Behind the Scenes: Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan (Meyer, 1982) with William Shatner/Leonard Nimoy

Fantastic behind the scenes
10 followers
33 Video Views·Jul 8, 2026
With the assistance of the Enterprise crew, Admiral Kirk must stop an old nemesis, Khan Noonien Singh, from using the life-generating Genesis Device as the ultimate weapon.
This audio-visual film commentary has been extensively edited, dubbed and transformed by Serious Feather in an original and thoughtful manner for historical, cultural and educational purposes.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Gene Roddenberry was given a consultant position and Harv Bennett became responsible to the studio
for the making of the picture. My first task was to see Star Trek and that I did. It took
me about three months and I ran 70, I think it's 76 or 77 series episodes on 16 millimeter
in a flickering projection room. It occurred to me, or at least it was the basis of my
my later work, that it was a trinity, literally a triangle of Kirk at the top, Spock,
Bones, that these three men represented the dimensions of the show. Logic from Spock,
passion from Bones, and there's Kirk who has to say, we have to do it this way,
I accept logic, I myself am passionate, I resolve these conflicts. And so I determined
immediately that this had to be a story, too had to be a story about that trinity. I've never been
afraid. But you left at the very time mankind needed courage. We offered the world order.
And Space Seed haunted me because it had flickered off the screen and it said,
here is this remarkable performance by a great actor, Ricardo Montalban. He dominated the show
and yet the conflict between him as a super person and the triangle of Kirk, Spock and McCoy
almost defeats the triangle. And yet when they overcome him, he's like Osama bin Laden.
Where is he? What do you do with him? And so they decide to exile him to some far place.
Would be interesting, Captain, to return to that world in 100 years
and learn what crop had sprung from the seed you planted today.
Yes, Mr. Spock, it would indeed.
And I remember thinking it stopped the projector. I got it. We will see him again in this movie.
And so began a series of writing and rewriting. Leonard didn't want to be in the film. He was,
I thought he was kidding. I thought, and, you know, I know him well. And now I didn't know him
so well then. And I thought it was a negotiating ploy. And I'm not so sure. He still insists that
it wasn't that he genuinely didn't want to be in Star Trek again. But I think it was the most
glorious negotiating ploy. And I think he got a hundred dollars a week more as a result of
insisting that he didn't want to be in it. So they were going to kill him off.
Leonard had written a book called I Am Not Spock, which he later revised into I Am.
And Leonard was going to be not interested in doing this film. I had worked with Leonard when
I was at Universal. So I knew him, respected him. And I came up with a notion, this was in
the early stages of the story development with Jack Sowards. And what the development was is
I met with Leonard after a performance of a one-man play he was doing. I said, look, Leonard,
I know you don't want to do this, but we need you. And in order to do it, he said to me,
how would you like to have a great death scene? And his own ears went up because he's an actor.
And that was the first I heard of this idea. So Harv Bennett brought me into the office one day
and he said, we've got to kill Leonard. We've got to kill Spock off. And I had a thought.
So I acted it out for Harv in his office, clear door, engine, me on the other side of the door,
hands to the door. And I fell out of my chair, brought my hand out and touched. Couldn't get
him out of there. Couldn't be brought out. He was dying, the two of us side by side, but separated
by perma-glass, clear, very clear, polished clear so we could see him rather than diffusion.
If the door, see, if the door had been opaque somewhat, so we couldn't see him through the
glass door, through the plastic door, I think it would have been better just to see the
outline of him crying. But they insisted on seeing him. I don't know whether that did the movie any
good, but I suppose it did. So I thought maybe this is appropriate because certainly this will
be the last of the Star Trek movies if they make this one. I can't see them making any more.
And maybe it would be an interesting final curtain for the Spock characters to go out
in a blaze of glory, so to speak. So I said, let's explore it. Tell me what you have in mind.
And he eventually sent me a script, which I received while I was in Israel doing The
Woman Called Golda project. And I was not crazy about it. I thought the Spock function in the
script was not clear. I thought the death scene was potentially touching. It came early in the
movie, and I thought it was perhaps out of place. I was absolutely buffaloed. Karen Moore was an
executive with Paramount Television at that time. And Karen said, I think I know who can help you.
