Reckoning With Harris' Silence On Gaza | Ta-Nehisi Coates
Live-streamed on June 26, 2026.
Ta-Nehisi Coates, author and journalist, joins the program for a conversation about his piece in Vanity Fair: “Did Kamala Harris’ Silence on Gaza Cost Her the White House?”
#kamalaharris #Politicians
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTa-Nehisi Coates examines the tension between the Black freedom tradition and American imperialism. He argues that U.S. foreign policy is a consistent history of plunder and empire, creating a paradox for Black leaders like Kamala Harris, who operate within a system that champions domestic democracy while inflicting systemic violence on populations abroad, specifically in Gaza.
Sam Seder, Emma Vigeland on the Majority Report. It is a pleasure to welcome to the program Ta-Nehisi
Coates, author, journalist of multiple books, including graphic novels, which I've actually
gotten my son one is into this, and also a contributing editor of Vanity Fair, Sterling
Brown, endowed chair in the English department at Howard University, and we're here to discuss,
at least in part, his piece, Did Kamala Harris Silence on Gaza? Kasser, the White House and
Vanity Fair. Ta-Nehisi, welcome to the program. Well, thanks for having me, Sam and Emma.
Good to see you. Let's, well, let's just start. What is your opinion? Just, I mean, on a,
before we get into actually the breaking down this question,
do we have a sense as to whether she lost over Gaza? I have a story to tell about that.
So, just the short answer is I do not. Like, I could not definitively tell you that. And I think
for different reasons on both sides, there are people who would like to tell you that. Maybe
they have a better sense of it than, than I do. The story I have to tell is that this,
the original headline, if you go back and look at this story, if somebody can do it through,
you know, the Wayback Machine, that was not the headline. The headline was something, I can't
remember what it was, but it was probably something more akin to what the story actually talks about.
And God, this is a horrible sign of our times. It was not getting read.
And so we had to, like, figure out on our side, and I was intimately a part of this, like, look,
we just spent all this time doing this research, doing all this, this, this reading and everything.
How do we get this thing? Like, how do we get people into this, you know, much more
complicated conversation that we want to have, that I want to have, actually, about American
empire, about Palestine, about Gaza, how that actually fits into, you know, American history,
and what happens when that has a collision with, you know, the Black freedom tradition in this
country that in fact made Kamala Harris possible in the first place. And I don't know what it says
about our times that we had to boil it down to this very, you know, fundamental, but hot question
that finally got people to read. So what I'm trying to say is, not only do I not have an answer,
even in writing the piece, I wasn't, I was only kind of interested in the question. I was
interested in something else. Well, what I love about the piece, I mean, there's so much to love
here, but one of the major themes is about adding empire to the list of adversaries to
Black people gaining power politically in this country. And at the very least, updating it to
make sure that that's included to reflect the history here. There's one great quote of yours,
I have it here on page 11, just saying, Gaza is not a betrayal of American democratic tradition,
but an expression of an American imperial tradition. Can you expand on that? Because I
also think it ties into how you interwove Fannie Lou Hamer's radicalism into the piece and contrasting
how that was kind of distorted by the DNC, and then embraced in a different way by the
uncommitted movement. Yeah, you know, thanks for that question. I mean, the first thing I have to
say is that a broader critique or the notion that the Black struggle is not just about, you know,
Black people's right to follow other immigrant groups and become white, you know, to integrate,
you know, the power. That's a long, longstanding critique that, you know, it's very hard to not
be aware of that. You know, everybody knows the famous James Baldwin quote about, you know,
integrating a burning house. I have to be honest with you, until probably I went over to Palestine
in 2023, and then all of the reading and all the conversation that spun out of that, I could not
have told you that in detail what that meant, you know. So, okay, did I know that obviously, you
know, the, you know, the United States of America was built on the theft of land, the genocide of
the indigenous people of the country? Yes, yes, I knew that. Did I understand that that was
immediately followed by, you know, the overthrow of, you know, the Queen of Hawaii? Yeah, I kind
of knew that. Did I understand, you know, about the war in the Philippines after that and Teddy
Roosevelt and imperialism and Cuba and the Dominican Republic? Yeah, kind of, a little bit.
What I did not understand at all was the extent to which the 20th century was not, you know,
the cessation of this imperial impulse, but in fact was the continuation of it. That Eisenhower
could not go a year without trying to overthrow, you know, the leadership of some country somewhere.
Sometimes democracy, sometimes not. Democracy was completely irrelevant to that. That John F.
