new administration's priorities, focusing on the cost-of-living crisis, local empowerment, and the challenges of restoring public trust.
Boris Johnson, who has blamed pro-Remain civil servants for the post-Brexit surge in legal migration,
alleging that Whitehall feared Britain would become a leper colony after leaving the European Union.
The former Prime Minister said officials encouraged higher immigration to fill jobs.
particularly in social care, before his government moved to tighten the rules.
His comments have been rejected by the former Conservative Home Secretary,
Suella Braverman, who is now at Reform, of course,
Who says ministers, not civil servants, blocked plans to cut migration?
With me now is former Liberal Democrat councillor Matthew Holbrooke.
Matthew, good to see you.
It sounds like Boris is blaming civil servants here.
I don't know why he won't take responsibility.
Yes, absolutely.
And you know, it's the ministers who make the decisions.
And so, ultimately, it's up to him.
And of course, for those who view immigration, whether legally or otherwise, as a negative thing,
They will undoubtedly not be very happy with Boris Johnson.
But I want to, you've just had a very robust debate there, Ben.
Let's see if we can have one here as well.
I want to share some reasons why immigration is a positive thing.
So, which isn't always the easy thing to do on this channel, but I'm going to attempt to do it.
The NHS would collapse without immigration.
Social care would collapse without immigration.
Hospitality would collapse without immigration.
Retail would collapse without immigration.
And that is just to name a few.
Immigration is a good thing.
Yeah.
All right.
Yeah, it's great.
I love it.
More people, please.
Let's keep going.
Well, I mean, I think that's great.
I mean, Ben, my friend, you know, you can be as sarcastic as you want to be.
But what in what I have just said is untrue.
Every single statement that I have just made is a statement of fact.
All of those industries and services and social services
would have collapsed in the UK, but for immigration.
Who says so?
Where did you get that from?
Well, just living in society.
I mean, have you been to an NHS hospital?
You've just noticed it.
You just reached a conclusion.
You've been out and about.
You've realized that the NHS, retail, and social care sectors would collapse without migration.
Any source for that?
Yes, because I've been in, you know, I've been in the hospital.
And I've been to shops, and you know, I've been to various services.
You've been in shops.
Right.
That's what we're dealing with now.
Well, I've been in a shop.
I was in a shop and I said that retail would be fine without migration.
So who wins?
Well, I win because it's just, I mean, there have been reports
On these things that have been said.
And you can laugh as much as you want.
I don't really care less what you said there.
Which report am I waiting for, Matthew?
There have been reports stating that the NHS,
I mean, anyone who goes to an NHS hospital knows perfectly well that,
especially in terms of people in social care
and people in some of the auxiliary staff and all the rest of it,
Many of those jobs are filled by immigrants to this country.
And I say, thank goodness for them.
Thank God for them and the work they do to serve us in our country.
That's what I say.
Do you know what percentage of retail workers are foreign-born?
Or non-UK nationals, Matthew?
Well, I mean, feel free to tell me, Ben.
I would be grateful to be enlightened.
But wait a minute.
You just said that you know retail would collapse without migration.
So you must know the figures.
No, come on.
No, you tell me.
Come on.
Here we go.
So I'm asking you first.
You don't know the answer.
I don't know the exact figure, no.
But, you know, what I'm telling you is.
You don't know the figure, so you go ahead.
Wait a minute.
So come on.
You say the NHS will collapse.
Social care will collapse.
Retail will collapse.
I said, what's your source?
You said, but I've been in a shop and you don't even know what percentage of retail workers
are foreign-born or non-UK nationals.
Is that where we are?
Well, yeah, I'll answer your question when you answer my question, which is,
Are you denying that in hospitals and in social care,
Many of the jobs are filled by people who come here from other countries?
Are you denying that?
Are you really denying that, Ben?
No, I think, I think, okay, I know that a significant proportion of doctors are foreigners.
Do you know what percentage of doctors in the NHS are foreign-born?
Well, I'm not a world expert on these matters.
I'm here to debate the general point, Ben.
If you want a world expert, go for it.
You're going to have to go for someone else.
I know the answer.
And I partly agree with you about the NHS—that we would need more doctors.
You're the one saying it, Matthew. Come on, let's be serious.
that we are both mature, intelligent men.
You said the NHS will collapse, social care will collapse, and retail will collapse.
You don't know what proportion of retail workers are foreign-born or non-UK nationals.
And you don't know what proportion of UK doctors in the NHS are foreign-born either.
I agree with you slightly on the NHS point.
We just need to replace and train British doctors.
But for retail, 16% of retail workers are foreign-born.
So retail would absolutely not collapse.
It's just nonsense.
All right.
How many people does that represent?
16%
Come on.
