Once upon a time the McLaren F1 boasted a mind-bending 627hp and was the pinnacle of the supercar world.
Yet here we are in late 2024 with a Ferrari 12Cilindri and an Aston Martin Vanquish that each sport around two hundred horsepower more than the iconic Big Mac!
In an era when combustions engines keep being read their last rites, that we’ve got two big twelve-cylinder motors not only alive, but producing ever most preposterous amounts of power, is a reason to celebrate.
Which we could do – but when two so-called ‘super GTs’ arrive so quickly one after the other, rather than let them rest on their laurels we’d sooner find out which was best.
So, before the snow and ice of winter descended upon Italy, we took a yellow Ferrari and a red Aston Martin to a rather special location. Top Gear’s Contributing Editor, Jethro Bovingdon, is your referee…
🌍 This video has been translated into French / German / Latin American Spanish using AI translation, with proper human oversight to ensure accuracy.
MORE ABOUT TOP GEAR: Welcome to the official home of Top Gear on YouTube. Here you'll find all the best clips from your favourite episodes, whether that’s Ken Block drifting London in the Hoonicorn, Chris Harris in the latest Porsche 911 GT3 or classic Top Gear clips from Clarkson, Hammond and May. You'll also find the latest performance car reviews from the TopGear.com crew, our brand new series American Tuned with Rob Dahm and the fastest power laps from our in house performance benchmark: The Stig.
Front-engine GT cars are the ultimate symbol of escapism.
We love to imagine them eating up continents at steady triple-digit speeds,
while the great unwashed trudge to Gatwick Airport,
dreaming of a full English breakfast washed down with a pint of lager.
They might forfeit a little bit of supercar agility,
but they're so much more glamorous and have an irresistible, unstoppable quality to them.
Pure sophistication.
Which is why we've brought the new Ferrari Dodici Cylindri
and Aston Martin Vanquish together on these fast-flowing Italian roads.
They really are the perfect pair.
And what a setting.
So today we're going to channel that cerebral, dreamy sensibility.
You know, 1960s glamour.
Well, yeah, we can discuss all of those things.
But let's not forget that the previous Ferrari 812 Superfast
was about as exciting as anything on four wheels,
and the new car essentially has the upgraded engine from the scintillating Competizione.
The layout says GT, but the numbers say pure-blood supercar.
819 horsepower at 9,250 rpm and 500 pounds-feet of torque at 7,250.
Plus all the usual good stuff.
Side-slip control 8.0, virtual short wheelbase 3.0.
That's rear-steer to you and I.
A new eight-speed dual-clutch box with e-diff.
It costs from £336,500.
Aston Martin isn't messing around with the new Vanquish either.
It has an all-new 5.2-litre V12 twin-turbocharged engine
with 823 horsepower and 738 foot-pounds.
The Spielstein DTX dampers as seen in the Porsche 992.
A new torque management system to help the rear tyres cope
and create a kind of normally aspirated feel to the delivery.
Bespoke new Pirelli tyres and massive carbon ceramic discs.
It's some 200 kilos heavier than the Ferrari,
although Italian fluids often seem very heavy,
so it's hard to be sure until we put them on the scales.
But it almost matches the Ferrari's price too at £330,000.
The Vanquish also promises to dial the Super GT formula
heavily towards the super part of the title.
Of course, the 12-cylinder and the Vanquish are proper GT cars
and you could no doubt cover huge mileages in perfect company in these cars.
This Aston now has the longer wheelbase, all forward of the A-pillar,
effectively between the A-pillar and the front wheel,
and that helps with ride quality.
The interior is, as they've done recently throughout the range,
a big, big step on from the DBS.
It feels pretty bespoke, handmade, sumptuous.
Sort of all the good stuff about handmade without any of the bad stuff.
So it's really a lovely, lovely thing.
It's deeply refined.
It scores over the Ferrari in that everything is relatively simple to use.
There's still a lot of touchscreen action,
but there are actual buttons.
It's more straightforward.
There's none of the haptic nonsense.
And it feels bigger, more luxurious.
That does mean it feels a bit more intimidating than the Ferrari,
which immediately feels quite small.
With this, you've got the really high scuttle.
You're sort of peering over like the car's one size too big for you
to see where the sort of ends of the car are.
But there's just this polish about the car
and that GT character truly does come through.
We flew into Rome and picked this car up,
but I would have very, very happily picked it up at Gaydon
and driven it all the way across here in one hit.
It's got that feel to it.
The same is true of the Ferrari.
In fact, on the launch of this car, when I looked at the coverage,
it was very clear that Ferrari had talked at great length
about how this car is more of a GT.
They've turned the dial the other way from the 812 super fast
and they've gone big on those GT elements.
And first impressions are that they really have.
