Blanche Caught In Lies About Jan 6th Fund Courtesy of Former Federal Judges!!!

GBN
3 followers
Jul 16, 2026
In an exclusive briefing, Popok is joined by former fed Judge Luttig and Miami trial attorney Andres Rivero to dissect their big win for the Rule of Law with Judge Williams’ scathing rebuke of Todd Blanche and its impact on the confirmation hearing.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis episode of Legal AF examines Judge Williams' ruling sanctioning Donald Trump and Todd Blanche for deceiving the court. The discussion highlights the intervention of 35 former federal judges to protect judicial integrity, the legal controversy surrounding a \"super pardon,\" and the broader implications of Todd Blanche's potential appointment as Attorney General on the rule of law.
Welcome to a special edition of Legal AF. As Todd Blanche is grilled in day one of his
confirmation hearing, one of the major topics was a 56-page decision by a federal judge in Miami,
Judge Williams. She taking painstaking detail in her order in which she excoriates Todd Blanche,
Donald Trump, his private lawyers ends up as part of her sanctions,
sending Todd Blanche off for a bar referral for possible discipline, finds ultimately that there
has been effectively a fraud or deceit on the court, and then sets about in setting up sanctions,
monetary and non-monetary to address it. And how did we get there? As people have been closely
following the story in Legal AF know, a group of former federal judges, 35 in number,
led by people like J. Michael Ludwig and Nancy Gertner and others, bound together and filed
a motion, a particular motion, to get Judge Williams to reconsider the dismissal of the case
and look into whether a fraud had been perpetrated on the court and have her say something about that
and the release, we call it the super pardon, that Todd Blanche, the nominee for attorney general,
gave or tried to give to Donald Trump, his family, his associates, his affiliates for tax and audit
liability and criminal cases as well. And all that came together. We've got the ruling,
it became fodder for today's confirmation hearing with Todd Blanche and the senators
on the Senate Judiciary Committee. And I wanted to bring back to the show,
Judge J. Michael Ludwig and Andres Rivera about the case and pick up the pieces from there.
Hi, Judge. Hi, Andres. Hey, Michael. Thank you for having us on this afternoon.
Absolutely. Let me read to our audience some of the key passages, just a couple,
just to get the idea of what you, Judge, and your fellow judges were able to accomplish
in guiding the court, at least providing her with the law and the facts and the jurisprudence
in order for her to render her decision. Here's what she says. This is starting on page two.
It says, after review of the record and the party statements, the court declines to adopt or accept
the credulous exercise of divorcing President Trump's current job title from an understanding
of what happened here. She then goes over what happened here. She said that perhaps the most
startling misstatement advanced by plaintiffs is their characterization of this case as ordinary.
The parties here are not private actors to a mine run dispute, recounting their proficiency in the
art of the deal they negotiated. Lead plaintiff and defendants are public servants,
pinnacle of the executive branch, sworn to uphold the law, faithfully perform the duties of their
office, protect the interests of the American public. The issue before the court is whether
instead they ignored ethical norms, court rules, and legal authority to manipulate the judicial
process. The issue is whether they did so to gild their efforts to gain unprecedented access
to the public fisc with the pentina of legitimacy. There is nothing ordinary
about this case. It is the very definition of sui generis. Judge, your comments about
Judge Williams, is this what you would hope that she would do in her 56 pages?
Michael, Judge Williams' opinion is a magnificent decision on the rule of law in America.
Before I answer that question, though, I want to thank you and Legal AF and Midas Touch for the
courage to represent the other members of the free press in America, many of whom
have refused to carry forward with their responsibilities as a free press in America.
Now, the wheels of justice and the wheels of the rule of law always grind slowly, very slowly,
but they always grind inaccurately to the point of and in the direction of
absolute faithfulness to the rule of law. In the past year and a half since Donald Trump took
office again, those wheels of justice, those wheels of the rule of law have been grinding
slowly at first, but then gradually faster and faster toward the rule of law in America.
