Electric vs petrol supermoto showdown ⚡️ Stark Varg SM vs KTM 690 SMC R

Fact Racing
22 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome to Motorcycle News and today we're going to be acting the fool with a pair of Supermotos.
Now on my left I've got the 2026 KTM 690 SMCR and this kind of typifies the classic Supermoto.
It's an off-road based platform from the 690 Enduro and big power single, long travel forks,
17-inch wheels, lots of skids, wheelies and fun. Now this is a slightly updated model,
there's a bit more power this year, the electronics have changed the dash and a few other bits and
pieces including a little bit more power up top which I think is probably just to
rain on Ducati's parade with the most powerful single which they no longer have,
KTM do. Nothing too big a change, we've ridden this before, absolutely love them.
On my right we've got what is potentially the new guard in Supermoto. Now this is the
Starkvag Supermoto funnily enough and this is based on their kind of disruptive motocross and
enduro bikes and for years we've been a little bit kind of turning our nose up at electric bikes
but this is probably the first bike to go okay we need to take these things seriously now because
this has been sort of doing the business of motocross, supercross particularly actually
where that instant hit of power really works and enduro as well. They're now competing in the Super
World Championship and they've been getting great results with these and now they've given it the
Supermoto treatment so big brakes, small wheels and road homologation as well so interestingly
the figures for this are actually quite comparable with the petrol option which isn't very often the
case because let's be fair electric bikes are usually heavier, slower, poor range and the
performance just doesn't add up but in some ways this is faster so we've got 80 horsepower here
versus 70 odd for the KTM. We've got lower weight, we've got a measured 125 kilos for the Stark
and this is over 160 full of fuel so actually for the first time we can compare them like for like.
So naturally with that interesting comparison we wanted to get stuck in and test them back to back
so that's what we've been doing for the last two days so we've been out on the local roads
terrorizing b-roads, a little bit of town and then we went up to Stretton cart circuit for the evening
as well to have a little bit of circuit fun as well and myself and MCN's deputy head of car we're
not necessarily Supermoto gods but we do like messing around with these things so we wanted to
make sure we kind of covered all the bases with these two bikes. So without further ado I'm going
to run you through how these two bikes compare, where the limitations of both of them are actually
because it was quite interesting and not necessarily what we expected from the outset. So I'll start
with road performance because that's where we're going to be riding these things most of the time
and I'll go with the old guard the kind of the proven formula if you like and as we expected
the KTM is a barrel of fun it's instant it's direct it's really aggressive and raw and it's
just an absolute barrel load of fun. What you get with this is a really kind of light agile sporty
feel if you're used to kind of big sports bikes and things like that this is not dissimilar you've
got real feel for the tyres it's on Conti Attack SM2s which are just like your droppings on a
blanket shall we say and great WP suspension loads of feel loads of control for that a little bit
harsh in some circumstances but you don't buy a bike like this expecting comfort like a grand
tourer. And then there's the brakes they are obviously only one disc that's all it needs it
doesn't weigh that much and it's a really strong one as well loads of power loads of feel and if
you like messing around backing in doing skids things like that it's got everything you need
endos as well not that we'd ever do anything on public roads track of course it's just it's the
whole package. Electronics too as well which is something a few years ago if you'd said supermoto
electronics you'd have gone no what do you want that for but actually KTM are very good electronics
they make it very intuitive very easy through that kind of little dash and you've got options of abs
which you can turn off in various degrees there's a supermoto plus option which
manages rear brake trailing if you're trying to back it in and get it sideways it helps you
manage that if that's not a skill you kind of have straight off the bat. Traction control too
obviously this is a really sort of punchy torquey sort of bike so if you're kind of a little bit
less confident or if it's wet or something like that you can dial it up and down as you need it
or turn it off fully if you want to take accidents into your own hands. And then we've got an up and
down quick shifter as well so you can just ride those hits of torque and just kind of snap through
the gears blasting up speed and then come absolutely nailing into corners just stabbing back
down through the gearbox as well. It's everything you would expect from a traditional supermoto and
those little changes they have just moved it on a bit but they've not ruined it either. And then
the Stark on the other hand it's not so much swapping bikes it's almost like swapping sports
it's totally different and it's really alien to start with and particularly if you've got off
something with clutch and gears you're going to pull away by holding the back braking stabbing
at a lever that doesn't actually exist so that's a bit that's a bit of a head fry to start with.