I didn't quite believe it because the 812 is such a sharp and nutty thing.
I didn't think they would be able to really tip that character
all the way into the direction of a GT.
But this car, they always rode well.
It rides really, really nicely.
It's so quiet.
I'm in sport mode, so there's wet, sport, race, CT off, ESC off as usual.
But in sport mode, driving along on the Italian Autostrada
or on these twistier roads, it's just so quiet and refined.
And for a car that's literally named after its engine,
it separates you a huge amount from that.
And I guess what that means is it would be a lovely place
to spend a lot of time, to do long journeys.
And it would definitely not be taxing or
you certainly wouldn't jump out feeling wired.
It really is much more of a GT car.
And I get that it's not as sumptuous inside as the Aston Martin,
but it's got that minimalist Ferrari luxury, which I actually quite like.
And yeah, overall, a bit more wind noise than something like a
not as subtle, not as isolating, but a huge shifting character.
And I guess I can see why Ferrari and Aston Martin have done that.
They want to separate these cars from the likes of Vantage, 296 GTB, SF90.
These are a different sort of car, that archetypal GT.
Thing is, I'm not sure I fully buy into this theory for a few reasons.
For example, at the launch of this car, I heard a lot that because Ferrari now has the SF90,
for the extreme performance, they can afford to turn this more towards the GT side of things.
But that conveniently ignores that the SF90 is a bit of a miss for Ferrari.
People don't love that car and the residuals are really suffering.
So why would we sacrifice the V12 spirit and character for a car that people aren't dying to
own? And then there's this GT argument. People use them all the time. That's what they want.
Well, I had a little look on the used market and that is not borne out by the facts.
I'm going to read out a few cars. 2018 car, 2,700 miles.
2019 car, this is a big one, 9,700. That's rare.
2018, 2,784. 2019, 5,600. People aren't using these cars to cross continents all the time.
That isn't really what they're about. And then similarly, this was really interesting,
the Competizione version of the 812, the car with the madness dialed up to like 158 or something,
is actually worth over a million pounds now. So maybe that's what people want.
And it's the same story when I looked at the vanquished predecessor, DBS Superleggera,
very low mileage cars. I think I wrote it down. Three of 29 for sale had over 20,000 miles and
the average was less than 5,000 miles. So maybe people don't really want a GT. They like the idea
of it, but they actually want a big, intense, super characterful sports car. That's what I want.
So let's take the GT credentials as read and say that the Aston carries a slight advantage here.
The Ferrari is quieter and rides just a bit better, but the Aston feels more luxurious,
isn't blighted with the haptic nightmare,
and the effortless torque is great for loping across big distances. Can we go fast now, please?
I think owners want an occasion, and my fear is that by making this car more civilized and
more usable, you actually make it feel less special more of the time. But now we're on the
road. Let's pretend we've driven a thousand miles to get here. We found the road, so does this thing
still do all the Ferrari things that we want it to do? Well, yes, it does in so many ways.
It feels lower, lighter than the Aston Martin. It's got this lovely low scuttle. It's almost
McLaren mid-engine car like. The view out is fantastic. The steering feels a little slower
to me than the 812, but that does make the car feel really nice and predictable as you turn it
in. It's not jumpy. It's still quicker than the Aston, but it's not hyper responsive,
which fits. It fits this new character.
Fantastic traction. The engine revs and revs and revs,
and it will still slide on demand because we have all the power in the world.
But even in obviously in ESC off mode, even in ESC off mode, you don't have
that manic edge that the 812 had. The engine is still extremely subdued. It sounds great.
The quality of the noise is good, but it's very, very tame in terms of volume,
and it doesn't feel, this is a wild thing to say, it doesn't feel fast in the way that the
Superfast did. That thing, everything about it was alive all the time, and I understand why
someone might say, well, that's not what a GT is about, but what I love about it and what I love
about Ferrari generally is they never seem to look at graphs and position each car in its own
little spot. Up until now, they always just build the wildest, coolest, best handling car they can
from the ingredients they've got, and that's what the 812 had. It was just manic. It was a
supercar, like a really, really sharp, fantastic supercar in a GT car sort of configuration.
Okay, I don't want to keep talking about the old car because that seems rude,
but it tells you that I'm searching a little bit. I am reaching a little bit when I drive this car
to find that absolute manic, wow level performance. This thing handles beautifully.
The steering is quick, not huge amounts of feel, but super accurate. Typical Ferrari,
really strong traction. If you can get it up to 9,000, mega. It's a hell of an engine.
