What Really Makes a Good Photograph?

The Landscape Lens
1 follower
Jul 20, 2026
What Really Makes a Good Photograph?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker reflects on 30 years of nature photography, shifting from a focus on gear and dramatic lighting to a philosophy centered on simplicity, curiosity, and the emotional connection between the photographer and the subject. He emphasizes that a great photograph is defined by its meaning to the creator rather than technical perfection.
Comments are disabled for this video.
I just want to take this opportunity to thank Squarespace for sponsoring this week's video.
Well, hello folks. I hope you're all doing well. Thank you ever so much for joining me for
this week's video. Always appreciate it. Thanks also to those of you that watched last week's
where I went on my trip to Namibia. Believe it or not, that video took quite some time
to put together. Not so much the video part of it, but the processing of the images. I had
probably more images or new images in that video than any other. So I appreciate those of you that
watched it and gave the old thumbs up and left comments. So thank you for that. If you haven't
seen the video, be sure to go check it out. Now, one of the questions I've been asked
countless times over the years is what makes a good photograph? Now it's somewhat of a complex
answer and question because it really depends on the type of photography you're into. And also,
you know, if I had 10 people in this room and asked them the same question, everybody would
come up with a different answer. But it is an interesting question because if you'd asked me
30 years ago, I probably would have given you a completely different answer than I would today.
Now back then, I probably would have talked about dramatic light, finding incredible locations,
and perhaps buying better cameras, or at least telling myself that I needed a better camera
to make the images that I really wanted to. Now those things, they do have their place. But
the longer I've been photographing, the more my thinking has kind of changed.
I'm still learning every time I take out my camera. But there are a few things that I've
come to believe over the years that have probably shaped my photography more than anything else.
Now, none of these are rules. They're simply observations. You might agree with some of them,
you might not. And that's perfectly okay. Photography would be a pretty dull hobby
if we all thought exactly the same way. All right, so let's start with something that almost
every nature photographer chases and that is light. Now, if you've watched my channel for
any length of time, you know that I'm always harping on about waiting for the right conditions,
or photographing the subjects that go with the light at hand. And I still hold that true good
light really does matter. But here's what I've realized good light doesn't automatically make
a great photograph. And we've all been to famous viewpoints where perhaps we have a great sunset
or a sunrise. And perhaps other photographers standing shoulder to shoulder making exactly
the same image. So the light is identical for everyone, yet only a handful of those photographs
are memorable. Why? Because the light didn't create the photograph, it simply enhanced what
was already there. Now I've made some of my favorite images under completely overcast skies.
So no dramatic sunrises or sunsets, just quiet, even light that suited the subject.
So these days I spend less time asking is the light dramatic enough and more time asking
does the light suit what I'm looking at? And those are two very different questions.
So
I remember when I first started nature photography, I pretty much tried to include everything.
If there was a mountain, yep, that would go in a lake that went into flowers. Absolutely.
Clouds. Yeah, of course. I thought more interesting things automatically meant a more interesting
photograph. Now, eventually I did realize that I wasn't really composing. I was just recording
everything I could see. So now I'm usually asking pretty much the opposite question.
What can I leave out? And that isn't always easy. Sometimes the hardest part of photography
isn't deciding what belongs, it's deciding what doesn't belong. So some of my favorite
photographs contain surprisingly little, a single tree, a few rocks, patterns in the sand.
So simple doesn't mean boring. Simple often means a clear vision of what you want to say
and keeping it as simple as possible.
Now, when it comes to photography equipment, my advice for anyone starting out in nature
photography, or perhaps you're considering a new camera or an upgrade is to make sure that you
enjoy using that gear, say over purchasing it just because some YouTuber like me gave it rave reviews.
Now, if you're not sure, my recommendation would be to try the equipment out first,
perhaps rent it. I currently shoot with the Fujifilm GFX 100 system of cameras because
I just love using them and they really enhance my photographic experience.
Do I need 102 megapixels? Absolutely not. Does the camera make me a better photographer?
Probably not. I use the gear that I do because I enjoy using it and that's it.
So my recommendation is purchase the gear that meets your budget
and also fills the needs of what it is you want to photograph.
So as an example, if you really enjoy photographing birds in flight,
you probably wouldn't go out and buy a Hasselblad X2D.
First of all, they don't make lenses that long and it's just not a fast camera to use.
So you would buy an appropriate camera that you really enjoy using for that type of photography.