Kennedy comes into office and before he was in office, you know, he went around the world and
all of this stuff against imperialism, got into office and went right at it,
you know, and was so profligate with it that in fact, you know, when he was killed,
you know, Malcolm X got in all this trouble for saying chickens had come home to roost,
but that was exactly what Bobby Kennedy thought. That was what Lyndon Johnson thought,
that Lyndon Johnson himself was no different, you know, that he followed that up, that obviously
Nixon was no different. And so when you start seeing it, you know, to that level, what you
see is this is actually a tradition that extends back to the founding of the country. And I think
what makes it hard is two things. The first thing is it is so contrary to how most Americans think
of their country and the image that America has propagated throughout the world. And in fact,
that when black people, you know, who have, you know, maintained integration as a huge part of
their struggle, see reaching, you know, the apex of power as a black president, the notion that we
would now then inherit that tradition and how that collides, you know, with our own, you know,
desires and impulses that have, you know, long been part of our struggle. It's tough.
You know, when I was in the part of your piece where you are comparing that era of
Kennedy and Johnson and Truman for that matter, but the gains that black people made, particularly
obviously in the 60s, it occurs to me too that like the impulse at that time, I mean, American
imperial impulse, the motivation or the justification maybe changes through our history.
In that era, it was very much driven by an anti-communism, which I'm also quite convinced
the gains of black people during that era were also through that lens of anti-communism as
we were involved in the Cold War with the Soviet Union. It's almost like that was part of the same
project on some level. Yeah, you know, but one of the really, and I'm glad you asked that question
because there was no room to get into this in the piece, but one of the really chilling things
is the extent to which, like, communism was often just an excuse. For instance, when Mosaddegh was
not a communist, you know, and that was the excuse they gave for overthrowing him. But the real
reason was they wanted access to, you know, the oil that, you know, he was threatening to
nationalize or had nationalize. Our Benz in Guatemala, I mean, he's not like a puppet,
you know, of the Soviet Union, but they use, you know, communism as this excuse. And so,
you know, look, had it been communism, that would have been wrong enough.
But so many of these governments were not, I mean, what would it, Lumumba was, you know,
wasn't a communist or wasn't yet. Certainly he was, you know, making alliances or looking to
make alliances with the Soviet Union. But so much of this effort was directed at, you know,
governments and states that, you know, you look at it and it's like, oh, you guys are just using
that, you know, as an excuse, you know. And I guess, you know, this is the point I would just
like to say that, you know, you know, the books that really influenced me on this, The Jakarta
Method, Steve McKenzie book, The Brothers, and what you see in that work is that, you know,
communism is just an excuse to take ---- from people, to be honest.
Corporations taking that. But I mean, to me, to be fair, I'm not convinced that they felt it was
communist for countries to nationalize their resources or to keep their resources for their
own people. That was their perception of what communism was. It was antithetical to capitalism,
which is in and of itself has a sort of imperialistic quality. I mean, it's
the shark has to keep moving or it dies type of situation.
Yeah. Just to expand on that, I'm curious about your thoughts on this. You know, when we're
talking about, say, you know, the enfranchisement of black people and the right to vote and those
gains happening in the 60s and the notion of democracy and what that means both internally
in the imperial core. We could also talk about Israel calling itself a democracy and yet
ruling over an entire population with impunity and giving them no political rights. It's almost
a mirror image of how the United States empire interacts with the world via imperialism,
where, OK, yes, within the imperial core, within the privileged state, there is some semblance of
democratic representation. But in the Jim Crow South, of course, black people were excluded
from that in this country. And then internationally, we make all of these decisions as an
empire that impact millions and millions of lives. We've killed millions and millions of people
for the American project. And they have no say in that.
Yeah. Yeah. I'm sorry, Emma, can you just clarify that question a little bit for me?
Sure. Just the comparison between, say, like American democracy being democratic for people
within it, Israeli democracy being democratic for people within it. But the sheer power of
the decisions that come from said democracy impacting people outside of those borders in
really deadly, destructive ways and how that shows, you know, what political rights within
these, say, kind of imperial cores means for the rest of the world.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, exactly. And I just I think one of the great problems with that,
and I haven't spent enough time in Israel proper to understand whether it is true,
but certainly within America, it's just like, look, I was raised in a pretty dissident family.
You know, again, I was not, you know, completely new to this to these arguments. But the extent of
it is really, really hard, like to understand, like, look, in the black community, Johnson is
seen as like one of the good presidents, you know, and to understand that, like, at the same time,
he's, you know, contemplating and signing the Voting Rights Act. You know, he's engineering
the overthrow, you know, of the government in Indonesia that is going to lead to a million
deaths and God knows how many people, you know, in prison that many of the people that you hold up,
you know, as being part of your very liberating struggle will then in turn do great harm,
you know, to other people around the world. I mean, it breaks the brain,
you know, because then it's like, OK, so what am I actually trying to do here?
Like, what is my struggle? Because in these communities, I mean, people really,
really are suffering. This is happening at the very same time, you know, that people are being
lynched, that your leaders are being shot down, that you are suffering, you know, segregation,
which in and of itself is its own system of plunder. So, like, what is my place in this?
