Good Day Uncut: Bonitatibus Glove Repair

Fox - Fox 29
15 followers
3 Video Views·Jul 8, 2026
All right, Philadelphia, what's going on, everybody? What's up, Jersey, Delaware,
Southeastern, PA, Montgomery County, where I am right now, Maple Glen to be specific, guys.
Looking back over the last 20 years of Fort Washington Golden Generals baseball, this
American Legion baseball, guys, and I'm told by their coach that they are in first place right
now going into the playoffs. There's apparently a couple of teams that'll be playing tonight.
The winner of that team will get Fort Washington going into the playoffs. American Legion baseball,
that's just part of what we're going to be talking about today. Going into all-star weekend right
here in Philadelphia, got to talk a little baseball, and there's no one better to talk
about the sport with than a man who has retired from his regular job and moved on to devise
himself an entire other sort of business based on his passion, and we love when we can see people
do that. But Gary Bonitatibus, I don't know how you've done it, sir, but thanks for making a
little bit of time for us. That's a mic. Just clip it right on. Gary, what have you done? You got a
ton of tools, and you got some baseball gloves down here. You got yourself a new business. Tell
us about it. Yeah, it's been a crazy adventure for me. Basically, let me just get this thing
on here the right way. Here you go. Let me see it. A little clippy right there. Oh, there we go.
So basically, my dad used to fix my baseball gloves, and my brother Tony, both of us,
he used to fix our gloves when we were kids and kept those tools over the years. And then
when I started coaching baseball myself, I started fixing the gloves for the players
that played for me, which was great. And then about six or seven years ago, I guess,
I realized once these shoe guys went out of business that there was not a whole lot of
gloves getting fixed anymore. People were just throwing their baseball gloves or
putting them somewhere or not doing anything. No, what do you mean the shoe guys? I can remember
when I would play, I mean, Babe Ruth years, Babe Ruth level, if my glove went south,
I would typically go into the garage, maybe find an old shoe. And maybe that's why you're saying
shoe repair guys. I mean, because maybe there's a lot of things in common between shoes and
baseball gloves at all if you want to fix your baseball glove. I always played with my uncle's
first baseman's mitt because we played the same position. A new one would have cost like $300.
That's the first baseman's mitt right here. It's not an average glove, guys. It's almost tantamount
to a catcher's mitt because you're catching burner throws from third base and shortstop. But
if anything happened to it, I would just kind of try to fix it myself, which is sort of the point,
right? Yeah, exactly. And I think people weren't sure what to do. And unfortunately,
they weren't fixing them themselves. And I don't think they knew what to do or get laces. And
sometimes you would just get a regular shoelace and fix a glove. But the shoe guys had the laces
typically because the laces that you use for baseball gloves, sometimes there's some similar
laces that they use on boots. So typically a shoe shop had those kind of laces. Right. And
typically it would be hard to just go out to a store and find this kind of leather string.
Exactly. Right. And today you can go to a Dick's Sporting Goods or something like that and get the
laces. But then you got to know what you're doing and you have to have the right tools to do that.
And, you know, they they sell you some of these kits, but those kits don't give you typically
all the tools you need to really do the glove the right way. So I was fortunate enough to start
doing that, you know, started out doing it on Facebook. And then I typically send an email out
to every local college baseball and softball coaches in a 50 mile radius and even the high
school coaches as well. And just got the word out and the word started spreading. People was
more word of mouth that, hey, I know a guy, I know a guy. And I give some business cards out
and it was taken off. You know, I was doing OK. And then my my son, Nick, who actually lives out
in San Diego, is more of a tech guy. He said, you know, dad, you got to get out on the Internet.
And I said, it doesn't that cause money. Me not knowing all that much about the Internet at my
age. He said, no, I can do a quick website. So we put my website together. And when he did that,
you know, things are just kind of taken off. And it's been great, you know, since I'm a baseball
guy, you know, I enjoy fixing baseball gloves for people. All right. Well, it's called Bonitata.
