Studio Ghibli's "The Boy and the Heron" won the Oscar for Best Animated Feature at the 2024 Academy Awards, but not everyone agrees with the decision. Spiderman: Across the Spiderverse was almost the guaranteed winner of the prestigious award, however when the real winner was announced, the celebrations were cut short....
📺 Check out my other videos:
Netflix's GENIUS Plan to Overthrow Crunchyroll • Netflix's GENIUS Plan to Overthrow Crunchy...
Its Your Last Chance to catch up to One Piece: • 2024 is Your Last Chance to Watch One Piece
Thank you so much for 7,500 subs as of writing this little excerpt. Words cant describe how grateful I am for all of the support on these videos. All of the nice words, and the hilarious hate comments have been so fun to read and talk about. Sorry for such a prolonged period between uploads. I do YouTube part time as of the moment and as most probably know times are tough, and so finding time to sit down and get work done isn't always the easiest. I have realized throughout creating these videos that I can only make videos that I truly enjoy to make. I think that my passion, and actual investment into the topics that I speak about are 90% of what makes my videos special, and the high quality that they are. I have scrapped multiple ideas that I almost 100% knew they would have been successful, but the problem was I didn't remotely care about them. I have zero interest in creating a video solely for the purpose of getting views, or subscribers. Im still learning, and trying to get better at this whole youtube thing, so all of the support truly is motivating for me to continue creating videos. Again, I cannot thank everyone enough for all of the support I have been given. I know most wont even read this, but for those who do, thank you to you especially. I hope you enjoyed the video, and Im excited to make more.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This analysis explores Hayao Miyazaki's \"The Boy and the Heron,\" framing it as a deeply personal, semi-autobiographical masterpiece. It examines the film's themes of grief and acceptance, its hand-drawn artistry, and the controversy surrounding its Oscar win over \"Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse,\" ultimately arguing for better representation of animation at the Academy Awards.
Studio Ghibli and more specifically Hayao Miyazaki are no strangers to controversy. In 2004,
Miyazaki refused to accept his first Academy Award in person due to his ongoing protest of the
invasion of Iraq. Miyazaki has a deep history with sharing his opinions and sharing them
wholeheartedly, such as the time he agonized the use of AI in animation as an insult to life
itself. In various documentaries and behind the scenes videos from inside of Studio Ghibli,
Miyazaki may come off as some grumpy old man, but as I watched, the more I saw a man who was
burdened by a life of artistic torture. A man who feels as though his art form has regressed into
something that he can't recognize and feels is no longer even human. Miyazaki spent his life
creating some of the most iconic and influential animated films to ever exist, with nobody being
able to come close. Spirited Away remained the only anime film to win an Oscar for two decades,
until Miyazaki released The Boy and the Heron, which won Best Animated Feature at the 2024
Academy Awards. Every film nominated had a strong reason for why they should win the big award,
but when the winner was announced, the celebrations were cut short.
The Boy and the Heron is a masterpiece. The latest entry in a Ghibli's filmography showcases
the life of Mahito, who moves to the countryside alongside his father after losing his mother to
the war. Miyazaki's work at Ghibli is unique in many ways, the most abrasive being his deviation
of the more standard three point plot structure. The Boy and the Heron disregards tradition to
provide a story not meant to be taken at surface level. Instead it stopped me, and made me reflect
and feel what Miyazaki was trying to confide in this film. What really reinforced this film's
ambiguity for me was my own personal viewing experience. After I had gotten into my seat,
I watched a father bring his two children into the theater, only to abruptly walk out about halfway
through the movie. With Kung Fu Panda 4 only down the hall, I couldn't help but recognize this movie's
stark contrast thematically, in how much this film relies on age and a foundation of life experience
to fully grasp its quality. This film is about life, death, change, grief, and wonder, but so
little of which is directed for children. Miyazaki had so many reasons to make this film, but I feel
as though he made it with a specific audience in mind, not the children who were upset that they
couldn't watch Kung Fu Panda 4, but the ones that were introduced to their new neighbor Totoro and
Princess Mononoke. The Boy and the Heron fits the shoes that it's attempting to fill. A potentially
final project from the most legendary anime filmmaker of all time, a hand-drawn visual
masterpiece that relies on the skill and dedication of some of the most talented artists in the entire
world, but most importantly, a movie full of humanity, pain, and retrospection for a man who
has experienced so much life in 83 long years. This film is undoubtedly Miyazaki's most intimate
and personal film he has ever created. The Boy and the Heron is a self-proclaimed semi-autobiographical
fantasy about life, death, and creation, in tribute to friendship. Mahito's struggles with grief, as well
as his connections to the Heron and his granduncle, are all reflections of Miyazaki's personal
relationships with fellow Studio Ghibli founders Iseo Takahata and Toshio Suzuki. Mahito's journey
unfolds as he is forced to submit to his trauma and grief, but it's not submission at all, it's
acceptance. Miyazaki, through the lens of Mahito, confides his acceptance with the loss of his best
friends and family into The Boy and the Heron. The themes of grief and conflict are glaring throughout
the film, but for me, I wasn't drawn to any of that. The film was released in Japan under the
and after watching, I struggled to figure out if Miyazaki was asking that to the audience,
or to himself. His stoic portrayal of self-control and how you will impact the world were my biggest
takeaways from this movie. The entire film showcases Mahito making choices that are
empathetic and thoughtful. He shows grace and maturity despite having every reason to be filled
with hatred and wrath. He refuses to become the new ruler of the other world because he knows that
The story of The Boy and the Heron isn't a groundbreaking epic, but for what it lacks in
traditional storytelling, it soars in creating a transporting experience that is so full of life
and emotion that the movie truly feels alive. The Boy and the Heron felt like Miyazaki's final
love letter to animation. From start to finish, it's nothing but pure eye candy, and so immersive
that you forget that you're watching art in motion. Every little moment in this film is treated with
just as much love and attention as the big climactic scenes. The way Mahito gets dressed
and runs throughout the town is seamless and so organic. The wide shots of Mahito being introduced
to the countryside provide such a beautiful sense of scale and wonder. The Boy and the Heron's
box office success and recognition by the academy is a shiny beacon of hope for the industry that
shows real art made by real people telling real stories still has a place in today's world.
