This Is the Army (1943) is a patriotic musical inspired by the real-life wartime stage production created by Irving Berlin. Featuring songs, comedy, and spectacular performances, the film celebrates the courage, unity, and optimism that lifted the American spirit during World War II.
Starring George Murphy, Joan Leslie, and featuring Irving Berlin himself, the movie combines memorable music with heartfelt storytelling. Rather than focusing on the battlefield, This Is the Army highlights the people behind the uniforms and the role that music and entertainment played in supporting those who served.
This video from \"Real Thoughts on Cinema\" analyzes the 1943 patriotic musical *This is the Army*. The discussion covers the film's unique structure, its role as a financial contributor to the war effort, and its deep connection to the music of Irving Berlin, while treating the movie as a historical time capsule of the World War I and II eras.
["The Star-Spangled Banner"]
While the storm clouds gather far across the sea,
Let us swear allegiance to a land that's free.
Let us all be grateful for a land so fair,
As we raise our voices in a solemn prayer.
God bless America,
Land that I love.
Stand beside her and guide her
Through the night with a light from above.
From the mountains to the prairies
To the oceans white with foam.
God bless America,
My home, sweet home.
God bless America,
My home, sweet home.
Sergeant?
Oh, yes, Private Jones?
I... well, I was just...
Don't stammer all day, young woman.
If you have something to say, out with it.
I'm just not sure about my number.
Which one?
All of them?
What's wrong?
I just feel so silly dressed as a man.
You're a soldier, aren't you?
Well, I'm a member of the Red Cross,
but when I signed up,
I didn't know it was going to get me drafted.
Well, you haven't exactly been drafted.
It's part of the show.
But why couldn't I play one of the girls' parts?
Now, look here, Jones.
We have a job to do.
And you know, this is an all-girls show,
so we need some of you girls
to play the part of enlisted men.
Now, does that make sense?
I guess so.
And after all,
you have to do whatever you're assigned,
because...
I know.
This is the Army.
I'm Tiffany Brannon.
I'm Rebecca Brannon.
This is Real Thoughts on Cinema.
Welcome to our Independence Day special.
There's nothing that brings people together
like a common enemy
and a shared common goal.
This is one reason why movies made about
and during World War II
are some of the most inspiring patriotic films ever made.
When thinking of patriotic movies
from the golden era of Hollywood,
probably the most obvious choices would be
Yankee Doodle Dandy,
or one of countless classic combat films,
or perhaps a movie by Frank Capra.
One patriotic musical tribute to the American spirit
that is largely forgotten today
is perfect for this semi-sequicentennial
because it is a tribute to undying patriotism.
This movie is
This is the Army from 1943.
In what is essentially a film version
of a big USO show,
the story follows a group of men
drafted into World War I
who, led by dancer Jerry Jones,
put on a musical soldier show,
Yip Yip Yap Henk.
The night of their first performance,
they are shipped off to France
and sadly Jerry suffers a career-ending injury
while in combat.
Over 20 years later,
with the outbreak of World War II,
many of the men's sons
are now drafted into World War II
and, at the request of their former commanding officer,
the old-timers get together
to put on another show,
This is the Army,
this time starring their sons.
One of the most important behind-the-scenes people
is Jerry's son, Johnny Jones,
who, unlike his father and countless other soldiers,
refuses to marry his girl
before going off to combat
because he thinks it would be unfair to her.
This movie was a Warner Brothers film.
It was produced by Jack L. Warner
and Hal B. Wallace.
It was directed by Michael Curtiz
and it starred
George Murphy,
Ronald Reagan
and Joan Leslie.
Now, if you're familiar with Warner Brothers
around this time at all,
you'll recognize a lot of these names.
The team of Jack Warner,
Hal B. Wallace and Michael Curtiz
is probably best known for producing Casablanca
around the same year.
But I think it's almost like a reunion
of many of the main performers
in Yankee Doodle Dandy.
That's true.
Because that came out the year before
and it was a really successful musical.
One of the first musicals
Warner Brothers had done in a while.
And it was a big hit.
And that movie also starred
Rosemary DeCamp in a mother role,
Joan Leslie as the young sweetheart,
as well as some incidental characters.
And you see the usual Warner Brothers suspects,
people like Alan Hale, George Tobias.
But interestingly,
I feel like there are a lot of actors
who were kind of young
and just starting out in this
that you might know from later things,
even from television in the 50s and 60s.
That's true.
It's sort of like a game
of like name that actor.
It's like, wait, that's...
And most of them,
I don't even know their names.
So they're just like people
I've seen in small parts later on.
And then they just pop up
maybe even only for a minute or two.
