Is the Selkirk OMNI a better-controlled alternative to the Selkirk Boomstik? In this Selkirk OMNI pickleball paddle review, we test its power, pop, spin, sweet spot, stability, adjustable MOI weights, and on-court control.
The Selkirk OMNI is a 16 mm Gen 4 foam-core paddle built for players who want serious power without the extremely lively response of the Boomstik. It still has enough speed to finish points, but the slightly lower power and pop make drops, resets, dinks, and defensive shots easier to manage.
We tested the elongated OMNI and compared it directly with the Boomstik. We also discuss the widebody version, which offers very high twist weight and may be a strong option for players who prioritize forgiveness and stability on off-center hits.
One of the OMNI’s most interesting features is the removable MOI weight system. The weights can be repositioned to change swing weight, balance, stability, and power. With the weights installed, the elongated OMNI weighs about 8.2 ounces with a swing weight around 121.5. Removing them drops the weight to about 7.7 ounces and reduces swing weight below 114.
The OMNI uses Selkirk’s InfiniGrit surface and produces more than 2,000 RPM of spin. In our measurements, it generated about 56 MPH of power and 36.6 MPH of pop. Those numbers are slightly lower than the Boomstik, but the OMNI is still clearly a power paddle.
Its three-layer foam construction combines a floating foam core, an expanded polypropylene foam ring, and an EVA foam outer ring. The result is a slightly firmer, more controlled feel. The sweet spot may feel smaller near the edges, but the paddle remains stable and predictable, especially with the weights in their original positions.
On court, the OMNI offers better control on third-shot drops, resets, dinks, and transition-zone defense. The ball does not launch off the face as aggressively as it does with the Boomstik, which can help players who often hit long or pop the ball up. The tradeoff is slightly less speed in fast hands battles.
We also discuss edge-guard and weight-system durability. Our paddle stayed stable during testing, but more long-term feedback is needed.
Overall, the Selkirk OMNI is best for players who want a true power paddle with more control, spin, and stability than the Boomstik.
Disclosure: Selkirk provided this paddle at no cost and had no input into this review.
Use Selkirk code INF-PIRATES to receive a $30 Selkirk gift card with an eligible purchase and support The Pickleball Pirates.
CHAPTERS
00:00 Selkirk OMNI review 00:05 Disclosure and gift-card code 00:29 Review overview 00:34 Paddle specifications 01:04 Weight and swing weight 01:18 Elongated vs widebody 01:22 Twist weight and stability 02:01 InfiniGrit spin performance 02:12 Power and pop measurements 02:29 Surface durability 02:52 OMNI vs Boomstik core 03:24 Three-layer foam design 03:50 Sweet spot and control 04:16 Balance and head-heavy feel 04:45 Adjustable MOI weights 05:02 Repositioning the weights 05:35 How weight placement changes play 06:02 Adjusting power 06:28 Possible rules concerns 07:02 Edge-guard durability 07:40 OMNI vs Boomstik on court 07:49 Why I prefer the OMNI 08:02 Sweet-spot comparison 08:26 Drops, resets, and control 08:36 Spin and dwell time 08:55 Sound comparison 09:00 Put-away power 09:13 Hands battles and pop 09:28 Is the tradeoff worth it? 09:49 Widebody stability 09:59 Design and appearance 10:13 Final thoughts
Hey everyone, today I'm gonna review the Selkirk SLK Omni,
the new hotness from Selkirk.
Quick disclosure,
this paddle was sent to me for free by Selkirk.
They have no input on what I say on this review.
This is my opinion, my opinion only,
based on my experience playing this paddle
and other paddles that I have reviewed.
If you wanna use our code
and get a $30 gift card from Selkirk,
it's right here up on the screen.
You can get INF-Pirates
and you can get a $30 gift card from the Selkirk store.
So let's jump right into it.
We're gonna talk about the specs.
We'll talk about the playing profiles
and I'll give you some comparison.
So first off, let's just go with the specs here.
This is a Gen 4, which means it is a foam core paddle.
It is 16 millimeter.
It has a 5.80 grip length.
So this is phenomenal for the 2E.
It has a 4.25 inch circumference grip.
So this is good for the smaller hands.
It also has stiff slats in the handle.
So it's not a soft handle.
So really feels supportive and sturdy on the handle.
So really like the way that they've done that.
This paddle comes in at 8.2 static weight.