That's his name, Bonitata, baseball glove repair. And Gary's the first one to go. I need to change
that. I need to change that. And he's to be Bonitata baseball and softball glove repair,
because that's the whole other end of the sport. Exactly. You know, that much more market
that you could be. So how's it been going so far? What's it like? You're almost sort of like
a cobbler in a way yourself now for baseball gloves. It's almost like running a small shop.
I mean, you told me yourself you like to camp out right here where you are working with your
baseball gloves and you've got all your repair gear in here. You got all my various laces,
different colors. How many different kinds of laces? So I offer six different kinds. I have
your typical black and tan, which would be most of the other gloves. But then I do I have a blue,
red and two types of blue, actually white and red. So that's what I offer. And some people
want to change and would like to, you know, hey, put red laces on there, put blue laces on there.
So I certainly do that for people. Spices up the glove a little bit and, you know,
makes it a little bit more. It's the same. It's the same piece of string. Yes. Yes. Same
lace. Just tied. Yep. Yep. Just dyed those colors. Yep. Yep. Okay. So Gary likes to sit here. He'll
watch Philly baseball on the big TV. He's got his I'm what I'm guessing is Augusta up here.
Right. You got your you got your baseball stadium out here. Is that the vet? That's
Connie Mack Stadium actually. Connie Mack Stadium. Yep. Back in the day. Yep. There you go. That's
me dating myself again. But there he is with one of his grandchildren. There's a big
mantelpiece full of baseballs. So you're a happy man camping out here watching the Phillies. I'm
guessing you'll be watching the all-star action this weekend repairing gloves.
How does it get to be quite so quaint, so convenient? How have you not maybe gotten
overrun with requests one way or the other? And tell me a little bit about these older
gloves that you have here. Are they just part of your collection as a lifelong baseball head?
Yes. My wife actually had one of those treasure hunt places or whatever and found these gloves
and said, Oh God, I think my husband would love these. So she brought them home and I put the
leather conditioner on them to put a little bit more life in them. I mean, this is a Nellie Fox
glove. That's not actually a Nellie Fox glove. When you're a kid, you want the one that George
Brett's got or whatever it is. That's what that was. Right. Exactly. And to have these gloves with
no laces is just crazy to think that that's what they use. They never had any laces. Right. The
only laces are right here and here, which is amazing. And they would play that way. Right.
And they would use that glove. This is a Mickey Maddow model. Right. So for the Mick,
they finally went ahead and started lacing the fingertips together. This is a Pee Wee Reese.
The hotshot shortstop of Brooklyn Dodgers, as it were. Yeah. Look, there's a ton of baseball gloves.
What's important here, guys, is that Gary Bonitonovic repairs them. He's probably one of
the best repairmen in the country. As a matter of fact, Google shouts him out because he's got a
ton of five-star reviews. You can look him up, Gary Bonitonovic baseball glove repair. Guys,
when we get back from a quick break, we're going to find out exactly how he goes about it and why,
if you've got an alien baseball glove on your shelf that wants to get itself back out on the
field, you should send it to Gary. We'll be right back out here in Montgomery County in two minutes.
Baseball tools, guys, and the baseball gloves that they serve right out here on the main couch at the
home of Gary Bonitonovic. Gary, you are the new baseball glove surgeon, as it were, at least the
one of choice online. And all you got to do apparently, guys, is send your glove out here to
him right near Ambler. It's easy to do. Was there a point where this changed? I mean, clearly you
did it for your sons, as you said. Did your dad teach you to repair them or did you teach yourself?