At this point, I'm prepared to say that the rule of law through the federal courts of the United
States have rendered their final verdict on Donald Trump and his administration's
effort to subvert the rule of law in this country. Judge, thank you for your compliment.
And of course, Judge Williams complimented your group and the other friends of the court. Here's
what she said in her footnote on page 53 of her order. The court acknowledges and thanks
court-appointed Amici and their firms, that's you, Andre, for their willingness to review
the unprecedented jurisdictional questions presented by this case, their thorough
and well-reasoned scholarship, and uncompromising commitment to the rule of law,
along with those of the organizations and lawyers referenced, SUPRA, are hallmark
of a vigorous, independent legal profession, critical to sustaining a vigorous, independent
judiciary. Michael, those statements by the court are immensely satisfying and gratifying
to all of the judges in America, and especially to those judges who filed the amicus brief in
this case. But beyond that, I won't have any comment on behalf of this group of judges
as to her opinion. But this is what we argued for as a friend of the court. And as you said
at the beginning of the hour, all we did was brief the court on the applicable law on facts
and the court rendered this decision based upon our brief and the court's own evaluation
of the facts and the law. Before I turn to you, Andres, let me frame a new issue,
because it looks like the Department of Justice captured by Donald Trump has ignored
about 99.9% of what Judge Williams wrote, and has latched onto and lighted onto
one paragraph and one footnote. I'm going to read it to you, and I want to get your
impression of this. They're now taking the position, it's almost like the Dumb and Dumber
movie. It's like you're saying there is a chance. So the release that Todd Blanch signed the day
after he created the weaponization fund through a phony bad faith settlement of a lawsuit that
should never have been brought, in which he alone unilaterally granted to the Donald Trump,
his family, organizations, and affiliates, a super pardon from tax liability and audit exposure
and criminal liability. That's not before the judge. That still stands. We still have that in
our back pocket. Here's one section, one section of the 56 pages that there looks like they're
relying on. She says that in the bottom of page 37, in dismissing the non-party's claims of
collusion, plaintiffs reveal the true position of the parties and say the quiet part out loud.
Regardless of whether plaintiffs had ever filed this action, the government and plaintiffs still
had the power to resolve all disputes between the parties. The power to resolve was never a
question before this court. Whether executive branch actors can privately agree to give
themselves and their former clients blanket immunities and billions of dollars in tax
monies for legally undefined grievances was never an issue advanced in this court.
The question is whether the parties could do so by claiming to be adverse
and engaging the legitimacy of a court proceeding, and the answer is a resounding no.
So they're latching onto that and another footnote. What do you make of that, Andres?
Well, Michael, there's a lot to talk about what the judge did and what the relief is, but
I would be very careful if I were them. I think they're over-reading, as you say,
one cherry-picked point. When they're looking at footnotes, they need to go to footnote 59.
By the way, this is a very well-done opinion. I'd recommend it to any of your viewers if they
have a chance at least to look at the facts. But in terms of what this judge said, besides what
you just referred to, which is not a positive for the president or the Department of Justice,
she says, however, this decision should not be understood as a final determination
regarding any fraud perpetrated on the court and does not foreclose the possibility of future
relief under Rule 60d-3, which is post-judgment relief, that rule. So the judge is saying,
do not fool with me. I still have the power to make a finding of fraud in the court,
which would carry additional serious consequences.
So she's inviting a 60d-3 motion.
If I can just briefly, I wanted to follow up on both your comment to the judge and his response.
You saw my thunder because I was going to quote the same language really about the judges,
and let me just say the former judges. And Judge Lutich as the leader has been fantastic,
but I think it's really important that everybody understand that this group of brave 55 judges
have really helped back up the independence of our judiciary and Judge Williams in particular.
