LIVE: FDA Roundtable Examines E. Coli Food Safety Risks

Live News Network
1.4K followers
23 Video Views·Jul 9, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Moreover, as we're highlighting in the red font and the red arrows,
between 2018, 2019, and 2020, environmental sampling that was done during FDA-led
on-farm investigations yielded that outbreak strain. First in 2018 from surface water
reservoir sediment. That was from the Santa Barbara County Farm. And then in subsequent
years, we found that outbreak strain in cattle feces that was picked up adjacent to Salinas
Valley Farms. So the FDA does have a very long history of conducting and accomplishing
longitudinal studies. And there are certain fundamental things that have gone into each
and every one of them. And that's what I'm highlighting here in these next five bullets.
The study area and where we perform the research is on a very large geographical area.
Over a period of years, we like to follow an adaptive research strategy. And so what this
means is that, you know, as the studies progressing over the years, maybe we see
data trends, or we have another reason where we want to make changes. And so this could be
changes to our sampling intensity. It could be, you know, maybe we add or reduce the number of
sampling sites that we're using. It could be the methodologies that we use. So we can either
adapt new or novel methodologies as the study's progressing. Or maybe we, you know, see that
some methodologies for sampling just aren't working out like we thought they would, and so
we can drop them. But importantly, we're not out there to place blame. We're not trying to point
fingers at anyone, and certainly not to start any regulatory action. But rather to provide a
scientific basis for our recommendations, and really specifically identify practical preventative
controls that the agricultural community can really implement, and that we know are going to
be effective. And so I'll just take another opportunity to really emphasize the collaborative
nature of these longitudinal studies, and just highlight that our overarching goal is always to
enhance food safety. So as I mentioned earlier, you know, we had a clear indication
of the geographical area that we wanted to focus in on, based upon the previous positive
environmental samples that we obtained, plus the recognition that the central coastal region of
California is where a majority of the leafy greens are being grown. And so on the map on the
right, that's the map of California. In blue, what I'm illustrating there is really where this central
coastal region is located. It's sort of sandwiched in between San Francisco to the north, and Los
Angeles to the south. And then the map on the left here, that's actually expanding upon that area,
just so you can visualize a little bit easier what it looks like, the topography looks like.
But I also wanted to highlight that within this region, we have different watersheds,
and that's what's being illustrated here with the W1 through W8 designations. And so overall,
our study area encompassed about 7,000 square miles. And we were out there sampling from
the summer of 2020 to late spring of 2025. So about a total of five years of continuous sampling.
Now, we looked at where we wanted to sample within this area. We looked at the topography of the
region, and we knew that there was two features that we wanted to study more intensely and really
to highlight in the study. One feature, and that's being shown there on the picture on the left,
is that we know that produce fields are often in low-lying areas in close proximity
to the hilly sloped cattle and other livestock rangeland. And so we knew that that was an area
that we wanted to study. And then on the right, we're showing a different area. And this is an
area where the farmland lies very much adjacent to riparian areas. Riparian areas are areas where you
have a lot of vegetation, and they're usually found along surface waterways like rivers.
Importantly, these areas are also where wildlife is attracted to it. It provides a habitat for
wildlife. And so we wanted to better assess what the impact of that might be. So the individual
sites here that we're highlighting in either blue or yellow, that's just for illustrative purposes.
These are just mock sites just to give you an idea. But in blue, we have our private operations.
Here we're showing on the right Farm A, on the left Farm B. And then in the yellow circles are
publicly accessible sites. So these are sites that might be along the hill slopes of that
rangeland I was talking about, or they could be located actually on that valley floor.
But how we choose those public sites is really what we want to do is to get kind of around the
perimeter or frame, right, our private sites. So in this case, again, we're showing that with Farm A
and Farm B for illustrative purposes. But each site we attempted to sample from every four to
eight weeks. This varied depending upon sample matrix and there might be some other factors that
were driving that. But so we tried to go again, very repeatedly back again and again to the same
site over the course of the five years of the study. So speaking of the matrix, I'm going to
walk through now the different matrices that we sampled from during those five years. We collected
samples from air. We collected samples from biological soil amendments or BSAs.
