The Most COMPELLING Evidence Presented at Tyler Robinson Hearing

WAN NEWS
12 followers
Jul 9, 2026
Megyn Kelly is joined by Jack Posobiec, TPUSA contributor and Human Events Live host, to discuss the most compelling evidence to emerge at the Tyler Robinson hearing, the significance of the DNA evidence that shows Robinson and Lance Twiggs on the towel and screwdriver, and more.
AI Generated·May contain errors
I mean, it is something to thank God we have, because I think about the Nancy Guthrie case,
where this poor woman's been stolen and is presumed dead at this point. And we have no
idea who took her. There's not a person to point at. This family's going to have to live likely,
possibly at least, forevermore without knowing. At least this man, thanks to the parents,
as you point out, is in police custody, is facing justice. Whether you think he did it or he didn't,
he's getting his due process, and the jury will be the final arbiters of his guilt or innocence.
But thank God, thank God his parents, when they recognized him from the tape,
they called their son. They demanded to see pictures of the rifle to see if it was still
in his custody, which it wasn't. He claimed he'd been home sick that day and the day before,
which the mother didn't believe. And then they talked to him directly about whether
he had killed Charlie Kirk. And he told them he wanted to kill himself.
There was obviously a bargaining going on between them. They called that family friend,
who was a former sheriff's deputy. That man came over, and what the parents reported was that he
convinced Tyler Robinson to turn himself in and to do it at the police station so that the police
didn't have to search his parents' home. He pitched it to him as a way of protecting his family.
This would be the honorable thing to do, and he did. And there's been testimony in this trial,
Jack, that they did not know who the perpetrator was before Tyler Robinson contacted them and
turned himself in, that he was the one who first made himself identifiable to them.
Let's talk for a minute about the evidence. Has there been a moment in the court that you've found
especially compelling one way or the other? Well, I think it's more of the process of the
evidence. They're going through it in a very methodical but very relentless manner, where
they walk you through. You can see what they're doing, chronologically speaking,
where first they start with the officer who was working that day. He was on top of the
hall of flags. He reported what he saw. Then they worked through the evidence from his perspective.
Then they brought up the case agent. Now they're getting into the investigation of the cameras,
and what the cameras see. The cameras saw these objects. Okay, these objects were later found.
What was found on those objects? Okay, DNA. Was the DNA matched? Were there exclusions?
We're going through all of that. It's laborious. It's grueling, especially when you're hearing
this two-and-a-half-hour argument over whether or not DNA science is real, like this filibuster
that happened yesterday. But when you actually just look at the nuggets of evidence again and
again, they're building their case. They are building the scaffolding of a very,
very strong case against Tyler Robinson. One thing that just popped in my head, and I know
everyone keeps asking about this, the Chick-fil-A. Agent Hull brought up that he got the Chick-fil-A
beforehand. On one hand, you think, how can someone just eat a Chick-fil-A before you go
and do something like that? My gut reaction was revulsion, but then my prior intel officer
side kicked in. I thought, wait a minute. If he purchased Chick-fil-A, then that's something you
can corroborate. If he used a card, or if he used cash, then you could go to that Chick-fil-A
outlet, or you could go to the credit card statement, and now you can begin the process
of corroborating, is that person that we see on video buying the Chick-fil-A at this time,
does that match up to a financial transaction? Same with the car, if he got gas, which I assume
we're going to get very shortly, cell phone metadata. It's very clear, by the way, that
there was something that Agent Hull said that we tracked him to that area later in the day,
and that's where they got that new Ring camera footage, or I guess Nest camera footage,
of the challenger driving up in the middle of the night. And it, reading between the lines,
it was pretty clear they had tracked his phone to be able to know to ask for that specific house at
that specific time. So it seems to me that they're building a very multi-layered, multi-tiered case
against him in a sense where, you know, you just mentioned Brian Koberger, where it seems like
there's a lot more evidence in this case than there was against Koberger, because there you
didn't have all the video, you didn't have the eyewitnesses, you didn't have family members,
and all of these other pieces. You had the cell phone, you had, I think, you know,
fingerprints, you know, on a knife sheath, and that was really it.
Right, and that was pretty much it, whereas this case, you've got a lot more to deal with.
You certainly didn't have an alleged confession. And there, the most damning evidence against
Koberger was that knife sheath and his touch DNA being found on the sheath. But of course,
had they gone to trial and there had been nothing else, they could have argued he went to the gun
store or the knife store and he touched that. How can you prove that he was the one holding
the knife sheath when the murders were committed? It was all the other evidence. And yes, I did
notice as they released the longer video of who they say is Tyler Robinson coming back to campus
with the jeans on now with the newfound limp, which it seems very clear he's got something
down the right leg of his pants, that it looks like there's a cell phone in his pocket.
