Are The Yankees In Trouble? + Andy Green On Mets Goals The Rest Of The Season | The Show Ep. 208

New York Post - Sports
11 followers
123 Video Views·Jul 9, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
I do also continue to believe they'll get healthier,
they'll fix some stuff at the deadline.
Their history for 35 years is to figure out
how to win 90-something games and get into the playoffs.
There is some overtones to last year's Mets to this team,
like where it's like, they were great till mid-June,
and then it started to go bad, and again,
I'll say John Heyman was ahead of the group
on this one also, and I kept saying,
almost to the finish line, come on, man.
They're better than the Cincinnati Reds
or the Miami Marlins, in the way that I'm gonna say
the Yankees are better than whichever of the Baltimore
Orioles or the Minnesota Twins or whatever.
Is there any chance that the Yankees peaked in mid-June
and they're in trouble?
Interim manager is not something most people want.
It's a very, very tough job.
It's probably tough still to have it
and have to talk to me and you
about what's going on with the Mets,
but Andy Green was kind enough
that he's gonna join us on the show.
Yeah, it's gonna be good to talk to Andy.
It's always good to talk to him.
He's a great talker and he has an impossible job,
so that's a good combination for an interview, I think,
so we're looking forward to it.
Yeah, we'll ask Andy, hopefully,
all the stuff that's going on with the Mets,
what their near future looks like.
Of course, he's still, in theory,
running their farm system.
John and I at the top will talk about
our interview with Steve Cohen last week
and the plummet of the Yankees.
We'll play hit and error at the end
if you stick with us on the show
John, we had the owner of the Mets,
Steve Cohen, with us last week.
He said a ton of interesting things
that I believe will have legs well beyond that interview.
Lots of people, obviously, responded to it
inside and outside the organization,
but you and I haven't had a chance
to kind of chew it over and talk about it,
so why don't I just do something broad to begin, John?
He talked to us for 45 minutes.
What lingers for you a week later?
Well, first of all, I think it's great
that he's out here talking to us,
not only us, but to the fans.
I think that's awesome.
Not that many owners do that.
Obviously, he felt the need to do it
with the Mets having this poor season,
and obviously, it's a disaster.
He wouldn't say anything else.
He made clear he understood where things stood.
A couple things he answered in questions that you asked
stood out to me.
One was, obviously, that David Stearns isn't going anywhere.
He said he's gonna stay for the five years.
You know, he did say a couple other things,
you know, nothing's guaranteed,
and he said the Met record's mixed and that,
but I do think he is gonna stay,
and that doesn't surprise me.
Obviously, the fan reaction wasn't very negative toward that.
To me, I understand it fully.
I get it.
David Stearns was an excellent GM in Milwaukee.
He did have a very good first year here.
You're right, the trend is not good.
He was not good the last couple years,
but look, he took a while to get the GM that he wanted.
Is he perfectly happy?
It's obvious that he's not,
but I'm not surprised, and I think it's correct
that he's not firing David Stearns immediately.
The other thing was on the Lindor-Soto relationship,
you know, everybody around the team understands
that they don't have a great relationship,
and they certainly didn't have one last year.
Maybe it is a little bit better this year.
As he suggested, I found it interesting
that him saying that it's better,
people said, oh, wow,
they really did have a big relationship.
I mean, we've said this on the show,
and maybe they didn't believe us,
or they weren't listening or whatever many times,
but now it's kind of out there.
He did also say that Lindor and Soto, for that matter,
not that anyone thought Soto's going anywhere,
aren't going anywhere,
and I know I've seen stuff out there since then.
People saying, oh, I think Lindor's going to get traded.
I know Mike Francesa said
they're going to try very, very hard to trade him.
Well, unless he was telling us some fib,
I don't believe that.
You know, Lindor is 10-5.
He has full veto power over trades.
My understanding is, from what I hear,
people close to him, he's not going anywhere.
Beyond that, it's not easy to trade someone
who's got $175 million to go in the middle of the year.
The Giants are the only team
that seems to want to take these kind of contracts on
in the middle of the year, and they're sellers,
so I don't see it.
I mean, someone's going to say,
oh, the Yankees need a shortstop.
He's not trading him.
First of all, I believe he's not trading him.
Second of all, he's certainly not trading him to the Yankees,
so those are kind of two of the things
that definitely stood out for me.
Well, a lot there, John.
I'll start at the end,
which is, without us knowing what the future CBA is,
and is there a salary cap?
Is the taxes going to be even tougher
if they don't get a salary cap?
It's very hard for any team to acquire a guy
who's making $32 million a year for the next five years
without knowing, does that put me way over a cap
if there's a cap?
So I think, beyond the fact that the owner
is on record telling us he's not being traded
and we would then have to reverse course,
I'm going to believe that the player's
not going to be traded.
I will go right to the beginning of what you said.
Look, the Knicks just won the championship,
so it's deodorant, you can do whatever you want.
Leon Rose, the guy who runs the team's operations,
he never talks to independent reporters
to explain why I didn't sign Mitch Robinson,
why I did this, why we're not making trades.
I think it's a real disservice and disrespectful to fans,
so I, A, have a lot of respect that David Stearns,
in the worst of times, every homestand comes out
and talks to reporters and does it,
and that the owner of the team comes out fairly regularly.
He's usually on with us at least, John, twice a year.
He's at the ballpark all the time.
