Additional information about PTAC: Physician-Focused Payment Model Technical Advisory Committee (PTAC) | ASPE (hhs.gov) -- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) | http://www.hhs.gov | HHS Privacy Policy | http://www.hhs.gov/Privacy.html
PTAC Members: Co-Chairs Terry (Lee) L. Mills, Jr., MD, MMM Soujanya (Chinni) R. Pulluru, MD Members Henish Bhansali, MD, FACP Lindsay K. Botsford, MD, MBA Jay S. Feldstein, DO Lauran Hardin, MSN, FAAN Lawrence R. Kosinski, MD, MBA Joshua M. Liao, MD, Msc Walter Lin, MBA Krishna Ramachandran, MBA, MS David C. Tyson, MA -- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) | http://www.hhs.gov | HHS Privacy Policy | http://www.hhs.gov/Privacy.
---
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)
http://www.hhs.gov HHS Privacy Policy
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome back. I'm Dr. Lee Mills, one of the co-chairs of PTAC. As you may know, PTAC will be issuing a
report to the Secretary of HHS that will describe our key findings from this public meeting on
targeting improvements in patient safety through alternative payment models.
We now have time for the committee to reflect on what we've heard in today's sessions and from
the PCDT. We'll hear more from other experts tomorrow in an additional session, but we want
to take time to gather our thoughts before adjourning for the day. So, committee members,
please refer to the potential topics for deliberation document and your notes. To
indicate a comment, of course, please flip up your name card and for Larry online, I'm watching you
so I'll know when you have a comment. And let's try to cover the room thoroughly and get comments
out for our staff. So, who's first? All right, Krishna.
That was a great day. It was fantastic to hear the perspectives and many sort of connected
thoughts as well. Like each speaker, of course, brought their own worldviews and perspectives,
but there was a thread that sort of kept coming through, which I appreciated.
One, it was helpful. I think Anish's example, even towards the end of
modeling it like the health ecosystem, I think was a great takeaway for us there. How do we
sort of leverage patient safety within the constructs of other collaborations,
recent collaborations, so recent in mind. I liked Susanna's point around using the waivers to sort
of even create a model or a structure. Loved some of the comments that came about using AI,
responsible AI, in order to further the patient safety, whether it's to increase the reporting
as well as to help the follow-up. Some of these model features could incorporate that.
And then some of the bright spots that stood out, particularly Dr. David Classen's work on
that evolution of the trigger tool to automate it, I think are good learnings that we can even
incorporate into these models as well. So anyways, I thought that was the connective tissue for me.
A lot of good ideas for us to formulate into a model that Abe and team can incorporate
with a focus on patient safety. Thank you, Krishna. David?
Yeah, I think one of the things that I sort of picked up on was this sort of,
let's call it the to model or not to model tension today. I think we heard from some
folks that came down on the side of, we certainly need to adopt a safety in all policies mentality
and sort of bake in patient safety in all of these models in some form or fashion.
And then I think in the last session, we got more of a, no, patient safety is distinct and should
not be sort of lumped in with quality. It would be treated as something sort of entirely separate
and worthy of its own study and measurement. And so I think for us as a group in terms of
making recommendations, I think navigating that tension is going to be one of the key
challenges coming away from this of, do we want to bake in additional patient safety metrics
and sort of approaches throughout a litany of CMS programs? Or do we want to recommend that
needs to be a patient safety model that comes out of this?
Yeah, I agree. This was a great day. A lot of substantive and informative presentations and
discussions. It really reinforced to me that patient safety needs to be embedded into APMs
as a core objective, or as David just said, maybe perhaps be the primary focus of a model,
although I'm not quite sure still how that might work. But regardless though, I'm convinced
even more so that patient safety should not be treated as a secondary afterthought in
value-based care models. We heard repeatedly that safety is broader than avoiding obvious
adverse events, but it also includes errors of omission, diagnostic errors, communication
failures, and unsafe transitions of care across settings. A lot of these things we've talked
about before in prior PTAC meetings. Although thinking about all the unintentional harm
inflicted upon vulnerable patients by well-meaning clinicians can be downright depressing,
we heard many important potential solutions and frameworks from our SMEs that give me optimism.
Examples include Sue Sheridan's reminder that patients and families often see safety risks
the system can miss, and that PROMs and PREMs can serve as important safety signals to providers.
