In this video, I tackle the challenge of choosing just 5 bottles of tequila to satisfy all my tequila needs. Inspired by a popular Reddit post about whiskey, I explore different categories of tequila and narrow down my choices to the best of the best.
From a reliable daily sipper to a special occasion showstopper, I share my top picks and explain the unique qualities of each. Expect in-depth comparisons, personal anecdotes, and insights into the world of tequila.
Whether you're a tequila connoisseur or just starting your journey, this video will help you discover some incredible bottles and maybe even inspire you to build your own ultimate tequila collection.
The speaker curates a definitive five-bottle tequila collection based on a Reddit challenge. By focusing on additive-free options, the selection covers every scenario from daily sipping and cocktail mixing to hosting guests and celebrating rare, special occasions.
What if you could only pick five tequila bottles?
Would you be able to satisfy all of your needs with tequila with just five bottles?
I try and attempt that in this video.
I stumbled upon this idea on Reddit.
There's a really popular Reddit post, I think in like the bourbon or whiskey subreddit,
where it was like, you only need five bottles.
And they kind of did a breakdown of the five kinds of bottles that you need.
And everybody was kind of giving their own suggestions.
So I thought this was really fascinating.
So what if we did this for tequila?
So the first category that they had was like a daily drinker.
I hate that phrase.
So I'm going to change it like a go-to drinker, like a nice, easy, like what's your kind of
go-to, what are you going to reach for?
Well, I had to narrow it down between kind of three options.
Basically, I was at a crossroads between Mijenta, Lalo, and Tequila Ocho.
Now, there's not much that separates them in terms of price, really, at least the Blanco.
Mijenta, very floral, very unique flavor.
One of my personal favorites.
You have Tequila Ocho, which is single estate, really renowned, incredible stuff.
Made by master distiller Carlos Camarena.
And you also have Lalo, which is made by the grandson of the original Don Julio,
which I think is doing really awesome stuff.
And between all three of these, I actually don't think you could go wrong.
But as it came down to, if I had to pick one, it would probably be the Tequila Ocho.
I think that Mijenta and Lalo were incredible options for this as well.
But I had to pick one.
So I'm going with the Tequila Ocho because I think that the idea of single estate and
using that as a nice, you know, talking point, and also just a delicious bottle,
I think is a great go-to kind of drink.
There's that great like black pepper kind of spice flavor, good citrus.
It's really well-rounded.
And I think that it just does everything super well.
And it's a nice, great expression of what a really well-made single estate tequila can be.
And that would be my choice for like a go-to sipper.
So the next category that they had was like to impress your guests.
You're trying to show off a little bit, but nothing super expensive.
Nothing too crazy.
And I came down between two options.
We have Recuatro and El Tesoro.
Starting off with El Tesoro.
El Tesoro is also master distilled by Carlos Camarena.
And it is another one of my absolute favorite brands.
Very traditionally made.
Tijuana crush.
Really nicely and incredibly made.
And Recuatro is actually made by Carlos's brother, Felipe.
And it's made at El Pandillo, which is one of my favorite distilleries.
But these are very different.
All the tequila that comes out of El Pandillo have a very particular flavor
because of the types of water that they use.
And if you want to check out this video that I made,
I'm going to link it up here,
talking about what I find fascinating about El Pandillo.
But these two brothers have been in the tequila making industry for generations.
Their family's been in the tequila making industry for generations.
And I think that both of these are incredible,
like to kind of wow your guests for different reasons.
For one, the Recuatro has a very particular flavor that I do think is very unique.
It's very minerally.
It's nice and bright.
It's got this incredible kind of different flavor than a lot of other tequila.
And El Tesoro, in my opinion, is just so well made, well crafted and incredible.
Recuatro, it's not the most expensive
because I think that it ends up being more expensive
because it ends up becoming allocated because they can't make enough.
Whereas El Tesoro is more widely available.
So depending on what my guests are looking for or who they are,
if I want, if they are experienced with tequila, I might serve them the Recuatro.
But if they are not the biggest tequila drinkers,
I think my choice would have to be El Tesoro.