So I have a lot, like when most people are hiding,
I'll say that Stearns isn't hiding
and I'll say Cone isn't hiding.
And on the big picture on Stearns,
the one thing is, the biggest thing I thought
that Cone said, you actually didn't hit on,
and that was that he's really worried about next year
because of how bad the farm system is performing at the top
while looking at what is here.
And yet he is saying he is keeping Stearns,
and again, I think that's the right thing,
but he's already anticipating another potentially bad year,
which would be three in a row,
as the team becomes more David Stearns' team.
The least David Stearns' team went to the NLCS.
They made the playoffs the last day of the season,
but as it's become more his team,
it's doing worse and worse,
and the owner is anticipating,
he said, he pointed out that he is very concerned
about the 2027 Mets.
I'll say this.
I mean, it's his job to be concerned.
I get why he's concerned.
These things change in a hurry.
Let's not forget, in 2024,
they had a very exciting, certainly finish,
and overall successful season.
They added Soto, and then we thought everything's great,
and they didn't make the playoffs the next year.
Now, they look very, very bad this year.
They are very bad this year.
I don't want to sugarcoat it at all.
They are bad this year.
Things change.
They had the number one farm system,
at least according to some rankings,
toward the beginning of this year,
or at least in the winter,
and right now, it doesn't look as good.
Now, those change quickly, right?
I mean, Tong had basically almost a zero ERA last year,
at a high level.
This year, it's like five.
I think these minor leaguers are not consistent,
so that can turn around.
I get why he's worried.
I would be worried, too, if I'm him,
but I'm gonna say that can turn around in a hurry.
We didn't expect Ewing to do what he's doing.
Bench, they were hopeful that he might,
but Ewing has obviously become
a very, very good player already,
and that's a positive, so there are positives to look at.
I get why he's worried, but I think it's cyclical,
and that can turn around in a hurry.
Yeah, when you talk about things
that turn around in a hurry, John,
a tortured segue here.
The Yankees were 46-28 through June 19th.
They have the second-worst record in baseball since then.
It's four and 13,
and they pretty much stink at everything for three weeks.
Starting pitching, which we thought
would be a strength, has been bad.
The offense and defense has been atrocious.
The attention to detail's been terrible.
You know what I was shocked at, John?
I looked at it this morning.
We have been, and I think they do need relief pitching.
You're gonna tell me they're bullpen, right?
They're relief.
Bullpen ERA, right?
Bullpen ERA is number one in the major leagues.
I just noticed that.
It's the only thing that's performed well
in this period of time.
John, I wrote about this the other day,
and I do wonder what you think about it.
This is the fifth straight year
where someplace in June or July,
the Yankees didn't struggle.
They nosedived.
They death-spiraled.
Pick your term.
And we know what good Yankee teams look like
because for the 25 years beforehand,
this was very rare for them to play badly
for a stretch of time.
20 games, 30 games, 40 games, 50 games last year.
Is this poorly constructioned by Cashman?
Is it bad leadership by Boone and his coaching staff?
Is it bad leadership by the judge
and whatever fabric there is in the clubhouse?
I wonder, this is not coincidence anymore.
It's always June or July after a hot start.
And to their credit, almost always a strong finish
that gets them into the playoffs,
which I, again, expect this year.
But this should be unacceptable.
It is weird.
Look, there have been championship teams
that have had tremendous lulls in June or July
or even August.
I can remember-
About five years in a row now.
Yeah, it is weird.
But look, 2017 Dodgers,
which should have been the champion team,
I think they lost 17 of 18 at one point
or 18 of 19.
They obviously lost in the World Series
to the trashcan Astros.
So, you know, it does happen,
probably more than we think.
It's a long season.
There's only 198 Yankees, but it is weird.
I will say that.
Another thing that's weird, which you mentioned,
is the bullpen having the best ERA.
I've thought, and maybe I'm wrong,
I've thought that's where they need to improve.
And I think that they think that too.
I think they believe that, right?
Certainly, Bednar has been good.
Cruz has been good.
Hill has been okay.
I'm shocked, frankly.
Hedrick has been good.
Hedrick has been a real special guy.
Yes, he's been good too.
And they said that.
They said in spring training,
I remember Boone saying,
telling me that this guy is gonna be good
and a big lefty, and he has been good.
So it's certainly better than we thought.
I've thought that's where they're gonna look to improve.
I will say that that list of bullpen pieces
that are gonna be available, it's pathetic.
So maybe they will look elsewhere.
Maybe they will emphasize Katcher.
I mean, we've mentioned Jeffers on here many times.
I do think that's the great fit for them.
And the Mets are gonna sell.
Will they give them Alvarez?
I think the Twins are a game and a half
out of a playoff spot.
I know, I know.
So maybe they need to go back and get Torrens
if they can get them.
That's who I would go get, rather than Alvarez.
But we know the Mets are gonna have a huge sale, right?
So maybe they will trade one or both of the Catchers.
I'm not sure about that.
I don't think they're trading Lador,
but I could see them trading one
or both of their Catchers, potentially.
Maybe they need to emphasize Katcher.
I did hear they are gonna look at the rotation now,
which is kind of a shock.
But as you mentioned, they haven't been that good lately
out of the rotation.
Can I call out a name for you, John?
And they got, yeah, and they got questions.
They got questions.
Obviously, Freed is still three, four weeks away.