And probably the most sympathetic reading, you know, I can give to, you know, if not to Kamala
Harris, but certainly, you know, the movement that supported her among Black people is it's like,
how are we supposed to think about this? Like, who are we supposed to be,
you know, inside this? And I wrote that piece to really to challenge people on that particular
point. I was also struck in the piece, getting back to that a little bit. There was a quote
by Tiffany Cross, a journalist and author who was part of an early movement to get Biden to commit
to naming a Black woman as the vice presidential nominee. And the quote is, I would think,
I would hope anyway, that a Black woman is someone who's going to say the uncomfortable thing
in the, I would trust that a Black woman could not see tens of thousands of children being
murdered and not be struck by that, not be moved by that. Whether you're a mother or not, I trust
we experienced that, we saw that firsthand of violence in America, and we've had to tap into
our humanity in a certain way. I mean, the piece is, in many ways, about that sort of paradox of
Black people have to now sort of like empower, buy into the same, I guess, the contemporary
version of what was happening in this country years back, or some iteration of it. But are we,
like, is that a problem? I mean, with our politics on some level? I mean, I see this with Jews,
right? Like, I was taught, much of my education, I'm at an age where, you know,
much of my Jewish education was founded on the Holocaust. I had my Hebrew school teachers,
a couple of them, you know, had tattoos on their arms. I mean, that was, you know,
we were 30 years out from the Holocaust when I was 10, or whatever it was. And the lesson
that I understood was that, like, Jews would never do what they're doing in Israel. And
I've been proven wrong. I mean, and to a certain extent, it's why I think, like,
many Jews turned a blind eye to what was going on there for so many years, because it was just
not comprehensible. And on some level, like, maybe the problem is holding on to these notions
that an identity, and even the cultural stuff that's built into that identity,
ends up dictating in these moments. Yeah.
Yeah. So I want to separate two things. You know, I think the one thing you mentioned is the notion
that because you go through an experience, because you're oppressed, you are necessarily
inured from the impulse to oppress other people. That is nonsense. You know what I mean? Like,
there's just, you know, it's not just Jews, it's not just Black folks. I mean, we just have plenty
of experience of, you know, immigrant group after immigrant group, you say, coming from Europe over
here and actually, you know, duplicating oppression, even as they flee from, and throughout
the world. I mean, that just is a consistent thing of humanity. The one part I want to hold
on to, and this is what Tiffany was really speaking to, because, I mean, she was actually
speaking to somebody who was disappointed in Kamala, you know, not as somebody who, you know,
was endorsing, you know, what Kamala's, you know, silence and her unwillingness, you know,
to have a, you know, a Palestinian speaker. She was actually speaking of a disappointment.
The notion is that it should teach you something. And I do hold to that. I do hold to that. Because,
like, I do think that it's important to ask of people who have been oppressed, who have been,
you know, terrorized themselves, who have been excluded and marginalized themselves,
that they learn something from that. And I actually think that is contrary to the expectation,
because I think it's contrary to the expectation that they won't, like, that they will have some
automatic understanding of it and thus won't do it themselves just because they went through it.
I think the expectation that there should be some degree of knowledge, some degree of compassion,
some degree of understanding, I think it's a good thing. I mean, one of the things I say to
the back of the piece is, look, despite everything we've heard and everything we've read,
and despite, you know, the division between, you know, certain camps of Black activists and
certain camps of Palestinian activists, man, if you look at the polling, I mean, the most skeptical
group of people of Israel's actions in Gaza were, in fact, Black people. The first, you know,
cosponsor of the ceasefire, you know, who works with Rashida Tlaib is a Black woman. It's Cori
Bush. And the first group, a majority, I think it was like half of the group of people who
ultimately signed on to that were Black. Yemi Church, which, you know, is not known for its
radicalism, you know, comes out, you know, against it. A number of Black pastors come out, you know,
against it. So this is a very complicated thing, you know, that's going on. And I've seen it even
in the reaction to my piece. I think it was, you know, very much in that piece. There were Black
women in that piece who, you know, will support Kamala to the hill. And there are Black women in
that piece who were deeply, deeply disappointed, you know, in how she handled Gaza. And so, you
know, I feel like as somebody who roots himself in the Black freedom tradition, like, I have a
responsibility to make sure that this experience does not become a badge for us to go and do
things to other people or support the doing of things to other people. Yeah. And it's also when
you... Does that make sense? Does that make sense? Yes. It does. It does. But I guess, I guess...
Yeah, please go ahead. I think it's an interesting question. Well, I mean, I think, like,
there's, there's a difference between a moral expectation and a political expectation,
right? Like, you know, I mean, there was nothing in Harris's history that would indicate a
particular sensitivity to a whole host of questions that one would, on a sort of like
moral or ethical sense, like, say, you know, maybe there should be more sensitivity simply
because of the tradition and what your ancestors have gone through. And so, it was simply a
function of a profile as opposed to someone who has actually engaged with... In a tradition.