Especially the Reposado here.
I think it's going to give them more of an overview
of what a really well-made aged tequila can be and should be
without any flavors that they may not be accustomed to.
Not that that's a bad thing, but just trying to, you know,
entertain your guests and be like,
hey guys, this is a really incredible Reposado.
This is what an incredible aged tequila should taste like
and why that is a great expression of it.
On the nose, the El Tesoro Repo, incredible spice aroma.
You get some of that oak from the barrel as well,
but the agave is very present.
The barrel is very present, so I think this might be easier
if you're sharing with a guest who's a whiskey drinker.
So there's some of those flavors present there,
but it doesn't shy away from its roots.
That agave is still super present.
Very nice and spice element that you get from a really great well-made tequila.
I think that the El Tesoro Repo would probably be my pick
for like, let's wow our guests today.
Then the next category was like,
the way they phrased it was a little frustrating.
It was like, oh, like using for cocktails
because your guests won't know the difference.
And I hate that because I don't think that a good spirit
being used in a cocktail diminishes it by any means.
I think it actually elevates it.
So I'm going to call this the go-to cocktail pick.
So this is what I would use for a cocktail.
Like you're tasked with, hey, we're going to make some tequila cocktails.
What are you going to do?
I have two options here.
You have Arete and Cimarron.
Both of these are liter bottles for about anywhere between like $20 to $25.
There are very few incredibly well-made additive-free tequilas that are that cheap.
And so these I think are your two best options.
Between the two,
I'm going to go with the one that I use at my restaurant more frequently.
And that would be Cimarron.
And there's a very good reason for it.
I think the Arete is great.
It's got an incredible flavor.
I find that the Cimarron has a very distinct, almost stronger flavor.
And it comes through a little bit more in a cocktail.
So I want it to taste like that tequila.
I want it to be sharp.
I want it to have that spice element a little bit more present in the cocktail.
I think the Cimarron is a much, not that a much better option.
I think it's just the one that I would have to pick between the two.
I think both are amazing.
I've used both in my restaurant very frequently.
And I think that they're both awesome.
If you're going to sip on it, I would actually say
sipping the Arete on its own is better than sipping the Cimarron.
But in a cocktail, they're both going to be incredible.
I just tend to lean more to the Cimarron
because I want that agave tequila flavor to be more present.
Right on the nose, you just get punched with like a little bit of a funky
kind of citrusy aroma.
Super robust.
So much flavor in all of that in like a $22 to $23 bottle.
It's astounding how good this is for the price.
One of my absolute favorites.
It's what I use in my well at my bar.
It's so good.
And this next category was the Friday night tequila,
like one that you just had a long week, just want to unwind.
You want to pop open a very special bottle to
to make yourself feel nice and special and really enjoy it.
And the way that I interpreted it, it was, you know,
it's a it's a little treat for yourself.
It's a bottle that maybe you won't open all the time.
And for that, I have a couple of options for a couple of different reasons.
So I have Fortaleza Repo.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
You guys are probably going to start being,
Oh, of course you would mention Fortaleza.
Well, yeah, I would.
And for a very good reason.
We also have Cascanes.
Either they're number nine or I would actually even say they're number 10,
which is my personal favorite.
They're still strength, but I'm almost running out.
So for the sake of this video, let's just go with the number nine.
And then also the Volans still strength, all for vastly different reasons.
Well, let's go through them one by one and I'll explain why.
And I'll tell you my pick for what would be my Friday night pick.
First off, Volans.
Volans is made at the same place that Recuatro is made.
Mastro is still by Felipe Camarena.
And Volans is one of my favorite tequila brands right now,
specifically because of this.
This is one of my favorite things that they make.
This is their still strength.
And it's got this incredible funky flavor because they actually ferment
and distill with fibers in the production process,
which gives it a really incredible funky flavor.
It's got that natural minerality that the tequilas from El Pandillo are known for.
Really incredible.
I think Fortaleza Repo or even the Blanco, either one is just incredible,
mostly because you can't find it that often.