Rodan, four, five weeks away.
So there are some serious questions there.
We don't know.
Schmidt could be coming back, but we don't know when.
Go ahead, what do you say?
So the answer probably is,
one, they need the help right now.
And two, the Mets aren't gonna help the Yankees.
In a year where the Mets are terrible,
the last thing they want is to trade anyone
to the Yankees who helps them get a parade
and have to explain that.
But to me, Clay Holmes is-
You know what, I don't think any of their players
is getting anyone a parade.
I mean, we've seen them play, right?
But you're probably right, you're probably right.
Historically, they're not making impact moves, right?
Lee Guterman was traded in there.
You know, there are occasional minor trades.
Jeff Nelson for Armando Benitez was a trade one time.
But I'm just saying that Clay Holmes
is almost the perfect guy
because you know he can handle New York,
you know he can handle October,
and you know he can help in the rotation now
and fold into the bullpen later.
You've seen it all,
and I think this is the best version of Clay.
Like, he's such a better-
He's gotta get on the mound.
I think he's gotta throw some pitch.
I mean, how can you give something up
for a guy who has not-
And he was great.
He went two, three ERA.
You know, we'll see.
Can he get on the mound in time?
I don't know.
We're running out of time here.
We got three weeks to go.
I mean, obviously, very bad luck.
He was their best pitcher.
It is interesting that the guys
who performed for the Mets
are the guys who were already proven in New York, right?
Weaver-
Weaver and Soto, right?
Soto, Weaver.
Before that, Severino.
But anybody they brought in from wherever it be
has underperformed other than New York.
So, I mean, maybe they do need to get guys
from the Yankees.
Was Carlos Mendoza in that group?
He was-
I like Carlos.
And I-
Soto and I.
That's one I wish I had pressed on a little bit more.
Steve said that they weren't gonna pick up the option
and, you know, they weren't playing well.
You know, my press would have been,
he's doing better than Stearns.
Why are we-
You know, he's having a better year than Stearns.
But what am I-
What is he gonna say to that?
But, yeah, I thought-
I think Mendoza will be a good manager for somebody someday.
This team was not well-constructed.
That's the problem.
John, I wonder if we could wrap up the segment with this.
I think that last week you said this.
I don't want to put words in your mouth,
but I think last week you kind of like,
the Yankees were two weeks into these struggles
and not three weeks into these struggles
and you were very much, they're gonna be fine.
I do also continue to believe they'll get healthier,
they'll fix some stuff at the deadline.
Their history for 35 years is to figure out
how to win 90-something games and get into the playoffs.
There is some overtones to last year's Mets to this team.
Where it's like, they were great till mid-June
and then it started to go bad.
And again, I'll say John Heyman was ahead of the group
on this one also.
And I kept saying, almost to the finish line,
come on man, they're better than the Cincinnati Reds
or the Miami Marlins.
In the way that I'm gonna say the Yankees are better than
whichever of the Baltimore Orioles
or the Minnesota Twins or whatever.
Is there any chance that the Yankees peaked in mid-June
and they're in trouble?
It's possible they peaked.
I don't think they're in trouble with one caveat.
If Judge does not come back,
and we don't know when Judge is coming back, right?
They won't even say when he's getting the re-imaging.
They do have a date.
I've heard they do have a date in mind, which can change,
but they don't wanna say anything for whatever reason,
whether it's Judge being-
So can I call nonsense on it?
What?
So this is my only thing, John.
And again, I'm talking to a foremost reporter
and I'm not saying it with false modesty,
who I know is smarter than me.
Like, I always try to play detective.
Only in math.
Go ahead.
I was trying to play detective.
His imaging was supposed to be done in four to six weeks.
I know, I personally asked him if he was still having pain.
And he said, I don't wanna talk about it with you.
Like, you know, not mean.
That sounded meaner than it was.
It was very, as you know, Judge is always gracious.
Very nice.
Always smiling.
Yes, he also then sent it to a group
about a week after I asked him,
he said to the group,
we'll talk about the pain afterwards.
It would suggest to me, if he had no pain,
then just say you have no pain.
But if he had no pain, I think they do imaging, right?
To say like, okay, let's see if it's filled.
So the fact, again, I know nothing.
It could be he's asymptomatic and has no pain.
But like, if you had no pain,
why isn't he getting imaging?
And why isn't he beginning something
that feels like a ramp up towards playing?
This feels like, like they could say
they have a target date.
What if the target date's September 15th?
Yeah, well, it shouldn't be
because originally it told us four to six weeks.
And we're, well, we had four weeks now.
It feels like-
For imaging, for re-imaging.
Re-imaging, yeah.
Not for playing.
No, not for playing.
He had the similar, not exactly the same,
but similar in 2020 when we were all away
due to the pandemic.
And to me, it sounded like he would have been out
at that point two and a half to three months.
So if that's true,
we still got another six to eight weeks to go.
But as I said, if he comes back at all,
at least for a few weeks,
I think they'll make it in this league.
This league is worth,
we can make fun of the Cincinnati Reds
all we want last year with the 83 wins.
You might get in with 81 wins right now, right?
Right now, 500 team is the sixth spot, right?
So you could get in potentially with 81.
It seems improbable,
but possible in the American League this year.
So I find it hard to believe
that they're not gonna do better than that.
Even after this terrible, terrible turn that they've had,
there's still several games over.
