The Arctic is not a barren, frozen wasteland. It's home to some of the most unique ecosystems in the world. More than this: it's home to people. Those people are at the center of the controversy over drilling for oil in the Arctic. The Trump administration is now starting the formal process of selling leases in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil companies, according to the New York Times. The move comes after the Trump administration opened the refuge for oil drilling in August 2020. There are potentially billions of dollars in untapped oil and gas reserves in the Arctic. But, there is value in keeping the region untouched, too. The Arctic provides more than $281 billion per year in fishing, oil, mineral extraction, tourism and climate stabilization services, according to a preliminary assessment done in 2016 by environmental economist Tanya O'Garra, who worked at the Center for Research on Environmental Decisions at Columbia University at the time the research was conducted.
About CNBC: From 'Wall Street' to 'Main Street' to award winning original documentaries and Reality TV series, CNBC has you covered. Experience special sneak peeks of your favorite shows, exclusive video and more.
Oil Versus Climate Change: The Economics Of Drilling In The Arctic
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The Arctic is a region of immense ecological and economic value, currently caught in a conflict between industrial exploitation and environmental preservation. While governments seek oil and gas reserves for energy independence, the region's role in global climate stabilization and the rights of indigenous populations present a critical counter-argument to drilling.
The Arctic is not a barren, frozen wasteland.
In fact, it's seen as quite valuable.
The Trump administration is now selling leases
in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge
to oil and gas companies.
That means these companies can stake a claim
for exploration and maybe drilling
in some of the 19 million acres
of basically untouched wilderness.
The Arctic is home to some of the most unique ecosystems
It's home to polar bears, porcupine caribou.
But more than this, it's home to people
that depend on the land and waters.
And the Arctic economy is formed in part by tourism,
fishing, mineral extraction.
From throughout the world,
adventurers travel to Alaska to strike it rich.
And then, of course, the oil and gas industry,
which has been a cornerstone of not only Alaska's economy,
but of the United States' strategy to energy independence.
Untapped oil reserves and a score of other minerals
vital to modern industry.
But the idea of exploring for oil reserves
and developing more Alaskan territory for drilling,
especially offshore,
strikes at the heart of the controversy.
Sea levels are rising, and so are we!
The Arctic is warming faster
than anywhere else on the planet.
What do we want?
Climate justice!
When do we want it?
Now!
This region essentially provides
for everyone in the whole world.
An estimated $281 billion per year
in food, minerals, oil, tourism, hunting.
And that estimate even includes
the value of the Arctic's unique ecosystems
just for merely existing.
Everyone is impacted by what happens in the Arctic.
Environmental change, sea level rise
from the diminishment of the Greenland ice sheet.
That affects all economies, all countries.
Weather patterns are changing,
increasing in storm severity and droughts.
Everybody.
So in an effort to stave off climate change
to preserve those Arctic ecosystems,
there's a push for energy solutions.
Even the big banks are refusing
to fund new oil drilling operations in the Arctic,
like Goldman Sachs, Wells Fargo, and Citi.
While there's potentially billions of dollars
in untapped oil and gas reserves in the Arctic,
it can be said there's value
in keeping the Arctic untouched, too.
Wells Ecosystems will be giving us more value
than the gross national product,
than all our economic activity put together.
Here's how we attach value, monetary and otherwise,
to something as big and alive as the Arctic.
Putting a monetary value on an entire region
is met with controversy because, of course,
how can we put a price on land for its potential resources
when people live there?
So you can't put a monetary value on nature.
That's commoditizing nature, or that can't be done.
You know, these are intrinsic values and so on.
O'Gara points to a controversial paper from 1994
that valued the world's ecosystem at $33 trillion a year.
And that valuation didn't include the Arctic.
I'm an environmental economist,
and a lot of my work involves trying to make visible
those ecosystem goods and services
that are otherwise unaccounted for by policymakers.
They're provided to us for free by nature,
and yet, because they're not traded in the market,
they often get ignored.
So O'Gara set out to approximate the economic value
of the Arctic's ecosystem services.