Now, there are so many statistics
you could say about this movie
that make it interesting.
The main thing is that this movie was made
not just to make money,
but to profit the war effort.
Very much like the shows featured in it.
Yes.
And I think it's really interesting
and inspiring that Warner Brothers
is often considered like the most greedy studio
because of some of the comfort methods
of the brothers themselves.
Yet during the war,
they were very patriotic
and they made two of their biggest films,
this one and The Hollywood Canteen,
they donated many of the earnings
to the war effort.
Like in this film,
the salaries of the screenwriters,
the producers and the director
were all donated to the Army Relief Fund,
as were the proceeds from this film,
which ended up being
the top earning film of the year.
Was it not also the highest earning musical
in Hollywood history up to this point?
Yes, it was.
And it wouldn't be out-earned
until over 10 years later,
another Irving Berlin musical,
White Christmas.
And when adjusted for inflation,
it's still ranked as like
the 40th most successful film ever
at the box office,
which is pretty good.
And what's even more surprising
is it's not really a well-known film.
And it's not really like anything else.
It's true.
I guess you could say
it's a bit like Hollywood Canteen.
But that is very much
one of those stories
that's about this place
and the different kind of
intersecting stories within it.
Well, this one, there is a story,
but it's really almost like
entirely this variety show.
That's why I say it's like a USO show,
but on film,
and I know it was shown
to the armed forces.
Yes.
And so the musical numbers
make up the body of the film.
There are performances of...
Sort of in the middle.
Right.
First of Yip, Yip, Yap, Hank,
and then of This is the Army,
with then the action scenes in between.
And the way that it just passes over these,
over 20 years,
between World War I and World War II,
it's kind of startling
when you watch it.
It is kind of startling,
but it really shows how
a certain generation,
I guess you could say
the lost generation,
experienced the bulk of both
World War I and World War II.
First fighting in the first world war,
which was supposed to be
the war to end all wars.
Yes.
And then just 20 years later,
having to send their own sons
off to that war.
It's kind of a,
I want to say,
almost a touchy subject
that wasn't,
or hasn't been explored that often,
this idea of World War I,
and then everyone was sort of like,
this is the end of this kind of warfare,
and then how soon World War II
sort of started,
at least in Europe.
Well, many people have said
World War II was just World War I.2.
It was the same.
The problems that were solved
with World War I
really weren't solved,
and the seeds were immediately present
in Germany to eventually
cause the next problem.
So the interesting thing is
that this movie manages
to have some combat scenes,
wartime death, loss,
as well as being very funny at times,
very heartwarming,
lots of musical numbers,
many different styles.
Very romantic.
You can see why
it was a high earning picture.
It could be appealing
to a lot of different people.
It was the first Warner Brothers film
to be made in three-strip Technicolor,
which is impressive
because they had been perfecting
Technicolor for over five years,
their first mainstream Technicolor film
being Robin Hood,
The Adventures of Robin Hood,
also directed by Michael Curtiz
back in 1938.
But like I said,
Warner Brothers didn't really
do musicals as much by this point.
They had done their three big,
flashy pre-code musicals in 1933,
but then they got into doing action,
historical swashbuckling.
Yes.
They'd swayed away from that.
I can see how this is more like
the modern, if you will,
not modern,
but more of the later look of color
that you saw in the 40s and 50s,
as opposed to,
there's a very distinct look
to those late 30s Warner Color movies,
which I love.
But it is interesting seeing
how this one has a little bit more
of that 40s look,
so that must be the three-strip.
Let's think about the actors.
It's really interesting
because there really are
two leading men in this film.
First, in the World War I section,
you have Jerry Jones,
played by George Murphy.
Not a household name anymore.
He was kind of,
toward the end of his film career
at this point,
as early as some of Shirley Temple's
first movies,
he danced and sang with her
as her father.
And then he was in several movies
at MGM with Eleanor Powell.
Interestingly, George Murphy
was not the first choice for this part.
I believe Fred Astaire was considered.
Yes.
And that, of course,
is such a well-known name still,
as one of the great Hollywood dancers.
And George Murphy
was a great Hollywood musical man,
sort of in the style
of a vaudeville performer,
I would say,
which is very much
what he's playing in this film.
Wouldn't you say?
Definitely.
And he's perfect for that part.
It's funny that he's kind of
just been forgotten.
Yeah.
But he was a great actor,
great dancer, good singer.
And then in the second part
of the film,
Ronald Reagan,
in one of his very early
film appearances as a leading man,
plays his son.
And to me,
that is perfect casting.
They both were very Irish,
very Americana,
and they both ended up
being important politicians
and presidents
of the Screen Actors Guild.