Thank you once again to Squarespace for sponsoring this week's video.
Are you ready to take your online presence to the next level? Meet Design Intelligence by
Squarespace, a fusion of world-class design and AI technology that unlocks your creative
potential like never before. Build a stunning personalized website that's as unique as you are
and stands out from the crowd. With Squarespace payments, managing transactions is easier than
ever. Get started in just a few clicks and let your customers pay their way, whether it's Apple
Pay, Afterpay or more. Need to invoice clients? Squarespace has you covered. Simplify your workflow
and focus on growing your business. If you're interested in building an awesome website,
why not head on over to squarespace.com and give it a try? And if you like what you find,
use the code ADAMGIBBS for 10% off your first purchase.
Photographers often ask me where my favorite place is to photograph and it's actually a really
difficult question to answer. As I mentioned in a video that I did some weeks ago now about
epic landscapes, I've been really lucky to visit some really incredible places around the world.
But I have to admit that some of the photographs I'm most proud of were made within an hour of my
home. There's something special about returning to the same place over and over again. I think
you begin to recognize subtle changes, perhaps how one season difference from another, how the
weather affects the landscape, where the light falls at different times of the year. So I think
eventually you're no longer photographing a location, you're getting to know it. And I think
familiarity often produces stronger photographs than constantly chasing somewhere new.
Now a subject that I have made a video about in the past, but doesn't get talked about that often,
is the shape of the frame or the aspect ratio. Now most photographers think about aspect ratios
after the fact with a crop, but I prefer deciding before I press the shutter. So with my camera,
the default aspect ratio is 4x3 and I can quite easily change it to a square or to a panorama,
a 6x7, 4x5 and so on. The thing about aspect ratios, it can completely change
the balance of a photograph without moving the tripod an inch. And nothing in the landscape
changes, only the frame around it. And I don't really think of aspect ratios as crops, I think
of them as different canvases. So basically every subject seems to have one that feels just right,
and I would highly recommend that you give it a go. Try different aspect ratios before you actually
take the photograph. Now photography, or nature photography to be more specific, has definitely
made me much slower. Now some of that, especially physically, might be age. Actually mentally might
be the same, the same thing as well. But when I was younger, I was always looking for the next
composition, the next viewpoint or the next waterfall. And now I often spend much longer
standing in one place, waiting, watching, often absorbing my surroundings. And sometimes absolutely
nothing happens, but sometimes everything changes. You know I've found that patience
doesn't always reward you, but impatience almost always costs you something.
Now when I was first getting into photography, or nature photography, I think I was more concerned
with making successful photographs. But these days I'm much more interested in just being
curious. I enjoy wandering around a woodland just to see what I might find, photographing details
I've never noticed before, trying an unusual aspect ratio, basically looking at familiar
places from a different angle. And of course not every experiment works, many don't, but every now
and then I'll discover something I never would have found if I'd simply walked straight to the
obvious viewpoint. I think I've come to realize that curiosity has probably taught me more than
success ever has. Success makes you repeat yourself, whereas curiosity encourages you to keep
exploring. And even after 30 years I still head out with the hope of seeing something I've never
noticed before. And I think, I could be wrong, but I think that's one of the reasons why photography
has never become boring to me.
This one took me a few years to accept, and that is that not every outing needs to produce a great
photograph. You know, sometimes the conditions just don't work, sometimes your head isn't in the right
place, sometimes nothing really connects. But that doesn't make the day a failure. You still spent
time outdoors, you still observed, you probably still learned something. So photography isn't
always about bringing something home, sometimes it's all about simply being there. So what really
makes a good photograph? Well, 30 years ago I'd probably have talked about dramatic light,
or the right camera, or perhaps traveling to some spectacular location. But today I think the answer
is much simpler. A good photograph is the one that means something to the person who made it.
Everything else, like the camera, the lens, the location, the light, they're all important, but
they're only part of the equation. The real difference comes from spending time outside,
learning to observe, learning to simplify, and learning to trust yourself, intuition. And perhaps
most importantly, learning to enjoy the process. Because I honestly do believe that if you enjoy
the process, the photographs will gradually take care of themselves. And that's certainly been true
for me. I'd love to hear your thoughts on this. Not your favorite camera or lens, but what photography
has taught you over the years. I'm always interested to hear different perspectives.
Thank you ever so much for watching, and I'll see you in the next video. Bye-bye.