You may have heard of compost, right? That's what we're talking about here. We collected a lot of
feces. We collected opportunistically fecal pets from livestock and also scat from wildlife.
We did trap and test a number of insects and also a number of leaf samples.
These leaves originated from our vineyard locations. And so the idea here by collecting
and testing the leaves was, you know, could we assess what might be the atmospheric deposition
of STEC onto plant tissue by testing the leaves of the vineyard? We collected a lot of soil samples
and also a large number of sediment samples. And by sediment, what I'm talking about is the
solid material that's often found beneath areas of surface waters like creeks or perhaps areas
where water is more transient. So think about, like, you know, ditches alongside of roadways or
ditches that might be associated with particular farms on the edges. And so that's what we mean
when we talk about collecting sediment. And then, of course, we collected a lot of water. And mostly
this was surface waters in the area, but we also collected a few samples of well water as well.
I'm just going to click through here. So for our microbiological analysis,
we looked at indicator organisms. So think about, like, generic E. coli.
But really what we wanted to focus in on was obviously pathogen detection, right? And so
we had a strong interest in detecting any kind of sugar toxin producing E. coli,
including O157H7, of course. But we also did some limited testing for salmonella and campylobacter.
And so today, because of time, we're just going to focus on the STEC results, but just wanted
to acknowledge that we looked for other pathogens as well. It was very important for us not to just
detect presence or absence of the pathogens, but to obtain isolates, right? So we wanted to obtain
the isolates so that we can subject them to whole genome sequencing. Because then what that would
allow us to do is be able to say genetically if it's the same strain that we're recovering over
time or in a different area or a different strain, right? And so we can do that by looking at the
genetic makeup of the isolates that were recovered. And then Dr. Leonard will be talking extensively
about her metagenomic analyses. And so at each sampling event, there was a number of
environmental data that was collected alongside of the samples. And I'm not going to spend a lot
of time in the presentation today talking about that, but just to acknowledge that,
you know, we would collect matrix-associated data as well as meteorological data.
And with the meteorological data, we were also looking at, you know, what was the weather like
24 hours before sampling and seven days before sampling. And so we're really now, because the
study's been complete, looking at overlaying some of that with our positive and negative results.
And so we'll be presenting that in some forthcoming publications. So again, just sharing our
collection locations. Here, what I want to highlight, though, is that, you know, again,
we had a number of public sites that we were collecting from, and those sites are listed for
each watershed region. A lot of the public sites were in the northern half of our study area.
This was also an area that we focused in on five different produce farms, and we had two
compost operations, and two vineyards, all from this northern half of the area.
With our livestock ranches, they were actually scattered throughout the study area. So we had
livestock ranches that were sampled in the northern part as well as the southern part of our study
region. And in total, after the five years of doing collection events, we had a total of 6,134
samples collected. In this next slide, I provide a summary of the results as an overview of what
was found. But then what we want to do is to use the rest of the presentation time today to really
go into more detail for most of these matrices. So just to kind of orient you to this table,
moving left to right, we're showing the grayish shaded cells, right? So those
are our matrix categories, and we have subcategories for some of those matrices.
And then in the orange shaded cells, the next two columns, what we're presenting there are the
percentages of positive samples for non-O157 S-TAC, and also the percentage of samples that
were positive for O157 H7 S-TAC. And so we split out the O157 H7 results because we recognize that,
again, because of the previous outbreaks and just really the public health significance of O157 H7,
we wanted to illustrate those results separately. And then the final column is our total samples
tested for S-TAC. And here, really what I want to highlight to you is that in some cases,
for a few of the matrices, we collected very few samples or relatively few samples.
For other matrices, we had several hundred samples collected. And then for a few of the
matrices, we actually collected almost a thousand samples. So just to highlight that there are some
differences, right, when you look at these percentages. So just take that into account.