She said, he's a friend of mine named Nick Meyer. I said, Nick Meyer? Nick Meyer,
7%? Nick Meyer? I got into Star Trek in a very roundabout fashion. It was a Sunday evening and I
was barbecuing hamburgers. And my friend Karen Moore, who was then an executive at Paramount,
was cooking french fries or something. And she said to me, Nicky, if you want to learn how to
be a director, you should direct. You shouldn't sit on your rear end in this house holding your
breath because you can't get what you want. Now, if my mother had said that to me, I probably would
have not paid attention. But there are things that you can hear from friends that you can't hear from.
And she went on to say, I have a friend down at Paramount. He's a very gifted guy named Harv
Bennett that you would like. And he's been assigned to do the next Star Trek film.
Why don't you go and talk to him? And I said, Star Trek, is that the one with the man with
pointy ears? And she said, that's the one. Nicholas is a man of enormous talent and
enormous energy. He's a man of great decision. He's a man who walks into a room and says,
okay, let's go. I came back to LA from Israel for a one week visit where I had a break in
the shooting. And for the first time I met Nicholas Meyer, who was to direct the film.
I had never met him before. And I walked into Harv Bennett's office and sat down and I was
introduced to Nick. And he said, what do you think of the script? I said, I'm not pleased
with it. I don't like it. And he said, much to my surprise and relief, I agree with you.
That's a very refreshing kind of comment coming from people who are about to make a movie.
And I said, why don't we make a list? It could be a character, could be a scene, could be a plot,
could be a subplot, anything. All of it. It could be a line of dialogue.
He said, I'm doing a rewrite. When do you go back to Israel? And I said, I don't know,
five days hence, whatever it was. He said, I think I'll have it ready in time so you can
read it on the plane going back. And I was young and somebody said,
And I said, oh, I can do this in 12 days. Well, I was really impressed. And that's the way it went.
I did get a rewrite and I did read it on the plane going back to Israel. And it was a much
improved script. Well, nobody, nobody rewrites in a couple of days. Nobody in Hollywood does.
Well, Nick did. Nick sat down and reformed some of the story. And I thought it was terrific.
Jim, what the hell is the matter with you? Other people have birthdays. Why are we treating yours
like a funeral? The age factor affected Bill Shatner a lot because he's a lot older than I am.
It's not a problem for me. I, of course, felt that with a lot of powder and a very thick base of
cosmetics could preserve the fact that I hadn't aged. I thought I carried it off. A lot of people
didn't feel that way. And lipstick. Lipstick's very important to avoid the aging process.
And I don't know that Bill wanted so much to be 50 years old to the world. So I started talking.
I don't even remember exactly how it came about. I said, we have watched people age,
our favorite movie stars age from being in their 20s to being in their 80s. And some of those
great stars did it with great grace and others didn't. And there's one example I can think of
because it just popped into my mind. I said, of an actor who aged so gracefully over the decades
that his aging became part of who he was. And you are his likely successor. You remind me of him.
It was a true statement. It wasn't a con. I really did believe that.
He said, well, who? I said, Spencer Tracy. He said, well, well.
A year later, I realized that I had seen Judgment at Nuremberg when it first came out.
It was Bill Shatner's first, possibly earliest Hollywood movie role. He was dynamically young
and he was the aid to Spencer Tracy. And you could tell from that performance that he was like,
oh my God, I'm on a stage with Spencer Tracy. The beauty of Star Trek II was the fact that
we tried to go back to the original series and the depth and the heart and the character
of the original series. So when somebody suggested, my son is there and therefore my
wife or my ex-wife or the mother of the son, I don't recall whether I married her or not,
it only added to the texture of the story. And to have my son captured and my son killed,
that was great stuff. And then never to see Con. I never saw Con, but that's another story.
We got in a very precarious situation. We started writing the script. We're going to get Ricardo,
but nobody had ever bothered to say, Ricardo, would you like to do this movie with us? And
we were getting pretty close to a green light when I remember we said, we better check and see if
Fantasy Island and other things will permit him to do this.
I was finishing the sixth season of Fantasy Island, in which I had been a very controlled
man, guiding everybody through the island in total control. Never show emotion. So they came
to me with this project and I read the script and I thought, well, it'd be interesting, but the part
is, I don't know, after six years of doing a television series, I thought I wanted to do
a part that had a little more size, let's say. But then I read it and I thought, well, wait a
minute, when I'm not on the screen, they're always talking about me, so the part will seem more
important. Anyway, I became intrigued by it and I said, yeah, I'll do it. It'd be fun to do.