I mean, what were the 18 over at some point?
That's been cut 18 and a half, basically.
But I mean, look at the names.
You never know in baseball.
We don't know.
We really don't know on Judge at this point.
They're not saying anything.
If Judge is back, they'll be in the playoffs at least.
Yeah.
Look, the other side of that team we know
is gonna be selling over the next few weeks
is the New York Mets.
Their interim manager who replaced Carlos Mendoza
is Andy Green, and he joins us next on the show.
Andy Green played in the major leagues for four seasons.
He was the manager of the San Diego Padres for four seasons,
became the bench coach of the Cubs,
and departed that job to, after the 2024 season,
or after the 2023 season maybe, right,
to join David Stearns and run the major,
the Mets minor league farm system,
and now he's the interim manager of the New York Mets.
Andy, thank you so much for joining us on the show.
Yeah, great to be with you guys today.
You've got an interim title,
and it looks like the team is going where it's going,
which is not in a great place, right?
Probably gonna have to be sellers in the next few weeks,
and it's gonna be an overall disappointing season.
What's important to emphasize
from here to the finish line for you?
I'm sure you wanna win as many games as possible,
but what needs to be emphasized from here to the finish line
to set you up better for 2027 moving forward?
Yeah, I think the goal in baseball,
regardless of where you find yourself, remains the same.
It's like to win the baseball game
that you're playing that day,
and if you're sold out to doing that,
that creates opportunities to build the culture you need.
It creates opportunities for guys to develop
and to get better, and it creates the environment
that ultimately leads to long-term winning.
So no matter where you find yourself,
there's a game to be played today,
and there's an expectation to go out there
and play it to win it.
You know, when you were appointed
the interim manager of the Mets,
David Stearns said that you will be returning
to your executive role as the farm system director
after this season.
Since then, I've talked to people,
and they use the words, that's the plan,
that's the expectation.
Can you enlighten us at all?
Is there any chance that you'll be the manager next year?
It seems to me like you're qualified.
You were a manager in San Diego.
You know, you worked in a front office,
which is something that people look at
as a valuable asset these days.
You know, is there any possibility
that you will remain the manager of the Mets?
I think what David and Steve came out and said,
and that I said the first day is the expectation,
is I am going back to the front office at the end of the year
that remains very much the expectation.
I certainly didn't expect to be down here
as little as two weeks ago or a week and a half ago.
So life changes, life moves fast.
My expectation is to do that.
I've got personal reasons why that matters to me.
And at the same time, this fan base, this organization,
David and Steve, deserve the right to go out
and find whoever they believe is the best person
to lead us going forward from the dugout.
Andy, everyone who's listening to us or watching should know,
I mean, you're great to deal with.
We see you an awful lot in spring training.
I know I always use you as a resource.
You have great insight into the game and into your team.
And when we talked in spring training,
by the way, not just Andy Green, Joel Sherman too,
sorry, third person reference,
but thought the Mets were going to have
a strong year this season.
And one of the reasons was I actually thought
you're gonna have a lot of depth to deal with things.
Why do you think the team is where the team is
and therefore you're managing that team?
Yeah, it's been frustrating.
I know it's been frustrating for the fan base.
It's been frustrating at Steve and Alex's level
with all they invest from a heart and soul level
into this team and from every single level into this team.
And from the dugout perspective,
I know it's been frustrating.
I spent some time talking to Marcus Simeon the other day
and we talked at length about when the team
was put together in Texas in his first year there.
And there was high expectations with him
and Corey Seager coming into the clubhouse together,
a lot of acquisitions, and it just didn't take off.
The following year after winning 68 games,
they were World Series champions.
Without substantial changes, changed the manager,
made a couple additions here and there
and subtractions here and there,
but largely the same club.
And for whatever reason, it's taking us time
to put winning games on the field.
We can point to injuries.
There's been a lot of those this year.
There's been a lot for Mindy to have had to navigate
and just haven't found our stride collectively.
And so I think that you can take some hope and perspective
in the fact of how quickly baseball can flip
and do genuinely believe there's a lot of talent
in this dugout.
Guys work hard.
They're good people.
They're out there pouring their heart
into winning every single day.
Do continue to believe that this will click
and this will get going well going forward.
That Texas turnaround, that was an interesting point
that Marcus made.
What do you see?
What are some of the positives that lead you to think
that it is possible that things can turn around
in a hurry?
Because we all know this season has been really, really bad
but obviously you must know about the talent
not only at the major league level
but certainly at the minor league level
being the farm director.
Where do you see the positives going forward?
I think there's a lot of talent here.
I think it's exciting when you look up
and we've got A.J. Ewing leading off
who flew through the system at 21 years old
and goes four for four last night,
hanging in on tough lefties, takes a walk as well.
You got Carson Bench hitting in the middle of the order
and it looks like that's exactly where he should be.
Got the best hitter on the planet,
Juan Soto in your lineup.
Francisco Lindor is exceptionally talented
and has played this game at an incredibly high level
for a long time.
It's been a tough year for him
from just stops and starts with injuries
and getting himself going on the field.
He's going to be a huge part of what we do going forward.
Nolan McClain, Christian Scott,
I think there are real pieces,
great players, good people.
And that's what you're looking to build a team around
and we'll continue to build around those guys.