I mean, Judge Williams is a very strong person. She's appointed for life,
but you still get public pressure. You still get these kinds of criticisms from the president and
other executives, and it can affect the judge. And I think it is extraordinarily important what
your group has done, Judge Lutich. And I'd encourage the other, if I count right,
is it 256 who I think joined one of your bar complaints. So there's a lot of independent
former judges out there, and I just want to send that message out. You all are doing
important work for the rule of law. Quick shout out, Matt Plotkin and his law firm,
Norm Eisen and Freedom Defenders, and my young colleague, Daniella Tenito,
who've been fantastic in this case. And thank you for mentioning the lawyers,
but this is really about the former judges and Judge Lutich and Judge Gertner.
Let me just say one more. Judge Williams did not accept other important amicus briefs,
and she really relied on this one because the credibility of former judges like Judge Lutich,
who was a circuit court judge, an appellate judge in the United States, their credibility
is so important. They don't have an ax to grind, and it's really important what this group has done.
Thank you, Andre. So what I would just say to that for your viewers and listeners, Michael,
is this. We do know that our colleagues who are active judges on the courts, both federal and
state, have been unsupported for the past two, five, six years, even by the Supreme Court of
the United States, and of course, unsupported by the Congress of the United States or the
administration or anyone else. We do know that the sitting active judges appreciate our interest
in the cases in which we've filed amicus briefs. It's, as I said, it's gratifying,
but your listeners and viewers must understand that all we have done as former judges is file
a brief which anyone else could file. Now, to the credibility point, Andres, this is the point.
No judge, and least of all these judges, would file or submit one single word
to a court of the United States. That judge or that group of judges was not entirely certain
was a statement of law or fact. That's a little bit in the weeds, but it's imperative
that your viewers and listeners understand that really simple point, which is when we speak in
our briefs, there is not even an argument that a single word is political. And to prove your point,
and I've been a proud member of the Southern District of Florida for over 30 years. I know
Andres is my contemporary and my peer. I was so proud of what Judge Williams did. I mean,
she's got the bona fides to write it. I mean, she was the federal public defender for two
different districts before she became a federal judge. But I was so proud of this particular
Southern District of Florida, one that Donald Trump often handpicks as his venue of choice for
God knows what reason, other than to try to get judges up in the northern part of the district,
like Judge Cannon. But he keeps filing in Miami, and he gets judges like Judge Gales and Judge
Williams and Judge Ungaro and other judges that are applying the facts of the law and
they're writing statements. This will live on in history, the way that she has written this.
To prove Judge Ludwig's point, when I'm an advocate in federal court, the only thing that
Andres and I have is our reputation, that the judges can trust and rely on what we say. They
may not rule in our favor, but they know if they ask me a question about a case, a precedent,
or a fact in the case or in the record, that when I speak, they can rely on it as an honest
officer of the court. And that is done with the Department of Justice. They don't have that
presumption of regularity or good faith any longer. Certainly not with Todd Blanch at the helm
or Donald Trump at the helm. And I think that's what Judge Ludwig is saying. When you guys write
it down, judges can sigh a little relief and say, okay, here's a nonpartisan, independent analysis
of the issues. That's why she reached out to her own Amici. She picked out former Judge Gleason
and a former Solicitor General to give her guidance on some jurisdictional issues until
the cavalry arrived, right? So, Michael, let me address that for a moment.
And give some context, if you will. So, for 150 to 200 years before the federal courts,
I am unaware of a single instance in briefing and especially in oral argument before a court
where the litigant has evidenced the contempt, the utter contempt for the court and for the rule
of law and for the court's constitution of the United States that this administration,
through its attorneys general and its Department of Justice officials,
shown to the federal courts of the United States every single day for the past year and a half.
This is not just unprecedented. This is forbidden by the constitution of the United States, Michael.
Well, maybe it's because people like Todd Blanche have lost their way. Look at this
Freudian slip during questioning today by a friendly Senator Kennedy from Louisiana
to Todd Blanche, where he's completely lost sight of who he is or what his job
is in the Department of Justice. Play the clip.