Little known fact
that George Murphy
was a California senator.
And then Ronald Reagan
became the California governor
and eventually president.
He tap-danced his way
into politics.
But they look a lot alike,
despite the fact that
George Murphy's a lot shorter.
But the facial structure,
their voices,
I totally can believe
that that's his son.
No, he's not actually
old enough to be
Ronald Reagan's father,
but he is a good deal older, right?
Yes.
They're making him look young
at the beginning,
and very convincingly.
And then making him look older.
Yeah.
There are those two
main leading men,
but then you have a lot
of great supporting actors.
You've got Rosemary de Camp
as the wife and then mother,
and then Joan Leslie
as the young leading lady
who doesn't appear
in many scenes.
No, Rosemary de Camp
is definitely
a more important character.
It's nice that she gets
to be young,
at least for a little while,
because she was playing mothers
for most of her career.
Of course, in Yankee Doodle Dandy
she was so much younger
than James Cagney
and played his mother.
I guess they just looked at her
and went,
this is a mother.
She's very warm and motherly.
I think the heart of this film
is the musical score.
It features 19 songs
all by Irving Berlin.
And a lot of them
are well-known,
and some of them
you will never have heard before.
You'll be like,
Irving Berlin wrote this?
Yeah.
And it's fascinating
because it's not just
this made-up story.
Irving Berlin
put on these two soldier shows.
That's right.
WWI and WWII.
So it's almost a biopic
of Irving Berlin
only they changed the names.
It really is largely based
on the Broadway musical
of the same name
which Irving Berlin
produced in 1942.
But it is,
like you said,
it's almost a biopic
of Irving Berlin
because he was a soldier
in WWI
who put on the show
Yip-Yip-Yap-Hank
and he wrote
many of the songs in that
which then were debuted.
And then,
it's kind of a
funny little cameo,
he then appears
in the soldier show
later on singing
Oh How I Hate to Get Up
in the Morning
which he wrote
for Yip-Yip-Yap-Hank.
So was
This is the Army
not actually a soldier show
that was a Broadway show?
That was a Broadway show.
Okay, so the WWI musical
was a real one
and then This is the Army
they made it a soldier show
but it was actually
a Broadway musical.
That's interesting.
And then they made that
into the very successful movie
and he was quite involved
with the production.
You'll definitely recognize
some of the songs
like
This is the Army
the title song.
I don't know
if this is a familiar song
to most people
but I Left My Heart
at the Stage Door Canteen.
If you listen to 40s radio
you'll have heard this song.
a popular one
that people recorded.
Mandy,
which is very famously
in White Christmas
is featured
quite prominently.
And that came
from Yip-Yip-Yap-Hank
originally.
And it's interesting
to see how the music
is woven throughout.
You hear some of the songs
in the beginning
when they're first
putting on the show.
You see them put on
that first show
then there's some story
then some rehearsal
then a good chunk
of that main show
then back to the story
and then they go back
to the show.
I remember pausing it
when it seemed like
we were getting
near the end of the story
like, how are there
47 more minutes
to this movie?
A lot of music.
Yeah, but it's around
two hours long
and I say it's
very entertaining.
There are some interesting
sort of novelty acts
and it's unusually epic
for a musical
because of how much
time and history
it covers.
You've got acrobats
a funny magician
a fellow who does impressions
and then you've got
That's right.
I appreciate how
for the most part
the costumes are
quite historically accurate.
You have a strong sense
of World War I
with the first part
of the story
versus World War II.
I think it's because
the passage of time
and the two different eras
are so important
they really needed
to highlight that visually.
And you see that
not only in the
soldier uniforms
but in the women's costumes.
My costume is inspired
by the outfit
worn by Ethel
the night she
sees Jerry
in Yip Yip Ya Pink.
It is a
light chiffon blouse
with sheer sleeves
a long black skirt
rose accents
and a notable
large necklace.
My outfit is inspired
by a costume
which we see
worn by Joan Leslie's
character
Eileen Dipple.
It's in the scene
when Johnny Jones
comes into
her father's
music store
and asks her out.
It's a black suit
with a pink
ruffled blouse
a cute little
black hat
and her
engagement ring.
There are some
moments in this film
which might
strike you
and might strike
modern viewers
as a little odd
if they're not
familiar with
the customs of the time.
I would say
more than moments,
honestly.
Okay, a few numbers.
Most notably
the Mandy sequence.
It's a minstrel number
and it's performed
in blackface.
And as a result
this number
is often deleted
from television
viewings of this film.
Right.
It's easily removed.
But I think
it's important
to understand
the context
in which
this was done.
