Three months before the US midterm elections, President Donald Trump has repeated allegations he says justify changes to voting regulations. The world has heard this before, but why is he returning to this topic now? Our expert, Scott Lucas from University College Dublin, fears the president is setting the stage for more dramatic action.
Chapter Breakdown 0:00 Trump calls for tighter federal voting rules 0:51 Scott Lucas, explains Trump's political intentions in claiming Chinese election interference, to put his thumb on his scale for the midterms 2:39 Lin Jian, Chinese Ministry spokesperson, responds to Trump's allegations of election interference 3:06 China rejects Trump's claims: In fall 2020, US intel agencies said China had considered meddling in US elections but then decided not to 5:54 Trump's low approval rating according to an IPSOS poll 6:39 Trump on legal and illegal votes 10:02 What might happen in the November midterms? #dwnews
Donald Trump has accused China of interfering in US elections to justify tighter federal voting rules. However, experts and intelligence reports suggest these claims are unverified or contradicted by evidence, which instead points to Russian interference in 2020. The discussion suggests these allegations may be a political strategy to deflect from low approval ratings and create a pretext to manipulate election outcomes.
US President Donald Trump is beating China with his favourite shtick at being election
interference.
Three months before midterm elections in the United States, he used an address to The Nation
carried on multiple American networks to escalate his calls for tighter federal voting rules.
Over a period of years, starting during the 2020 election cycle, the People's Republic
of China carried out what is believed to be the largest compromise of election data in
history.
The Chinese government wanted US President to lose the next election and the reason they
wanted me to lose is because they knew I was wise to them.
Trump says he fears the type of interference that led to his loss to Joe Biden in 2020.
That's a theory disproven by his own intelligence agency.
So why again now?
Scott Lucas is a professor of American Studies at the Clinton Institute at University College
Dublin, someone we've used many times to interpret the words and actions of the American
president.
Scott, good to see you.
Here we go again.
I want to say at the outset, if I could, we did debate here among our editorial team the
value of reacting to this story.
But but here we are.
I wonder, do you in some way share some of those reservations and where do you land?
Yeah, I absolutely share these reservations.
I mean, this was not a speech to bring clarity, to bring new information.
This was a political speech by Trump to try to put his thumb on the scales of the forthcoming
election in November.
And so, you know, it's a party political speech and some US networks chose not to air it precisely
for that reason.
That said, I'm glad we're having this discussion because we need to get out in front of what
Trump said.
First of all, to expose the fact, and I'll use the polite word here, that it was incorrect.
I could use stronger words.
And secondly, to explore the motives, which are not just simply to pass an act regarding
US elections.
It is actually possibly to manipulate the elections and even to overturn them.
It's vital, therefore, we go through that speech and juxtapose it with what we actually
know to get to the truth.
This time, Trump seems to be referencing one unverified, at least one unverified FBI field
report.
One quotes an unnamed source in China saying that claims mail-in ballots were being manufactured
at scale to be flooded into the US to influence the election.
If it is that he's referencing, it's not officially verified intelligence, but the allegation
was something that a Chinese spokesperson from China's foreign ministry has responded
to.
The claims made by the US are pure fabrications and malicious smears that have long since
been proven to be groundless statements.
China upholds the principle of non-interference in internal affairs.
It has no interest in the US election and has never interfered in it.
Scott, I want to ask, are China worried or offended, or are they also getting used to
Trump and his use of this interference stick?
Well, in this case, China is simply rejecting an allegation and let's keep it.
So what are the facts behind that allegation?
And this is important.
That document that was selectedly declassified is a piece of what we call raw intelligence.
In other words, someone happened to claim, to make a claim, that China was harvesting
mail-in ballots.
But in fact, there's no indication that that was correct, that was verified.
And in fact, here's the key part of the story that Trump withheld.
In autumn of 2020, US intelligence agencies assessed that China had considered influencing
the US election, but had rejected that.
The reason why the Chinese rejected that, according to multiple US intelligence agencies
in this assessment, was that they wanted to avoid destabilizing US-Chinese relations,
and they also feared blowback.
This could actually look bad on them if they did this.
But there's more.
What the analyst also said is that while Iran was trying to help Joe Biden, something we
can discuss later, Russia was the major country interfering in the US election, and they were
doing so on behalf of Donald Trump to undermine Joe Biden.
Now if I can extend that, the reason why we know that document was legitimate is because
Trump officials ordered the director of Homeland Security, Chad Wolf, to bury it, to make
sure this does not circulate.
And at the same time, they ordered US agencies to focus on Beijing and Tehran, and to not
look at Moscow.
That's the autumn of 2020.
Immediately after the election, by the way, Donald Trump fired Christopher Krebs, who
was the head of US cyber operations, in other words, monitoring what other countries did.
Now here's the stinger in the tail.
After Trump's speech, there's another document that was released.
This is a National Intelligence Council assessment.
This actually reconfirms that in 2020, Vladimir Putin used proxies to spread disinformation
about Joe Biden, including the allegation he was involved in corruption in Ukraine.
What's interesting about those named proxies is that they are confirmed associates of Donald
Trump's lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, and Donald Trump's former campaign manager, Paul Manafort.
So in fact, the US intelligence says exactly the opposite of what Trump said last night.
China was not involved in interference in 2020.
