This Fancy Thrift Store Hides Incredible Bargains

What treasures are hiding in this little mountain town? We find surprising bargains, unusual antiques, and vintage pieces we’ve never seen before.

A viewer invitation brings us to Payson, Arizona, for our first visit, and the town quickly proves to be full of surprises. At the Humane Society Thrift Shop, a carefully curated front boutique gives way to bargain-filled back rooms where we uncover a $2 Heisey Lariat relish, Tea Leaf ironstone, $5 sand paintings, unusual MCM-style Kokeshi dolls, a charming 1930s lady powder jar, and even a faux catalog that also serves as toilet paper for the outhouse. Every stop offers another unexpected discovery, reminding us that great vintage hunting often happens in places most people overlook.