But overall, we found that the S-TAC prevalence was highest in animal feces. So this being either
livestock or wildlife feces. And then also, we saw a high percentage of positive samples coming
from our river and creek water, as well as the river and creek sediment. And so those are
highlighted in the darker orange color here on the table. A lower percentage positive was seen
in our air samples, our soil samples, as well as our compost samples. And then with that,
I think I'm going to turn things over to Dr. Leonard, so she can give
results for our livestock and wildlife feces. Yeah, thank you. So now we're going to start,
as Dr. Case mentioned, kind of going through each matrix in a little more detail,
types of samples that we collected, and the results for each type. And we're going to start
with the livestock and wildlife feces. Next slide, please. This is basically a map of that
same region that you were just shown previously. And now on it are shown our 16 sample locations
where we collected livestock feces. So this is livestock. And after this, I'll show you the
wildlife map. So this is basically cattle feces, mainly cattle that would roam around on the
hillsides. And the size of the circle denotes the sample size, or how many samples we collected at
that particular location. And then the color, as denoted in the legend on the right, shows the
prevalence of Aztec that we found in the cattle feces collected at that location.
What you can really easily see when you see it in a format like this with a map is that we found
Aztec and cattle feces throughout the entire region that we looked at and collected samples from.
We found quite a diversity of different Aztec serogroups, which are listed here. And I don't
expect you to be able to read them all. Just wanted to point out that it's not just one or
two different serogroups we're finding. We're finding a lot. Some have more public health
relevance, have been tied to outbreaks. In particular, 0157, as mentioned, and you can
see those in the red font. We found those in several locations. And also 026H11 in green font,
again, scattered throughout the region. And that's a serotype that's been also known to
cause outbreaks in the past. And one thing that was really interesting and a little surprising
for us, actually, was that as we were collecting these cattle feces, some would be very fresh and
still kind of wet and others, you know, old and dry and have been sitting for quite some time
in the sun and really just dried up. And we were actually able to isolate viable or live Aztec
from both the fresh and the really old, dry feces at a similar prevalence. So, we kind of
didn't expect the prevalence to be as high in the older, drier feces. But what that means is that
it's still a risk of Aztec contamination out there, even when the feces has been
out there quite some time and is old and dry. Next slide, please. So, this is that same map.
And now there were 32 different locations where we collected wildlife feces or opportunistic scat.
And again, you can see throughout the region, we were finding various Aztec strains and again,
some 0157 and many locations 026H11. Next slide, please. Okay, so we mentioned we were
collecting wildlife feces and where we found them and what the prevalences were.
But we really wanted to identify what the animals were that had left the scat behind
so that we would know what animals are carrying Aztec in this region.
And some scat, as you can imagine, or maybe know, you can kind of tell like what animal
left that scat. But others, it's not quite as apparent. For example, was it a coyote or a bobcat?
They look kind of similar. So, we wanted to be really sure and we used a scientific method to
determine what the animal was that had left the scat. And that is by using mitochondrial DNA
sequencing. Basically, the way this works is that you take your fecal sample and extract DNA from it
directly and then sequence that. And then we have a huge database that has the genetic code or
sequence or the mitochondrial DNA of all these different species of animals. And so, we can
compare our big database against the sequence of the fecal sample and find where we find a match.
Next slide, please. And it turns out it was actually quite a variety of wildlife in the
region that are carrying Aztec, as you can see from the table on the left.
The overall prevalence, if you just average everything together, all types of animals,
was 13% or, you know, fairly high. If you look specifically at 0157H7, it was 1.3% of the
wildlife were carrying that particular serotype. Now, not all animals were carrying Aztec 0157H7,
but there were three animals in particular that are in bold font in the table. And that was bobcats,
coyotes, and feral pigs. And you can see that also there are some other wildlife that even
though we didn't find or isolate Aztec 0157H7, we did isolate other Aztec and at fairly high
prevalence. For example, birds 15%, and deer 15%. Elk is high at 50%, but I want to caution
that number because the total number of samples of 16 is low, so that actual percent can really
change a lot, you know, as you add just a few more samples. Yeah, I mean, in particular, we'll
keep bringing up feral pigs a lot. Feral pigs, we collected quite a few samples, and they had a
we saw prevalence of 27%. And feral pigs and cattle do co-mingle on the hillsides.