In that tradition. And that's where I start getting into the political.
I disagree with that. Like, look, I mean, this is the thing I say at the back of the piece.
I mean, she's very clear in her biography about, like, how she grew up and the values she grew up
on. She talks about her, you know, her parents being involved in the protest tradition. She was
born in 1964 in the Bay Area, which is, you know, a hotbed of political activism and radicalism.
She's very clear in her book about, you know, who she was raised on, about seeing people like
Amiri Baraka, about seeing people like Fannie Lou Hamer and how that influenced her. She,
herself, roots herself. Now, you can say in her career, like...
Well, that's what I'm talking about. Yeah, I mean, she may self-proclaim, but, you know,
she was a prosecutor.
I don't have a complete breakdown on her career. But I guess what I want to say is
I don't really want to... I am deeply uncomfortable condemning or writing off people
who looked at her, saw themselves in her, and also said, we expect you to see some measure
of our struggle and your humanity in other people. Now, maybe they were ultimately wrong,
you know, in that, but I guess I'm a little uncomfortable, you know, condemning that.
Well, it's also, I think, you know, when we're having a systemic conversation about, you know,
you have a quote fairly... or not a quote, you write early on in your piece about a Black
presidency as a contradiction. It owes its power to a movement against racist state violence at
home, but seeks an office which has always practiced racist state violence abroad. And I
think, you know, Harris was not a transformational political figure in terms of a vision in that way.
And the circumstances in which she was thrust into the nomination did not give her the ability
to pivot in that way. And I don't necessarily think ideologically she had that kind of politics,
but it's perhaps more of a way to indict the system of empire than it is to, I don't know,
basically indict assumptions made about her from voters that have been, and Black voters in the
Democratic Party in particular, have been told time and time again, election cycle after election
cycle, that you have to vote Democrat as a harm reduction measure. The problem is that we've
gotten to a point where there's no credibility on that. Or less credibility.
Yeah, no, no. And I was, like, one of the things I really was trying to do was to
some degree take the focus off of her and think about this, like, the idea of a Black presidency
period and to a large extent about the presidency. And, you know, Sam, I think the question you're
kind of getting at is probably one that I have been thinking about since I came back from Palestine.
You know what I'm saying? Like, the extent to which these groups and this history actually
matters when you're talking about, you know, actual power. And, you know, Emma, I guess at
the end, you know, I'm still trying to figure this out myself, you know. And I don't have a
firm answer here. But I guess the question I am asking myself, which goes beyond the scope of
that piece, what is a Black presidency actually worth? Like, what are we trying to do here? And
maybe larger than that, to what extent, you know, should we be organizing our politics
around individuals as presidents? Now, presidents have a lot of power. I'm not, you know, saying
the presidency period, but individuals, you know, as presidents. You know, there was nothing,
to your point, Sam, there was nothing, if you look at the biography of Abraham Lincoln,
that would indicate the kind of impact he would ultimately have on Black life in this country.
You know, he was a pretty middle of the road, you know, and really kind of remained one until,
like, the last two years of his life, really, you know, as you get deeper into the war.
What I think is that we maybe give more attention to the character of people than we should and
don't pay attention to maybe the history and the context that's happening around them. You know,
ultimately may, you know, shape them, you know, more than, like, who, like, how great they are,
you know, necessarily as a human being or, you know, how courageous they are themselves.
Yeah. I mean, it's about, I think, having a collectivist worldview as well, which I think,
you know, perhaps at one point, maybe we'll talk about New York. We're having some of,
I think, people's minds are changing about what Zoran Mamdani describes as the warmth
of collectivism versus the rugged individualism that sometimes, I think,
sets people, figureheads like Kamala Harris up to be. I mean, frankly, the way that Biden
sidelined her and also at the beginning, I would say, undercut her by explicitly tokenizing her
to a degree didn't help her in many ways. And just to stay on your piece for one more second,
because I really appreciated this part of it as well. When you were contextualizing
black women's trauma in this country, and you were describing enslavement as a system of rape,
and you quoted this historian, Paula, Paula, she alone could birth give birth to a slave.
Blacks constituted a permanent labor force and metaphor that were perpetuated through the black
woman's womb, just this idea that black women in particular bore this burden in America,
as they could produce more slaves. Right. And just to compare it to right now,
you see some of the atrocity propaganda and how Israelis present themselves as victims of
these scary Muslims, rabid Palestinians that are coming after their women to attack them.
