In The Courts: July 19, 2026

Fox - 5 DC
35 followers
6 Video Views·Jul 20, 2026
Thanks for joining us in the courts. I'm Katie Barlow. Off the top,
Todd Blanche's confirmation as the next Attorney General of the United States now hangs in the
balance as key GOP senators weigh his testimony this week. Blanche, who's currently serving as
acting AG, appeared for about five hours of questioning before the Senate Judiciary Committee
on Wednesday. He's battling concerns about his allegiance to Donald Trump, the man whom he served
as a personal attorney rather than Trump, the President, and the American people.
Are you and President Trump friends?
I'm his lawyer, was his lawyer, and now I'm the Deputy Attorney General. So I met him as his
criminal defense attorney. I'm not sure there's very many people who have ever had a criminal
defense attorney who calls that person their friend. I now have a-
Well, let me put it this way. Are you enemies?
No, we're not enemies at all, no.
Have you ever seen a President of the United States appoint an enemy to be Attorney General?
I have not.
Usually they appoint their qualified friends, don't they?
Yes.
One main focus during the hearing, Trump's deal with the IRS to settle his lawsuit against the
agency. The deal includes complete immunity for Trump and certain family members related
to previous tax audits and a so-called 1776 fund. That fund refers to a now maybe defunct
$1.8 billion that was allotted for, quote, anti-weaponization, intended to compensate
people who claim they were unfairly targeted by the IRS. Many, including GOP senators,
are concerned the fund would be used to pay off Trump's allies and friends. Blanche says
the fund is no longer in the works and he is committed during his testimony, he said,
to help develop language to enshrine into law that the fund cannot rise from the dead.
Blanche's confirmation depends in part on two key Republican senators,
Tom Tillis from North Carolina and John Cornyn from Texas, whom Trump abandoned in his primary
for reelection in favor of Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton. Tillis appeared to be a yes vote
before saying that Blanche would need to meet with Epstein survivors first before he will vote
yes. Blanche eventually did that. Both sides of that meeting came out with different takeaways.
Cornyn is keeping his cards close for now. We don't yet know how he will vote.
Meantime, in Virginia, Theo Stamos was named first assistant U.S. attorney in the Eastern
District of Virginia. Recall this office was once led by Lindsey Halligan before a judge ruled that
appointment was unlawful. Stamos now fills the second highest position in that office,
and some outlets have reported that Stamos will automatically become the acting U.S. attorney
under something called the Vacancies Reform Act. But if you've been watching our show for a while,
you know that's not exactly how this works. As friend of the show and the Cato Institute's
Tommy Berry points out on X, a federal appeals court has held that someone appointed to be the
first assistant after a vacancy opens up is in fact not eligible to become the acting officer.
So there may very well be a legal challenge to Stamos purporting to be the acting U.S. attorney
for the Eastern District. The Stamos pick is also noteworthy because she was elected to serve as the
Commonwealth's attorney for Arlington, Virginia, in 2015 as a Democrat. She ran again as a Dem as
recently as 2019, but lost in the primary. Meantime, the New York Times has moved to
quash subpoenas to journalists who reported on security concerns about the new Air Force One
plane that was gifted to President Trump by the nation of Qatar. This sets up a classic court
fight pitting national security against freedom of the press. And lawyers for the New York Times
say the government, in trying to force reporters to give up their sources, is violating the
Now, recall, this is not the first time this administration has gone after individual
reporters. Back in January, the FBI raided Washington Post reporter Hannah Natanson's home
after her reporting on changes to the federal workforce. And this is not the first time the
New York Times has gone up against the government in a fight over national security related reporting.
The most famous case, perhaps, is the landmark 1971 New York Times company,
the United States, also known as the Pentagon Papers case. There, the Supreme Court cleared
the way for both the Times and the Post to publish the then-classified Pentagon Papers
without the threat of government censorship. The lawyer for the New York Times in that case
was a legendary First Amendment lawyer, Floyd Abrams. And Abrams had a daughter by the name
of Ronnie Abrams, who became a judge in the Southern District of New York, where
this current fight between the Times and the Trump administration is playing out.