She says there's a lack of data on the Arctic,
so her paper in 2016 is a preliminary assessment.
But she ultimately came to this number, $281 billion per year.
That's slightly more than the market cap
of both Exxon and Chevron combined.
It includes items like food, mineral extraction,
oil production, tourism, hunting.
But in addition to those industries we can see
and therefore more easily quantify,
most of that $281 billion valuation
is provided by what O'Gara calls climate stabilization.
The Arctic provides the entire world
with climate stabilization.
And in the absence of that,
we may well see changing growing seasons,
more hurricanes, more droughts,
and more unstable climate with everything that comes with it
and probably the decimation of many species.
Climate stabilization provided by the Arctic
came out to be worth more than $216 billion.
It includes the Arctic's storage of methane and frost.
Methane is a huge contributor to global warming.
If the methane is trapped in the Arctic's ice,
the gas is kept from impacting the ozone layer.
And then there's the ice albedo effect.
This is when the ice and snow reflect the sun's radiation
and that helps keep the Earth cool.
The fight over the Arctic is a lot more nuanced
than just assigning a number
to whatever the region may or may not supply.
There's a lot we don't know about the Arctic.
There are oil reserves that may exist
and they could be offshore,
so like out in the freezing Arctic waters.
That makes it expensive to drill down
and explore for those resources,
not to mention dangerous.
When it comes to the U.S. economic development
in the Arctic,
it is concentrated on the North Slope of Alaska.
That's the most northern part of the state.
It has nearly 89,000 square miles of land
and it's part of the Arctic Circle.
Its population is made up of 80% indigenous people.
White men are coming to the Arctic now
in ever-increasing numbers.
Rosemary Atomarock lives in Nooksit, Alaska,
which is right in the middle of a ton of oil
and natural gas development.
I would see the natural gas flares
while they were 60 miles away.
You can see the reflection off the snow
and into the sky above the clouds
surrounding our community,
surrounding us with lights and activity.
Nooksit is home to fewer than 500 people.
It can be accessed only by air travel.
There's one school.
Hunters riding snowmobiles
with rifles slung over their shoulders
rely on the microwave.
And snowmobiles,
which are called snow machines in Alaska,
are used to get around the village.
Whaling is linked to the immediate needs
of small communities.
Whaling, hunting, and fishing
are still a big part of the cultural identity
and the local economy.
April is called the moon for the beginning of whaling.
Migratory routes of caribou have shifted.
People have to travel farther to harvest.
We'd have to go out more,
come home with empty catches more often
because the changes are not conducive
to why are animals coming to our land and waters?
And community members are increasingly suffering
from respiratory diseases,
and not from COVID-19.
Started seeing changes in our health.
We had people who were having respiratory troubles
and illnesses that were developing.
She's been fighting against industry development
in her community for years.
And she says these companies
don't offer many lucrative job opportunities
for her community.
Even if we do take some of those jobs,
the jobs we get offered from industry
are the stick pickers,
picking up the trash at the development site,
working in the camps to clean up the camps,
or ice road truck driving,
in which we're building a temporary ice road.
Oil development is a huge part
of the North Slope's operating revenue.
In 2006, more than 74% of its income
came from property taxes.
Whose property?
Mostly the oil and gas industry.
We had to allow oil and gas development to happen
to have a seat at the table.
And yet I have worked on this process
for almost 40 years.
So people who really work
at protecting our communities
often have barriers put in place
to prevent them from even entering the door.
The North Slope currently holds
approximately 6.1 billion barrels of oil
that can be extracted.
That could be worth an estimated $561 billion.
But that value depends on wherever oil prices go.
And right now, that's certainly not up.
I worry about these processes
because when my voice is not in these tables,
who's looking out for human health
and the importance of tradition and culture?
Because it's not something my community will leave behind.
The American Arctic is pretty politically polarized.
This administration is going to open up to drilling
and allow it to be destroyed
for an indeterminate amount of oil.
And the controversy over drilling
Why?
is loud.