All right, next slide, please. And speaking of co-mingling, this slide
really is a good representation of some interesting results we found at one particular
ranch. And when I say ranch, it's like a hillside where the cattle are grazing, you know,
freely but fenced in. And this graphic, what this graphic shows is a sample date along the bottom
or the x-axis. So these are each time that, you know, we went back to sample at that particular
ranch, and then the prevalence on the y-axis. The top half shows what was found in livestock
species at that ranch, and the bottom half shows what we found in wildlife species at that ranch.
And it was really interesting. So for a while, it was negative. And then we saw this
strain A that we're calling it. It's an Aztec 0157H7 strain. And the herd was colonized with
this particular strain at a fairly high prevalence of 40%. It stayed high for a little while and then
dropped back down to, we didn't find it again for a few months. And then the next year, that herd
was colonized with strain B. So again, an 0157H7 strain, but a different strain than before. And
then that prevalence we saw go down. And then again, in the third year, we saw a new strain,
strain C, we saw strain B, a resurgence of strain B, which we know to happen sometimes in herds as
well. But what's really important here is to put the livestock feces and wildlife feces with each
other in perspective here. And what you see is that when a particular strain is found in the
cattle herd, we also find it in the wildlife feces at that location. So you can see it kind of mirrors
basically when strain A is in the wildlife, it's in the cattle. When strain B is in the cattle,
it's in the wildlife and so forth. So that was a really important result. And it really
also drives home the importance of, in this study, what we were able to do with our whole
genome sequencing, where we can determine if strains are the same, if two samples are
containing the same strain or not. All right, next slide, please. Okay. And, you know, I showed you
information at this one particular ranch, but what I want to make sure that, you know, we
show you is that there's actually a widespread spatial and temporal distribution of Aztec
strains in the area. So if you look at an individual strain, like for example, at the top
half of the slide, an Aztec 026H11 strain, we found that same strain in both cattle feces
and elk feces. But interestingly, those samples were collected a geographic distance of 71 miles
apart. So this isn't just one, you know, location. These Aztec strains are found in various locations
a given strain around that whole sampling area, as far as 71 miles apart. And sometimes, you know,
really long duration. So we see a particular strain really persist in the environment,
and it may persist at distant locations or close locations. And there's an example at the bottom
of the slide where the locations for these three samples are only one or two miles apart.
But this particular strain was found in feral pig feces, and then six months later in coyote feces.
And 25 months after that, it was found in a different feral pig feces sample. So this
particular strain you can see is really persisting in the environment a long time.
Next slide, please. Okay, and then this is a much more filled in genetic cluster. And again,
what this is showing is various samples where we isolated the same Aztec 0157H7 strain from each of
these samples. And just to show you again, an idea of distance and duration and time at location one,
the strain was found in cattle and feral pig feces. But that was five months different and
10 to 15 miles from location two, where it was also found in cattle feces, but then found also
in creek water in insects. So we're finding the same strain, not only shared between cattle and
wildlife, but also in the water, which if you think about it, wildlife moves, so we can move
the Aztec strain around, the water also moves, and can move the Aztec strains around the valley.
Next slide, please. Okay, so now we're going to move on to a different sample type, soil.
And as Dr. Case mentioned in that big table that you saw at the beginning, the prevalence of Aztec
in soil was only between one and 2% if you take into consideration all five produce fields that
we sampled. But we're going to focus for a couple slides here on one produce farm in particular.
This produce farm sits very close to the Salinas River, so there's a riparian habitat along one
edge, and on the other edge of rangeland where there's cattle grazing in the hillside. And we
sampled here for about three, almost three and a half years, and took a total of 670 soil samples.
It turned out 15 were Aztec positive, or 2.2%, and some of these were sent for metagenomic
sequencing to the FDA. And one of the reasons that we sequence, we like to do a microbiome
analysis is because if we see a difference between the soil microbiome where Aztec was found and
where it wasn't found, it can give us some idea possibly of the source of the Aztec. In this case,
we saw no difference, so it couldn't really give us a clue to that. But we did see a difference in
the microbiome of the soil when the field was flooded and not flooded. Next slide, please.