And there's obviously a lot more high quality players
I didn't mention right there,
but that gives you real hope for a real lineup
and a reason to believe there's good days ahead.
Andy, there's a bit of a dichotomy
on maybe the farm system a little bit
because what team wouldn't sign up every year
to have two players debut
to the level that Benj and Ewing are.
And look, McClain's still rookie status this year.
He's working through some stuff,
but he's still been better than not with a high upside.
And yet Steve Cohen was with us last week
and he mentioned that he has real concerns for the 2017
because a lot of your prospect base
that made people very excited by the end of last year,
the Tongs, the Weningers, the Reimers, Ryan Clifford,
et cetera, maybe have backed up a little
or stalled this year.
I know you've used the term that it's not linear
and of course it isn't,
that prospects move from point A to Z cleanly.
Are you still optimistic?
Because this was your job
until two and a half weeks ago or so, two weeks ago.
Are you still optimistic about this group and if so, why?
Yeah, I think the first responsibility of a farm system
is to add talent to the major league level.
Would you like to have three
of the top 25 prospects in the game
or would you like to have three of those guys
up here producing to where they're gonna,
probably on the path they're on,
like they're gonna be three guys in contention
for rookie of the year status.
There's other good rookies out there in baseball
but any farm system that throws three rookies
into the rookie of the year chase
like has done some positive things.
That speaks to drafting, that speaks to coaches,
that speaks to like an organizational infrastructure
that's churning hard to get guys to the big leagues.
At the same time, we have gone all out to win baseball games
over the last number of years here.
We've made trades at the deadline.
I think it's 20 plus players
have gone to other organizations.
And as you do that and you take shots at winning,
you bring talent in with the expectation of winning
which is what the New York Mets fans
should be having an expectation of.
That's what we have an expectation of.
So as those things happen and that churn occurs,
yeah, there's a little bit of a depletion
in the farm system because you wanna graduate
your best players to the big leagues.
And it's true, there are some guys
that haven't had the year
that we still genuinely believe they're capable of
at the top half of the farm system.
And most of these guys have come from off the radar
to like prospect status.
And there's people that deserve some credit
for getting them to that point.
Now it's up to us to get them to the next point.
And I've always said that we should love
and welcome adversity in the minor leagues.
We can't run from it.
It shows up in the big leagues.
In any place that has development take place
that doesn't challenge the players,
that they don't see adversity,
like they're not gonna be ready for it
ultimately hits them in the big leagues.
Bench had a rough spell in AAA last year.
Nolan didn't win a start
in his first 10 or 11 AA baseball games.
A.J. Ewing went back to A ball after punching out a ton.
And these things are good for players
and it's good for player development.
We have to use the tough times to kind of launch them
to their next level of greatness.
And if we don't embrace that,
if we run from it every time and we give up on people,
because they run through a tough stretch,
we're not going to be fortifying the big league team
in years to come.
So I think we're genuinely excited
about who has graduated here
because of what is intrinsic to them,
what is inside of them,
the way they go at the baseball game every single day.
You watch, if you have the privilege to watch
Carson and A.J. and Nolan compete,
they're a great representation
of a lot of people's effort and energy
into giving them everything they had to be great.
And we're going to continue
to relentlessly do that as well.
Joe and I were supporters of Carlos Mendoza
when he was here at the same time.
And he's not here to really debate this or anything,
but I like the idea that you made a couple of changes.
Ewing at the leadoff spot.
I think that to me makes sense.
He has a great idea of the strike zone.
I mean, he's maybe not the incredible savant slash prodigy
that Soto is at age 18,
knowing exactly which is a strike and which is a ball,
but he's pretty darn good.
And that made sense.
Are there other changes that are maybe more subtle
that we haven't seen that you've implemented?
Is there anything else you might consider?
I mean, Weaver's been your best reliever.
Can he be the closer?
Or is it too much of a track record thing
that with Williams and the money and all that,
that you wouldn't change that?
Anything else you might change?
And if you could talk a little bit more
about the Ewing decision.
C.A.J. is the quintessential leadoff hitter.
I have believed that as we watched him
go through the system,
it took a few people watching a few games
to realize he is eventually going to end up there.
I don't think there's anything wrong
from Mindy's perspective of waiting
for that moment to arrive.
I assume at some point in time,
maybe Mindy would have made that decision as well.
Carson profiles a little bit more
as a middle of the order bat, driving in runs.
Doesn't mean A.J. doesn't have pop,
but I think A.J. when we made that change
was rocking a 390 on base percentage
against right-handed pitching.
It's not rocket science when you're seeing somebody do that
to want them to lead off in front of Juan Soto
and get on base at that level.
And to be doing that as a rookie
with 12 games in Triple-A and 200 at-bats
under your belt in the big leagues
and flying through Double-A as well,
it's incredibly impressive.
And do think Carson is just gonna drive in more and more runs
as time goes on.
So I think that one, as I slid into the seat,
felt like that was coming in about a weekend,
felt like the right time to do it.
Andy, obviously the person who's kind of
under the glare right now, under the negative spotlight,
is your boss, David Stearns.
He's taken a lot.
The team didn't get into the playoffs last year.
One loss-wise, it looks far worse even this year.
You've worked with him for well more than two years now.
I'm sure you're very positive about it.
If you were trying to explain to the average fan
who's furious about David Stearns
why David Stearns ultimately
is going to get this turned around,
what would you tell the fan?