And I started looking at the script and beginning to study the character, which I knew from the
past, but nevertheless, I thought, well, I'll articulate a little bit some of the scene.
And I started saying the dialogue and I said, my Lord, I sound just like Mr. Rourke in Fantasy
Island. The audiences are going to laugh at me. This is going to be a disaster for me. What can
I do when I was already committed to it? And so I asked to be sent a tape of the original
Space Seed and I ran it and I ran it again. And about the third or fourth time,
I started to remember what I was trying to do as an actor then. And pretty soon,
this character started to sort of take life inside of me. And I thought the only difference is
that then I was then and today, where is this character? Well, he's been abandoned
in a planet where everything went wrong. And his wife, whom he loved passionately,
dies this horrible death with little animals that go in her ear. And the one obsession he has now is
to get revenge against Kirk, whom he blames for death. So I thought that was an interesting
character. And then I started reading. And this time I articulated, and to my satisfaction,
at least, I didn't sound like Mr. Roker at all. I started getting to the essence of the
character that I had originally done. It is ironic that in this great confrontation between these two
titan icons, iconic titans, that Kirk and Khan, with their K-alike names, one syllable all starting
with K, don't ask me why, that they never actually play a scene together. And that was certainly
Khan. Bloodsucker. You're going to have to do your own dirty work now. Do you hear me? Do you?
Kirk was in a different ship, and I was in this ship. I never shall meet. And therefore,
I could never have a conversation with him. What happened was that I was doing my scenes,
these scenes with passion, talking to a wall, literally the wall of the studio, because
he wasn't there. And the lines were coming back to me from this script girl, who was one of the
sweetest persons I've ever met in my life. But she was not really an actress, nor should she be.
So I was giving this line, you know, about Kirk, you. And the line would come, the line would come
from this little sweet voice saying, well, but I don't. Yes, you do. No, but I really. And I tell
you, it was seemingly one of the most difficult things I ever had to do in my life to maintain
this character, having a response from somebody that was not Captain Clerk. I mean, Captain Kirk,
then Captain Kirk. And so that was the difference. The first one, I felt more at ease talking to him
and enjoying the rapport and the, you know, the dueling with words and so forth. In this case,
it was very difficult reacting to this script girl's voice.
And I should also say, while we are discussing Ricardo Montalban, that
that is his chest. That is the question I am most often asked about Star Trek II,
the chest of the Wrath of Khan. And they ask if that's his chest, and it is his chest.
The original ending of the picture was grimmer, more final. It said Spock is dead. The picture
ended over the feelings of Kirk in that wonderful moment when he says,
of all the souls I have encountered in my travels, his was the most human. That's how
we were leaving the picture. The preview audience was aghast. There was silence in the theater.
And what have I done? Crept into my mind. What have we all done? And people walked slowly out.
It was leaving a funeral. So we had a couple of meetings, and we said, you know, it's a great
ending. It's a dramatic ending, but it's a downer of the worst sort. And it may end the franchise.
There may not be another Star Trek. Nicholas was very properly adamant that this was what
we had written, and this is what we should do. I began to have second thoughts about
the death of Spock. I had, as I said earlier, brought into it because I thought this will be
the last of the Star Trek movies for sure, which goes to the issue of whether or not I have
precognition. The answer is no, I don't. I'm sometimes pretty good instinctively, but in this
case, no one could foretell we were going to do a whole bunch of movies. So when we began to make
the film, and I began to realize that we had the kind of energy, and we had the kind of chemistry
amongst the cast, and the storytelling opportunity that we used to have when we were making good Star
Trek episodes, I began to wonder if indeed there might not be a future for Star Trek. And here I
was committed to leaving it. So because I had committed to leaving it based on the notion or on
the perception that this was going to be the last film. And now here we are making a film that
promises a future for Star Trek rather than an end. So I began to be concerned about that.
That obviously sparked in me, should I kill him now that he's having a good time? Should I kill
him? You know, it's not fair. It doesn't seem to make a lot of sense. But I don't think his
enthusiasm went that far as to say, so let's do another one, okay? Don't kill me. He didn't say
that. But I began to think it was a smart idea to preserve some future appearance by Spock in some
way. I didn't know what way. The day we did the death scene was extremely sensitive for me. I
think for others too, but certainly for me. I remember vividly, just as we were about to
shoot Spock going into the chamber, Scotty is, I believe, unconscious.