When Irving Berlin
wrote this number
again back in 1918
minstrel shows
were very popular.
In vaudeville, right?
In vaudeville.
On the circuit.
And they
were popular
back in the 19th century
both before
and after
the end of slavery.
Drawing from
the unique
musical styles
which the
African-Americans
had developed.
Bringing their
own musical styles
from Africa
and blending it
with southern themes.
And it wasn't
really accepted yet
for black people
to be performers
so this was
the white performers
way of sort of
paying tribute
to that culture, right?
That's right.
And by this time
the 1940s
there were many
black performers
and there were
some excellent
singers and dancers
in the show
who do some
great numbers.
This is their own
Harlem themed number
which is kind of
interesting
that now
this minstrel
number is
frowned upon
so that can
easily be cut
but at the time
they had to worry
about southern
censor boards
would probably
cut the scene
that actually has
black performers in it
hence why
they didn't
actually have them
in the Mandy number
because the style
of that is to be
a minstrel show
which is just very
different than
the Harlem style
which was the
black jazz musician's
own style.
Yeah.
Now some might
consider this
racial appropriation
but I think
it should be called
racial appreciation
because it's
sort of a
loving tribute
to their style
but it is interesting
to note how
this wasn't
like 50 years
before people
would start
to be offended
just 11 years later
by the time
White Christmas
was made
the Mandy number
is no longer
done in blackface
even though it's
still minstrel
they're all
just like black
themselves
all the white
performers
because by the
mid 50s
it was already
considered taboo
to do minstrel
I'd say through
World War 2
was about the
end of the time
it was acceptable
after that
for instance
the military
began to be
desegregated
and then
it was less
acceptable to do
such things
but I think
it's important to
look at it from
the context of
Warner Brothers
they were always
for the underdog
they were always
for showing
underappreciated
or underrepresented
groups
and the fact
that they showed
not only the
minstrel
but the actual
black performers
as well as
the black
boxer
Joe Lewis
in featured roles
and consider
the fact that
there are these
black performers
in the same
regiment if you will
with these white
performers to put
on the show
even though
they in actual
combat wouldn't
have been together
because they had
a separate regiment
but in this show
they all come together
to put on this
group effort
so I think
rather than saying
this is a sign of
bigotry
consider just
how much
segregation was
still part of many
parts of our
country at this
time and how
Warner Brothers
was in a way
trying to do
something positive
instead of
they weren't doing
it to enforce
those stereotypes
or to do
something negative
just try to take
it in the spirit
in which it's
meant
yes anytime
you're looking at
pretty much
anything from
the past
you have to
take it in
the context
of the time
yeah
just like if
somebody from
then time traveled
to now
they'd be like
what's going on
because there's a
context for our
time as well
so I think that's
something very
important to take
into account
going in pretty
much any classic
film
yeah you'll see
there's different
slang
different
clothes
this being very
much a product
of two times
but the world war
one and then
world war two
it's such a
product of its
era it's like a
little time capsule
a look into the
window of 1943
and I think that's
not only entertaining
but it's very
educational to see
the other thing
that might strike
modern viewers
not necessarily as
odd but just
differently than it
did at the time
is the fact that
this is an all-male
show
300 soldiers
that's right
but they do
many numbers
that require girls
so they have
men dressed like
women
in a very
comical
funny way
it's not akin
to the drag
shows of today
it's in a much
more
innocent
family friendly
kind of way
and often times
they purposely
cast the
ugliest
most manly
men
with particularly
horrible wigs
and outlandish
makeup
they're not really
trying to make
them look like
women
they just look
like kind of
ugly guys
who are wearing
dresses because
they have to
because this is
an all-soldier
show and they
clearly are kind
of embarrassing
you can see
them smoking
their cigars
it was done
because they
couldn't have
women in the
show
not for the
reasons that
pride shows
are done now
or anything
like that
so I think
families
if they're
viewing this
try not to
think of it
like the way
you think of
a drag show
now because
that's not
really the
context
we of course
talked about how
this features
Irving Berlin songs
that you might
recognize and
Irving Berlin songs
you probably never
heard but there's
one in here that
if you're an
American I'm sure
you've heard this
song and it's
fascinating that
while this movie
wasn't its
introduction this
was the first
time it was
featured in a
film is that
right?