So, it turned out that in this field, being close to the Salinas River as it was,
flooded three different times during our sampling. And during those flooding events,
the prevalence of Aztec was much higher at 13% than when it was unflooded at 1%.
So, you can see the circles on the field are the locations where Aztec was found, and the red
circles are in the absence of the flood, and then the blue when it was flooded.
And then, also, we took tailwater samples from this produce field that were always negative,
except for one when the field was flooded or a month post-flooding, we still found a couple
positives. Next slide, please. Okay, Dr. Case already talked about riparian habitats and
rangeland, so I won't really go over this much other than to say, you know, there is this question
of, well, if you're close to the riparian habitat or rangeland, is it more of a concern for Aztec
prevalence in the farm soil? So, we attempted to, you know, answer that question. Next slide,
please. By kind of mapping out where we collected samples and how distant that was from either a
riparian area or a rangeland. So, in this graphic, what you see is a sample distance from a riparian
area along the x-axis and distance to rangeland along the y-axis. And those five geometric shapes
you see in there are the five produce farms that we sampled from, and so you can see the edges of
the field are located inside this graphic according to the distance they are to a riparian area or
rangeland. And you can see there is a trend based on adjacent and nearby land use, and that is as
you're closer to a riparian area, you start to see more positive, Aztec positive samples in the soil.
Or if you're really close to rangeland and a little more distant from riparian, also
more positives. Part of the reason for these positives we know is the flooding from the
riparian area. Next slide, please. I try to move along here to keep us in time. So, now we're going
to start talking about surface water and sediment. And this is just from public sites. Next slide,
please. We already covered the produce fields. So, this is rivers and creeks and ditches that
you might find along the road where we find tailwater if they're irrigating a produce field
and the water's running along ditches by the road. So, we had 57 different locations, and again the
circles denote the locations of where we sampled water, and then the prevalence by color again.
And you can see, you know, it's not, there's not any particular location where we find all the
positives, again, scattered a bit. And still, these serum groups, 0157 and 026, that are of
great public health concern, are found throughout the region. Next slide, please. So, that previous
slide was the surface water. Now this is the sediment or kind of this soil below the water.
And you can see it looks very similar, as you might expect, in that we see, for example,
the 026H11 strain throughout the entire region. Next slide, please. Okay, and now like we did
with soil, we're going to focus on one particular location to give you kind of a flavor of what
we're finding. In this particular location, we sampled sediment in a ditch, and that ditch was
between a vineyard and a produce farm, and it was downhill from a cattle rangeland. So, we would
go back and sample sediment in the ditch, and sometimes there was water in the ditch as well,
and when there was water, we would sample that as well. And there was water in this ditch when either
the produce farm was being irrigated, and so the runoff from the irrigation would end up running
into the ditch, or if it was raining, water from the hillside, from this cattle rangeland, would
wash down and through this ditch. Next slide, please. And these are the results. It's a little
busy. I'm going to kind of walk you through this graph. Along the bottom are a bunch of dates.
Don't worry if you can't read them. What you need to know is that each bar is a different
sampling event or time that we went back to collect, and the sediment samples are the red bars
and the water samples are the blue bars. So, you can see there wasn't always water in the ditch,
but we would go collect three or four sediment samples. A number of samples is on the y-axis,
and if the bar is open, it means it was STEC negative, and if it's filled in, it was STEC
positive. So, you can see there were quite a few times that we went back to this ditch
and found that it was positive for STEC, and in fact, the STEC prevalence was 37 percent in the
sediment, 64 percent in the water, but again, I kind of caution that it's not a lot of samples,
but the water was often positive. Again, we compared the microbiomes of the STEC positive
sediment and STEC negative sediment to see if we could discover a possible source of the STEC, and
we saw no difference in the microbiomes, but interestingly, and this is helpful in thinking
about possible sources, we did detect cattle mitochondrial DNA in a couple of the sediment
samples and some of the water samples, and so what this suggests is that the source of the STEC or
maybe, you know, one source of the STEC is the cattle feces that would be up on that hillside,
and then when it rains, the water washes the fecal material down and into the ditch,
and then we find the STEC in the ditch. Interestingly, also, there was one sample
where we detected feral pig mitochondrial DNA in one of the STEC positive samples, sediment samples,
so that could give you a clue as to another, you know, possible source of the STEC in this ditch.