In fact, we froze the frame and have it here where we zoomed in on it. To me, it looks like
obviously the outline of a cell phone. Do we have it? Can we put it on the board, please?
Where it seems obvious that he not only had his cell phone as every young person does,
but that he was carrying it as he committed the crime, because this is him coming back to
allegedly commit the crime. This is right before. And so if he had that cell phone on him while he
committed the crime, then they're going to know a lot from that phone. I agree, but I have also
heard a theory posited that that might be the buttstock of the rifle. And that what you're
looking at is, in fact, the buttstock of the rifle. And that's why he has that limp,
because he's got the rifle sort of in between his pants and his shirt, and that's how he's
concealing it. But it seems very clear that he's got a cell phone on him somewhere.
And the car too. I mean, in the Alec Murdoch case, the car data, and I don't know how recent
his Dodge Challenger was, but if you looked at my car right now, which is a 2025 or 24 model,
it would tell you everything about me. The car can reveal how fast you went, where you went,
whether you slowed down, whether you sped up, what buttons you were pressing.
They can merge it with the cell phone now to see whether you were on the cell phone while
you were speeding. We've seen that being done in accidents. So both of those two things,
neither of which is on the evidence list for this hearing, because they don't need it.
This isn't the real McGilla. This has just got to show enough to show he probably did it.
So the prosecution is not going to show all of their cards, though they're showing a lot.
Let's talk about the DNA, because this made a bunch of headlines yesterday,
because they found the towel that the gun was wrapped in. They found the gun in the woods,
and they found it wrapped in a towel. And they also found a screwdriver on the roof
of the Losi building from which they believe the shot was fired.
And the prosecution had a DNA expert testify about the DNA found on those items. And it was
revealed for the first time that not only was Tyler Robinson's DNA on those items, but so was
the DNA of Lance Twiggs, the trans furry roommate who we expected to testify by videotape, again,
either later today. They were hoping it would happen yesterday. So I'm hopeful it'll happen
today, if not, then tomorrow, we think. And people were running with a report that it was
predominantly Lance Twiggs' DNA on this towel and this screwdriver, which would be potentially a
game changer in the case. That's not what was testified to. Here is what was testified to,
setting the record straight on some misinformation that's out there. Watch.
You stated, I believe, that the minor sample, the minor contributor was less than 20%,
and that it was actually 5%. The ratio was 5% to 95%.
For one of the samples, yes.
Do you remember that?
Yes.
Does that mean the 5% was from Twiggs, and the 95%, that 95% is assumed from the defendant, the
Robinson?
When I calculated the statistic, Twiggs' DNA profile aligned with the 5% contributor,
and Mr. Robinson's DNA profile aligned better with the 95% contributor.
Okay. Same question with regard to eight. I think you said the ratio was 11%
from the minor and 89% from the major. Is that Twiggs being the 11% and Robinson being the 89%?
Yes. Twiggs better aligned with that 11% contributor, and Mr. Robinson better
aligned with that 79% contributor.
Just to correct myself, that was a defense witness. They called their own forensic witness
who had done examinations in this case because she wasn't going to be able to testify later,
so she came during the prosecution's case.
For the first time since World War II, our national debt has exceeded the gross domestic
product. America's reckless government spending keeps catching up with us.
Higher inflation, higher prices, higher cost of living expenses,
and higher interest payments on the national debt.
Every dollar Washington spends on interest is a dollar it has to tax, borrow, or print.
Smart retirement planners prepare for potential setbacks, and they can do that by diversifying
with a time-tested asset known for weathering the storm.
Consider physical gold from Birch Gold Group.
Text MK to the number 989898 and Birch Gold will send you a free info kit on converting
an existing IRA or 401k into a tax-sheltered IRA in physical gold.
You don't pull the ripcord on your parachute once, you've already hit the ground.
Don't wait for economic turbulence to diversify.
Text MK to the number 989898 and consider owning some gold from Birch Gold.
Your thoughts on all that, Jack?
Yeah, and actually this is my notes from in the courtroom as well.
And so item seven that they're talking about, if I have this correctly,
is the towel, and then item eight is the screwdriver.
So the major contributor, Tyler Robinson, is the 95%.
The minor is 5%.
That's the towel.
And then 89%, 11% on the screwdriver.
So this was the FBI DNA tech out of Quantico.
The reason that we're not hearing yet about any touch DNA that was found on the rifle
was because that was sent to the ATF labs.
That would have been a different lab, a different technician that would come forward
to discuss that, which I believe we will be getting at some point as well.
So we're going to have another one of these sort of DNA days.
This idea, of course, that they were roommates,
towels that had shared DNA from touch DNA or just towels that are in the same bathroom.
That's something that's pretty common, I think.
Screwdrivers as well.
Obvious reason that that would be a common piece of something that would be shared, a common item.
