Why Are Expiring ACA Subsidies Raising Health Insurance Premiums?

Smart Insurance Choices
22 followers
128 Video Views·Jun 28, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
I think there's a sense in which current debates are just the next stage in the
debate over the Affordable Care Act that we've been having since 2010.
And I think we're likely to see Republicans look for more ideas like the ones that made it across
the finish line in the reconciliation bill this year that can allow them to make sort of progress
towards ACA repeal without necessarily, you know, undertaking a full frontal assault on the law.
Hi, I'm Fred Dues, and this is The Current, part of the Brookings Podcast Network.
In 2021, Congress expanded premium subsidies available to people who buy
health care coverage through the Affordable Care Act's marketplaces.
With those expanded subsidies set to expire at the end of 2025,
Americans on ACA health plans are starting to see big increases in their monthly health care
costs for 2026 as insurance companies send out their annual notices.
Here to talk about the causes and possible responses to this challenge is Matt Fiedler,
the Joseph A. Peckman Senior Fellow in Economic Studies and the Center on Health Policy.
Matt, welcome to The Current.
Thanks for having me.
So why are Americans enrolled in Affordable Care Act plans starting to see
large increases in their premiums for 2026?
So most people who buy their coverage on the individual market, around 85% of them,
receive a subsidy from the federal government that helps pay their premium.
And those subsidies have existed since the ACA marketplaces were first implemented in 2014.
They were then expanded in 2021.
And those expanded subsidies are slated to go away at the beginning of 2026.
So when the subsidies shrink,
the portion of the premium that enrollees have to pay out-of-pocket grows,
and we'll have a lot of people who are facing higher bills.
What I'll say is happening at the same time is the sticker premium,
the sort of pre-subsidy premium that insurers set, those are rising too.
For people who do receive subsidies, that's not actually going to affect what they pay
because the sort of subsidy moves up and down based on the premiums that are available to people.
But for the 15% of the market that doesn't receive subsidies,
the increase in those sticker premiums will translate into higher costs.
The one other thing to keep in mind is that the sort of changes in sticker premiums
are not actually completely unrelated to what's happening with the subsidies.
Insurers expect that when the subsidies go away
and the sort of broad swath of enrollees in the market face higher costs,
that some of those enrollees are going to drop out of the market
and that the people are going to left behind are going to be sicker than the average today.
And so part of why sticker premiums are rising
is insurers are anticipating that they'll see that sicker risk pool
and setting higher premiums to compensate.
That's not the only thing that's going on.
There's also increases in underlying healthcare costs that may even be the larger factor.
But part of why sticker premiums are rising
is linked to these risk pool effects from the disappearance of the subsidies.
Well, so just so I understand, I mean, healthcare costs rise every year.
Our insurance rates go up every year as do prices for everything.
So is this period that we're facing now kind of an unusual happenstance
just because of what Congress did in 2021
because these premium subsidies are expiring at the end of this year in particular?
So we've never seen something quite like this, at least in the ACA marketplaces.
You know, as I alluded to a little bit before, for people who receive subsidies,
they're pretty insulated from year-to-year swings in premium costs
because when premiums go up, the amount of the subsidy goes up
and the amount that the enrollee pays stays the same.
So for subsidized enrollees, what really matters
is when policymakers change the underlying subsidy formula.
So when the subsidies were expanded in 2021,
we saw enrollees see big reductions in what they paid,
and we're now about to see that go into reverse
with subsidies shrinking and enrollees seeing big increases in what they're expected to pay.
The changes in sticker premiums, which again matter for what unsubsidized enrollees pay
and matter for the federal government's costs,
those increases are on the high side of what we've seen historically,
but not wholly out of line with what we've seen historically.
We saw some pretty big increases in 2017 and 2018
as insurers adjusted both to the initial implementation of the ACA
and then some policy changes made during the first Trump administration.
But in terms of what's happening to subsidized enrollees,
we've never really seen something like this before.
We talked about Congress passing the expanded subsidies in 2021,
but it's been out of session until this week, mid-November.
So what could Congress do now?
That's right.
There's a timing dimension of this that if Congress was going to extend the subsidies,
it would have been better, frankly, to do it many months ago
because then insurers would have assumed that they're going to retain
the healthier risk pool they have today in setting their premiums for 2026.