How many people would that amount to?
That would amount to a lot of people, right?
Yes, it would cause short-term supply issues for retail staff.
But that is different from the outright collapse of the UK retail sector.
Just nonsense.
You can call it nonsense all you want.
I have broad shoulders.
I'm not going to waste any tears on you—calling it nonsense.
What I'm telling you, my friend, is that our country depends heavily on immigration.
That's really my main point to you.
As I say, it's a difficult thing to come on here and try to advocate for immigration.
And I'm doing my best here, and apparently failing, but I'm going to keep going anyway.
What I'm trying to say to you is that immigration can be
A good thing, and our country would be poorer without it.
That is my point.
No, I agree.
Thank you.
And I appreciate you coming on and sharing your perspective and your argument.
But when you say that the reason I sounded so harsh there and went for you, Matthew,
because you came on and said the NHS, retail, and social care would all collapse
and the UK would be nuked without migration, which simply isn't true.
So, as much as I appreciate you coming on and I enjoy your company, you're a good bloke.
I will push back against it because that is merely hyperbolic nonsense.
But thank you anyway.
Thank you for staying up, and I look forward to sparring with you again, Matthew.
Using the internet without a VPN, a virtual private network,
is a bit like hitting the road without car insurance.
All it takes is one unlucky moment to cost you a lot of money.
This video is sponsored by Private Internet Access.
They are the VPN designed to keep you safe.
Click the link in the description below to find out why over 30 million people
have downloaded PIA to protect themselves online.
A virtual private network is an app that hides your IP address.
and helps keep your data private.
When you're browsing the internet at home,
you surrender a vast amount of data to businesses, to stores,
and indeed to social media giants as well.
Hackers can easily steal your personal data.
including sensitive information such as passwords
keystrokes and even your personal photos.
Private Internet Access helps protect your personal data
by encrypting your internet connection to keep your data secure
out of the hands of cybercriminals
And it's not just hackers to be concerned about either.
Information can also be censored.
When Canada passed their C-18 bill,
Social media giants decided to ban news content on their platforms.
But PIA can protect your ability to consume the news and content you love.
Private Internet Access is available for Windows users,
macOS, Android, Linux, iOS
And you can use one PIA subscription to protect an unlimited number of devices.
And we also have a big discount on GB News for you too.
Click the link in this video's description
and you'll get a massive 83% off PIA.
That's under £2 a month, the price of a coffee.
And you'll get an additional four months completely free on top.
Also, there's a 30-day money-back guarantee as well.
Visit piavpn.com/gbnews
to start protecting yourself digitally today.
Andy Burnham will promise to give people more breathing room.
in his first speech as Prime Minister later today,
saying Britain needs a more stable and responsible politics.
I mean, it sounds like the same old thing we've heard over and over again,
but the incoming PM is expected to focus on easing the cost of living pressures
while promising tangible improvements for voters.
He will also begin unveiling his first cabinet.
and outlined his priorities for the government.
So just what can the great British public expect
as we enter the Burnham era,
including who will his chancellor be?
And let's pose this question to former Labour MP Stephen Pound.
Good morning, Stephen. Thank you for your company.
Will we call a general election, Stephen?
Of course not, no more than Liz Trusted or anyone else.
No one calls a general election unless they absolutely have to.
And the reality is that no political party
No party that has changed its leader in midstream has ever called a general election.
So we're not going to start now.
There are more important things to do.
We are not one of those parties that believes in performative politics.
against Count Binface in Clacton.
We're not going to do anything like that.
What we're interested in is actually getting the job done.
And Andy Burnham is actually the man to do it.
OK, well, I agree with you on that.
I don't think you can have people like Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak trusted
and whoever becomes Prime Minister without a general election.
And then those on the right side of the argument complain
that Andy Burnham is now Prime Minister.
That's just how it goes, unfortunately.
Well, we can't really talk about Clacton.
There's a by-election taking place.
But who is Burnham's chancellor going to be?
Well, we don't know.
My chip, and I have to say, yeah, I've got the kiss of death here.
I must admit, I have to say, I thought Norway was going to win the World Cup.
The truth is, I thought it was going to be John Healey.
because that would have been such a cool move.
Because John Healey, obviously an incredibly important
Minister of Defence and Secretary of State
And he has obviously had his major conflicts with the Treasury.
It would have been a good call.
The word on the street is that it's going to be Shabana Mahmood.
And I have to say, you know, the word on the street once again in the markets
It was extremely, extremely positive.
Personally, I think Andy, Ed Miliband is highly qualified for the job.
But he's doing such crucial work.
And the price is important.
Life-saving work we're doing to achieve net zero
and get the Russian boot off our necks.
So I think we should let him continue doing that crucial, important work.
