Check out Bon Charge wellness products (Code SIIM for 15% discount): https://boncharge.com/siimland Timestamps: 00:00 Intro 00:23 Where did the vitamin D RDA come from 01:23 What’s considered normal vitamin D 02:13 Group averages vs individual response to supplementation 02:44 Why most people would need 10x more than 600 IU-s of vitamin D 03:52 Bon Charge sponsorship 04:58 Should you take vitamin D supplement 06:39 Optimal vitamin D levels 08:21 What influences your vitamin D production
P.S. This is not professional medical advice and should not be taken as such. The creator of this video is not held accountable for your health. Consult your doctor first.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video discusses a potential statistical error in the Recommended Dietary Allowance (RDA) for Vitamin D. It argues that the current recommendation of 600 IU may be based on group averages rather than individual needs, potentially leaving millions of people deficient. The core message is to prioritize blood testing over generic guidelines to determine personal supplementation needs.
What if one of the most important vitamin recommendations in America was based on a statistical mistake?
This mistake may have caused millions of people to take far less vitamin D than the recommendation was supposed to guarantee.
For years, most adults were told that 600 IUs of vitamin D per day was enough.
However, it might be that the required number is over 10 times greater, up to 8,900 IUs.
Let me explain.
In 2014, researchers Paul Weigelers and John Paul Eguaru published a paper with a blunt title,
A Statistical Error in the Estimation of the Recommended Dietary Allowance for Vitamin D.
The paper argued that the recommended dose of vitamin D per day was not only too low, but it was statistically misinterpreted.
The 600 IU vitamin D recommended daily allowance was established in the 2011 report by the Institute of Medicine.
They came to the 600 IU RDA by focusing on bone health outcomes, not broader claims about cancer, immunity, or longevity.
They concluded that for vitamin D, an intake of 600 IUs per day for ages 1 to 70 and 800 IUs per day for ages 71 plus
would correspond to a serum vitamin D level of at least 20 nanograms per milliliter,
which they said would meet the needs of at least 97.5% of the population.
The RDA was never supposed to be about the average person.
It was supposed to cover almost everybody.
That's the entire point of the RDA, to make sure that most people would meet their requirements.
Vitamin D levels below 20 nanograms per milliliter or less than 50 nanomoles per liter are considered insufficient,
and they're associated with an increased rate of bone loss.
Vitamin D levels over 20 nanograms per milliliter are considered sufficient.
However, it's been suggested that the insufficiency line should be at 30 nanograms per milliliter or 75 nanomoles per liter.
That would mean that there would be even more people at vitamin D insufficiency than currently accounted for.
The vitamin D intake of 600 IUs would get 97.5% of the people into the 20 nanogram per milliliter threshold.
The Institute of Medicine based that recommendation on 10 supplementation studies,
which together produced 32 study averages.
They plotted those averages against vitamin D intake, created a dose-response curve,
and from that concluded that 600 IUs per day would get 97.5% of individuals above the target level.
But here's where the problem begins.
The authors of the 2014 study claimed that the 2011 study authors looked at group averages,
but not how individuals would respond to supplementation.
And this difference changes a lot.
Because the RDA, as I said, is supposed to cover most people, not the average person.
It's like saying the class average on a test was high, so everyone must have passed.
In reality, some people passed, and some people still failed.
And according to the paper, that's exactly what happened.
So the 2014 study authors went back and looked at the data.
This time they looked at how did supplementation affect individuals individually.
Their analysis suggested that if you take 600 IUs per day,
97.5% of individuals would be expected to get above 26.8 nanomoles per liter,
not above 50 nanomoles per liter, which is what the recommendation was assumed to achieve.
That's half of the recommended vitamin D level to be considered not deficient.
This means that 97.5% of people taking only 600 IUs of vitamin D would be severely deficient,
unless they get a lot of sun exposure.
The authors estimated that to get 97.5% of individuals above 50 nanomoles per liter,
they needed to take up to 8,900 IUs per day of vitamin D.
Now, of course, this doesn't mean that you should immediately start taking 9,000 IUs of vitamin D every day.
The authors clearly warned against that.
Whether or not you need vitamin D supplementation depends on your blood vitamin D levels.
And you don't need to take vitamin D.
You can realistically have optimal blood vitamin D levels without supplementation.
But what it means is that the official gap between the RDA and the dose predicted to cover 97.5% of individuals
is a lot higher than people expected.
It's not 600 IUs. It's a lot higher.
I want to take a quick break to tell you about the Bonchart Infrared Sonar Blankets,
my go-to way of getting 20-minute sonar sessions on the go,
without needing to spend an hour to warm up a regular sonar.
Taking the sonar is, in my opinion, one of the best things for your overall health and heart function.
Studies show that taking the sonar regularly is associated with 63% lower risk of sudden cardiac death,
63% reduced heart disease mortality, 46% lower risk of hypertension, and 40% reduced all-cause mortality.