And as luck would have it, Business Insider reports that the case has been assigned to her,
at least initially, because she leads the Manhattan Federal Courthouse's Access Committee.
Meantime, Supreme Court Justices Elena Kagan and Amy Coney Barrett appeared on Capitol Hill
requesting more funding for security on behalf of the court. It marked the first time
in seven years Supreme Court Justices testified in front of Congress.
Around the time of the Dobbs leak, my security detail sent me home with a bulletproof vest,
and I carried it into my house, put it into my bedroom, dropped it down on a table,
turned around, and my 12-year-old son was standing in the doorway of my bedroom.
And he wanted to know what it was and why I had it, and I didn't know how to respond.
While there appears to be broad bipartisan support for granting the Justices' request,
at least one lawmaker says Congress should use this moment and the power of the purse
to force the court to make meaningful ethics reforms. Georgetown Law Professor Lewis Seidman
happens to agree, saying that Congress should actually do its job here. He also has a new book
out this month called The Constitution Cannot Save Us, Why We Can No Longer Rely on Our Founding
Document. And Professor Seidman joins us now. Thanks for being here.
It's such a pleasure to be with you, Katie. Thanks for inviting me.
So in the book, you talk about perhaps, I think, maybe the most important theory of
constitutional interpretation, originalism, and why maybe it's not the best way to think
about the document. And you open with perhaps somebody else's example, but talking about a
witch's brew recipe in Macbeth. Could you explain that example and how maybe it leads to some
questions about originalism as an approach itself? Well, the words in Macbeth, the witch's brew,
don't refer to the same things now that they did then. And that's a real problem for originalism.
But, you know, maybe the basic problem is the people who wrote the Constitution,
they're dead for 250 years. They were dealing with another country that was radically different
from our own. They were people who thought it was fine or some of them thought it was fine to
own other human beings and that women should have no role in our society. The notion that
we ought to turn over to them really important questions for us seems kind of crazy. This is
our country. It's not theirs. They've been dead for a long time. And we have the responsibility
to decide what kind of country we want. To your point about how the focus should be on us,
you also talk about how we should focus the debate on the issues that divide us
rather than the method of interpreting this document in one particular way. Can you explain
that? Well, that's right, Katie. So a big part of the problem here is that there are really
important questions that do divide us, questions about, say, abortion or affirmative action,
or the recent case, whether Congress has some role in setting the term for government employees.
These are things Americans care about. And the right way to deal with those questions
is for people to debate them, to engage in compromise, to organize, to have elections.
Here's the wrong way to deal with it, to turn those questions over to nine people in Washington
who are deliberately isolated from political accountability. They're responsible to no one.
They can do whatever the hell they want. And we shouldn't let those people in their robes and
marble palace decide for the rest of us what kind of country we want to have.
Sarah Isgerd kind of makes a counterpoint in her recent book,
The Last Branch Standing, about the Supreme Court. She basically says
Congress is no longer doing its job. They're spending more time on Instagram than they are
passing laws and finding agreement across the aisle. Meanwhile, the president is trying to
take more and more power for the executive through executive fiat or executive order.
So while those two branches aren't functioning, we're actually entirely reliant on those nine
people who are not accountable to anyone because that's the only way the system is functioning
right now. So how do you actually get to where you're trying to go when the branches aren't
working? Well, if she's right, and she may be, that's a really sad state of affairs.
But look, you always have to make comparative judgments. So our political system is in serious
trouble. And Isgerd is right. Congress is not working very well. The president's not working
very well. But one thing you can say about Congress and the president, if we don't like
what they do, we can do something about it. We can replace those people. But we can't replace
the Supreme Court justices. They're there for life. They can't have their salaries cut.
They can do whatever they want. And that's no way to run a country.