McCoy tries to stop me. I neck pinch him and he collapses to the floor. Harv Bennett came to me
and said at that moment, before we shot that particular piece of business,
what could you do to leave a thread for the future? Maybe he's thinking what I am, that there
may be another movie. And I understood that immediately because as I said, I felt that we
were making a film that might lead to other films. So I said, let me do this. And I did a mind meld
on the unconscious McCoy where I simply said, remember. Now that was vague enough to open a
door for any other kind of story. Remember meaning what? You could develop a story out of that moment.
I thought it might be a useful hinge to an open door to get into another story.
I said, great. It's perfect. And I didn't say it because I immediately said, that's it.
I just knew that that was the right tonality.
My theory about the coffin and Leonard Nimoy whispering something into McCoy's ear
to the two things that looking back suggests that Spock might come back,
those two things had such calculation. Those two guys, Nimoy and Bennett, were in collusion.
There's no question. And they kept me out of it. And to this day, I resented. They knew.
And the terrible thing is, neither Bennett nor Nimoy to this day will admit it, that they knew
what they were doing. And when I saw the coffin and I saw Spock go like this to McCoy's ear,
extraneous business. See in a film, the film, every shot has to count. Every moment,
you don't, especially when you're going towards the end, you don't have any extraneous moments
or time. Everything's to tell the story. What was that all about? What was the coffin all about?
Unless Nimoy expected to come back. We all mourned him. I hugged him, and I sobbed,
and Leonard, you're not coming. Took me over the coals, that guy. And to this day, he won't admit
it. They knew. And what we did then was to modify the ending by adding one word. We had ended the
picture without hope. We now needed to restore, certainly in a science fiction context, the
possibilities. And I remember taking the theme for that from Spock's oft-repeated lines in all
the episodes I had seen. There are always possibilities. And it became the theme of
what we did in the reshoots. Not a lot. We shot the last scene, and the last scene was rewritten
to reflect life from. And then ILM shot that remarkable sequence of the landed coffin.
It's very, very beautifully done. And James Horner wrote beautiful music to go with it.
And that's the shot where you go onto the Genesis planet, and you see Spock's coffin lying there.
It's the sequel set up. And me being such a flat-footed, unimaginative fellow, said,
he's dead, Jim. I don't see how you can bring him back, but shows you what I know. Where all
that popcorn was at stake. It was at that point that we decided, okay, let's really go for it,
and have Leonard do the prologue. So there was no prologue in Star Trek II,
Space, The Final Frontier, because we decided in post-production to save it for the end,
and let Spock's voice, for the first time in Star Trek history, read it.
I think the final argument was, that was too much, folks. That was too much. If you do that,
they know you're going to bring him back. And those of us who were for that said, yeah, so.
Space, The Final Frontier.
We ran the picture for a preview audience with the revised ending. The audience
rose as one, tears in their eyes and applause on their hands. And I felt like all of us had
done something right and noble. And I know that's corny, but I walked out of the theater
that night saying, yeah, yeah, that's the way it should be. I remember that after the picture was
released, one of the most respected critics of that day, and still, Janet Maslin of the New York
Times, began her review of Star Trek II with the sentence, well, that's more like it.
The French director Robert Bresson said, my job is not to find out what the public want and give
it to them. My job is to make the public want what I want. And that's the way I sort of think,
rightly or wrongly. I've never been very interested in what the public wants.
So I made the Star Trek movie that I wanted to see, on the assumption that if I liked it,
other people would like it.
We all know and love Star Trek II, The Wrath of Khan. But what's so interesting about this
is it's a movie that almost never got made.
It was great concern about the future of Star Trek at the studio. And it was obvious that if
number two didn't work and make them a lot of money, that the franchise itself might just
disappear.
The studio wasn't happy. They weren't happy with the way things went on Star Trek,
the motion picture.
The original Star Trek I was budgeted at about $24-25 million. And it went to $44-45 million.
And the bulk of that was in visual effects, as I was told. Bob Wise, who was a wonderful director,
and Gene Roddenberry, the two of them were somewhat at odds. I heard that during the
production of that one, that there were pages occurring not daily, but hourly.