One thing that I did find that was interesting was that McBride,
who was the prosecutor there, Mr. McBride,
he's the star of the day as far as I'm concerned in terms of just his clarity and his ability to
get the message across, the same way he fought for one of the affidavits earlier regarding
some of the turning point mission, that he pointed out that there's degradation
potentially if something is left exposed to the elements.
And it took me a second to realize, why does he keep bringing up degradation?
Then I realized, oh, because he's talking about the fact
that one of these was left on a rooftop exposed to UV light.
So it's a sunny day at UVU.
And then the other was left in a wooded area.
So even for several hours was exposed to the elements as well.
And it seemed to me that he was kind of working his way to lay the foundation to tie that together.
Jack, something that's confused me about this case since we first started getting glimpses
of screen grabs from the videos is, if you know, and it may not have been discussed yet,
or you may not know, but what is the theory about how the gun was transported there and
away from there?
Because they show him returning to campus in the long pants.
And it looks like he's got the long gun down the right leg, which is why he has the limp.
But he has the backpack on him.
And then we see him get onto the roof, assuming it's Tyler Robinson, as they say,
see him get onto the roof.
And we're told he fires the fatal shot and then runs across the roof and has the gun still.
And by the way, we believe the screwdriver was necessary to assemble the gun.
But if he had the gun down his pants, why would he need to assemble it on the rooftop?
And then why, when he ran after the shooting, would the gun remain assembled,
which it appeared to be as he jumped off the side and then it was found assembled?
That's my information in the woods.
He didn't disassemble it or stuff it into a backpack.
So do we understand anything about how the gun was or was not assembled,
what the screwdriver was for and what he did with the gun?
There's a YouTuber and I have to give a shout out to him named Matt Kester,
who's actually done some really, really good reconstructions on this because he's been
trying to answer that same question.
Something that I certainly have thought about over the last 10 months.
And he put together a pretty compelling,
I guess, reconstruction where he took the two pieces of the Mauser,
the stock and then the barrel, separated them.
And he found, I guess, a friend who's pretty much the same build as Tyler Robinson
and put the stock down one side of the pant leg and then the barrel down the other
and said, look, if you disassemble this into the two major pieces,
so the barrel would have the scope on it,
that it's actually concealable underneath the clothing without even needing to use the backpack.
So the backpack could just be the other set of clothes.
And then they showed, as this individual was walking up and down the stairs,
or just walking back and forth,
he had the exact same sort of stilted gait and limp that we see Tyler Robinson have,
but he's still able to bend his knee, move up the stairs.
So it may have been that the gun was disassembled.
He gets up to the roof.
And by the way, I've gone to the campus now and walked this very same area,
the stairwell, going up to the roof.
Part of it's blocked off now, but got as close as we could to the area.
It's very accessible.
This is a campus that's built into the side of a hilly area there off of Utah Lake.
And so there's stairwells and walkways all out, all open to the public.
It's very, very easy to access this area.
And so he gets on the roof, then assembles the gun,
so puts the two pieces back together of the rifle,
uses the screwdriver, and it's very quick, kind of like field stripping.
It's a very quick way to reassemble.
It only takes about 35 seconds and fires the shot.
And then after firing the shot, drops the screwdriver,
or perhaps forgets that it's up there, presumably,
then runs away with it still assembled.
And we find it still assembled.
So that's the best theory that I've seen on this
and seems to fit the facts as they lay.
We actually have some of that Matt Kester video
demonstrating part of what you just said.
We'll look at it now.
You remember that image of the gigantic cell phone sitting right here in the thigh?
That's your stock.
That explains why the leg motion cannot come forward
because it's completely locked in.
And if you see, I'll put the image up on the screen in the photo,
you can start to see an outline of the stock.
This has solved the riddle that has been bugging me the whole time
about the bulk of the stock.
Essentially, I believe now with 90 something percent certainty
that the stock was carried this way
and the barrel was carried on the side.
Now, whether or not the scope came off or not,
that's an item for debate
and we can talk about the ramifications of that later.
But I think with certainty or fair,
not you can't be certain about anything,
but I think as close as we can be to certain,
this is how this was carried.
That's why I think he hooked it underneath his armpit.
He kept his arm straight down
because if you see when he walks,
he doesn't have his hands in pockets.
They're out.
Keep your hands out.
All right.
Now walk towards me.
His model walking.
Yeah, it's a similar gait.
It looks like somebody who's lost the full use of their right leg,
which is how Tyler Collins did.
I find it very compelling.
Would love to hear your feedback.
You can email me to Megan,
M-E-G-Y-N at MeganKelley.com
or just leave a comment below,
but join the community by becoming a subscriber.
We really, really value your input and your support.
You may not always agree,
but we are always going to talk about it and respect.
No BS, no agenda, no fear.