And then you're going to pull away and even in the lower modes there's just kind of this instant
kind of jerk as it picks up and goes and it's just that this seamless kind of drive forward and
some it feels like you're instantly at 50 miles an hour which is not far from the truth to be fair.
Even in the sort of modes three and four which kind of sort of 50-60 horsepower something like that
it's just so quick and so effortless it's kind of really alarming to sort of get your head around
from the first few miles. And then the chassis is that's probably more alien than the motor
actually you can soon get your head around that because when it comes down to it it's very simple
you twist you go throttle off you slow down particularly if you've got the regenerative
braking turned up and you soon get your head around the left lever giving you the back brake
rather than the clutch and actually that's kind of a real positive. Obviously we've seen that in
short circuit racing where scooter brakes as they're called have become a real performance tool
but the chassis like I say is the bit that's been most difficult for us to get our heads around.
It's very firmly sprung very firmly damped as well so there's very little in the way of weight
transfer and also shock absorption as well so you feel every last little bump and even when you get
hard on the front brakes it doesn't dip much it doesn't squat much under power even when you're
unleashing all that torque if you stick it in mode five and stick 80 horsepower to that back
Pirelli it just doesn't give you much back and sort of counter-intuitively to what you usually
get with a supermoto where they're great at sort of slow speed pointed square flicking around this
is actually better with more speed the more load you get on it the better it is the more feel you
get for those tyres because the really low speed stuff and I'll come to a bit more of the track
stuff later but on the kart circuit sometimes it was really difficult to kind of feel what was
going on and it doesn't make you very confident and just I previously mentioned the brakes a
little bit the brakes are probably my biggest criticism of this bike it's got a great big
Brembo style Emma caliper and big disc on it as well but there's something wrong in the hydraulic
ratio there it's got a great big master cylinder on it and what that has done is given it a really
short lever travel really kind of lacking in feel and that also throws out the power as well there's
very little braking power there it's very hard to kind of know what you're doing with it and
sort of place it where you want it which is a real shame back brake is great it's a very
conventional mass cylinder and the ratios there are good so you can play with that all you want
and actually if you put it in full engine braking modes full regenerative braking
you can bury the front as hard as you can as much as you can kind of trust the front at least
and trail a bit of back brake and that engine braking does exactly what you do on a KTM when
you stab it back a few gears and lean on the slip clutch and it starts to back in which which
takes a little bit of getting used to because it's a very different way of controlling the bike and
it's a little bit unnerving because it does feel synthetic a combustion engine is obviously very
mechanical and very visceral and if you've been riding for a few years you come to know what to
expect with these things so when you start playing around and learning these new kind of skills and
silly bits of fun that you do with supermotos you know where you are but trying to apply that
to the stark is is very difficult actually so it's going to take a better man than me to kind of
do it instantly but it is in there and with more time you would get it the only limitation to that
would be the steering lock it doesn't have a lock lot at all and i'll just gently turn it there on
its stand but as you can see it's not got a great deal at all whereas the KTM is like a typical
dirt bike it's got much more so if you are a real kind of backing in demon you can get it all the
way out and you're not going to run out of lock and get into bother with it and then also with
the stark is very narrow very small so you are super exposed and i never thought i'd say this
about a KTM supermoto this actually feels comfy when you get back off that and onto this see it's
that little bit wider the whole bike is that bit wider and in comparison the suspension is a bit
softer so it suddenly feels that little bit more rounded and of course you're starting from a
slightly softer start point so you could mess around with the WP's adjusters and make it even
softer and actually in some ways this is quite a friendly bike i think it doesn't necessarily need
somebody that has kind of these mad supermoto skills and is going to go everywhere on one wheel
or sideways you can knock the power back on this it's got different kind of power throttle response
modes so you can tame it a little bit and of course throttle goes both ways you've got six
gears to play with as well so you can kind of give as much or as little as you want whereas
that is a little bit more straightforward it is it's going or it's stopping and it takes a lot of
self-restraint because there's no gear changes or power curves to kind of rein you in you open
throttle you just keep going as until you back off yourself or you hit something in all honesty