If you take the removable weights off,
which I'm gonna talk about a little bit later,
this drops down to 7.7 without the weights.
It has a 121.5 swing weight.
And when you take the weights off,
that'll drop it down to under 114.
I am talking about the elongated.
I will make some mentions on the wide body here
just to get some stats that have been measured
by the independent testers that I think is worth noting.
The twist weight on this is 6.8 to 7.1
between the two different models.
And it will drop down to 5.59
when you take off the MOI weight.
So it does drop down significantly
when you take the weights off.
Now, one small note, like I mentioned earlier,
the wide body version of this by the independent testers
is one of the highest twist weight paddles
that have been measured.
So that is pretty incredible when you think about that
of across all the thousands of paddles
that have been measured,
it is one of the highest,
if not the highest in the twist weight category.
So good note there,
if you like the standard or wide body version of paddles.
The spin on this, this has the InfiniGrit surface.
It has over 2000 RPMs on the spin,
which is actually over a hundred RPMs higher
than the Boomstick.
That might be a little bit about the playing profile,
but it is a little bit higher on the spin.
On the power metrics, 56 miles an hour on the power,
which is about two miles an hour slower than the Boomstick
and 36.6 miles an hour in the pop,
which is about one mile per hour slower than the Boomstick.
The InfiniGrit surface has been proven to last longer
than the traditional carbon face paddles,
but the newer paddle faces like the 6.0 DiamondGrit,
they're new paddle textures that are coming out
that are being shown to last longer.
But this is proven scientifically by the measurements
that it will last longer
than a traditional carbon fiber face.
So let's get into the guts of this thing
and talk about what's different
between this and the Boomstick.
The Boomstick had two EPP foam cores.
It had a floating EPP foam core,
which EPP stands for expanded polypropylene,
which just means they fill it with foam
and it fills up the gap, right?
And so it had a floating core
and then it just had an EVA foam core, a ring around that.
So had a floating foam core, EVA foam ring around that,
which is just a softer, more plus feeling foam.
And that allows it for a little bit more stability,
soft feel around the edges.
What they've done differently on the Omni
is it's got three rings.
It's got the floating foam core,
and then it has a secondary foam core of EPP,
a little bit higher density foam core around that.
And then it's got the EVA foam ring
all the way around the edge,
which is a little bit smaller EVA foam ring,
which I'll talk about how that affects the sweet spot
just a little bit later.
But overall, three different textures in the paddle core,
which gives this a different feel than the Boomstick.
In my opinion by feel,
this paddle feels like it does have
a slightly smaller sweet spot by feel
and feels a little bit stiffer because of the foam rings,
but it is a power paddle
that is more controllable than the Boomstick.
So overall, because of the little bit less power
on this thing, it is more controllable.
By the sweet spot measurements
and consistency across the face,
this is gonna feel a little bit differently
than the Boomstick.
Now this is gonna feel a little bit more head heavy
than the Boomstick because its balance point
is a little bit more far forward.
It is gonna feel more stable
because it does have a little bit of a higher twist weight,
but it still has the same hollow feel and sound
as the Boomstick with a little bit more on the stiff side.
And that's probably because of the foam rings,
like I said earlier,
because of the higher density foam ring,
it's gonna feel a little bit stiffer in the hands,
but very similar profile to the YOLO 4
or the Bread and Butter Loco.
So very similar feel to those paddles.
Let's talk about the movable weights a minute here.
Now these movable weights here,
this is one good addition they've done from the Boomstick.
You can just take off these movable weights
and it does make an adjustment on the paddle itself.
As I talked about earlier on the weight difference,
you can really move these around
to get the different playing profiles.
They come in stock here around the three and the six,
and then you can move these around to the nine and the three
or the eight and the four,
and you can really change the profiles significantly
by moving these weights around.
But what this does is this just moves the inertia, right?
So we're putting weights around here in this band.
And if we move these around,
we move these down below or we move these up higher,
this is gonna change the profile significantly
by two to three points in each direction.
Meaning that if I take these weights
and put them down here on the edge of the bottom,
then this is gonna lower the swing weight.
It's gonna make the power of this paddle go down.
It's gonna make it a little bit less controllable
because I'm moving the weight
to the more center of the paddle,
which is going to make my off-center shots
a little bit less stable.
I typically like to have mine up here on the edge.
I like these actually where the stock position is.
They felt the most stable to me
with the most consistent feel across the face.