And there's this kind of self victimization as well, where, you know, specifically if people
of color show humanity towards Palestinians, you'll have Zionists treat these calls for
liberation as like attacks as bigotry against the oppressor. And I'm just wondering if you've
noticed some of those similarities about the atrocity propaganda about Palestinians,
and how in many ways, it looks like these were clipped from the Jim Crow South to justify
lynchings. Yeah, yeah, I have. I have I have, I definitely have. And you know, my way of dealing
with that is, there's right or wrong, there's right and wrong in the world. You could take
the worst, you know, most heinous thing, or the most heinous system, you know, that you've seen,
maybe slavery itself and nothing, you know, about that makes me think that that should be done to
the people that perpetrated it. Some things are just absolutely in themselves, you know,
completely wrong. And I think having a politic that is more based on peoples as opposed to ethnic
affinities is extremely, extremely, extremely, extremely important, you know, and maybe even in
this question that we keep, you know, that we've been circling around in this interview. You know,
I mean, I've said this before, but to me, look, you know, what I saw over there, either it's right
or wrong, you know, and there is nothing that I could see any Palestinian doing that would make
what I saw on the West Bank, in Hebron, in the settlements themselves, which I which I actually
went into nothing, nothing, I can see that like, like, nothing makes that right. I don't care what
they did, you know, and like, there is this implicit notion that some people deserve certain
things, you know, and that is then in turn used, you know, or, you know, it becomes very,
very vulnerable, because if you can pin certain acts on certain people, well, they're terrorists,
well, they just look at who they kill, look at you, you know, that somehow then can justify,
you know, systemic cruelty, systems of plunder, systems of exploitation. And I just,
I just, I just don't, I don't believe that. Can I, can I, can I just take just a quick
journalistic license before we move off this piece? Of course. Sam, I want to ask you, because,
you know, I've actually heard you, you know, speak about this quite a bit on this show.
And your question really does intrigue me. What? Like, having seen what everything you've seen,
and come to your place of consciousness about Palestine and Israel and Zionism and everything,
like, what is all of that teaching about the Holocaust means to you? Does the Holocaust have
any sort of place in your politics? Does it have anything to teach you in terms of struggle?
I mean, honestly, like, I think at this time, when I think about it,
and its resonance, I see it as a mass trauma. Like, it, I mean, it's almost like my perspective
on it has changed to, you know, that's just what dominates my thinking now, in this era, is that
this is, it's really more of like a psychological thing. Like, there is literally a,
what we're seeing is some type of mass reaction to like a mass trauma. I can't really place it
in any other context. I mean, I, you know, I, the relationship between the Holocaust and Israel
was so cemented in my young Jewish teachings. I mean, I think as a kid, I was aware, you know,
my son just got bar mitzvahed, and I remember my bar mitzvah speech, I said something to the effect
of like, we're all here because of the Holocaust. And like, we're guilty, we feel guilty. And that
was not met with the, not everybody was excited about that, but at the time, but in retrospect,
I think I was on to something on some level, like there was a, in the license that many people
perceive that it gives them, I think is just really problematic. Like, somehow, I mean,
I think it's just like a trauma reaction, which is, you know, I hope people don't interpret as a,
as an excuse. But then also empowered by like the state as well, and by institutions in ways.
I think that came after. I mean, I think the impetus, I mean, look,
the people in the Ergun and the Haganah and the Stern Gang, they justified doing some horrible
things. And I think it was because we're owed something. We have license. And I think that,
you know, disseminates through a people. And I don't know how you recover from that. I mean,
I have no idea. But it's, it's a bad thing. You know, like, what's the point of teaching
about the Holocaust? If the answer is, we just need better guns.
Yeah. I mean, one thing, and again, you would know this better than me, but I,
being struck by just the sheer number of Jewish voices in the Palestinian freedom,
I mean, being struck, struck by what happened in what was Dan Goldman's district. I mean,
is there not one argument that actually people heard the lessons too well? I mean, like they,
they just, they just believe them and, and, and, and took them too well in, you know, ways that
maybe, you know, some of the people teaching the lessons did not want them to, and they're
just applying those universally. Oh, in other words, that it wasn't taught. It was not taught
like this means for everybody, but that some people absorb that. I mean, that was the argument
that yeah, that was the argument that I think like, was it a former Obama official was making
on her book tour? Oh, yes. That literally like people misunderstood. I mean, yeah, that's what
she said. She did say that. She was like, we made a mistake. Yes. I mean, that's, that's nuts.
I mean, in my mind, that's nuts. Like, I don't remember, like, you know, and you know, I didn't,
I grew up in, in, in Western Massachusetts. It was not like a very, like, it was not the,
the most Jewish of places, but we were, you know, in Hebrew school, I don't remember a, a teacher
saying, Hey, look, this, you're learning this. When we say never again, it means that we've
got to get armed and fight like that. Isn't that nationalism though? Isn't that the drug
of nationalism that gives you this feeling of empowerment and pride, and it can be addicting
in and of itself. And you have Israeli nationalists that say we are not the Jews that would let the
And that is not reflective of Jewish diaspora in this country at all, but in Jewish institutions
where they're at large scale Zionist institutions, that is the more, that is the operational view.