So the thing just ballooned. It was completely out of control.
So Michael Eisner decides, yeah, we're going to do Star Trek again.
But it has to be done for a lot less money. As a result,
the plan was to develop it through the TV division.
And the reason for that was very simple, economics.
Now, a lot of people misunderstand. They think that Star Trek was going to become a TV movie.
And that Star Trek II turned out so well, they decided to release this movie. That is not true.
It was always going to be a feature, but developed by the TV division.
It was thought maybe the TV division can do this better, faster, go back to the roots,
the never-ending search in Hollywood to try to make things cheaper.
Michael Eisner went to Gary Nardino, who ran Paramount Television at the time.
They had just signed Harv Bennett to a deal to do television for them. He was going to be doing
Woman Called Golda and a lot of their MOWs and miniseries. He'd done the TV series The Mod Squad,
Six Million Dollar Man, Bionic Woman, a lot of success in television.
Harv's charge was to come in and try to make a movie for
less than $40 million in 1981. And he did. He said, I can make three movies for that price.
In handing keys to Harv Bennett, that means the keys were taken away from Gene Roddenberry,
who had spent all the 70s, you know, trying to get his show back,
talking about the ideals that he had, becoming as much a philosopher as a producer, inspiring fans.
If I may be so bold, it was a mistake for you to accept promotion.
Commanding a starship is your first best destiny. Anything else is a waste of material.
But not being in the driver's seat for movies. Roddenberry did not like being
basically pushed into the role of executive consultant. Harv now brings on an old,
old college friend of his, Bob Salen, Robert Salen, done a lot of commercials, really talented guy.
I was happily running my company, which I had, commercial production company,
which I had for 18 years. I was getting a little sick of the 30-second format.
Harv Bennett approached me a number of times. I had not been a producer,
but I've had produced my own commercials, so I knew how to do it.
Harv was working primarily on the script. We had a number of writers.
The work that was coming in was just inappropriate, is the best way I can describe it.
The smart thing that Harv Bennett did, who did not know Star Trek, was he reached out to fandom.
We got phoned by Harv Bennett, who said,
we're going to do a second Star Trek movie. She'd done the Star Trek Concordance.
Which was sort of an encyclopedia of the first series.
He sent over the script.
So I read it very carefully, and I redlined everything, and wrote notes in the margin,
and then typed in 18 more pages to send over to him. I get a phone call, and he says,
hey Joe, when I sent you the script, I was really expecting you to phone me and say,
this is utterly fantastic. Not an 18-page critique.
Harv Bennett did a couple of drafts.
Harv is struggling with the script. I'm feeling very nervous,
because I see that there's nothing there that we could really shoot.
I had to start the search for directors.
I must have made a list of 30 or 40 directors.
The problem was, they didn't want to do Star Trek.
They didn't want to do a sequel.
One of the directors I know that I was keen on was a young man who
actually came in at paramount suggestion.
Why don't you have a look at Ron Howard?
And I thought, great.
So we had a nice chat. We talked about Star Trek.
He loved Star Trek, by the way.
And that counts for a lot too, based on what I've just been through.
And I thought, boy, this could be really interesting.
I'd like to pursue this.
And I got shot down.
So we went together to Nick's house, and I thought to myself,
this is an incredibly bright man.
And they said, if we don't have a screenplay in 12 days,
ILM, George Lucas's special effects house,
they can't guarantee delivery of the shots in time for when the movie opens in June.
And I said, what do you mean the movie opens in June?
And they said, well, the movie's already been booked into these theaters.
You book the movie into theaters, and you don't have a movie?
After I got over my shock, I said, OK, I think I can do it in 12 days.
And they still didn't look happy.
Harv turned to me and says, I don't think so.
I said, the guy gets it.
He really gets it.
He understood what we were trying to do.
It was one of those, you talk to somebody,
and you see it in their eyes, and you know they understand.
And I said, we got to use him.
I said, well, forget my deal.
Forget the credit.
Forget the money.
Whatever.
Just let's get on with it.
If I don't do this, there's not going to be a movie.
Nick, on his own, in 12 days, did a page one rewrite.
And he literally saved the film.
If we had shot what we had up to that point, it would have been a disaster.