They're not computers. You can fix a baseball glove. No, exactly. It's not that hard. It's
like any other job. You got to have the right tools. If you have the right tools, you can do
things. I always liked doing puzzles as a kid. I think some of these gloves are puzzles. You got
to put the puzzle back together again that broke. Maybe take a cell phone picture of it before you
de-lace it, just so you know that they go back together. Absolutely. Because sometimes I'll get
a glove I've never seen that way before. And absolutely, I'll take pictures of it just to
make sure how it ends up. And the trapeze webs are a little bit more intricate because of the
way they intertwine. So you got to be a little bit careful with them. So I typically will take
pictures of them every time I do a trapeze glove, just because, again, they're a little trickier
than a normal glove. Well, take me through a little bit of it. I don't sit here and expect
that you can just fix a glove on Fox Soon and Good Day Uncut time. I mean, I would imagine that you
got to do it until it's done, and that may take more than a half hour. But right now, what exactly
is it you're doing? It looks like you're replacing maybe a worn out piece. Yes. So I'm going to
replace the top web of this older glove. To be honest, this is my old glove that's probably
30-some years old. Now, would the piece that you're replacing now be one that you've actually,
because you're good at this, maybe you replaced it 10 years ago? Possibly, yes. And this particular
glove, probably I did. And how common a repair is the one that you're doing right now? Do you
have guys out there that are nervous enough about their gloves, who are obsessive enough about their
gloves that they'll send it away to you before it's broken to say, Gary, this looks like I just
don't want this to go? Occasionally, some people want them tightened up, so the laces might not be
bad, but the gloves are loose, and they just don't feel comfortable with the looseness in it.
Typically, what I do is, let's say if the fingers are broken here, I replace both the web and the
fingers. Because I tell everybody, if one breaks, the odds are something else is going to break
pretty soon after that. Right. If they didn't get weak on their own, they all got weak together.
Yes. And you don't want to be coming back to me, I don't want to do your fingers, and then
a month later, you're going to give me the glove back and say, well, now the web went. So typically,
I do a combination, the fingers and the web, because if anything else breaks, if any of these
break, a kid could still use the glove. Sure. But if the fingers break or the web breaks,
you can't use it, basically. That was my next question. You sort of answered it, Gary. You
said if any of that breaks, a kid could still use the glove. Is that more or less whose gloves,
who's sending them to you these days? Are you getting any major leaguers sending them to you?
Is it going to be American Legion kids, AAU kids, anybody playing ball?
Yeah, basically anybody playing ball. I did have a minor leaguer for the Baltimore Orioles,
because... I guess he heard about you the same way everybody else did.
Yes, he did. Yeah. And he actually brought me five gloves. He brought me his brother's glove
and a bunch of his gloves, because even though they give him new gloves, his was already broken
in. So he wanted me to fix it, one of them I fixed, one of them I tightened up, one of them I
reconditioned. So I kind of did all that for him. And he loved it and wrote me a tremendous review.
So that was very exciting to get somebody like that.
Well, maybe that's kind of where your niche is in the fact that you understand that. And that
minor leaguer you're talking about, he understands it as well. What you're giving people here is not
a fixed glove. What you're giving them is their feel back. You're giving them their touch back
out at second base, at first base, at shortstop, at third base. You're giving them
that personal feel back that you need in a baseball glove. It's why you break them in,
so that they feel right to you. You don't want to be thinking about catching the ball,
you just catch it, right? I mean...
Yes, yes. I've also fixed the gloves for the bullpen catcher for the Iron Pigs.
Oh, how about that? Are they catchers, Mitch? Do they wind up coming in the door more than
your average right fielder's glove? Yes, absolutely.
Why so? Well, when you think about how often
a kid is catching the ball between warming up a pitcher before the game, and then in the bullpen,
and then between innings, and then 100, 200 pitches a game, you can see how quickly that can add up.
So he's catching more balls than anybody else, number one, but he's catching really hard thrown
balls on the dime on any given night, which would be a fastball from a pitcher.
Correct. In fact, if you go on my website under resources, you'll see a video link of a 100 mile
an hour fastball hitting a catcher's mitt, and seeing the impact it has on the laces
when that happens. It's crazy when you think about how hard that impact is, and the pounding
that these laces take on a 100 mile an hour fastball.
For sure. And here you are fixing them, because at a certain point, something's got to give.
What's that tool called that you pull the string?
This you can buy in the store. Typically, it's a finger tool that they'll sell you.
I'll either use this or this needle. Sometimes the needle doesn't always stick in there
as cleanly as it can. If it does, I can do these a lot faster.
The biggest thing where people get caught up is when you go to Dick's, they'll sell you this.
