That time Jupiter was a puffball planet

Mysteries of the Universe
550 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video reveals that early Jupiter was a \"puffball planet,\" significantly larger and more magnetically powerful than it is today. By analyzing the orbits of its moons, researchers have reconstructed Jupiter's primordial state, its rapid mass accretion, and its eventual contraction as it cooled to become the gas giant we observe today.
Jupiter is arguably the most important object in the solar system, other than the sun of course,
in influencing the past, present, and future of the system.
This was not only the first planet to form, but is more massive than every other planet in the system combined.
Its orbit captures thousands of Trojan asteroids in its orbit,
its moon system is comparable to the planetary systems of red dwarf stars,
and it's so gravitationally dominant there's about a 1% chance that Jupiter's gravity will eject Mercury from the solar system in about 3 billion years.
You may have also heard theories that Jupiter was on its way to migrating into the inner solar system,
but was stopped by the formation of Saturn or the ejection of the fifth giant or something like that.
This is somewhat outdated today, and more modern models suggest that Jupiter formed roughly where it is today,
and what actually stopped it from spiraling inward was friction with the sun's protoplanetary disk,
and shortly after was locked in a 1-2 resonance with Saturn.
Jupiter likely never came close to entering the asteroid belt, let alone the inner solar system.
Jupiter forming much further out is also unlikely,
because it's inconsistent with the timing of the formation of meteorites with specific compositions.
But this still leaves a lot of questions about Jupiter's formation history.
What was Jupiter's environment like during its formation, and how about its moons,
and what effect did Jupiter have on the formation of the early solar system at large?
One recent paper attempts to answer this using the orbits of Jupiter's present-day environment
to guess at what the Jovian system must have looked like in the past to produce the modern arrangement of moons.
And they found something pretty interesting.
Just a few million years after the formation of the sun, Jupiter was not only pretty much done forming,
but was also much wider in radius than it is today,
with their estimates suggesting the primordial Jupiter was over two times wider than the modern Jupiter.
Not only that, but its magnetic field was also expected to have been over 50 times stronger than it is today,
both of which likely had significant effects on its forming moons that we can still see in their orbits now.
We've seen many hot gas giants that are so close to their stars
that the heat causes their atmospheres to inflate and expand,
creating puffball planets, gas giants of extremely low density.
In this scenario, Jupiter was a puffball planet right after it formed,
and remained so for several million years.
So what caused Jupiter to end up like this, a puffball planet with a very strong magnetic field,
and more importantly, what were its broader effects on the Jovian moons and the rest of the solar system?
Jupiter's four innermost minor moons play a pretty big role in this.
Jupiter is circled by the four large Galilean moons, Io, Europa, Ganymede, and Callisto,
but interior to these worlds, much closer to Jupiter itself, are four much smaller asteroid moons,
Metis, Adrastia, Amalthea, and Thebe.
Even among these moons, there's a wide amount of variety.
For example, Amalthea and Thebe are between ten and a thousand times more massive than Metis and Adrastia.
This suggests they had different formation than the smaller moons.
Specifically, Metis and Adrastia are expected to have formed out of ring material,
created when a larger progenitor object crossed Jupiter's Roche limit and was torn apart.
This means these two moons are significantly younger than Jupiter itself,
and so can be ignored when talking about the early history of the Jovian system.
Amalthea and Thebe, on the other hand, being more massive,
are suggested to have formed further away from Jupiter,
and were flung onto their present-day orbits by the migration of Io,
which spiraled inward and then later began moving outward.
This is where this paper comes in.
The paper and their explanations for their results will be in this video's description,
but essentially, they can guess as to how far away Io was from Jupiter during its formation
to explain the formation of Thebe and Amalthea in terms of Jupiter's radius at the time.
To put it simpler, they find that for Thebe and Amalthea to be where they are today,
Io's original orbit must have been four to five times Jupiter's radius at the time.