And I think that's part of the contradiction when you see that, you know, a majority of Jewish
Democrats believe Israel's committing genocide, but the Jewish institutions are not reflecting
the population in this country. But I think it's also has to do with like,
age proximity in, you know, temporal proximity to the Holocaust. I mean, certainly, you know,
I've, I've told this story many times, but like someone, a friend of my father's who came to my
bar mitzvah, my sister's bar mitzvahs had many Passover's with us, called him like a year ago
and asked if I was an anti-Semite. And my father asked, are you inviting him to Saul's bar mitzvah?
And I'm like, ah, no, I'm not going to be doing that. Nope. Nope. Because he's Jewish. Yeah.
I said, we have a, we have a quota. Too many Jews are coming.
But I mean, honestly, it was like, I think that's just a mass psychosis, frankly. I mean,
and I don't know if it's question of like, there was a, you know, I think in the context of Israel
and certainly the Molly Crabapple's new book, I mean, covers some of this and certainly the
research, there was a disdain for the Jewry of Europe. There was a victim blaming. I think that
took place. And I think like the, the reason why Benjamin Netanyahu, you know, calls himself
Benjamin Netanyahu as opposed to change his name. I don't want to deadname him. I don't remember
what it was, but I think it was an idea of escaping that profile. Like we don't want to be
those shtetl Jews or those ghetto Jews. And it looks a lot worse as time goes on.
With that said also. Sorry, I took us on a tangent. No, that's fine. The, I want to ask
also like in terms of like the, the, that paradox in the, in the piece, where does Obama fit into
that? Like where does like, like in terms of that, like how do you perceive Obama within that,
that framework? In much the same way I perceive Harris. I mean, I think it's the same thing.
You know, I think it's actually completely the same thing. And again, this was not a,
an awareness or consciousness, you know, I had, but I mean, obviously, you know, you have,
what is it? The week after he's elected and Bush is, you know, a lame duck, they
airstrike a wedding party. And then five years later, I mean, everyone was in Afghanistan,
five years later in Yemen, they airstrike another wedding party, you know, Libya.
You know, look, and you can, you know, say all these things about, you know, how bad a guy
Gaddafi was. I'm not here to disagree with you. But the notion that our policy is that a head of
a state, you know, should die being dragged out of a pipe and, you know, sodomized, you know,
with the bayonet, and then that the Secretary of State will go on national news and laugh about it
and brag about it, right? Like that there's a particular, you know, kind of disdain. And I
just think, like, we have this acceptance. And, you know, to your point, clearly, being Black is
not, you know, inert individuals, you know, from this acceptance that, you know, we're just going
to make war in the Middle East. And it's fine. You know, it's fine. And that's just the state
and that's okay. And, you know, look, to be honest with you, and Obama's, you know,
obviously kind of the apex of this. What I am concerned with, maybe this is like the latent
nationalist in me. What I am concerned with is that from Colin Powell, to Condoleezza Rice,
to Barack Obama, through Susan Rice, through Linda Thomas-Greenfield, through Kamala Harris,
that we are becoming the face of this ----. And I don't want us to be the face of it.
I don't want, like, I don't, I don't want us to be the face of it. You know, I just,
I don't think we want to be the face of it. You know, I don't think we quite understand,
because I didn't, you know, what that all, you know, means. You know, and again, I cite them
as individuals. But I don't, I'm not, you know, necessarily interested, you know, in their
particular, you know, moral failings or whatever. You know, I think that, you know, there's systemic
things at work, you know. But I just, I don't, I don't, I don't, I don't want the inline of our
struggle to be us sitting in the UN justifying dropping bombs on people, like how they drop
bombs on Tulsa. You know what I mean? Like, I don't, I don't, like, that's not what the struggle
is for me. I mean, I get, like, what is, this is gonna sound like a weird question, but, but why?
Like, I mean, I mean, I get it. I mean, I get it from like a, I get it on one level. But the,
what, what are the implications of that? Outside of like, existential for me? Yeah.
And I can tell you why. I mean, I just like, I am not here talking to you. I'm not here having this
conversation with you. If not for the fact that people sacrificed, you know, people died. I mean,
I'm gonna tell you what you already know. You know, people struggled, people made this possible.