It's hard to keep it up there, and the balance, again, really sweet. Lovely body control,
no understeer, always just on the edge of oversteer or a lot of oversteer if that's what
you want. It is mighty and technically does so many things well. It just doesn't give me the
oh my god moment. It only comes together and delivers the huge thrill that you want from a
Ferrari when you are right up it. I'm driving it fairly quick, and it's great, but how often can
you do this, you know? I can't go around driving like this. I can, because it's not my car or my
tyres, and I'm on this dream road, but the super fast made you feel like I just felt then fully
lit, absolutely squeezing every last drop from yourself and from it, even when you weren't.
It was alive in a way that this car is not, and I don't want to be overly negative because
in so many ways, the engine is superb. The gearbox is fantastic. It knocks the Aston's
gearbox into the middle of next week. It's much better. The brake feel more immediate and better,
although it does a strange sort of, as they get hot, it can almost feel like they're frozen.
The pedal goes dead, but in a lot of ways, and if we're on track doing lap times,
this thing would eat the Aston. I'm absolutely sure of that. I drove DBS Superleggera and A12
back to back more than once on the same road, and there was clear air between the super fast
and the DBS. The A12 was like another planet, and the way they've developed this car leaves
a big old chink of light for Aston to go and stick the nose of the Vanquish into.
So immediately after the Ferrari, there's a bit of an intimidation factor with this car.
Partly, the view out is nowhere near as good, and it does feel bigger, a bit heavier,
but it feels so unbelievably fast, and there's a slightly more brutal character, but having said
that, there's also a real poise and delicacy about this car. It's so quick, and where the
Ferrari, despite the name, slightly hides the V12, I would say Aston have embraced it.
This thing sounds like, how you imagine, like a Pagani Utopia or something.
So much more volume than the Ferrari, and honestly, it feels like more performance as well.
The torque is outrageous. Okay, what else is going on here? Well, the steering,
I find the steering wheel too fat. I don't see why it needs to be quite so
chunky. It doesn't feel as sophisticated as the rest of the car, but these are obviously minor
gripes. Listen to the noise. Yeah, Ferrari have sort of hidden that V12 away. This has got
a really clear V12 ultra-powerful noise, and on the straights, what I love about it,
you can tell that it can only just contain the performance on offer. The car sort of
rear torque steers, if you like, up the road. It twists itself up the road. There's so much
performance, and although initially it can feel a little bigger, not quite as agile,
once you get over that,
I think the handling is really very good.
You can probably tell that the Vanquish is a pretty overwhelming experience,
perhaps not ultimately as pin sharp at the front as the Ferrari,
but still with superb balance and progression.
I'm in Sport Plus mode, got the damper in the middle setting,
and it copes beautifully with this surface. Brake feel is a little less immediate than the Ferrari's.
You can hear it just lighting itself up.
Just down the straights, even straights are called as in this car. What a thing.
Gearbox doesn't have the snap, the immediacy of the Ferrari. In fact, Ferrari does this
weird sort of surge thing, which I don't love on upshifts, but there's no questions.
But the gearbox is pretty good. It's got the eight-speed transaxle,
E-Diff for the first time in one of the V12 DBS top-of-the-range cars, and it's just wild.
It rides better than a Vantage. It feels more luxurious than a DB12, but
it also feels absolutely out of its mind. And I think some of that just pure joy and energy
that I was looking for in the Ferrari has been adopted by Aston Martin with this car.
It's like proper thing. Although there are absolutely dynamic elements where the Ferrari
beats it. Brake, feel and durability. Gearbox, 100%. Body control, absolutely at the optimum.
Yes, I think so. And coping with lots of different inputs all at the same time. So,
if you've got to brake into a corner, get on the power early while you're still turning hard,
the Ferrari just has an ability to overlap all of those dynamic needs that the Aston doesn't
quite match. But it's an absolute riot, this thing. To find out that Ferrari have
taken one of the great experiences and just changed the focus of it. Fine, if that's what
they want to do, I think it loses quite a lot in that process. Aston have gone the other way.
They've realised that excitement, drama, intensity sells. And they've built the most intense,
most insane GT car that you can buy right now. And I'm very happy about it.
I think this is going to feel like a public therapy session because I have had to do a lot
of soul searching today. I came into this test assuming I knew the outcome already.
The Aston would have character and charisma and be really good fun, but ultimately the poise,
that dynamic ability that Ferraris always have, would see it just disappear into the distance.
It's the old story played out over and over again. But it hasn't really worked like that
today. I love driving the Ferrari, the precision, the adjustability, it's fantastic. All the things
I like in a car. But I found myself reaching for that magic moment and it just hasn't quite
materialised. Maybe the shadow cast by the 812 Superfast is just too long, it can't escape from
it. The Vanquish on the other hand, every time I get in it I'm laughing, I'm excited, I'm vaguely
terrified. But what a thing. So despite having fallen in love with Italian roads all over again
today, the Aston Martin beats the Ferrari. I don't think I've ever said that before.