supermarketSupermarket champagne vs Veuve Clicquot — a sommelier's blind taste test that shows exactly what a 300% price gap actually pays for. If you've ever stood in front of a supermarket wine shelf wondering whether the £15 bottle is really worse than the £45 one, this video answers it honestly.
Behind every supermarket wine is a producer the label sometimes doesn't want you to see. Some shops hide their winemakers behind fake names, others put them front and centre. Both approaches are marketing — and once you can tell them apart, choosing a bottle in the supermarket stops being guesswork. Anya Gariboldi, a professional sommelier, wine judge and DipWSET graduate, explains how Tesco, Aldi, Waitrose, Lidl and other private label wines actually work — and which 3 categories you can safely buy.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Two bottles of champagne, one cost £45, one cost £15. By the end of this video,
I'm going to taste them both blind and tell you the truth about the gap between them.
But here is the part that should bother you before we even start. There is the real chance
that these two bottles were made by the same family, in the same village, from the same vineyard,
in the same year. Hi, I'm Mani Gariboldi. I'm a professional sommelier,
wine judge, and diploma WSAT graduate. And today, we're cracking open the biggest secret
in the supermarket wine aisle. Who actually makes the wine with the shop's name on it?
It's never the shop. Let's go. First, what is a private label and why does it even exist?
A private label, or own brand wine, is any bottle that carries the supermarket's name
instead of wineries. Tesco's own label, Sainsbury's, Aldi's, Waitrose. The shop did not
make that wine. Somebody else did and agreed to hide. Why would a real winemaker agree to do that?
Money and timing. Picture a serious producer. A good year hits and they grow more grapes than
their own brand can sell. They have a choice. Float the market with their own label and watch
their own price collapse or quietly sell the surplus to a supermarket. Fast for cash and a
different name. They take the cash. The supermarket puts its own label on it and the wine that could
have been a 30-pound bottle sits on the shelf for 12. Both sides win. The winemakers emptied the
tank and got paid. The supermarket got genuinely good wine to sell cheap. The only person who
doesn't know what happened is you. Can you actually catch them? Sometimes, yes, producers hide but the
law forces them to leave a trace. On French wine, there is a small quote on the back label. The
It identifies the town where the wine was bottled. Type it into a search engine and you can find out
who actually bottles wine in that town. Sometimes, the cheap supermarket bottle leads straight back
to a famous house. The label can hide the name but cannot hide the fingerprint. Why do some shops
hide it and some brag? This is the part nobody explains and once you see it, you'll read every
shelf differently. There are two completely different games being played. Game number one,
The Secret Treasure. This is Aldi and Lidl. They invent a fake-sounding brand name. They tell you
nothing about who made it and they leech off you like a clever detective who found a hidden bargain.
The mystery is the marketing. You don't know whose wine it is and that's the whole point.
Game number two, The Curators. This is Waitrose and Mark & Spencer. They do the complete opposite.
Waitrose's blueprint range openly prints the names of the actual winemakers on the label.
M&S builds the whole campaigns around its wine buyers. They are saying trust our taste,
we did the hard work, we picked the best for you. Both are marketing. One sells you the thrill of
the hunt. The other sells you the comfort of being curated. Neither is lying but neither is doing you
a favor out of kindness. It's the positioning. The wine underneath can be excellent in both.
You're just being sold two completely different feelings. That's the whole reason I built the
WineSense method. Both of those games work on you for the exact same reason because the label is
doing the thinking for you. The course is the opposite approach. It teaches you to read any
bottle yourself in any shop and judge what's actually inside the glass. The link is below
if you want it. Now back to the aisle. Is supermarket wine second rate? The big fear
is that the supermarket bottle is the leftover junk and real wine goes into the proper brand.
The honest answer is yes and no. Often, the supermarket bottle genuinely is slightly
simpler wine. The second press, younger wines. It's built to be opened and enjoyed tonight.