Everybody really liked the script a lot.
So we prepared a budget, and it was $12 million.
I worked with the then studio production manager.
His name was Marvin Miller.
Wonderful man.
So I took the budget to the powers that be.
And the word I got back was, no, you have to take a million dollars out of it.
I couldn't understand.
Marvin just sat there and smiled.
And he said, they do that all the time.
And he said, no matter what the budget.
He says, they always come back at you and want you to take money out of it.
He says, tell them it's $11 million.
I said, but Marvin, that's not true.
He said, that's OK.
So when people ask me, what did I learn when I did Star Trek?
I learned how to lie.
I said, I think I'd better go to ILM.
That's the only way we're going to make this happen.
I flew up to ILM, which is in San Rafael.
And I was with Bob Salen.
And they've got the script.
And they were drawing stuff.
We're talking.
And I get called out to take a phone call from Harv, who says, well, we have a problem.
William Shatner hates the script.
I said, he hates it?
How could he hate it?
Everybody likes it.
Everybody loves it.
I go back into this meeting.
And I'm just in a daze.
There's no movie.
As far as I can tell, there's no movie.
So this is like play acting for the next four or five hours while we go through these shots.
You know, I'm kind of numbly going, yes, no, whatever.
And then a day or so later, I'm in Harv's office.
And Bill Shatner comes in.
And he says, this script is a disaster.
This is a disaster.
I just kept having to leap up and go to the bathroom.
I just kept having to pee.
Just pee like there was like no tomorrow.
I guess I was so upset, my bladder just kept bursting.
And then he left.
And I was distraught, which is an easy place for me to go.
And Harv, who'd been in the television business all his life, he just sort of said, well, you
know, I think we can do this in sort of bite-sized pieces.
Let's talk about what he's really saying.
And what he was really saying was, Captain Kirk should be the first man through the door.
I was after some different things than they had done before.
I was interested in people who were off their game, who were tired, who were depressed,
who were older.
Wouldn't it be easier to just put an experienced crew back on the ship?
Galloping around the cosmos is a game for the young duck.
The subjects of the movie, as I understood them, and an artist is not the best or definitive
judge of his own work, but certainly what I thought I was making a movie about
was friendship, old age and death.
Jim, I'm your doctor and I'm your friend.
Get back your command.
Get it back before you turn into part of this collection.
Before you really do grow old.
So Kirk is a different Kirk than cocky Kirk.
He's exhausted Kirk.
He is Kirk depressed.
No longer a captain either.
Kicked upstairs behind a desk.
So those are the things we sort of worked on.
So I went back and in 24 hours with a lot of scissors and scotch tape and white out
and whatever your fingers are all covered with.
And I dropped it off at his house.
And then I got this message on my answering machine tape about, oh, you're a genius.
And I kept that tape because I thought, you know, the day will come when I'm going to
play that at him.
But I don't think I ever did.
It was the best of times.
It was the worst of times.
Message?
None that I'm conscious of.
Except, of course, happy birthday.
Surely the best of times.
Memory is a tricky thing.
Somebody said to me, did you have a lot of interaction with Gene Roddenberry?
And I said, no, not really.
You sort of met him before you started the movie and he wasn't really involved.
And then years later, I saw a collection of my papers at the University of Iowa
library where they collect this stuff.
And to my surprise, there was a whole exchange of typewritten memoranda between Mr. Roddenberry
and me arguing about this movie, about the script.
Gene Roddenberry always insisted that Starfleet was not a military organization.
He said it was more like the Coast Guard.
Nick Meyer tried to do stuff to make the Star Trek world feel more real.
Things like David wearing a sweater and having a sweater around his neck and no smoking signs
on the bridge.
And it was this kind of stuff that made Roddenberry apoplectic.
You know, Gene was really upset and gave a lot of notes about that.
He didn't like it and really fought the idea of a more militaristic hierarchy.
I said, everybody's got to have ranks, got to have insignia.
So you know who's who on this vast ship.
And you sort of saw the evolution of Gene Roddenberry from the original series to what
he became with the next generation, because he would fight stuff like,
why did they destroy the Setial?
That's a new form of life.
Why would they fire their zap guns and kill this when they should have studied it?
That kind of futuristic, less violent, less jingoistic Gene Roddenberry who really gave
birth to the next generation, you can see being sort of born out of the crucible of
Star Trek II.