He's incredibly smart.
He's introspective.
We're evaluating all of our processes,
everything we do in the acquisition space,
everything we do in the development space,
everything we do in the major league space.
We're committed to getting this right for the fans,
for our players, for the organization.
He carries an immense amount of pride in getting this right.
I think what you want in life is to give intelligent people
who are introspective an opportunity
to course correct over time.
I think a lot of organizations make the mistake
of deciding they need to change at the top
and not allowing intelligent people the time
to make adjustments and to move forward.
I think David is the type of person
that when you're around him,
you realize how introspective he is.
You realize how intelligent he is.
You realize he actually really does
get the human element and how tough this game can be,
how tough this market can be at times.
So I think just when you're around people like that,
you know if you just give them time,
they figure it out, they get it right.
Speaking about this market,
now you played here briefly,
but you've coached, managed all over, right?
Arizona, Chicago, San Diego.
So you've been basically in almost every quadrant
of the United States.
New York is something different and something to consider.
And Nigel and I had a segment
which we just talked to each other.
And one thing we mentioned was how much more success
the team has had signing guys
who already were New York proven,
even going back to Severino,
but certainly Weaver, Soto, Holmes.
It feels like the ones that were New York proven
are the ones that are really succeeding with the Mets.
I mean, is this a big,
as big a factor as it seems to us,
or is this just a small sample size up we're looking at?
It's definitely something we've discussed internally.
Aware of, especially midstream
when a player's only been in one organization
and they come in for a playoff chase.
We had a lot of introspective conversations about that
heading into the second half of last year
after we made trades for guys
that didn't really find their footing.
So I think we are asking those questions,
we're talking about that.
And we do genuinely believe
that really good players,
when you create the right kind of environment
in a major league space,
they tend to flourish in time.
And you can talk about free agent signings
all across the game.
Some big ticket signings often take a while
to find their footing in any market,
not just the New York market.
So I think that is true to an extent everywhere.
And it probably does ring a little truer here in New York,
but it makes winning here all the more sweet.
It makes it really, really special.
Andy, look, it became a story again in the last week.
Maybe it will get put to bed at some point,
but I'm wondering, again, you're around a lot,
especially in spring training.
What do you think of the Soto Lindor dynamic
and in general, the leadership abilities
within your clubhouse?
Yeah, they're both great.
You said dynamic, they're both dynamic baseball players,
and you're hungry to have dynamic baseball players
on the field.
They're getting along well.
I did not have a ton of past experience
in the major league clubhouse in my old role,
so I wasn't walking through these halls
paying attention to those types of things.
I've seen teammates that like each other,
teammates that get along well,
teammates that go on the field
and they compete like crazy to win baseball games.
And the more winning you do collectively,
I've never been in a place where culture doesn't get better
after you post some Ws.
Those things help immensely.
But what I'm looking at on a daily basis
is guys that enjoy themselves, like themselves,
unafraid to have real conversations in the clubhouse.
And that stuff is what you're looking for
and what you want.
That's what's been in abundance over the last 10 days.
A follow-up on my first question,
which was about what you might be doing next year.
And yeah, the way I'm hearing it from other people,
as I said, is that it's the expectation,
the plan that you go back to the front office.
And you alluded, when we asked you about it originally,
you alluded to some personal reasons
where you may not be the best fit for manager.
So my understanding is, at least the Orioles,
and I think there were multiple teams
that showed interest in you,
and you told David you wanted to stay with the Mets
and they kept you in the front office at that point.
Why did you decide to do this?
And is it your choice for next year?
Is it their choice?
How do you think it works and what exactly?
And I have some idea about your personal situation,
but if you could elaborate on that a little bit.
First, it's their choice.
David and Steve make the determination
on where we go in this respect in the organization.
My choice to turn down those opportunities
to interview at other places over the last couple years
goes to a few things.
One, I do genuinely enjoy the mission we have,
what I was doing, the people I was doing it with.
I don't think there's anything more special
than being at the start of somebody's journey
and watching them go across the board
and impact your major league club.
I genuinely love that,
and I love the people I worked with in that role
and in that respect, and I still very much do.
The personal reason to get into that,
why I turned down other opportunities
that I think are amazing opportunities
in another time in life I would have been all over is,
I've sat in this seat before.
It demands all of you.
The fan base should expect all of you,
and it has all of me in this moment.
I have twin daughters
who are gonna be seniors in high school next year.
There's some seminal moments in their life
that I wanna be there for
that go beyond just cap and gown day.
And that's the last year
before my wife and I have an empty nest.
And so that is like a personal reason to me
that matters being more present
than I believe this job allows next year.
Now, the timing of this
when David and Steve made this decision
falls into a different window
where I can still fulfill those family,
I don't wanna say obligations, but desires.
Because a lot of people sacrifice that
to do other things in life,
and I fully respect that sacrifice.
And where I'm at in life,
being present for my daughters in their senior year
as much as humanly possible
while still working crazy hard
to do something special with a group of people,
that's real to me right now.
And the first time I managed,
I missed a good portion of their life
because this job is incredibly demanding.
The guys who have sat in the seat know it full well.
It grips you not just from a time perspective,
but emotionally, mentally,
and the city deserves all of that.
So that has been one of the reasons
I have allowed opportunities to pass by.
And it's always been with a ton of gratitude
that people see me as somebody to even consider
because there's a lot of really good people out there.