If Io's primordial orbit, that being its orbit right before it started moving outward,
was closer than four Jupiter radii,
Amalthea would have been caught on a four-two resonance with the moon
and would have a different orbital inclination than it does today.
If Io's primordial orbit was larger than five Jupiter radii,
Thebe would have been caught in a six-four resonance
and also have a different orbital inclination than it does today.
So, to summarize before we move on.
The Galilean moons, most importantly Io, formed further away from Jupiter than they are today.
Due to friction with Jupiter's moon-forming disk, they began moving inward,
where Io's gravity threw the smaller moons Thebe and Amalthea closer to Jupiter.
Then, once the disks dissipated, the Galilean moons began moving back outward,
and we know that Io must have been about four to five Jupiter radii away from Jupiter at the time,
or else Thebe and Amalthea would have different orbits than they do now.
So, because we know roughly how close Io got to Jupiter before it started moving back out,
and we know Io must have been four to five Jupiter radii away from Jupiter,
we can guess as to what Jupiter's radius actually was at the time.
And this paper comes to the conclusion that during this time,
Jupiter was between 2 and 2.6 times wider than it is now.
The upper limit of 2.6 comes from the fact that anything higher
would make Jupiter larger than Amalthea's orbit, which is obviously not possible,
because in that scenario Amalthea would not exist, which it does.
However, the lower end of that estimate is preferred anyways,
because Thebe's orbit was influenced by more than just Io.
So, Jupiter used to be twice as wide as it is today.
The next question is when this happened.
We can use both the migration of the Galilean moons
and what we know about solar system formation to answer that.
Based on the magnetization of certain meteorites,
it's been estimated that the solar nebula the planets formed out of
was blown away about 3.8 million years after the solar system's formation.
It's expected that the energy required to blast away the solar nebula
would have also been enough energy to blast Jupiter's debris disk away from Jupiter.
This means that the material Jupiter's moons formed out of
also dissipated 3.8 million years after the formation of the solar system.
The Galilean moons began moving outward once the disk dissipated,
so we can use that to say that Jupiter was twice as wide as it is today
3.8 million years after the formation of the first solid material in the solar system.
This makes sense, because when planets form they are very hot,
and this paper suggested that Jupiter had a warm star,
which would help puff out its atmosphere and expand its radius.
They also found how fast Jupiter was accreting new mass.
Based on this radius and the estimated density of the solar nebula before it dissipated,
it's expected that Jupiter was accreting material at a rate of
1.2 to 2.4 Jupiter masses every million years.
Now, given that Jupiter is obviously not more than one Jupiter mass,
this suggests that Jupiter was accreting material at this rate
for only a short amount of time, less than a million years.
Using this, it's also possible to find Jupiter's magnetic field strength at the time.
This is because the Jovian magnetic field itself limited the extent of Jupiter's
circumplanetary disk through a process called truncation.
Using this, it's possible to estimate the strength of Jupiter's magnetic field at the time.
It was found to be about 210 Gauss,
which is stronger than the current magnetic field by a factor of 50.
So, ancient Jupiter right after it formed was an extremely different planet
compared to the one we know today.
Due to high temperatures after its formation, its atmosphere is puffed out,
causing its radius to be twice as wide as it is today.
We also know its magnetic field was around 50 times stronger than it is now,
and that Jupiter was accreting material pretty quickly,
with most of its mass apparently gained in less than a million years,
which itself is partially caused by the stronger magnetic field.
And we can see how this unique formation affected Jupiter's present-day environment,
and that of its moons.
Unfortunately, this paper doesn't get into how the Galilean moons themselves formed,
as it wasn't important for their analysis.
It doesn't matter how Io formed, just that it was there to pull on Amalthea and Thebe.
However, it's likely that Jupiter significantly altered their environments.
Io is the most volcanically active object in the solar system,
but despite releasing tons of volcanic gases,
it doesn't have an atmosphere because it's stripped away by the radiation
coming from Jupiter's magnetic field, which is in part caused by Io itself.
This is also the same reason why Io is so massively irradiated
that if you were to land on it, you'd be dead in a matter of hours, even with shielding.