Yeah, Andy Burnham says he's going to give British people,
more breathing room and address the cost of living.
I mean, we've heard it all before.
Does it mean anything anymore, Stephen?
It just sounds like political rhetoric.
Well, I don't know.
I mean, I remember Boris Johnson coming in and saying
The first thing he was going to do was level up.
And many politicians have done so as well.
I think we recognize the reality is that
We are one of the most centralised countries in Europe.
Local people, and you know, I've been in politics,
elected politics for about 30 to 40 years.
Local people, on my patch, don't feel they have any say in their own lives.
They don't feel they have any say in politics.
They believe that 70% of local government spending
Is everything predestined, preordained?
They don't feel they can make decisions.
Now, I think that's one of the most crucial things.
anything that any leader of this country can do,
Actually give a little power back to people locally.
I'm not a great admirer of the federal system.
in America or in Germany,
but it actually works infinitely better than a man,
And it's usually the man in Whitehall who knows best.
People on the street, people on the patch have got to feel
They have some skin in the game.
They must feel that they are involved,
And if you do that, things get a lot better right now.
To be honest, you know, by God,
You're a pretty astute political journalist.
You know the score.
People don't feel engaged,
and I think that's one of the key things
that Andy Burnaby is going to go for.
Well, no, because everyone keeps lying to them.
They keep saying the cost of living will go down.
They keep saying they'll stop the boats.
They keep saying that crime will go down.
They keep saying they'll be able to buy houses.
They keep making U-turns.
One minute they're robbing pensioners,
The next ones are doing a U-turn.
Then they're robbing farmers,
Then they're making a U-turn.
How can the U-turned British public
to believe or trust politicians
When do you have a lot of favorites?
No one robs farmers.
Immigration is at its lowest level in 25 years.
The boats are stopping.
We have far, far less immigration.
Where are you getting that from, Stephen?
What immigration?
I'm sorry, but I don't know which immigration level is the lowest in 25 years.
I'm sorry, immigration,
legal and illegal immigration to this country
has decreased by 80% over the past two years.
Fact.
But as for your point earlier regarding Donald Trump.
You just said legal and illegal.
So what do you mean?
Choose one or the other.
They can't both have gone down.
No, no, no, I've put them all together.
I mean, where did you get that from?
No, no, no, I'm not letting you get away with that.
You just pulled that out of thin air
I guess I'll just let it go.
What has decreased by 80%?
That's not true.
The OMS statistics,
which are publicly available
The last ones are admittedly three months out of date,
but the most recent one, three months ago,
show quite clearly that since 2024,
legal and illegal
The total amount of migration has actually declined significantly.
Stephen, and you know this,
Why has legal migration decreased?
I'll give you one chance to answer.
Before I reveal the answer.
Quite simply because the idea that people
could actually bring in their dependents,
I mean, 16 and 17 people who are members of the family
on student visas, on temporary visas.
Yeah, and also the British are leaving in large numbers.
I think 250,000 Brits left the country.
because they were so disgusted
with the way Keir Starmer has been governing things
in his extremely brief and wretched premiership.
Tens of thousands of them leaving the UK,
That's why legal net migration has decreased.
You're pulling this fact out of thin air.
How do you know it's 250,000 people?
Well, you can talk, Stephen, come on.
That's my job.
People might want to go and live in the sun,
They want to go and live in Australia.
They want to live anywhere.
You haven't spoken to 250,000,
or perhaps you have spoken to 250,000 people,
but there's no way in the world on God's green earth
you can say that every single one of those people
Who left the country has left it quite simply.
because they were actually disgusted
with what's happening here.
People, you know, marry people.
Well, if they were happy in the UK,
They would have stayed in the UK.
One more question, Stephen, if you don't mind.
What does it say about the Labour Party?
that you couldn't find someone
amongst your cohort of 400 MPs
who won by a huge margin
backed by the great British people on July 24,
that not one of them was competent enough
or capable enough to be selected
for your new leader as prime minister?
Well, because we had someone
who was, at that particular time,
He was outside the tent.
who was more than competent, more than capable,
and above all, it's a person who actually
brings optimism and hope into this country.
That's what we were.
We're tired of pessimism,
tired of people talking the country down
Let's talk up the country
and have a little bit of optimism for a change.
Well, I agree with that.
But we would also like to see results.
If you're going to say stop,
We're going to stop the boats.
Then please stop the boats.
If you're going to say that energy bills
will decrease by £300 per year,
Please make sure that happens.
We are stopping.
It doesn't look like it.
Yeah, it doesn't look like it.
Get yourself down to Dover, Stephen.
Stephen, thank you very much.
Thanks as always.
Have a great rest of your weekend.
Stephen Pound, former Labour MP