There are really important questions that divide us. We need to debate and sometimes
compromise over those things. But nine isolated justices purporting, but not really, following
a 250-year-old document written for a different country and different people,
that's not a way to run a railroad. All right, Professor Seidman, George
Seidman, constitutional law professor. Thank you so much for joining us. You can find his book,
The Constitution Cannot Save Us, online or at your local bookstore. And we'll be right back
with more in the courts. Welcome back in. Divorce is rarely easy, regardless of what stage in life
it happens, whether you're splitting up with young kids involved or if you've made the decision to
end the marriage in your golden years. It can be ugly, messy and difficult on all parties involved.
But many couples are choosing mediation now over a long drawn out divorce case. And joining us now
is family law attorney Sandra Fava. Sandra, welcome back to the show. Thanks. Thanks for
having me again. So you are seeing a trend of more families trying to pivot to mediation to
get to the end of the road instead of going to court, which is what we hear about at least more
often when divorces really are tough and both sides can't reach agreement. Why do you think
that is? Well, I think there's a few reasons for that. I think, number one, many courts are
still facing backlog, meaning that judicial resources are being extended to their max
and cases are moving slowly through the system. So mediation or alternative dispute resolution
allows families to get to the end, hopefully quicker. I think the other reason is that
mediation is oftentimes, if successful, a lot more cost effective. People don't litigate,
so they're not spending money, you know, fighting generally in courtrooms where there's motions and
paperwork that have to be filed in court rules to be followed. I think also it gives people
more control in the outcome of the resolution. They have a lot more say. You can be a lot more
creative in the mediation setting. Obviously in a courtroom, a judge has to follow the rule of law.
So, you know, that's not available in that setting. But mediation allows people to think
a bit outside of the box and do things that are going to work for them and their family.
Mediators, there's sometimes a hesitancy to trust someone like a mediator with your
family's entire future. Can you explain a little bit about the experience that mediators bring to
their when they walk in the room? Are they required to be lawyers? They're not quite like
judges, as you point out, but they do play that central role and can be that ultimate resolver of
these disputes. Sure. Well, first off, I think that, you know, when you're talking about a
distrust issue, sometimes mediation is not a fit for everyone or it's not the right time to try
that process. Sometimes people need to sort of feel out the process. Oftentimes in a divorce
situation, one party's at a different emotional state than the other party. It's rare that people
are on the same exact page or moving through things at the same exact pace. So sometimes
timing is a big part of it. In New Jersey, mediators do not have to be attorneys. We have
some financial advisors who have gotten the training and certification that allows them to be
mediators. I think that in most states, attorneys and retired judges do serve as mediators.
And on my team, I have a retired judge who sat in family as a trial court level and then went
up to our appellate court. So he brings a breadth of experience both at the trial court level
and in issues that were brought before the appellate division here in our state. I think
mediators need to understand that every family is unique. People come with different
expectations and personalities. They have to be prepared to sort of delve into the issues,
which is a benefit that I think people expect when choosing a mediation route versus the courtroom
because judges often don't have the time or the bandwidth to kind of listen to every single
minor detail. They kind of need the big picture and move things through. So I think being heard
for many people is valuable in the mediation setting. We only have about a minute left,
but I want to get to your seeing a rise in what is called gray divorce, which may or may not be
an apt term, but it's people over the age of 50 who are deciding to go through a divorce.
And there's a rising trend there. Why do you think that is?
Oh, that's a longer than a one minute answer for me. I think to sum it up, I think people
are realizing that the world has changed. Societal norms that were placed upon couples
in that specific age group or whatnot, they see that it's changing, the stereotypes no longer
there. And I think that people, especially post COVID, are really valuing the preciousness of
their lives, wanting to be happy, wanting to enjoy that. And, you know, having children out
and grown makes them feel like they have a sense of security. They don't have to worry about those
issues. And if they're in a financial position to do so and they're not happy, I hear, you know,
more and more often that people just want to have whatever is left for them, you know,
happy and peaceful. And if that's not something they're having in their marriage,
they're not as afraid as they once were to exit the relationship.