Next slide, please. Okay, and like we've been showing, these genetic clusters are basically
what this means is different samples where we found the same STEC strain, so this is another
STEC 0157H7. It was isolated from three different locations, and I've been showing you these
clusters that connect the livestock and like the cattle and animals, and now I'll show you
one in which we isolated this STEC from cattle feces, and then nine months later and two and a
half miles away, we also isolated this strain from creek water, and then 71 miles away from river
water. So, again, you can see how these STEC strains are shared between different matrices
and are not really at some pinpoint location in the valley. We really, they really are moving
via either water or animals around the valley. Next slide, please. Okay, now I'm going to hand
the presentation back to Dr. Case to finish it up. Thanks, Susan. Yeah, so I'm going to finish
things up by talking about our results for the error matrix, and so basically with our passive,
or I'm sorry, with our error collection, we had two different methodologies. The first methodology
was to collect error passively. What that means is that we took a sterile piece of cheese cloth,
it's about three foot in length, we attached it to two wooden stakes that are pounded into the ground,
and then we leave that cheese cloth out there for between 12 and 24 hours.
We had 31 different locations where we deployed this collection methodology, and overall,
out of the 139 samples, we only recovered two STEC isolates, and that's what's shown here on
the left in the map. So we recovered an O100H20 STEC in the northern part of our sampling region,
and then an O93H28 in the southern part of our study region. We also deployed active error
samplers, and so these are shown here in the picture to the right, but these are mechanical
devices that are operated on a battery, and what they do is what it sounds like they would do,
right? They pull in air actively, so they're pulling in a certain volume of air. In our case,
we did only deploy them for an hour, and so that translated to collecting only 6,000 meters of air,
which might seem like a big number, but in reality, it's not a really large volume of air
that we were sampling through these active error collectors, but that said, we did collect 173
samples, and we did not detect STEC in any of those. However, because, again, we were doing
indicator organism testing as well, we know from our aerobic plate counts that we were able to
recover bacteria using this sample collection methodology, and so I just want to finish up
by showing, again, by now you're familiar with our genetic analysis and how we were able to connect,
right, the same strain between different matrices, and although we only had, right, a limited number
of STEC isolates from air, the O100H20 strain turned out to be very interesting
because this was collected in October of 2024, but what we noticed was that samples from feral
pig scat that yielded the same serotype were actually a genetic match, and these samples
were collected a few months prior to that, but importantly, when you look at the location where
these were collected, the distance spanned 63 miles, and so pretty significant distance, right,
involved, and also, interestingly enough, there was a feral pig sample that was collected about
the same time as the passive air sample, and that was actually positive for the same strain,
as well as having one isolate from soil that was collected around the same time in August
where we were seeing the feral pig samples yielding the same strain. We also recovered
it from a soil sample, so again, very interesting to hone in on the whole genome sequencing results
for some of these serotypes, again, making those connections and really helping to uncover how
STEC might be moving in this region. So, I just have a couple of slides to kind of summarize
our findings for you before we take questions, but overall, we did recover 12 unique O157H7
STEC strains from our samples. However, we did not recover the outbreak strain that I was referring
to earlier in the presentation. We have numerous and diverse non-O157 STEC strains that were
detected, including O26H11, which Dr. Leonard rightly was mentioning about the public health
relevance of finding other non-O157 STEC strains out there. We use, obviously, whole genome sequencing
quite a bit, right? And from that, we know that or suggest that wildlife and surface water are
contributing to STEC persistence and dissemination in this region. And we were able to find genetically
similar strains of STEC isolated from cattle, wildlife species, water, sediment, and soil.
And in some cases, we found genetically similar strains up to 70 miles apart from one another.
And over a time of sampling interval up to 25 months. So, again, a fairly large span of time
to find the same isolate. A relatively high percentage of STEC samples were positive
in our wildlife species. Primarily, these were from birds, bobcats, coyotes, deer,
elk, and feral pigs. And we did isolate STEC O157H7 from bobcat, coyote, and feral pig species.