And there is a tradition of their vision of liberty, not just being solely for Black people
to get things. That was like why it was important to cite Coretta Scott King, you know, and to note
the fact that Coretta Scott King was loudly against the Vietnam War, three, four years before
Martin Luther King himself was for it. She, you know, what she says is so, so powerful. You know,
she says, listen, how can Lyndon B. Johnson be so sympathetic to these Black kids in Alabama
while dropping bombs on Vietnam, you know, Vietnamese children? And she says something
really, really important. I think it's because we let him, you know, for Fannie Lou Hamer,
you know, at the same time that, you know, she's arguing against, you know, segregation,
you know, and the Mississippi, you know, Democratic delegation being segregated
to be against, you know, what she calls this racist war in Vietnam. And I focused on Black
women because that was the piece, but there's certainly, you know, many more, you know,
we can go into boys. What I'm saying is I owe them, man. Like, I owe them. They're the reason
I am here. And, like, they were fighting for something. And I guess I feel a particular
debt to them. And so, like, that's the why. You know, like, I feel like I owe Coretta Scott King.
I owe Fannie Lou Hamer. I owe W.E.B. —
Why do you think, then, doesn't Obama and Harris? Like, what?
Well, no, no. But why do you think they don't think that?
Brother, that's the million-dollar question. Because, as I said, you know, it was very
important to me that I end that piece the way I did because Harris's biography does not strike
me as somebody who was new to the notion of Black struggle and that intersection with a broader
international struggle. In fact, she probably knows more about it than I do. You know, I just
read some books recently. She probably has been thinking about this for years. It's in Obama's
book. It's actually in his book. Like, he arrives in Indonesia maybe a year, you know, after,
you know, they start, you know, massacring people and putting people — and he writes about it. I
mean, you know, it's defense. It's not like he hides it. He's very much aware that why that
didn't, you know, ultimately play a larger part in his policy. I don't know. I don't know. Maybe
it's because you got to be a peculiar or different kind of person to run for president, to be the
president in the first place. You know, maybe that, like, weeds out, you know, certain people,
you know, right off the bat. You know, I don't know. You know, I don't know. Some would say it
actually did, you know. And this is about as restrained as it gets for an American president,
you know. Some would tell you that, you know — and I'm just telling you what the reporting,
you know, I did told me. I don't think this, you know, should offer any sort of comfort or
consolation or forgiveness on the parts of Palestinians themselves. But I had so many
people tell me — in fact, I had, you know, founders of Uncommitted tell me that behind
the scenes, you know, Kamala Harris clearly disagreed with Joe Biden and would say that
they believed her and they believed that she was sincere, you know. Now, what you would say to me,
and I think this is correct, is that what you say is what matters ultimately. And what you say
off the record and behind the scenes is kind of irrelevant, you know. So, you know, I'm just — I
don't know why it doesn't matter more. I don't know. I guess —
Well, isn't it —
Sam, can I just — I know I've talked a lot, but I'm actually thinking this through as I talk.
What I will tell you is, even in that era, there were people who thought that it should not be
a bigger deal. There were people that were mad at Fannie Lou Hamer. The SCLC was mad at Coretta
Scott King for going out and talking about the Vietnam War. W.E.B. Du Bois had tension
with the NAACP, you know. And so even in that era, what I have to acknowledge is, yes, there were
very, very important Black people who actually said, oh, no, actually, this is just for us,
you know, and that's a tradition, too.
Well, perhaps it's about weighing the — say, what blame goes around against the institutional
barriers and the newness of Black civil rights and also the impulse, frankly, by many liberals
to, as you say, put up Black faces in places and people as a way to obscure,
I think, some of their own policies. And it is — kind of results in a culmination of an erasure
of the collective struggle that the right is speedrunning, of course. Like, we could talk
about America 250 and this insane nationalism, cage matches on the White House lawn and what
that's supposed to indicate about America's history versus the reality. But perhaps it's about
melding in that context when trying to talk about critiques about the roles that Black
people play within the institution of our government. Yeah. I mean, I do think it's that.
And I just think, like, you as a Black person, like, your pain, your agony, your slavery,
your Jim Crow, all of that, is very much responsible for this country as it exists.
And yet, you yourself also believe that there's maybe some wonder — not maybe you do — that
there's some wonderful things about this country that, you know, the notion of
all men are created equal, actually, if it could be realized, that is a beautiful thing.
And so, like, asking people — which is, in fact, what I am asking — asking people to fight
for their own right to be fully invested citizens of this country, while at the same time transforming
what the country is on a deeply, deeply fundamental level. Because, like, this country
has been imperialist from its founding. It's a high bar. It's a high bar. It's a very, very,
very high bar. I think it's a necessary bar. But it's — I can't tell you another group that's
actually done that. Maybe somewhere there is. You know, maybe people know. But that — like,
you're fighting two things at the same time, you know? And that's, you know, great, great — you
know, it's very difficult to try to integrate into something while transforming the thing at
the same time. Does class play any role in those who don't have that same recognition of what
maybe the past — what kind of responsibility they have in the present? Possibly. Possibly. I mean,
you know, I don't — like, the people who I've cited, their class origins are diverse. You know,
you can't really draw a straight line from Fannie Lou Hamer through Coretta Scott King
through, you know, W.E.B. Du Bois. I — I mean, I guess this is not — you know,
I guess this is somewhat, to some extent, class. I do think that not having access to resources
as Black people tend not to be, and certainly as, you know, working-class and poor Black people
tend not to be, means that you just see less of the world, you know? And then at the same time,
I mean, like, the question you asked me, you know, at the beginning — or not at the beginning,
just a few questions ago. And yet those who actually see more of the world are not necessarily
always transformed by it, you know? So I don't know. I don't know. And I literally don't know.