Just the ancient environment of Io alone was likely really interesting,
with it moving closer to and further away from Jupiter over the course of a few million years,
which is likely to have altered its environment.
Io was also probably more volcanically active at this time,
since it was younger and had more internal heat.
And that's not even mentioning the other three major moons,
or the hypothetical object that was broken apart by Jupiter to form Medicine Adrestia.
And this isn't even mentioning what was happening to the other planets around this time.
It's probably likely that something similar happened to Saturn,
which, if I had to guess, was also probably larger and had a stronger magnetic field
during the very earliest years of its formation.
Unfortunately, however, this paper doesn't say much else about Jupiter's environment,
just a bit more about how the circumplanetary disk was affected by the magnetic field and stuff like that.
It's been estimated that Jupiter's disk must have been truncated
at about four times the planet's radius at the time.
It doesn't say anything about Jupiter's atmospheric composition when it was a puffball or anything like that.
However, we can make some guesses based on other exoplanets we've seen,
such as the four worlds of the HR 8799 system,
a system of at least four super-Jupiter planets that are extremely young and still in the process of forming.
Or the two planets Levantes and Isacopaque,
another two very young gas giants still forming that have been observed by James Webb.
None of this is confirmed and is just my own speculation,
but based on these worlds, it's possible that Jupiter likely had a dusty atmosphere
fed by infalling material from the circumplanetary disk.
The planet Levantes is expected to be red in color due to a dusty atmosphere,
and it's possible that ancient Jupiter may have been similar.
Depending on how hot Jupiter was at the time,
it may have had some interesting cloud compositions as well.
The exoplanet Isacopaque has been observed by James Webb
and found to likely contain clouds made of vaporized enstatite rock.
Again, ancient Jupiter could have, at least in theory, have had an environment similar to this.
However, these same observations also suggest that Isacopaque doesn't have a circumplanetary disk,
which is weird and suggests it and Jupiter may have had different formation histories.
Similar observations by James Webb of the four currently known HR 8799 planets
have found evidence of carbon dioxide, ammonia, acetylene, and methane on the planets,
but each planet has a pretty different composition.
For example, HR 8799b, a 6 Jupiter mass planet 19% larger than Jupiter in radius,
has been found to contain ammonia and carbon dioxide, but has very little methane.
HR 8799e, on the other hand, a 9.6 Jupiter mass planet 13% larger than Jupiter in radius,
has been found to contain methane and acetylene, but no detectable ammonia or carbon dioxide.
My point in saying this is that while we do have a lot of planets
that may be decent analogues for the environment of ancient Jupiter,
they all vary wildly from one another,
and there are still a hundred different environments the primordial Jupiter could have had.
Young gas giants are still a pretty understudied type of world,
and the more we can study examples outside our solar system,
the more we can learn about the early environments of our own gas giants.
Similarly, the more we learn about Jupiter,
the more we can use that knowledge to make better guesses at the environments of these young gas giants.
Isacopaque, which is 7 Jupiter masses, is 44% larger than Jupiter in radius,
showing that other hot planets still in the process of forming
can have their atmospheres puffed out by heat, though less so than Jupiter,
because larger planets will have an easier time pulling that atmosphere back down.
So, while the exact environment of the primordial Jupiter is still pretty unknown,
we now have a pretty good idea of the general characteristics of the world,
based on observations not of Jupiter itself, but its moons,
and what their orbits tell us about their past.
Jupiter used to be twice as wide and a puffball planet less than 4 million years
after the formation of the first solids in the solar system,
and formed pretty quickly and had a powerful magnetic field.
This state obviously didn't last forever,
and as Jupiter cooled and its moons settled down,
the atmosphere contracted and the magnetic field weakened
until we got the planet we have today.
There's still a lot to learn about the very early solar system
and the distant past of our own planets,
and hopefully we can find out more soon.
Thank you for watching.
If you enjoyed, check out my other videos about exoplanets and space exploration.