Perhaps one of the most surprising findings, again, is that the older,
drier livestock and wildlife species contain viable STEC that prevalence is similar to the
fresh material or fresher material. Again, suggesting that there is an extended period of
risk with having that fecal material out there in the environment for extended periods of time.
And the isolation of STEC from soil was greater during or immediately after flood events.
And finally, though, again, just want to highlight that while our air sampling was not,
there's things that we might want to go back and do with our air sampling, for instance,
to deploy the active air samplers for a longer period of time to sample a larger volume of air.
The results that we have so far do suggest that air is a limited vector for STEC movement in this
region. So, we've reached the end and so I'm happy to take any questions from folks. I'll just stop
sharing. Okay. And I think we can, I see a question. Is your impression that the STEC
strains are reproducing in the environment, Creek, or that every strain nine months later was shed
from an upstream continuous source? And certainly one thing that we find happens in the environment
is that wildlife were colonized with the STEC strain. And so during colonization,
the STEC would be, you know, basically what's reproducing or during that time at least.
May or may not be reproducing in water, but definitely has a chance to multiply
via the wild animals. And Julie, I don't know if you wanted to add to that.
No, I think you covered it, Susan. Okay. I'm not seeing any additional questions.
Do you see anything, Susan, on your end? I'll just continue.
Okay. Oh, did the Cal study investigate whether hydrologic connectivity existed between potential
pathogen sources in the affected farms? I don't think we dug that deep other than just to know
that, you know, we would find the same strain in water at, you know, distant locations, but,
you know, nothing more, no deeper analysis than that, I would say.
Okay. I'm seeing wood orienting the cheesecloth horizontally instead of vertically make a
difference. That's a really interesting question. I mean, that's one thing that we
did not experiment with is really modifying the size of the cheesecloth or the orientation of the
cheesecloth. And so, you know, this has come up in terms of kind of optimizing things, right?
And that's something that we didn't undertake with this study. We had done a previous longitudinal
study in Arizona, actually, where there, it does seem like STEC is moving through the air.
And so, we were deploying the cheesecloths in that study. But even there, we really didn't
focus so much on the orientation or really anything about the size either. So, that's a really
interesting question or comment. Susan, do you have any?
No, I just, we, our soil samples were surface samples. So, that's not the same as collecting
on a gauze, I guess. But it would be more of a flat surface. We did actually have a couple
positives on the grape leaf samples as well. So, there was definitely, you know, some amount of
kind of deposition via dust. It was just much lower than what we found in other locations where
we've conducted longitudinal studies and much lower than what we found the STEC prevalence to
be in wildlife and water in this particular location. Okay, I see another question. How
representative of air over time do you think your air samples were? Yeah, another good
question. And again, you know, one thing about the passive method is that because it's really like a
low cost methodology, you know, we were able to leave that out there, right, for up to 24 hours
at a time. And so, you know, the idea is that if there are changes like in the wind direction,
you know, you can capture that with the passive means, whereas like with the active air samplers,
because, you know, they're costly, right, and you don't want to necessarily leave them out,
and you're also maybe limited by the battery life, right, for these samplers. And so,
you know, that is one limitation with them is that maybe you can't leave them out as long,
but if you do deploy them for, you know, more than just an hour, you are collecting a larger volume
of air. So unfortunately, we weren't able to do that at this point with the study, but that is
something I think that we should consider if we're able to go back out and to do some additional air
sampling. Okay, I don't, let me scroll through here. I'm not seeing new questions. I see,
maybe, yeah, maybe we already covered those. Okay.
Well, we can go ahead, and if there are additional questions, we can share your
information with the attendees if there's any additional questions. So, thank you so much,
Dr. Case and Dr. Leonard for this wonderful presentation. I will go ahead and share the CME
credit information. Again, the code is 767009, and if you have any questions, please go to our
Grand Rounds website. You have eight hours to claim the credit for today's presentation.
So, thank you so much again to Dr. Case and Dr. Leonard. Thank you. Thank you.