Like, I'm not trying to, you know, bat away your question, but — look, there are people who write
these kind of pieces because they have reached a definitive answer. And I've never been that kind
of, you know, journalist myself, you know? I mean, this is a process, you know, that, as I said,
began like three years ago, you know, that I'm in the midst of, you know? And if I'm doing it
right and, you know, we talk in another three years, you know, I'll have a deeper and more
complicated answer. Do you think that your politics have changed? Or to what extent have
they changed, would you say, over the past couple of decades? Yeah, I mean, they had to. They had to,
you know? What I would say is, you know, my father was in the Black Panther Party,
you know? My mom was, you know, had her own set of radicalism herself, was, you know,
the first person, you know, that taught me to read. And reading was an act of liberation. I
mean, the first person who I heard about the notion that maybe something was going wrong,
and it was some sort of, you know, behavioral, you know, issue, some issue of oppression,
and it was like sitting there with my dad watching the evening news. But the problem is,
there is so much about the world that you hear within your community when you're young,
that because we don't have the resources, we don't then therefore have access to the science
and the information to back up those resources. And so, you know, I go off to college. I go off
to become a writer. You know, I went to a lot of, you know, I ended up working for a lot of
elite institutions where they didn't know how to produce the kind of journalism that, you know,
I'm producing now. I had to learn from them, because there was no Black radical
publication that, for instance, could support the work that I had to do to write the case for
reparations. That's really expensive work, man. You know, it actually costs a lot of money
to tell a writer that for the next year and a half, this is all you have to care about. You
go read about this. You go to Chicago, you know, as many times as you want. You interview as many
people as you want. You know, there's only a certain, you know, few places where you can go
to learn how to do that. And I guess one of the more shocking things is, you know, like to do all
of that research, to do the reading, to do the reporting, and for it to bring you back, you know,
to your dad's living room, you know, where maybe folks' analysis was not the most sophisticated,
but their basic moral sense was right. You know, and if there's one thing that I probably regret,
I mean, regret is a strong word, but it's the word I have right now. If there's one thing that I
regret in the process of coming to consciousness was the notion that somehow knowledge dictates
morality. That because people can know things, you know, they will necessarily, you know, have
a moral outcome. And so, therefore, because I was working around people at different points
in my career whose vocabulary was larger than mine, who maybe didn't have my Baltimore accent,
who had been to places that I had not been, you know, like my mom's analysis of Israel-Palestine
would be, oh, the Palestinians are the blacks. Like, that's what she would say, right? And you
would say, oh, that's, you know, somebody who had been there or knew what I would say, that's not,
you know, sophisticated enough because this isn't that. At the end of the day, my mom was right,
though. Like, morally, my mom was correct. You know what I'm saying? Like, she might not have
the vocabulary and she might not have, you know, never been there, but that these people who have
traveled the world, you know, have been in war zones, you know, covered crises, read books that,
you know, I, you know, had not read, spoke languages that I did not speak, you know what
I mean? Had been in rooms that I had not been in. And my mom's morality, you know, was not just,
and my dad's morality was not, you know, just the thing that should be, you know, the guiding
start. Actually, it in some ways mattered more, you know, than the knowledge. That was not a thing
I knew. And that was not a thing that, you know, I was aware of. And I guess I say that I don't
regret it because when I try to think about how this could have went another way, I mean,
I regret it because that's the emotion I have. I have an emotion of regret. But Sam, when I try to
chart a path by which I become somebody who can answer the questions that I have about the world
in a way that is sufficient to me, that satisfies my own curiosity,
I don't know how else this goes, you know.
Ta-Nehisi Coates, the piece is, did Kamala Harris's silence on Gaza cost her the White House,
though that title was sort of a...
Updated.
That is the, that is the, the...
You got to get y'all to read, man.
Exactly.
You got to get y'all to read.
It's a tremendous piece. Really appreciate you. We, of course, will link to that at
majority.fm and in the YouTube and podcast descriptions. Thank you so much for your time.
Really appreciate it. Big fans of your work.
Hey, thank you for your questions. I don't, I don't, these are not questions I normally get
asked. So thank you for that.
I appreciate that.
Hey, folks, don't forget to hit the subscribe button and check out our daily show. We do it
every day at 12 p.m. Eastern for about two and a half hours. We even take phone calls.
You should check that out.