And I am certain wherever this ends up next year,
we're gonna end up in a really good spot there,
but there's a lot of baseball to be played between now
and then.
There's a lot we need to focus on
before we start talking that far down the road.
We've got games to win.
We have an expectation to win.
And we have an expectation to make these next three months
as magical as they possibly can be
and recognize that that is incredibly hard
given where we are,
but we're gonna keep grinding here to do this really well.
Just to follow up,
since I've heard it's the expectation, it's the plan,
it's not a hard and fast.
Is it fair to say that it is possible that you might,
if they draft you to do this,
that you could consider it next year as the manager?
Yeah, I am not there at all.
I am here today.
If you asked me two weeks ago,
if I'd be sitting here talking to you from this role,
I would have told you no chance in the world.
So I'm done trying to predict the future,
done trying to predict where I will be
three months from now.
I am here, I'm present,
pouring everything in to try to make this
as best as possible and to go win baseball games
because our fan base deserves that,
our city deserves that, our players deserve that.
So I'm all in right now and that's where I remain.
As a way to wrap this up,
maybe one twin dad to another is in this situation,
let's, something real positive,
which there's a tinge of negative to it is
Juan Soto has played as great as you can
pretty much play these last two years
and the Mets haven't kind of followed.
I do wonder when you have the eye level that you have,
what, this is an historic offensive player
and really just a good baseball player.
What, give us an insight maybe you have today
into Juan Soto you didn't have two weeks ago
because you're getting to do it from the office
you're in now and the viewpoint you're in now.
Yeah, the focus, the time he steps on deck,
this time he steps in the box
reminds me of watching my old bench coach
when I was still young and watching Mark McGuire's focus
as he stood on deck before he went to the box
and that chase where he hit 70 homers
and just seeing that relentless focus,
it's a separator, he doesn't give at bats away ever,
it doesn't mean he wins every one,
but Juan is as special as I've ever had
the opportunity to be around
and one of the greatest things about being
in a major league dugout is being around greatness
and he is that and he also made a heck of a catch
last night in the game,
it was really impressive diving play.
Yeah, that was a Russian novel of a game last night,
a lot was going on including a great play
by Soto diving the line.
Andy, this is a rough time for the MET organization,
it's a time of real transition for you
and your graciousness here is appreciated
that you would join us on the show.
We wish you nothing but success moving forward
and thank you again for joining us on our podcast.
I appreciate you guys, thanks for the time.
Thanks Andy.
John and I of course thank Andy Green for joining us,
John, hit or error?
I'm gonna give a little error to MLB
for not picking Zach Wheeler for the All-Star game,
I also think Sonny Gray should have been there
but Zach Wheeler has spoken out about it
so I'll side with him, I agree,
he is definitely worthy of it,
it was intense competition, National League pitching,
you've got the Mids, you've got Sanchez,
you've got Sale, you've got Burns,
you've got a lot of guys but he's one of the guys,
he's one of the top guys, the game's in Philadelphia,
he came back from the thoracic outlet syndrome
like no one's ever come back from it before,
even before the no walk 14 strikeout game yesterday,
he was deserving,
I think that the factored in was that he's pitching Sunday
which some other guys are pitching Sunday too
but pitching Sunday and they would have to replace him
but he should have been put on the team and then replaced
and I think also they thought about the fact
that he declined the last couple of years,
maybe that was a factor and they said,
hey, this guy's not that enthusiastic about it
because it's hard to figure out why he's not on the team,
Logan Webb's fantastic but he's got a three and a half VRA,
Paul Skeen, same thing, so I didn't get it,
Zach Wheeler was correct, he should be on this team.
Yeah, I think he should be on the team also
and I'm with you, John, just name him and replace him
so that he gets to say he's an all-star justifiably,
something that might help what might end up
being a borderline hall of fame career
where you get to say, some people care,
I don't care about it but some people might say
the difference between, he was a five times, six times,
seven, whatever number of time all-star,
he deserved it this year.
John, somebody who is going to the all-star game,
I just, Shohei Otani, let's give a hit,
hit his 300th homer yesterday and I just, again,
every once in a while, I just like to do this,
so Shohei Otani has hit 20 homers with a 949 OPS
in 391 plate appearances.
In 340 plate appearances against as a pitcher,
he's allowed four homers, that's plus 16
and he has a 519 OPS against, which is plus about 450.
So he, it would be remarkable if he pitched once
every three weeks, like okay, but he is,
I mean, I think we've lost our awe at just what he's doing
and I just want that at the moment of a milestone
hitting his 300th homer, he's a full-time pitcher
and he's one of the 10 best at that,
he's a full-time hitter,
he just might be the plain best at that,
especially with Judge Out.
It's, every once in a while, I do think it needs
a pit stop to go, guys, this is the same human being
doing this, it's still stunning.
Yeah, and he runs well, too.
You know, he wanted to steal 50 bases, so he did.
He wants to win the Cy Young now, I mean,
to win the Cy Young when you've got a 950 OPS,
it looks like it's not gonna be possible.
He's having a fantastic year, but you know,
other guys having even more fantastic years.
He's the greatest player that any of us have ever seen.
I don't want to hear any debate over it.
Obviously, Barry Bonds is an amazing player, he did cheat.
You know, Alex Rodriguez is an amazing player,
he also did cheat.