As tax reform has been long awaited,
so has opening the 1002 area
to limited exploration and production.
The effort to open the Arctic Refuge
has nothing to do with national security,
has nothing to do with gas prices,
or has nothing to do with energy independence.
It has to do with greed, plain and simple.
The Trump administration opened up
the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge for drilling
in August 2020.
Well, they can open it up,
but if nobody wants to drill there,
then it becomes a good point.
It's a symbolic act.
The refuge is a 19 million acre protected wilderness area.
They basically reopened it.
And so this is what I call the pendulum swing policy.
Closed under the previous administration,
reopened, and then it just keeps going.
The 1998 US Geological Survey
estimated that the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge
could hold 10.4 billion barrels
of undiscovered, recoverable oil.
Industry will decide what it wants to do.
And drilling activity in the United States
is close to 100 year low.
Long story short,
besides the actual drilling,
just exploring for possible oil reserves is costly,
time-consuming, and even dangerous.
Not to mention destructive to the environment.
Exploring for oil can take years
and companies need infrastructure.
Add Arctic weather into the equation,
that drives up costs and risks.
So basically...
The math does not work.
And it could be a PR nightmare.
Oil companies do not care about politics,
but they care about PR.
And even if, hypothetically,
the economics in the Arctic were attractive,
which they are not,
that PR reputational risk of going into a place
that will provoke lots of protests.
All these people peacefully out here
trying to keep Shell from drilling in the Arctic.
Lots of environmental advocacy.
That alone would turn some companies off.
First of all,
there are only so many countries that actually have a say
as to what goes on in the Arctic.
There are the players that actually have territory at stake
and that's the United States,
Russia, Canada, Norway, and the Kingdom of Denmark,
which is just Greenland.
Then there are the neighbors,
Iceland, Sweden, and Finland.
All eight of these countries make up the Arctic Council.
And alongside the council are the permanent participants,
which are the indigenous communities that live there.
The Arctic has always been important.
We just forgot about its importance in some ways,
particularly at the end of the Cold War.
Submarines constantly on guard.
The Arctic, just very basically,
has always been essential for U.S. national security.
For the Nautilus, route to the Arctic.
And Alaska was always essential
for America's energy independence.
Since the U.S. purchased Alaska in 1867,
it's been seen as a critical piece
of the U.S. national security strategy.
Military strategists know that the United States
is vulnerable to attack.
That an enemy from across the Pacific
could base on Alaska.
There's billions of dollars in the energy sector.
For example, Russia has spent a lot of time and money
trying to find oil up there.
Russia has a lot of say and a lot of power.
The Arctic for them is about national survival
from a security standpoint,
as well as an economic standpoint.
The Arctic is a big part of Russia's energy industry.
As for the U.S.
I see that the power in the Arctic
that the United States needs to focus on is Russia.
They have legitimate issues and their presence is growing.
It's still unclear whether exploration for oil reserves
in the Arctic will continue
and whether drilling will happen at all.
And the evolving digital landscape
might just be perfect for the Arctic environment.
What I call the digital Arctic.
And this is increasingly,
we're seeing some of the major technology companies
build very large data storage facilities in the North
because it's cool.
You can save energy.
You don't have to have those big coolants.
The Arctic isn't just short in shipping distance.
It shortens information distances.
So if you can shorten the distance,
you'll get that financial information
one centilla faster than anybody else.
That's huge.
So you see the Chinese very interested
in building undersea cables from Finland to China.
We're looking at space-based assets
that again, we have competing GPS systems
and the Russian system and Chinese system.
As for what happens next, only time will tell.
In terms of what will happen, I really don't know.
It depends on public attitudes.
It depends on the outcome of the election.
We need the voices throughout our nation
to rise and protect the public lands that are important
because we share migrations of birds and animals
that come to the Arctic,
that travel to all seven continents.
When they come to us, they come for renewal.
They return to you to grow
and then come back in the new season.
We want to continue to protect our lands and waters
for we are in this together.
Protecting our lands and waters throughout our nation
is important for the health of all of our people.