At least they'll sell you something to try to repair it with. Some places will just be like,
here, the new gloves are over there. You got a broken glove, time for a new glove. That seems
to be the way American society can be sometimes. Exactly. The problem is, if I go to do this
catcher's mitt, and I have to put a lace through the top of this catcher's mitt, you can see
that tool is not going to get me through the end.
On my own, I figured out the way to get around that is I had to cut this.
I cut that piece off. Now, if I need to go through that thing,
I've got a long enough piece to do that. It's long enough, but probably still a
good chunk of work. You got to do some pulling and get it in there to do that.
That's why if you don't have the right tools, they'll sell you that, and you'll start to do
that. Now, what am I going to do? I can't get it through there long enough to pull it through.
A lot of it is, look, I went through some trial and error on stuff, obviously, when I was first
doing it and said, gee, how am I going to do this? I just figured things out on my own for the best
way to fix that. This glove is an interesting glove in that this is a typical old glove that
I got. This guy, his father caught him with this glove, and now he wants this glove totally
relaced and reconditioned so he can have a catch with his son or even pass it on to his son.
I got nothing but questions for you, Gary. I got a million of them. We got to take a quick break.
Tell everybody how to get ahold of you real quick. Is there a better place to get with Bonitavis
Baseball Glove Repair?
Yeah. If you go to my website, Bonitavis Baseball Glove Repair, it'll shoot you. It'll give you
my text number. It'll give you my phone number. You can call me. You can text me.
People have shipped me their gloves. Very easy to get it to me.
I actually have a bin on my front porch that people can leave the glove in there.
When I was coming in here 40 minutes ago, there was a woman that pulled up and her van came over.
Gary was like, it's right over there. She went over and picked it up. Clearly,
your son's a player or daughter's a player or something like that.
Yes, correct.
I saw it in action right now. You're online. You're easy enough to find. It's like Bonita-tivus,
Bonita-tivus. Bonita-tivus Baseball Glove Repair, guys, right out here near Ambler,
Montgomery County. You can send them a glove from anywhere. Give us two minutes.
We'll be right back. Got all-star weekend coming up. Dreaming about baseball, guys.
We'll be right back.
You want baseballs on the mantelpiece? Yeah, you'll have them at Gary's house, everybody.
The guy is a baseball library's coach of the Fort Washington Golden Generals right now. We'll get
back to that in a second. Gary, you spend a lot of time. There's a Fort Washington Golden General.
Is he down for a free glove repair?
Absolutely.
Is he?
Absolutely.
I just wondered where the lines were there.
Yes. Every one of my players gets free glove repair.
But you haven't stopped smiling since I've been here. This is something that you really enjoy.
I do. I do. It's therapeutic for me. Like you said, I'm a baseball lifer. I've been doing this
for 50 years or whatever. I just enjoy it. I enjoy helping people. I enjoy hearing them say,
wow, my glove looks brand new. My son's loving it. The one thing that separates me from everybody
else, again, I think is how quickly I'll turn a glove around. If somebody tells me I've got a
game tomorrow night, I'll do everything I can to have it fixed in time. People have set up
appointments and sat here with me. I'll do it while they wait, especially if they have to come
from an hour, hour and a half away. Then the biggest thing is I put leather conditioner on
every glove I do. You'll see the difference right away.
That hasn't seen any leather conditioner in a long time.
In a long, long time. You see as soon as you-
Well, that's a blonde leather anyway. That's a lighter colored glove anyway, right?
Yes, to begin with. But you can just see how much difference that makes in the glove just by
putting this paste on that glove. I do this on every single glove I've done for every year.
It just brings the life out in the glove again. Especially the black gloves, you can really see
it. But you can see the difference. This happens to be an old Lance Parrish glove.
There you go. Now we're talking.
Back in the day.
They all got to have an autograph on them. It's got to be a somebody glove. Hey, Garrett,
this is just me talking. I've been out of baseball for a long time. I was never really
all that good at it. I wasn't fast. Do you find that a lot of what would be baseball
glove technical improvements are really more just marketing in this kind of day and age?
I'm sure there are some improvements. I think what I'm asking is, do you find
many guys in this day and age playing with their uncle's glove, their dad's glove,
because it's already broken in, because it feels a certain way? Or do modern ballplayers
feel like they're missing out if they don't play with a modern glove?