So it is a bottle to be treasured in a way,
though I personally believe it to be,
you need to just drink the things that you have
because that's what tequila is meant for.
But some people might feel that they wouldn't pop this open
unless it was a special occasion.
So I would probably make my like a pour Fortaleza like a Friday night drink.
And lastly, you have the Cascades number nine for this category.
And I think Cascades ends up being a little bit higher up on the price side.
But I don't think that it's a it's a bad thing.
I think that it's definitely worth what it is.
It's just it's not the cheapest.
So you don't want to maybe, you know, pour it all the time.
Because of that like price difference,
I think that I mean, for some folks,
finding a Fortaleza is going to be as expensive as a Cascades.
So you can kind of make your own judgment call on that.
I can get Fortaleza a little bit cheaper, usually as a bar.
So normally I would pick this, but I can't really go wrong with any of them.
But for the sake of the video,
I want to do a Cascades as my nice Friday night pick.
Man, that's so nice.
It coats your mouth beautifully.
You get an incredible citrus element.
Good spice.
Agave like punch to the face of flavor.
It's just it's so good, man.
It's just yeah, let's let's go with Cascades for this one.
Because Jesus, that is wow.
And the last category is like saving for a special occasion bottle.
It's like you would only break it out because you know it's super limited.
And it's like you love it and you don't want to, you know, pour it out whenever.
Now, that being said, my pick for this.
First of all, the bottle's empty because I drank it all.
But my pick for this would be any Fortaleza Winter Blend.
This is one of very few bottles of the 2024 Winter Blend.
It has my name on it and it's empty.
It's very empty.
A lot of people give Fortaleza hate because you can't, they can't find it.
But genuinely and truthfully, the Winter Blend, I have two bottles at home.
I should have brought them in for this video.
I have a 2022 that's about a third full and a 2023 that has like maybe an ounce in it left.
I got this when I went down there in August for the press trip for the release of this.
I cannot talk to you enough about how incredible I think that this product is every year.
And it's been consistently that way.
Though I will say the 2024 is just that much better in my opinion than the 2022 and 2023.
I love the 2023.
But the 2024 was stupidly good.
Now you have seen, but I'll never be able to find it.
Well, this is the whole point of this.
It's a special occasion bottle that you're going to break out every once in a while.
Now I have this bad habit of just sharing really special bottles with the guests at my bar
because I want to share with people who are going to enjoy it.
So my pick for this would be the Winter Blend 2024.
Anyway, I went to go rummage in my office and I found two more
bottles that I would consider for this category.
The number one, again, it's fully empty, is the El Tesoro 85th Anniversary Edition.
This was by far one of the best tequilas I ever drank.
And then I found this last little bottle of 2023 for the Lays of Winter Blend,
which we're going to drink and talk about.
It'll be my gift to you guys for, well, I guess not really a gift for you.
It'll be a gift for me, but I'll get to actually taste it and talk about it.
So we'll just have a little sippy sip because it's very rare.
It like brings tears to my eyes how good this is.
This one in 2023 was aged in four separate barrels and blended together.
You had American oak, French oak, Hungarian oak,
and some barrels that were used to age Charanda, which is Mexican rum,
which just was, it creates such a beautiful, splendid mixture of flavors.
The 2024, I actually made a,
I'm going to be making a whole video about what this tastes like.
So make sure you're subscribed to check out for that.
But yeah, my choice would probably be a
Port de Lays of Winter Blend for that special occasion bottle,
like really like special occasion bottle.
I said that twice.
Cheers.
And so there you have it.
My five picks for the only five bottles of tequila that I would need
within this fun little game that we played.
But if you want to know more about the 2023 Winter Blend,
I actually did a whole video last year comparing the 2022 and the 2023,
which, you know, might be fun to watch,
even though you might not be able to get your hands on some.
But I do have this other video that you can watch where I talk about
my trip down to visit Port de Lays and whether or not I think they're overrated.
I mean, if you made it to this part of the video, you don't, you know,
you might not think I think so.
So just just go watch that video.