Are you and President Trump friends?
I'm his lawyer, was his lawyer, and now I'm the Deputy Attorney General. So, I met him as his
criminal defense attorney. I'm not sure there's very many people who have ever had a criminal
defense attorney who calls that person their friend. I now have a-
Well, let me put it this way. Are you enemies?
No, we're not enemies at all. No.
Yeah, he forgot. I'm his lawyer. Could you imagine Merrick Garland or any attorney general
in history forgetting who his client was, as in the United States of America and the American people?
No, and it was a fraud. I saw the Freudian slip where he says, I am, I was. Let's not forget,
Judge Williams is also a proud alum of the U.S. Attorney's Office here in the Southern
District of Florida, as I am, before she was the public defender. This is an indictment
of the conduct of the Department of Justice. It's a thoroughgoing indictment of the conduct of that
gentleman who's up for attorney general and of the United States Department of Justice,
and it will stand. Michael, I think this is a moment of shame. As a former prosecutor,
very proud of my service, it's a moment of shame for our Department of Justice.
Let me read, before I turn back to the judge, let me read from the order, page 50, 56. You can pick
any other page of this and read it aloud, and I think law students and civic-minded
people should all do it. We've posted it up on Legal AF Substack.
Defendant's conduct is equally untenable. It is telling that the Department of Justice,
which is tasked with enforcement of United States law, has remained conspicuously absent
and silent when serious questions about this matter have been raised. And when representatives
did choose to expound on the department's conduct, they offered misleading explanations of the facts
and the law in abdicating its responsibility to zealously defend the interests of the United
States. The government entered into a settlement, in quotes, that deviated from its litigation
posture and similar actions, disregarded DOJ policies, and accomplished objectives beyond
those authorized, as well as those specifically prohibited by law. Under these circumstances,
the court may reasonably infer that the government failed to defend the lawsuit
or to respond to the court's jurisdictional inquiry because its position would not withstand
judicial scrutiny, and because resolution of these threshold issues identified by the court
would not have favored the preferred outcome to this case. I mean, judge, you've been a judge.
You ever written words like that about the Department of Justice?
No, of course not. But the point is, no judge in American history has ever had
the occasion to say anything like that. Judge Williams' opinion, as a consequence,
will now be studied and parsed forever throughout the remainder of American history.
It is unassailable, but most importantly, it is a statement of the rule of law in America
in the context of the President of the United States having attacked and gone to war with that
rule of law through his attorneys general, Todd Blanche. I'll go on to say, to the relevant point
today, if the Republican Senate confirms Todd Blanche to be the next attorney general,
it will represent to America and Americans the beginning of the end of the rule of law in this
country. Talk about, on that note, let me just show you a clip about the Jan 6th Weaponization
Fund and point-blank questioning by, I think, Senator Padilla today during the hearing and
just get your reaction to it. Let's play that clip. Coming back to January 6th,
there've been several of my colleagues who've asked about the quote-unquote slush fund.
Do you personally believe that someone who forcibly entered the US Capitol and assaulted
law enforcement should be rewarded with taxpayer money? Yes or no? I can't answer it yes or no,
but if you want the answer, I think that the fund that doesn't exist anymore set up parameters
where no, somebody that you just described would likely not recover funds.
Which brings me to my other point, because several members have asked, and I know Senator Tillis
specifically focused on the weaponization slush fund and language versus declarations versus
appropriations bills on how to undo this. I also need to be clear that January 6th-ers should not
be able to seek payouts from other sources, including the Federal Tort Claims Act. Do you
commit to vigorously defending taxpayer money from being paid out to January 6th-riders,
those who were convicted of their involvement with January 6th, regardless of the source of
funding from the Department of Justice? You're talking about a statute that exists
and allows anybody to file a suit against the United States. So I can tell you we always
vigorously defend our cases, but I can't speak to a particular case-
But we know this is a hypothetical. There's been at least four letters that I've signed
on to along with Senators Durbin, Klobuchar, and Whitehouse who asked earlier about the status of
January 6th-riders seeking payouts from the department. When can we expect responses to
those letters? When you say status,
you mean those that have filed cases in court? I don't know what that means.