that's right
this movie
probably its
most famous
moment is the
performance of
God Bless
America
Irving Berlin's
beloved patriotic
you might be
surprised that
Irving Berlin wrote
that because I
kind of was
yeah and I
love the fact
that this movie
exactly recounts
the history of
that song
we see that
he's first
writing it
back in
1917-18
for Yip Yip
Yap Hank
there was someone
playing he's like
no no not that
I've scrapped it
which is true
Irving Berlin
wrote it
for that show
but then felt like
it killed the
pacing of the
show so he put
it in the trunk
and he didn't do
anything with it
for 20 years
but then in
1938 on the
20th anniversary
of the armistice
Kate Smith
the beloved
radio singer
debuted it on
the radio and
it was a huge
hit so then she
recorded it
she kept singing
and sort of
became her
calling card
and then in
this movie we
see her singing
it in a radio
broadcast that's
supposed to be the
20th anniversary
of the armistice
and you see
George Murphy
there proudly
saying like oh
I wrote this
song 20 years
ago and then
the jokers
they say oh
we're presenting
a new song
it's a new
song I wrote
that 20 years
ago and cut it
it's a very
long rendition
of the song
it's four
minutes long
with a choir
and the orchestra
and then during
the song they
cut around to
show all the
different members
of that original
Yip Yip
Yap Henk and
now how they're
older and they
have their sons
and daughters
and how the war
the new war is
brewing and it's
really interesting
and it's a
beautiful transition
as well as just
a beautiful moment
and this song
made both Kate
Smith and Irving
Berlin famous
not that he
wasn't already
famous but it
was an important
part of each
one of their
legacies and she
continued to sing
it for decades
and it just was
her top song
but this is
really the best
example of her
singing it on
film in her
heyday you see
that strong
impressive voice
and the passion
with which she
sang it and
how this is
really just a
call for peace
he thought it
was important to
have this call
for peace in
1938 as the
war was brewing
he was concerned
about the
persecution of
Jews as he
was a Jewish
American and
as part of the
whole patriotic
nature of this
movie it's very
appropriate with
this song he
Berlin donated
all the proceeds
of this song
to the Boy Scouts
and Girl Scouts
of America
and he set up
a trust for it
and that continues
to profit them
to this day
so it's
the movie is
worth watching
for that moment
alone and you
can find just
that scene on
YouTube but it
really it's even
more meaningful in
the context of
the whole film
because you see
these characters
and it's really
special to see
how they've
aged but they
still have that
patriotism and
just to imagine
how that must
have really
touched Americans
at the time
as something
very real so
it's just a
beautiful moment
in this film
now for
whatever reason
Warner Brothers
left the copyright
on this film
laps decades
ago
I feel like
Warner is a
little bit sloppy
with their copyright
sometimes which is
funny because they
have the Warner
archive collection
and they own
like all of
MGM's movies
but they let
this one lapse
so it's now
in the public
domain but as
a result you
can find it
for free on
YouTube it's
on a lot of
DVDs that
aren't as high
of quality you
can also stream
it for free on
Amazon Prime
Video so that's
a good thing
you can enjoy
this patriotism
why do you
think this movie
is a good
celebration for
our 250th
anniversary of
the Declaration
of Independence
I think
because it
not only celebrates
the spirit of
America but it
really is a
tribute to how
much we've had
to fight for it
it's not just
something that
comes free
to have freedom
and our liberties
that so many
men fought and
a lot of them
died and then
this is showing
sort of a lighter
side of that
yes of course
we see the combat
and how they
gave their lives
but these men
are performing
and some of them
are kind of
embarrassed about
it they're not
they're like we
want to go and
fight do a man's
job and we're
here you know
wearing makeup
but just how
there's this other
side of the war
effort and to
raise money and
so how much
had to be
sacrificed and
and also knowing
the behind the
scenes of that
this donated
so much money
to the armed
forces and was
also shown
soldiers around
you can really
think about how
inspiring this
must have been
for the men
in combat areas
to see yes
and it's
interesting that
in the credits
all the members
of the cast
and crew who
were in the
armed forces
are credited
with their
military titles
so that is just
part of how
it's really
they're trying
to show how
it's a soldier
show as well
as the show
in the movie
is a soldier
show and
there aren't
movies made
during the
revolutionary war
which we can
watch today
there aren't
even many
classic films
about the
revolutionary war
but we can
remember these
these wars
that happened
sometimes during
the lifetimes of
people who are
still alive today
our parents
grandparents
great-grandparents
who survived
these wars
and became
stronger as a
result and the
reminder that
these were
things for which
we should fight
and this movie
reminds us to
continue working
fighting and
praying for
the peace and
welfare of our
nation
if you enjoyed
this conversation
about a wonderful
patriotic film
be sure to check
out all our
other episodes
every week we
talk about a
new classic film
to help you start
your journey
into the golden
era of Hollywood
thank you for
watching
goodbye
and happy
4th of July