All screenplays are overwritten.
And when you rehearse, you chop out stuff.
I find that the attrition rate for dialogue in a screenplay of mine between the first
draft of the script and the finished movie, what we used to call the answer print, is
50 percent.
And the more of them you can get rid of in rehearsal, the more money you're going to
save down the road.
Actors want to know one thing about the director anyway.
Is he crazy?
How crazy?
The rehearsals for Star Trek II took place off the lot in my dining room in Laurel Canyon.
What about my performance?
I'm not a drama critic.
And we had a read-through of the script, and then we broke down and did scene work and
stuff like that.
These people had all done this many, many times before.
And they knew how to sort of roll with the punches, and they knew their parts.
They knew who those people were.
Bill was very protective of Captain Kirk.
He had no ego, Bill, but a lot of vanity where Captain Kirk is, you know, that was his persona.
And he guarded it, but it was a stretch to get into Kirk depressed, Kirk exhausted, Kirk
not on top of his game.
That's how Khan beats him in the first round.
Bill and Leonard and the rest of the cast, you know, all professional, everybody doing
first-rate job.
There was a little bit of looseness.
I'm not saying this in a critical way, just a little bit of looseness, shall we say.
But everything was going smoothly, and the performances were great, and the guys were
great.
Ricardo came on the set, and we only had him for 10 days.
And the first shot Nick had him do was a master of his speech.
Ricardo nailed it.
It was flawless.
You couldn't get it any better than that.
I've done far worse than kill you.
I've hurt you, and I wish to go on hurting you.
Well, the next day, Leonard and Bill are there, and all their lines are learned, and
things moved along a lot faster.
But it caused the game to be raised a little bit.
Ricardo was professional, a gentleman.
You couldn't ask for anybody better.
You're my superior officer.
You are also my friend.
I have been and always shall be yours.
Leonard's relation to the character of Spock was ambivalent, to say the least.
He wrote a book called I Am Not Spock, and then 20 years later, he wrote a book I Am
Spock.
The fact is, he is Spock.
I mean, Gene created the role brilliantly.
Gene wrote Spock as half-human, half-alien, having this hybrid personality.
Brilliant to begin with.
My father firmly believed that to build a character, you must find something about that
character that you can relate to on a personal level, that you have to bring aspects of your
own personality to that character to bring it to life.
The point of acting is to play a role convincingly with some sense of realism.
And the best way to do that is to find elements of the character that you can relate to on
a personal level.
And Dad brought a lot of his own experience to Spock.
And the story that Harve tells is he said he got Leonard to do the movie by promising
him the greatest death scene you could possibly have.
And Leonard said, okay, give me a great death scene.
Aren't you dead?
If you read Leonard's memoir, he remembers being very pissed off at me because when he
came in to shoot his death scene, I was dressed as Sherlock Holmes.
I've never dressed as Sherlock Holmes in my life.
But I was wearing a suit.
I'm a big opera fan, and I would go almost every night.
And in those days, you wore a tie, you put on a suit.
And so that's what I did.
But I was so out of it in the sense of not understanding Star Trek or its hold on people
that we're filming this death scene.
And I look over at my cinematographer, Gane Rescher, who also photographed the face in
the crowd for Ilya Kazan.
This is not nobody.
And he's crying.
And then I'm looking over at the other members of the crew.
Everybody's crying.
And I thought, what am I missing here?
Frankly, I think I wiped away a tear or two, too, because I thought it was beautifully
done.
I thought the two of them, they just did a wonderfully moving moment.
Don't grieve, Admiral.
It's logical.
The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few or the one.
The end result of what played out, the emotional stuff, was a very purposeful, designed,
thought-out way to tell the story.
I have been and always shall be your friend.
Henry James said that life is hot, but art is cool.
If you are the puppeteer, you cannot be out front sobbing at the performance.
You must stay backstage dry-eyed and make sure that the strings do not get tangled.
So that's what I was doing.
They were just totally lost in this very important moment.
We shot that sequence towards the end of the film, but not at the very end.
Then the word got out.
We tried to maintain security, and you can forget about that.
You can number scripts, you can do thumbprints, and it doesn't matter.
The scripts are going to get out there somehow.
And people were furious that we were going to kill Spock.