Russia, which of course had been interfering in the 2016 election in which Trump was elected,
was also doing the same in 2020, amplifying, if not working with the Trump camp on their
disinformation.
Right.
So we move on to the question with all of that in mind, Scott.
Why is Trump doing this now?
It might have something to do with a new poll from the Washington Post and the pollster's
Ipsos.
It indicated his approval rating had dropped to some 37 percent.
You can see how Trump's approval rating has trended in his second term from an opening
of 45 percent approval in February of 25.
Now it's down to that 37 percent mark.
Voters are reportedly unhappy with the president's handling of the economy and the war with
Iran.
If this is a deflection, Scott, I want to ask you if you think does election interference
as a topic work?
Now before you answer, just to underline the point of to how often Donald Trump has leaned
into this topic, here's a quick recap.
If you count the legal votes, I easily win.
If you count the illegal votes, they can try to steal the election from us.
Now it is up to Congress to confront this egregious assault on our democracy.
This was a fraudulent election.
That election, the 2020 presidential election, was by far the most corrupt election in the
history of our country.
The elections are rigged.
The rigged elections.
Your elections are crooked.
Yeah, so it's been a real go to.
As much as that might get a collective eye roll from people, Scott, polling would suggest
that it's something that concerns a lot of people, right?
Are they seriously worried about interference as much as the president hopes, though?
Yeah, full disclosure, I'm working on a book on Trump in America, so I've lived with those
quotes the past few days while I've been writing.
My starting point is I don't think it may be the primary issue for Americans in November's
elections.
I think that's more likely to be the economy.
I think for some it's going to be the failed Trump attempt to crack down on immigration.
I think the war on Iran will be there, but that's not the point here, and I think I need
to explain why.
What Donald Trump is setting up here is the possibility of manipulating the elections
for November, and then it could be, and I must emphasize, could be as serious as declaring
the elections rigged and moving to overturn them in November.
We know that Donald Trump never believes he lost an election, so we know that he thinks
every election has been rigged against him going back to 2016, even though he won the
Electoral College.
But beyond that, what Trump said he wants to do, first of all, is to get adoption of
the Save America Act.
Now, the Save America Act is not just the name, and it's not just voter ID.
It's actually an attempt for the federal government to take power of elections away from the states
and to make it much more difficult to vote.
I mean, this needs a full discussion, and I'm happy to do so, but it's an attempt to
restrict votes, which would affect Democrats.
However, there is more.
Beyond Republicans redistricting to make it easier for them to win elections, what the
Trump folks are hoping to do is also possibly to restrict mail-in balloting, because that
may also favor the Democrats, and they may use these claims as a pretext to do so.
But here's the most serious thing that could happen.
Back after 2020, what the Trump folks wanted to do in a last-ditch effort to overturn the
election, before the Capitol attack, they actually considered seizing voting machines.
Now, of course, if they seize voting machines, they could then flip the votes from Biden
to Trump.
This was discussed in a high-level White House meeting.
It was the subject of a draft executive order.
It was not implemented at that time.
But earlier this year, Tulsi Gabbard, then the Director of National Intelligence, went
to Georgia to ostensibly look at the voting machines to set up the argument it might be
necessary to seize them.
What Trump is doing is saying, you cannot trust the outcome of this election, therefore
setting up the pretext, if they want to use it, and I'm not sure they will, but if they
want to use it, which is, we've got to go in and seize those voting machines from the
states, which would be questionable in terms of constitutional authority, but we know how
far Trump will go to try to stay in office.
Scott, if deflection doesn't work, if what you describe as manipulation doesn't work,
what then happens in November?
How bad could it get?
What would it change about his behaviour if Republicans get the sort of beating that his
approval ratings might imply is coming?
I'm going to go back again, and partly because I've been writing about it, I'm going to go
back to 2020.
And I just want to remind folks that although that was a presidential election, not just
congressional elections, how close it came to what in effect was a coup.
And that is, had the Vice President Mike Pence not refused to, in effect, intervene over
the congressional certification of the vote, if Pence had followed a scheme put out by
Trump and his advisers, where they would not recognise some of the states that Biden won,
that coup probably would have succeeded, irrespective of the capital attack that followed later
that day.
That's how close it was.
I'll also remind folks out there right now that in 2026, during the second term of Trump,
the Trump folks have removed regulators of elections.
Just a few days ago, they removed the commission or the committee that's responsible for liaising
between the federal government and the states.
It was created after the 2000 voting issue in Florida, but it basically liaised over
administration of ballots and on the counting of ballots.
They've removed that regulator.
So they have cleared space to do this.
Will they do this?
I can't predict they will, but there is form that they have tried this in the past.
And if they try, we're on unknown territory, because, just to put it bluntly, no sitting
president has ordered the seizure of voting machines and no president before has considered
issuing a national emergency, an order of a national emergency, in order to justify
trying to do so.
Scott, the president has really set the scene for what promises to be an incredible three
months in the lead up to the midterm elections.
Thanks so much for drawing your focus to it today and ours.
We thank you again.
Scott Lucas from University College in Dublin.
Always a pleasure.
Thanks so much.
Thank you.
So there is a lot to unpack on this one.
Do you believe Trump, if it is a cynical strategy deployed to offset low approval ratings?
Will it work?
Should we even be reporting on it?
The floor is yours.
We'll be reading your comments until we see you next time.
From Berlin, it's bye for now.