This is mediated by an increase in body temperature and increased heart rate
that mimic a cardiovascular workout, while at the same time improving arterial stiffness,
endothelial function, blood flow, immune system function, blood pressure, and metabolic health.
It doesn't matter if it's a traditional wooden sonar, an infrared sonar, an infrared sonar blanket,
or anything else that elevates your body temperature above what's normal.
Bonchart Infrared Sonar Blankets have the advantage of shining far-infrared light
that can penetrate deeper into your tissues than regular sonars can.
It warms up in 2 minutes to the optimal temperature of 70°C, and it's low in EMF.
You can get a 15% discount by heading over to www.bonchart.com/.seemlund
and use the code SEEM for a 15% discount.
So what does this mean about vitamin D supplementation?
About 18.5% of adults in the USA take vitamin D supplements,
and if the RDA recommends only 600 IUs, a lot of them might be severely underdosing.
That's roughly 1 in 5 US adults.
The 600 dose would greatly underdose the required effects for bone health and other health benefits.
Of course, you don't get all the health benefits from the vitamin D supplement that you get from the sunlight,
but it's better to take the supplement than be deficient in vitamin D.
The paper points to two Canadian studies where vitamin D deficiency
remained common even among people who were supplementing.
In one study, despite vitamin D supplementation of 400 IUs or more,
with a total intake of about 632 IUs, 10% of participants still had levels below 15 mL per liter.
In another study, 15% of supplement users were still below that level.
On page 2, the figure based on study averages makes the 600 IU recommendation look to be enough,
but on page 3, once the analysis shifts towards individual variability
using the lower tail estimates from the studies, the whole picture changes.
The corrected lower line sits dramatically lower,
which shows why a dose that looks sufficient on average may still leave many individuals under the target.
Unfortunately, the vitamin D RDA hasn't been updated.
It's still at 600 IUs.
But this doesn't mean that you should take 9000 IUs of vitamin D.
That's because the vitamin D dose isn't the same for everyone.
People need different amounts of vitamin D,
and they respond differently to sunlight exposure and to supplementation.
Things like your body size, your body fat percentage, your age, your skin pigmentation,
they all influence your vitamin D status.
So the most important lesson is to actually measure your vitamin D
and to see if you are deficient or with optimal levels.
So what's a good vitamin D level to have?
We've established that vitamin D levels below 20 ng per mL or less than 15 nm per liter are considered insufficient.
Vitamin D levels over 20 ng per mL are sufficient,
but it's likely that the insufficiency line should be at 30 ng per mL or 75 nm per liter.
This would mean that the requirement for vitamin D would be even higher than 8900,
probably up to 10,000 IUs per day.
When it comes to the range for lowest all-cause mortality,
then this 2017 meta-analysis saw that compared to vitamin D levels of 30-40 ng per mL or 75-99 nm per liter,
those with vitamin D levels of 16-20 or 14-49 nm had a 15% higher risk of all-cause mortality
and those with a vitamin D of below 12 ng per mL or less than 30 nm per liter saw a 67% higher risk.
Similar results have been found with cardiovascular disease mortality.
A 2017 meta-analysis of prospective studies found that serum vitamin D levels
were inversely associated with cardiovascular disease events and mortality.
The lowest risk was at 30-40 ng per mL or 75-99 nm per liter,
which is the same range as the one in the previous study on all-cause mortality.
Vitamin D levels above 40 ng per mL or over 100 nm per liter
are associated with a higher risk of cardiovascular disease mortality and myocardial infarction.
It's very hard to reach those levels with regular sunlight exposure,
unless you're also supplementing with vitamin D.
So it looks like the vitamin D range of 30-40 ng per mL or 75-99 nm per liter
is the most optimal for the lowest all-cause mortality risk and cardiovascular disease risk.
Yes, you can achieve it with supplementation, but you don't need to supplement if you get it from sunlight.
Things that affect how much vitamin D you make from the sun include
your skin pigmentation, with darker skins needing more time in the sun,
body fat percentage, being ovoid makes you store vitamin D in the fat and less in the blood,
time of the day with morning and evening sun having much lower UV index,
so it takes more time to get enough vitamin D,
the season, summer providing more vitamin D and winter less,
and the UV index, higher UV index equals higher vitamin D, but also more skin damage.
So there is a fine balance between excess skin aging from UV damage and making vitamin D.
You definitely don't need to roast out in the sun for many hours to make enough vitamin D.
When supplementing vitamin D, you should also take vitamin K2-MK7
to prevent calcification from excess vitamin D,
especially when taking larger doses of thousands of IUs of vitamin D.
Overall, this study doesn't prove that 8900 IUs is a dose for everyone,
but it does suggest that the official recommendation of 600 IUs
may underestimate how much most people would actually need.
So the real takeaway isn't that everyone should megadose vitamin D or spend a lot of time in the sun,
it means that you should measure your vitamin D status to know what is your blood vitamin D status
and then adjust your lifestyle and supplementation accordingly.
Vitamin D as a supplement is controversial, it has some evidence, but it's not a panacea.
Check out my video where I rank a hundred supplements from worst to best next.