To Jason Mitchell's description of Geisinger's work to become a higher liability organization
that enables them to provide a warranty for heart surgeries. To Hal Gandhi's presentation on how AI
has real promise to improve safety by decreasing cognitive burden, identify risk earlier, and make
safety problems more visible before they become harm events by measuring the thickness of the ice
before the patient falls through it. From a payment model perspective, my big takeaway is that
value-based care broadly and advanced payment models specifically have a unique opportunity
to make these risks visible and actionable. At the same time, I think one of the most important
cautions we heard today from Patrick Romano is that payment models by themselves do not have a
strong track record of improving patient safety, but rather this depends on heavily, often depends
heavily on professionalism, continuous quality improvement, a culture of safety, and a true
learning organization. Several speakers also emphasize that a strong safety culture depends
on transparency, psychological safety, encouraging clinicians and organizations to report harm events,
near misses, unsafe conditions without fear of blame. So I think in kind of as I think about
tomorrow and our discussion on payment mechanisms, a key question is not simply how to attach
financial consequences to patient safety, but how to design payment models that reinforce rather
than undermine the intrinsic motivations and safety culture we need. Approaches like
no savings without safety or shared savings withholds and earnbacks may have promise,
but I think in light of some of the discussions we had this afternoon, they need to be designed
carefully so they reward robust reporting, learning, corrective action, and measurable improvement
and align with what matters most to patients, families, and purchasers
without encouraging underreporting, risk avoidance, or stinting on care.
Outstanding. Thank you all.
Good comments by my peers already. I think one reflection I've had in thinking through this is
we often talk about in payment models how the total cost of care is the gold standard or
looking at outcomes and not just process measures, but some of what I heard today actually reflects
that maybe it's the process measures and systems that are more important than the outcomes
to drive that culture ultimately as opposed to just penalizing for bad outcomes.
Another comment that struck me was along the line of putting too much money on the line
can sometimes incentivize the wrong things and encourage gaming and as we think about how some
of this fits in payment models, I worry some of the same things could come true when it's
thought of as a payment model as opposed to a different approach. So inherently linking payment
to it or a payment model that might try to demonstrate it might inherently subvert the
objectives we're trying to solve for. I think I was struck by the comment just around payment
models haven't done a great job in the past so we need to be thoughtful of it, yet in every
presentation it is clear that funding or payment is needed. I don't know if it's a payment model
or if it's a different type of investment in tools and systems that support that culture of safety,
things like the AI, EHR investment, and human factors designs that could move the needle more
than payment models. Thank you, Lindsay. Larry? Well I've got my top 10 just like everybody else
I think but you know I don't want to be replicative of what everybody said about structural measures
and you know we heard errors of omission. We actually said it in Cheney's presentation are
probably more significant than those of commission. I heard clearly that we need to
move out of the hospital environment and the ambulatory environment so that we can get more
of a longitudinal view. We also heard that this is going to be difficult to build statistics from
since the numbers fall very rapidly but the longitudinal here is really what's going to be
important. An interesting comment from one of the presenters was that the results of without a
longitudinal we're not going to find some of these errors because the results of errors sometimes
don't show up until quite a bit later. I like the comments around the fact that we need to address
the provider experience. I think we need to stop using the term error and try to build some type
of a positive improving a safety quotient something like that because as long as we're
punitive and negative on what we're finding we're going to kill the culture because we
I think our biggest challenge here is to instill a culture of change. You know we could take
take some learning from the from the aerospace industry I mean the airlines I mean my god
nobody gets nobody is more scrutinized than the airline industry and they've accepted it but we
we're seeing it all around us you know I mentioned police having you know cameras and now we even
have electronic baseball umpires and you know if technology is affecting all of us all around
and I was encouraged to hear from the presenters today that the technology is there remote
and sustain the change that we need it's there. We've got to build the culture to accept it
and inject AI into it integrating it in but seriously monitoring it as we integrate it to
make sure it's not prone to its errors and maybe we need to learn from some of these other industries
and be incremental in our deployment of this so we don't get the pushback that we would if we're
too intrusive. We need the providers need tools they don't need more regulation they need things
that help their their their not complete their work every day. I like Chopra's suggestion this
could be something that could you know be the structure of our letter to of our report to the
secretary that we need to bring the EHR vendors together but we also need to bring together those
that are going to implement those EHRs and those that are going to pay for those EHRs
in order to to build a solution that we can incrementally deploy
and build this culture of change. It was a great session.
At the risk of being somewhat repetitive I'll try to go fast but I summarize the day for myself and
in a structure that I thought about the first being it's vertical and the first being data
and infrastructure and Anish spoke to needing to standardize it make it easier for people to access
and and not making and and have CMS really drive that right and and have it be an
interoperable data layer this comes up all the time just as important for safety. The second
was really in EHR and being more provider and patient centric versus just being a tool that
that adds more burden because having increased documentation burden also leads to safety risk
there's a cognitive burden there and I think that responsibility needs to
be a part of whatever we design. The third is when Suzanne really spoke about collaboration
and how they're designing structures under her watch of coordination care coordination
and collaboration as a part of some of the work that she's doing at CMS. Fourth is really thinking
about how does the tactical culture of the provider group so Dejal brought up leadership
Michelle brought up training I think we didn't speak about the fact that
we need to have an incentive and structure around people being trained in safety.