It's not the producer's deepest, most complex word but simpler and not bad. And here's why
it's rarely junk. Their reputation. A winemaker who puts faulty wine into the supermarket
contract destroys their relationship with the buyer and their contract is huge money.
They cannot afford to. So where do you lean in? My top three categories. Champagne. Supermarket
label champagne is one of the most reliable bargains in the entire shop. It's still real
champagne made by the traditional method. You are getting the method that matters at a fraction of
the famous name price. New Zealand. Sauvignon Blanc. The Marlboro regions run on a small number
of very large wineries. There is a strong chance that the supermarket bottle and the expensive
branded bottle came out of the same tanks. Rioja Reserva or Gran Reserva. Spanish law is strict
about these words. To be called Reserva, the wine must be aged a set time under controlled rules.
The law does quality control for you. Supermarket Rioja Reserva is almost always a safe,
genuinely good buy. One-hand rule. Never buy the cheapest of the cheap private labels. If the
bottle has no vision whatsoever and it just says wine of France or wine of Italy and it costs you
$5 or pounds, walk away. That's not a hidden gem. That's an industrial blend. Wine from everywhere
but from nowhere mixed in a tank and filtered until it tastes of nothing. There is no winemaker
behind this bottle, just a technician and a machine. So let's taste. Here is a bottle of
Veuve Clicquot, the famous yellow label, around 45 pounds and a supermarket champagne around 15.
This one. Look at them side by side. For a second the supermarket one was designed to remind you
of the famous one. The color, the style of the label. That's not an accident. Who actually makes
that supermarket bottle is a story in itself. I tell it in full in my Aldi video. It's linked.
Today we are not reading labels. We are tasting blind and I would need some help here. Are we ready?
Can I taste this? Okay, I'll just start with glass number one. So on the nose I feel a hint of apple,
citrus peel, also a touch of brioche. Like really classic champagne really. All right,
let's try this one on the palate. It's brewed. Clearly it's not extra dry. You get that bright
acidity, crisp bubbles, lemon, green apple and a clean like biscuity finish. It's fresh and polished
and to be honest with you quite convincing I have to admit. All right, let's try one number two.
It's very similar stylistically. I detect apple, brioche, citrus with a little more depth perhaps
and toastiness underneath. All right, the palate. So on the palate the mousse is a little bit finer.
I have more texture, more length. Everything feels just slightly a bit more layered and precise.
So which one is which? You have to tell me which one is which. I detect by what I've tasted I think
that glass, which one is this? Glass number two. It's just a little bit, it's slightly more complex
than the previous one. Let me, I suspect that glass number two should be vertical and glass
number one. Yes, this is what I think. I think glass number two is vertical. This one is this
and this one is this one. Am I right? Am I? I'm still good at blind tasting. Here's the honest
truth. I'll be transparent. Boeuf Clicquot has never been my favorite champagne and I've stated
that so many times. I've made the whole video about why. It's a competent commercial wine but
it's not the Grand Cru, it's not Krug, it's not that kind of bottle. Tasting them blind without
the window, I could barely tell them apart. Both are fine. Neither is extraordinary. I had to think
hard about which one is which and I do this for a living. The difference in the glass is almost
nothing. The price difference is 300%. The big part is that money never reaches the wine at all.
It pays for the heavy bottle, the cold fall and the name of the label. So the question isn't
which is better, it's what are you actually paying for. If you want a champagne that genuinely moves
you, neither of this is the answer. You go to a grower champagne. But if you want a bottle for
a dinner party and nobody's analyzing it glass by glass, save your money. Nobody will know. That's
the whole game. The supermarket shelf is full of wine wearing disguises, some hiding the makers,
some flaunting them. All of it priced on a story rather than what's in the glass. Once you can see
past the label, you stop paying for the costume. That's exactly what I teach in the Wine Sense
Method. How to read any bottle in any shop and know what you are really buying. If this video
opened your eyes, that's your next step. The link is below. Pay for the wine, not for the label.
I'm Anna Gariboldi. Cheers.