Status of their request for payouts being reviewed, approved, or not.
I think anybody, including January 6th defendants, can file a claim under the Federal Torts Claims
Act, and I think some of them have. Those cases are ongoing. They're publicly available on ECF.
Yeah, you saw all the top dancing there. They always vigorously defend their cases,
except when they're not vigorously defending their cases in the IRS Trump case.
Now, Michael, Mr. Blanch's testimony today before the Congress of the United States,
contemptible. Every word of it, contemptible. As a candidate for Attorney General of the United
States of America, he is an embarrassment to America itself. Again, if the Republican Senate
confirms this man on his record to be the next Attorney General, it will mark the end of the
rule of law in America. Let's touch briefly here at the
end, Judge, with the Society for the Rule of Law and its Institute. That's been a big part of your
life, one of the founders of it. The group has issued a statement today. Talk to our audience
about that and how they, because I know they admire you so, and you've been on with me probably
two dozen times already. I don't know if you read your comments. I certainly do. You are definitely
a hero among our audience. What can they do, having watched all of this, hearing you, this
call to action? Maybe it's something related to the rule of law society. Talk about that.
I would encourage every one of your millions and millions of viewers, Michael, to join
the Society for the Rule of Law for a nominal annual fee so that you can read every day,
if you want, about what's going on with the rule of law and the Constitution in this country,
just like they can tune in to you every day and get the same information.
The only difference, and I mean this in all good faith, the only difference is that
being the Society for the Rule of Law, we speak legalese, but when it really matters,
as it has in the past year and a half, the legalese is eminently understandable
by every person in the streets. That's what I would say in short. Then,
in the short time that we have here, I would say, follow what we do as a society,
follow what the Judges Coalition does every day for the next two and a half years,
and follow what you say on your broadcast of Legal AF, Michael.
Appreciate all of that, Your Honor, and thank you always for being here. Andre,
it's always great to see when your name pops up in many of the cases opposing the Trump
administration. We had you on originally, I've known you for years, but we had you on originally
about the library and the land grab for free that was a $300 million gift to Donald Trump
that he still hasn't paid back to the taxpayers and to the alum of the Miami Dade College.
From there, glad to see that people like Matt Plotkin, who I know well from his time as Attorney
General of New Jersey, and Norm Eisen grabbed you to be local counsel here. I can't think
of anybody finer to show up in the Southern District of Florida than you. Thank you,
Michael, and we've got more coming, so stay tuned. Okay, send it to me. I'll embargo it.
In the meantime, Judge Ludwig, thank you for being on here. As things develop, and I'm sure
unfortunately for you, I guess you wanted to retire. Your work is far from over,
especially if Todd Blanche ends up getting that nomination. He can't lose one vote. The question
is gonna be whether somebody like Senator Tillis, who's got nothing left to lose, or Senator Cornyn
from Texas is gonna decide to oppose him. Tomorrow's gonna be some sort of testimonial
witnesses of some sort. And for everybody here on Legal AF, come over to the live tab,
because we've been running the live stream of Todd Blanche's confirmation hearing. Day one
got over 150,000 views. I did the pregame show to start it, and we're off and running now with day
two. Pick it up on the live tab here on Legal AF. In the meantime, gentlemen, thank you for joining
us and briefing our audience. Thank you, Michael. Thank you, Michael. And take a moment, and if you
like this kind of content and you support the rule of law and our pro-democracy channel,
hit the free subscribe button. Until my next report, I'm Michael Popoc.
We got some new reporting. We got interviews. We got ad-free versions of the podcast
and hot takes where Legal AF on Substack. Come over now to free subscribe.