I got a telephone call on my answering machine that said, I'll never forget this, it said,
you kill Spock and we'll kill you.
Someone leaked the plans to kill Spock.
Turns out it was Roddenberry who did not want Spock.
He leaked the plans to the fans who were apoplectic.
You kill Spock, I will never come and see Star Trek.
I will never support Star Trek.
Once it was being done, it was Gene's job not to badmouth it, but to promote it.
He leaked Spock's death, got some flack from R. Bennett for that.
Actually, I got flack because I went out and told this at some convention that I went to.
And when I got back, Gene had already leaked it.
I'm not the one, Gene had already said it.
But apparently because I said it in front of a huge group, that was it.
But no, he was interested in promoting it.
If he was going out there and publicizing Star Trek, it was his baby.
He felt strongly about the franchise and wanted the best for it and wanted it to succeed.
He wasn't going to go out and say, oh, don't go see it, it's not by me.
There was a lot of mail that was coming in, and people were upset.
And you can't do this, you can't kill Spock.
Yeah, you can kill him as long as you kill him well.
You can do anything as long as you do it well.
But if you do it badly, people will throw things.
I remember when we first previewed the movie,
we previewed it without the ending that's on it now.
When Spock dies, the sobbing that you could hear in the theater was almost overwhelming.
It's 9, 10 o'clock, and after the preview, we're struggling with what needs to happen.
Barry Diller stepped in for a while.
It was this massive powerhouse.
The cards show that the audience is depressed that Spock's dead.
So I was overruled.
Now I look back and I think, what were you making such a big fuss about?
It's okay.
You do get a sense of closure and catharsis, but you also get that hope.
I remember the Man's National Theater where we opened the movie.
As part of post-production, I took an extra interest in going into the theater
and being sure that it would sound and look like the way it should.
So I got in there and got the studio to redo those speakers and rewire that theater before
we opened in Westwood because I knew that it wasn't going to be anything like what
we had done on the dubbing stage.
Of course, the whole term blockbuster comes from people lining up,
and they'd show up in line with their uniforms,
and they'd buy a ticket for every showing that day.
I've seen Wrath of Khan 40 or 50 times.
I've seen it over and over again.
It's one of my favorite movies.
It's a movie that I'll sit down in the home theater and make an evening of to watch.
So I can't remember how I reacted the first time I saw Spock die.
I do know now when I sit down to watch the movie that he does die,
and I know he comes back in the next movie.
But I cannot for the life of me remember what it was like to see Spock die the first time.
I'm going to assume sad.
Wrath of Khan, in many ways, felt like the first Star Trek movie.
I mean, there was a number two after it,
but you didn't need to see the first movie at all to understand it or get it,
or even to have seen Spacey, the episode that it was a sequel to.
It was much more like the original show that we all remembered and loved,
you know, with a focus on the characters.
It accepted the passage of time.
It was just a delightful movie from beginning to end.
When the film was finished and out there and obviously on its way to success,
I was called up to one of the executive offices at Paramount.
The gentleman in charge said to me,
we would like you to stay on and do more Star Treks.
What do you think about that?
And I paused and I said, what do you mean?
He said, well, I would like you to produce more Star Treks for us.
And I said, what about Harv?
And he said, well, we'd like him doing television.
And I said, well, let me think about that.
So I went home and I thought about it.
And I came back and I said no,
because I couldn't, what I felt,
betray a man who had given me a chance to do this.
Even though he and I had a lot of differences, I couldn't do that.
I felt that was morally wrong.
As I reflect back on Star Trek at the time,
I must confess it was a very anxiety-provoking, tension-filled experience.
I would say that it's one of the things I'm most proud of, of course.
And the fact that people have responded the way they have to this day
is enormously gratifying.
When people are asked what they think of something,
and somebody said that journalism is the first draft of history,
but our understanding of what Star Trek is or was
will probably be better in another 50 years.
Whether it's just a blip on the horizon or whether it,
you know, had some larger significance, whether it really lasted.
I got into a conversation with my father once about Cyrano.
And I said, this is a great play.
And he said, do you think so?
Seems like all the other characters are just sort of feeding him cues.
I said, and I was a kid and I just loved this play.
And I said, this is a masterpiece.
He said, let's talk in 50 years.
So that's what I have to say.
Let's talk in 50 years.