Otani is not cheating and doing fantastic stuff both ways,
pitching and hitting, and we've seen other guys
try to be a pitcher and a hitter,
and like, who even, nobody can close,
but did anyone, was anyone productive both ways
that we've seen?
I don't think so, not even like productive,
like, you know, a 750 OPS plus a 3.5 ERA,
we haven't even seen that, so not that I expect to.
He's one of the greatest athletes ever,
and I'm not gonna speak for all athletes
because I'm not an expert in these other sports,
but he is the greatest baseball player
that any of us will ever see, and there's no debate there.
Yeah, I'm with you, John.
You know, I'm up at the network as I do this,
and a couple of weeks ago on one of the shows,
somebody was still doing well, should he just be pitching
or just be hitting at this point?
I'm like, well, what would he have to do
to convince you that he should do both?
He's like, one of the best at both,
like, until he breaks down completely at one of them,
the advantage he gives, but by the way,
with one of the extra advantages,
they get to play with 14 pitchers
when everyone else is limited to 13.
And they need him at the, I mean,
Snell and Glasnow are out, right?
Snell and Glasnow are out at this point,
so they need him as a pitcher.
He's certainly not giving up his hitting, right?
So I guess they're saying giving up the pitch,
it's ridiculous, and also we live in the real world.
They're making hundreds of millions of dollars.
Yeah, they're making hundreds of millions of dollars
off the fact that he is this incredible phenomenon.
They'd still make big money
because he'd still be Joey Otani if he gave up pitching,
but they're making hundreds of millions of dollars
and it enabled them to do whatever they want.
One of the things they wanted to do
was to give Kyle Tucker $60 million a year.
I don't get that.
The Mets can breathe a sigh of relief over that.
That's the highlight of the Mets year,
the fact that Kyle Tucker didn't want to come to New York.
Thank God.
That's the one positive we can take.
I mean, obviously Soto's having a good year,
Luke Weaver's doing well,
but can you imagine if they had a $240 million contract
of Kyle Tucker on the books, too?
Yeah, you know, John, is it possible
the two highlights of the Steve Cohen administration
is the Dodgers beat him out
for both Kyle Tucker and Trevor Bauer?
I knew you were gonna say that.
Yeah, I was fortunate.
Look, the Mets have made efforts all over, right?
Verlander retired.
Congratulations to him.
We could have had him as a hit.
Fantastic career.
They spent the $43 million on Verlander.
They spent the $43 million on Scherzer.
I don't want to say that they're not trying
or he's a bad owner or whatever.
Oh, they're trying.
Yeah, yeah.
That was snarky of me.
Yeah, no, I know.
I'm not talking about you.
I'm just talking about the fans that I'm reading
and he's a bad owner.
He's trying hard.
That's what you need from the owner, to give them money.
That's number one, right?
No, obviously they got to do better on the decision.
Yes, but might need to spend less.
Maybe, maybe it's better to spend less.
I don't know.
They certainly, I think-
Well, so the question you asked, John.
Yeah.
You asked about like,
is there a lot of pressure in New York?
I mean, and you rightfully pointed out,
it's kind of like the ex-Yankees who have succeeded here.
Like when they've come with some, you know, a claim.
I just wonder is like, do you have to back off at the,
like is there something,
because clearly like Max Fried has succeeded
with the Yankees, like as a big guy from the outside.
Like the Yankees have had some success.
We always do Ed Whitson on them,
but it's been a long time since Ed Whitson.
Like they've had a lot of success in free agency.
The Mets at the highest levels of free age,
outside free agency have not.
And I just wonder, like,
do they need to maybe go into the more comfortable zone
of David Stern's?
And as much as it's,
that Cohen's capable of spending at the top of the market,
should he pull back a little bit?
Well, I wouldn't advise that,
but yeah, I mean,
certainly Stern's was very successful in Milwaukee
on a shoestring.
So I don't know if you would repeat that in New York.
I don't think you can.
The fans would not probably allow that.
You should be having an advantage
being able to spend $380 million
instead of a hundred million.
That should be a major advantage.
And you probably can't limit yourself to just guys
you've had before or played for the Yankees.
It is weird.
As you mentioned,
you point this out correctly,
the Mets have had a far bigger issue
with the transition to New York than the Yankees, right?
Ed Whitson is a,
what is that?
40 something years ago at this point,
almost 50 years ago, probably.
The Mets have had,
Alomar was not the same,
Bayerga, I mean,
George Foster,
but I mean,
there've been a number,
Beltran wasn't good the first year anyway.
He was great after that.
Even Lindor wasn't great the first year.
I don't know what it is.
Something about the Mets.
Dave Lennon tells me it's built on burial grounds
or something like that.
I don't know.
I think,
I don't know if that's apocryphal or an actual thing,
but there's something weird going on with the Mets.
It's not,
for whatever,
it's been going on for now 60 something years,
almost as long as I've been around.
It's something.
But I do think they should spend,
they should just spend better.
Yeah.
All-star game coming up on Tuesday,
the end of the first half on Sunday.
The draft begins on Saturday.
Our all-star is Tommy Hogan,
our producer.
Thank you, Tommy, so much.
Apple, Spotify,
wherever you listen to podcasts,
please rate and review us.
It does help the show.
So does going to the New York Post Sports YouTube page
and watching our show.
And please continue to stick with us on the show
with Joel Sherman and John Hayes.