But the way you would use this is in,
let's say you're having a really strong day
and you're hitting the ball out of bounds
and you're popping it up a little too much,
you can just lower the weights down or down to here
and that'll take some of the power off
or exactly the other way around
is that if you're not hitting strong,
you can always raise the weights up.
If you go all the way to the top,
you're gonna lose some power and lose some twist weight,
but you can go all the way up here to the edges
and you will increase the swing weight
to give you more power.
So I like the adjustable nature of it.
The one question I have is that,
will the PPA or the APP Tour,
will they eventually make a rule
where you can't modify a paddle in a game, right?
Meaning that you can come in
and realize you're hitting too strong
and then just lower the weights here
in between points or in a timeout.
I don't know if they're gonna make rules against that,
but that's to be determined.
But it does seem like you could adjust
and make things different during a match,
which could be an unfair advantage.
So we'll see if the rules change on that,
if any high profile games get won or lost by that.
I doubt anything's gonna happen with it,
but it is just a note, just a thought I had.
And then the other thing is,
is that will the edge guards hold steady?
Because one of the drawbacks of the Boomstick
has been that the edge guards came loose.
These have been very stable.
I think Chris Olson did a video
where he removed these a hundred times
and the edge guard didn't come loose.
So there is a benefit there,
or it seems like they've stabilized it up here.
But I know at least John Q showed an example
of the top edge guard coming loose
when he moved the MOI weight up here.
We're gonna have to get more of these in the wild
before we see if the edge guard's gonna become a problem
like it did on the Boomstick.
For now, this looks like they've done a pretty good job
on the edge guard.
Now I've played the Boomstick for months,
so I could definitely tell a difference
in playing this paddle.
I could tell a little bit less pop, a little bit less power,
but it wasn't so drastic that I hated it.
It was just a little bit different.
I actually prefer a control paddle,
so I actually like the Omni better than the Boomstick
because I had a little bit of problems
with the elongated Boomstick of keeping it in play
and really popping the ball up and getting killed.
Playing this though, if you're a paddle nerd,
you will feel the difference.
I can tell the difference in the sweet spot.
So the sweet spot does feel a little bit smaller in this.
As you get towards these edges,
it's a little bit less consistent than the Boomstick
where the Boomstick has a little bit more consistency
across the face, probably because, like I said,
the change of the foam rings,
we're only dealing with two changes of density versus three,
which does change the properties of a paddle.
But drop shots, any of the control shots,
I love the Omni better.
I wasn't getting killed in my drop shots.
In the kitchen, much, much control.
The spin is definitely noticeable,
probably because there's a little bit more dwell time
on this paddle,
because it is a little bit of a softer feel
when it comes off the paddle.
So it does feel like it has a little bit more dwell time.
So it does have about 100 RPM more on the spin.
So I was able to notice that a little bit,
but that's my guess on the dwell time a little bit.
Same similar sound.
The Boomstick does have a little bit more
of a boomier sound.
This has a little bit less, but very similar.
You're probably not gonna notice a huge difference in that.
Still has plenty of power to put the ball away.
Like you can still put the ball away.
The couple mile an hour difference
is not gonna be the difference of night and day,
but you are gonna feel the difference in hands battles
because of the pop difference.
You're gonna feel that the ball's not on your opponent
as fast as this,
and the ball doesn't just pop off like a rocket,
like the Boomstick.
So it is a little bit noticeable difference
of the power and the pop,
but is the trade-off worth it, right?
It's $30 less of a paddle.
It is a little bit more controllable.
So it really depends on the playing profile that you like.
Do you want a little bit less power,
but still in the power category?
You might do a little bit better.
You might have a little bit more consistency
on your touch shots,
a little bit more consistency on the control shots.
And because of the twist weight increase,
especially with the wide body version,
your resets or anything from no man's land
is gonna feel more stable with the Omni.
Lastly, and I know this is just aesthetics.
I like the logo better.
I like the way that they've done the design of this
and the color schemes
and the way they've changed some of the things
on this paddle.
So personally, I like the looks of this paddle
better as well.
So anyway, that's all I have for the Omni.
Once again, you can use our code in the description below.
That'll help you get $30 gift card at the Selkirk store.
I wanna thank those of you that are using our code.
It helps us keep the lights on,
helps us bring you these reviews
so you can make informed paddle purchases.
If you don't like Selkirk
and you wanna try a different brand,
come here, check out these reviews here.