However, Studio Ghibli's triumph was met with controversy and exposed the world to the ugliest
parts of the film industry. The biggest competition for the award was Spider-Man Across the Spider-Verse,
a movie so full of charm and character that it was almost considered a guaranteed win. I struggled
for a long time on how I wanted to cover this section of the video and how to come up with
concrete reasons on why Across the Spider-Verse didn't win. I love Spider-Verse and the movie
stands as a beautiful triumph for animation as a whole. But what makes The Boy and the Heron
better? These types of videos are always difficult, but how do you convey such admiration and love for
both movies while still having to put one over the other and provide a reason that's more substantial
than I just like it more? When you have a film like Spider-Man that everyone had expected to
take home the trophy, that feeling of rejection for something you love can be brutal. Many fans
across the Spider-Verse were outraged at the self-proclaimed snub, even as far as Shameik
Moore, the voice behind Miles Morales, sharing his thoughts on the award not going their way,
with a one-worded tweet reading, Robbed. Robbed? Robbed? Robbed? Robbed? Anyways,
he would later go on to pay his respects to Studio Ghibli, but the damage was already done.
The main star of the series had already fanned the flames of the outrage beginning to kindle.
So that leaves the question, was Spider-Man truly robbed of the award? I don't think so.
As I look at Spider-Man Across the Spider-Verse, I recognize its greatest characteristics are also
its biggest flaws, and frankly, what I believe is the reason the film didn't win. Across the
Spider-Verse is a movie that was destined to be good from its inception. The film knew exactly
what was required for the movie to be a guaranteed success, and they did it with flying colors.
This choice resulted in one of the most beautifully animated, enjoyably fun movies I have ever seen,
but I knew it was going to be that before I ever sat down to watch it.
Experiencing The Boy and the Heron for the first time was otherworldly. The film captivated me
from beginning to end and rekindled a childlike wonder inside of me as I watched in awe of the
colors dancing around the screen. The heart and soul poured into everything from the visuals to
the characters to the score is indescribably more human and genuine than Spider-Man came
across to be for me. Spider-Man Across the Spider-Verse is a Wagyu steak at a Michelin
Star restaurant, while The Boy and the Heron is your favorite home-cooked meal made by your
parents or grandparents. This is what sets apart The Boy and the Heron for me. It gave me something
that I didn't even know that I wanted. It surprised me in ways I never thought possible, and
did so in a way only achievable by those that have dedicated their life to creating works of art
such as these. The Academy Awards and debates surrounding them will continue until their mutual
demise. However, I think that it's time that the discussion around how animated films are
represented at the Oscars is the true conversation to be had. No matter where you fall on the
spectrum between Spider-Man and The Boy and the Heron, it's an insult that animation is forced
to fight over scraps at the largely perceived kids table of the Academy Awards. There is no
reason why Spider-Man should have left the ceremony empty-handed, and same goes for The
Boy and the Heron. Animation has been long disrespected within the Academy, and I truly
believe it's time for it to receive its flowers and recognition. The addition of categories like
best 2D and 3D animation, best animated VFX, and many more to accommodate the medium would alleviate
all of the repeated frustration expected every single year. At the end of the day, I truly believe
that both films should have been awarded for something, and it's a crime that we now have to
pit these two great films against each other for the rest of time. But even if you believe Spider-Man
should have won, in the words of Christopher Miller, the producer of both Spider-Verse movies,
well if you're gonna lose, might as well lose to the GOAT.