Inside NYC building buckle: Structural engineer breaks down emergency evacuation

Fox - 5 NY
45 followers
Jul 7, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Joining us now to break down what could be causing the building to buckle is Brian Falconer,
a structural engineer from Severud Associates Consulting Engineers. Brian, thank you so much
for joining us. Thanks for having me on. All right, so Brian, what could cause a building
like this to buckle? So the two elements that seem to have buckled are probably columns. They
might be something that was put in temporarily for the construction. They might be original
members in the building, but obviously they were overloaded. So whether just there was a lot of
materials or something put on certain parts of the building that put load on them, or whether
maybe something was altered in the building and load was transferred into them that they
weren't intended to carry, one of those things had to have happened, you know, I presume,
and that's what then caused them to buckle, to overload. And do you think that this was
a compounding issue that lasted for a while, or did this happen just kind of all of a sudden?
Well, it probably happened, you know, pretty abruptly when it actually happened.
You know, I'll also tell you, though, that it's very good news that it stopped, right,
that they did fail, they did buckle, and the floors came down a certain dimension,
but then it stopped. And that just meant there was enough redundancy in the building that it
would stop it from progressing into a much worse condition. Now it's more of a risk if there's
something unplanned for that might happen, like if there's heavy winds or something like that,
and that's why the DOB is shutting down the neighborhood and evacuating people until they
can figure out what's going on. I would also say a strong vote of confidence for the New York City
Department of Buildings. They're very used to dealing with emergency situations. They have
very strong protocols, and I know it's inconvenient for everybody, but, you know, definitely they're
creating this to be a much more safe situation for everybody in the neighborhood, and they're
going to oversee that whatever's done temporarily and permanently to correct the problem is in
everybody's best interest. So what are crews doing right now to help stabilize the building
and prevent it from collapsing? So right now, I think they're just clearing the area and they're
observing what's going on. I would assume that they're going to add some kind of shoring inside
the building, maybe some bracing inside the building to stabilize this part of the floor
or this single floor. I think also as they research it and they maybe get some
theories about exactly how this happened and what this happened, they might do some other things
in parts of the other parts of the building, like taking loads out of areas or if maybe
something was cut, putting something back somewhere else, maybe reinforcing these bent columns
in place so that they can't bend anymore. Anything like that, I think that they could be doing
shortly. And several other buildings were evacuated in addition to this building here.
What was the reasoning behind that? So like I said, the building was strong enough to
have enough redundancy. It took the load out of those columns because they were failing and it
passed the load into other columns around the building. And like I said, it's great that it
had the redundancy to do that. Otherwise, we would have had a much worse event right away.
But because they're concerned, well, what if there are heavy winds or something? We had 80 mile per
hour winds just a few days ago and something like that could take a building like this and put more
stress on it. I assume the workers were there yesterday, so I don't know what happened between
yesterday and this morning to make this happen. I don't think it was 80 mile an hour winds,
but that's what they need to figure out, what happened yesterday or overnight to make this
happen. And obviously the goal right now is to stabilize the building, but how does this get
fixed long term? So after they stabilize it, they probably are going to introduce some jacks into
the system so they can then re-level all of those floors and then fix everything off, reinforce
everything so that they can then remove the jacks and everything is still stable. Now,
a reporter on the scene, Richard Giacobbe, said that the media has been pushed back,
bystanders have been pushed back. I assume that that means that there is a growing safety concern
right now. Yeah, until they really feel like they know what happened and why it happened,
they're going to keep a wide perimeter. They don't want anybody in the area because
they don't really know what the risk is to somebody down on the street.
And Brian, is there anything else I'm missing that you think people watching this need to know
if they're wondering about this building collapse, if they're watching even from their
phones out on the scene? You mean like,
should they be concerned about their own buildings? Yeah.
Far and away? Exactly.
Probably not. And remember, this was a building under construction. So if your building's not
under construction, it's probably not going through anything like what this building is
going through. And so I think that the general risks to buildings is very small. Things like
this seem to happen every year and every few years in New York. And we have 8 million people here.
We have hundreds of thousands of buildings. So just statistically, the risks are small.
But it is the built environment. And there are always some risks like this.
All right. Brian Falconer, structural engineer, thank you so much for breaking
down all of that for us. I appreciate it. Okay. Have a good day and everybody stay safe.