I loved Jason and how he brought up the fact that I love his thought around you know hey don't
punish the providers let's talk about shared savings let's just not have them take a pay cut
because that's what this looks like when you when you really think about mandatory measures.
When we speak to measurement you know I thought Clayson hit it out of the ballpark with the fact
that part of the problem is we are not measuring what needs to be measured and the current measures
we seem to be improving but in aggregate we're not improving and maybe the problem why we're
not improving is that we have the wrong we're not measuring what we need to and it's only a
percentage the PSI and Terry brought up systems engineering and I think you know every system
how do we I mean we as a committee need to really think about how we incentivize
that kind of tactical on the ground FTE and how does that become a part of what we
create an incentive structure we have quality officers all over the country now how many people
have safety officers and so the last and I would say kind of the most important thing in my mind
that that came out of all this is that the patient needs to be a big part of the reporting structure
and you know Prescani does this really well and back when I was at DuPage we looked at Prescani
reports and it's just patients if you listen hard enough will tell you what the near misses are
and there's not a systematized mechanism right now in our infrastructure to pick up on that
measure it and react to it and have accountability for it and I think that that's that's important
so let's stop here okay great comments and review I've tried to pick out a few items
that haven't yet been picked up some of them have
first to David's prior comment about is it is safety you know part of mandatory every model
or is it a unique model and I think my response at the end of the day is it's it's a yes and
question not an either or question that we ought to bake safety you know measurement and cinema
concepts across the board into everything that CMS and CMMI do but there may be a place in a
space especially on a pilot for a new new approaches for a specific patient safety model
and so that that has some merit I really love the the parts about adding PROM and PRIMs to
to be expected to be a standard part of the data set when you're doing any type
of experiencing measuring or or quality data reporting and I think that makes good sense
you know we all are doing whatever your vendor is press press Danny or any other we're all doing
patient experience monitoring all the time and yet we're not using some of those standardized
questions that can get get some of those domains and that would be valuable
I'm still in cognitive dissonance about this idea that patient safety is not quality and I get it
from a pure academic discipline they have different ramifications and yet at the same
time if you show me a patient safety problem I'll show you a low value low quality care issue
and so they really are the same I think the hook maybe is for the most practicing
clinicians who spend a whole lot of time thinking about improving clinical quality
but never think of that in the same vein as a overt safety issue if you if you didn't get
you know those last 10 patients to have their cancer screening you hurt somebody just as surely
as if you mopped and didn't put out a sign and they fell and hit their head right so I think
maybe that duality is is more useful with clinicians and then with the wider audience
we heard some about mechanisms that Lindsay touched on that that you know shared savings
may be a vehicle there may be some need for for initial investment to increase process
and capability performance that made sense in the second second panel we heard a lot about
that it's really important that we have to make it not cheaper to take the penalty
than it is to implement the safety program and so again that's a great systems theory
you've got to make it hard to do the wrong thing and easy to do the right thing and if right now
it's just too easy for a CFO to say I'll take the penalty and not build the systems we've got to
change that incentive structure but that then led me to a 5,000 foot level we've had this conversation
multiple times that really we spend a lot of time talking about models and metrics and measurement
and incentives in our minds all thinking about making the pitch to practicing clinicians to do
these and actually sometimes the pitch is really to the employment CEOs and CFOs that are running
big integrated health systems and employing physicians across the country right so in a sense
that this safety issue is as most safety issues come up in integrated health delivery systems now
they often just disappear into risk management and never see the light of day and so it makes
me think that we need the you know the chief councils and the compliance officers and the
risk safety community to be part of the conversation to solve this that they've
got to have a different culture of how we take this on and all right emphasized a powerful point
and then lastly okay and lastly what we heard loud and clear this afternoon which which is
kind of a first in in six years in the PTAC is that it's not a technology issue it's not an
information issue it's not a regulatory framework policy or legal space issue it's just a willpower
issue all the preconditions we need to do something really really special already exist it's just a
matter of lining up the dots build the system and get it released and that that's an exciting place
not a funding issue okay other final comments or thoughts okay well at this time i want to
thank everybody for participating today on both our our wonderful session experts my p-tech
colleagues and all those who joined us in the audience today both in person and online thank
you for that we'll be back again tomorrow morning at 9 a.m eastern time where we'll be joined by
four incredible experts who will share their perspectives during another expert session on
payment mechanisms and financial incentives to encourage patient safety and alternative payment
mechanisms there will be an opportunity for public comments related to the meeting topic tomorrow
morning at approximately 10 50 eastern time before the meeting concludes and i believe at this time
we have four public commenters signed up look forward to hearing their comments
we hope you will join us then thank you and this meeting is adjourned for the day
produced by the u.s department of health and human services