No, I think you get a combination of both. Like I said, I get a lot of people that want
their old gloves repaired because they want to pass it down. The biggest difference,
I can remember when I was young, a lot of times the leather would rip right here in a regular
glove.
Now if that happens, if the leather right there in the pocket rips,
you're kind of at an impasse, right? Doesn't that kind of do it for the glove?
How do you repair that?
That can be fixed. Like I said, there's a leather guy that I could take to that.
Now to do that, though, you'd have to take every lace out and then he would
sew that piece back on.
So the repair is going to go as much as a new glove, maybe.
Sometimes. But I don't see that in today's gloves. I don't see that hole there like I
did when I was a kid. So I think the leather itself that they're using to make these gloves
are certainly better than they were back in the day. So that makes it easier.
But like I said, it's kind of nice that you don't have to deal with the holes anymore.
But like I said, everything's intricate. You know, you can see the older gloves all have the
impact, the circle things here.
The grommets make it a lot tougher to fix gloves because now you have the tool
that can go through there. And sometimes I have to manually just with my hand,
put it through each of the grommets on the newer gloves.
You know, you don't see the grommets.
Well, I was looking at that first baseman's mitt. I don't even know if that's a new one or not,
but it has it doesn't look that different than the one that I played with, which again,
was my uncle's when he played high school baseball with it, like in the late 60s.
And I was playing with that in the 80s or whatever. And it was just fine.
The problem with any mistakes was typically me, not the glove.
Tell me about what's the strangest thing you've heard from a client that come in the door as we
go over to check out what we've got to, because again, you might be talking about a 15 year old
kid that just wants his glove good for tomorrow night. Have you had anybody come in or with
anything, even for approaching museum quality? Listen, I've got an actual Stan Musial original
glove. That might not be something that I I'm sure you could do it, but like,
has anyone approached you with something? I've had some real old gloves and sometimes I told,
I told people I'm not going to do anything to that glove, right? Cause it's the original lace
of a glove from the 1930s or something like that. Why would you want me to do anything? You're not
going to use the glove. So if you're only going to keep it in a, um, a showcase somewhere, then,
then, you know, if you want me to put some leather conditioner on it to at least, you know,
bring out the color, that's fine. Right. But I don't, I don't want to mess with those laces.
If they're the original lace of a glove, that's that old. So guys, he's the coach of the Fort
Washington golden generals, and he's also the best glove repairman in the area. Bonitata bus
baseball glove repair. Get ahold of him online. We'll be right back to talk about the state
of AAU and more importantly, American legion baseball. When we get back with more on cut.
There you go. Everybody look at it. The 2022 edition, the Fort Washington golden
generals post 10. Uh, and they were, uh, in that particular year, the champions,
I think that at the lower Monaco champions, uh, first place over here, coach, this is a pretty
good baseball team. And what I'm hearing from kids these days, and my kids play travel hockey,
uh, is that individual youth sports just cost so much anymore. Make the case for American
legion baseball. You all have been running these, these golden generals for the better part of two,
two plus decades. Yeah. Yeah. I I'm, I'm a big believer in American legion baseball,
community baseball, playing with your high school buddies. Uh, you know, it costs about $300 to play
for us. You're going to play 25 baseball games, full uniforms, helmets, uh, you know, uh, undershirt
socks, the whole bit, it's going to cost you $5,000 to play AAU. You're going to go on tournaments
every weekend. You have time baseball games, you have no batting practice and you have no infield
outfield. So, um, you will, my guys get infield outfield at every single game, every single home
game, they get batting practice at every single home game. So, um, to me, it's a no brainer. Uh,
everybody, uh, they're going to the same colleges that all these guys are spending $5,000 to go play
AAU. And my guys are going to the exact same colleges that all these people are playing.
So I'm a firm believer in American legion baseball. Good stuff, guys. This is Gary Bonitata,
but let's get ahold of him. Uh, he will sit on his couch and fix your baseball glove and
right there with you staring at the TV, which will be colored up.
I'll see you tomorrow for another live on top. Be well.