Sandra Fava, thank you so much for sharing your insights tonight and helping us learn a little
bit more behind the scenes of what can be a very difficult and heartbreaking process.
Thanks for joining us. Thank you. We'll have more in the courts when we come back. Don't go away.
Now to some stories ripped from the headlines. Andrew and Tristan Tate, two brothers with a
big following on social media, have been arrested by federal authorities in Miami. According to the
U.S. Marshals Service, the warrant for their arrest was sealed. But last night, British
prosecutors announced they're seeking the brothers extradition from the U.S. on rape and sex
trafficking charges. The offenses are alleged to have occurred between July 2010 and August 2017.
The pair was previously arrested in 2022 for participating in schemes to sexually exploit
young women. President Donald Trump has paid E. Jean Carroll the 5.6 million dollars ordered by
a judge after a jury found him liable for sexually abusing her in the 90s. Trump tried
numerous avenues to fight the order, including asking the Supreme Court to intervene. They
declined. While Trump's lawyers promised to continue to fight the case, Carroll's lawyers
confirmed she has received the payment. Remember when Elon Musk offered voters one million dollar
checks in 2025 in the Wisconsin State Supreme Court election? Turns out that was probably illegal.
According to the Wisconsin Election Commission, Musk was trying to fight for majority control of
the battleground state's highest court. The commission referred the matter to the state's
attorney's office to determine whether they will file criminal charges against Musk for allegedly
violating election bribery laws in Wisconsin. Prosecutors have the next 40 days to decide.
Meantime, former Wisconsin Judge Hannah Dugan is appealing her federal conviction for felony
obstruction to the 7th Circuit. Dugan was recently sentenced to pay $5,000 for helping an immigrant
avoid ice in the courthouse. She avoided prison time despite prosecutors asking for at least a
year behind bars. Dugan tried to argue that her prosecution was unconstitutional because she was
a judge. The trial judge rejected that argument, but she may try again before the Federal Appeals
Court. Time now for sports in the courts. The NCAA can't seem to catch a break. According to ESPN,
11 Division 1 athletes have filed another class action lawsuit over eligibility rules that block
them from longer college careers and those name, image, and likeness opportunities that come along
with it. Minnesota basketball star Kade Tyson is among the 11, as is Northern Colorado's Brock
Wisney. They take issue with the same new eligibility rules that have been the subject
of other lawsuits that allow college athletes five years to compete but deny further eligibility to
athletes whose eligibility expired this past season. Former Kansas basketball star LeGerald
Vick was charged with attempted first-degree murder in Tennessee. According to ESPN,
Vick was already facing charges for breaking into his former girlfriend's house in June
when a man claimed that Vick shot him during a confrontation on July 4th. The victim reportedly
identified Vick as the perpetrator from a photo lineup. Bail was set at 1.5 million dollars.
Still ahead tonight, we'll award this week's legal loser. Don't go away.
Tonight's legal loser, rapper Boozy, was reportedly trying to buy himself a pardon
from the Trump administration, according to notice, for $600,000. Boozy, whose real name
is Torrence Hatch, was convicted of, among other things, having a gun as a convicted felon.
Far-right political activists Jacob Wall and Jack Berkman apparently, at one point,
told Hatch's lawyer that they had successfully gotten the pardon signed by the president.
Alas, that turned out not to be true, and now Hatch is suing the men for failure to execute
a contract. He wants $300,000 back. Wall and Berkman apparently don't have the money,
and say the legal bills have already surpassed the $600,000 that they were paid.
Filing a lawsuit because the president didn't honor a bribe is certainly a choice.
Thanks for joining us in the courts. Feel free to chime in and tell us what you want to hear
about on the show. Hashtag us on social media and hashtag in the courts, or send me an email
with your ideas. We'll be back the same time next week, but until then, have a good night, everyone.