which in some ways is part of the fun it's a really unique experience in some ways like i say
it's quite different from this but equally it's that same very simplistic animalistic hooligan
kind of fun and i won't get into too much of what's been going on because we'd never break
the law obviously but we had our fill with that one and i mentioned we went to a kart circuit
which allowed us to have totally legal fun and i expected the stark being lighter being more
powerful not having a clutch and a gearbox to play with i thought that was really going to
shine there and that's where the kind of kind of slightly more road focused ktm would fall down
but it was the absolute opposite in all honesty stark's really rigid chassis just doesn't work
at low speed you can't really kind of get the brakes hard if you can't get enough suspension
travel you can't generate that feel for the front tire and coming out of slow corners as well it's
running on predi diablo rosso force and they're a good tire but they're not really designed for
an application this light i feel they developed more for you kind of a2 sports bikes and ninja
500s and things like that so this is probably not really generating the load at low speeds that
these tires need to work the best and it always just feels like it's on edge it's really kind of
difficult to get to grips with and you kind of lose the benefit of that insane torque and that
big power because you end up pegging it back to get something where there is that grip there and
you kind of feel safe really kind of opening it up and again coming back to the brakes when you've
when you really want to kind of feather a brake in and trail it into a corner
that caliper and that combo just won't give you what you need to really kind of play with it
so it was a little bit of a disappointment really but obviously we don't spend all our
time on kart circuits so where do we stand overall on the stark versus the ktm is this the new guard
now price isn't really a factor in your decision whether to kind of go with the new technology or
the sort of proven formula 10 990 pounds in the uk whereas this is 10 600 so there's a few hundred
quid in it nothing to write home about but the ktm still offers a much more complete package
and i think crucially most of the time it's more fun and as a real petrol head i love two strokes
big twins triples kind of really charismatic engines i expected to not especially gel with
start because of the motor but actually that's the bit i like because it is it's a real party
piece it's it's just wild how it just goes zipping from zero to a decent speed shall we say with
absolutely seamless drive and it'll pick the front wheel up kind of all manner of kind of crazy
speeds it's a real kind of event and i quite like that okay there's no sound apart from a kind of
whining sort of hair dryer kind of noise or an rc car something like that but that's the bit i
liked it's the rest of it at the moment i feel it probably needs a bit more development time
stuck say this does have different geometry to their motocross and enduro bikes but i don't
think it's different enough and if they have made it kind of quite a lot more different
it's kind of gone in the wrong direction it probably needs to be a little bit lower a little
bit softer and maybe even more raked out because it doesn't need to be quite as aggressive as it
is it needs to generate a bit more feel which is where ktm's kind of long-standing experience
or 20 30 years or more building dirt bikes in the first instance and then supermotos off the back
of them that really sort of that's the strength of the 690 is you can just trust it to the absolute
hill even if you've got everything turned off you know exactly what the front tire is doing you can
load the back tire until it's just on the brink of letting go there's just so much feel you can
really trust it and it becomes your kind of hooligan playmate and it's just such a brilliant
experience not everybody should buy one it'll do your head in if you're kind of doing long distances
or you live in an area where all the roads are quicker rather than tight back lanes but everybody
should try one at least once whereas the stark i feel not through dint of the electronic power plant
it needs a little bit more development elsewhere and to be honest we should probably expect that
because stark are quite new to building motorcycles in general and while they've gone and got on quite
well in the dirt world the road is a different place and an equally supermoto competition is
something else i'm not aware of anybody racing one of these yet but it'll be interesting to see
how they get on with that and maybe a bit of development time will sort of feed into that
and they will start to do well and hopefully that will feed back down to the customer models as well
but for now it's not the future it's a very interesting option and like i say if you can
get your hands on a demo anywhere it's very much worth your time trying it but for christ sakes be
careful there's no abs there's no traction control and it's one of the most direct wild machines you
can buy so that wraps up this test if you want to see more electric bikes and mtn please let us know
if you want to see more supermoto in general please let us know and drop a few comments down below and
tell us how you feel about the starks supermotos electric bikes in general and how you feel about
what we've kind of dealt with this test thank you for watching see you again next time