And that would have translated into lower costs for unsubsidized enrollees.
That would have translated into lower subsidy costs for the federal government.
And now we're also in a dimension where each day that passes,
more people are seeing what their premiums will be if the subsidies expire.
Some of those people, if Congress subsequently acted,
would probably come back to the market later.
But some of them may conclude coverage is no longer affordable for me to drop out of the market.
And so insofar as part of what policymakers would be trying to achieve through an extension
is ensuring that the people who are covered today remain covered,
the scope to do that sort of shrinks with each passing day.
And so we're talking about the looming premium subsidy expiration,
but the so-called One Big Beautiful Bill Act that passed into law over this past summer
also included some big health policy changes.
How would those changes affect coverage?
So that legislation made a whole bunch of different changes to Medicaid in the marketplaces.
Most of them are either narrowing who's eligible for coverage through Medicaid
and for subsidized coverage through the marketplaces,
or they're changing the enrollment process in ways that are likely to cause
some number of people, in many cases people who are clearly eligible for the program,
to fall off the program.
The Congressional Budget Office estimated that taking together the provisions in the Beautiful
Bill would reduce the number of people with health insurance by around 10 million people
in the long run.
If you put that together with various administrative actions taken by the Trump administration
and the expiration of the premium subsidies we were just talking about,
you're probably talking about a reduction in insurance coverage of around 15 million people.
That sounds like a big number, but it's also large in terms of the swings of insurance coverage
we've seen in a historical context.
So if that comes to pass, the increase in the uninsured rate we're likely to see over
the next decade or so is enough to wipe out about three quarters of the fairly large decline
we saw in the uninsured rate from the implementation of the Affordable Care Act through 2024.
So people losing health care coverage, premium subsidies expiring,
Affordable Care Act marketplaces perhaps shrinking.
What about the impacts that all these changes are going to have on people who get their
health coverage, not through the Affordable Care Act marketplaces,
but say through their private employer?
So the effects on people who don't get coverage through the marketplaces,
my suspicion will not actually be that large.
What is certainly the case is that people who no longer have marketplace coverage,
they're likely to use less care.
And in some cases, you know, they're still going to show up at the emergency room.
And hospitals are required by law to treat people when they seek emergency care.
And so hospitals are going to deliver care and not be compensated for that care.
So what that means is, you know, there will be consequences of this reduction in insurance
coverage for health care providers.
They're going to be under financial strain.
But we don't have a lot of evidence that that necessarily spills over
in a substantial way to the broader population.
It doesn't seem like health care providers are able to raise prices
for people in other forms of coverage when they're under financial pressure.
And while that does mean they're probably going to need to make some
cutbacks of various kinds, in some cases that may be,
you know, reducing labor costs or reducing other operating costs.
And in principle, those things could have consequences for quality of care.
And in extreme cases, you could see providers have to actually close their doors.
My suspicion is that, you know, those types of effects are not going to be particularly large.
So the first, in my view, at least the first order effect of what we're likely to see,
both with the premium subsidy expiration and with the changes in this year's
reconciliation legislation, is that we will see a lot of people become uninsured.
Those people will have more trouble accessing care.
That'll have negative consequences for their health, for their financial security.
But the spillover effects to the rest of the health care
system may not be as large as people sometimes think they are.
Well, I want to pick up on that point you made about spillover effects.
What are the other kinds of longer term downstream effects
that you're looking at that you're concerned about?
The evidence is pretty clear that people, when they're uninsured, they access less health care.
I think that's fairly intuitive.
But the evidence shows that pretty clearly.
I think one of the things we've gotten a better picture of over the last several
years is that really does have downstream consequences for their health outcomes.
And specifically, the one that's actually, in many cases,
easiest to measure from a data perspective is we can look at mortality.
And it does seem like when people become uninsured, they become more likely to die.
That also may seem a little bit like common sense.
The evidence for that was actually fairly thin until the last several years.
And in fact, there's been a lot of research
enabled by the implementation of the Affordable Care Act.
There were a lot of natural experiments created there that I think have given us
a much sharper picture of what really is the linkage between being uninsured
and people's health outcomes.
You know, I think when we think about the downstream consequences of being uninsured,
we often focus in the first instance on people's ability to access care
and their health outcomes.
But health insurance is also, of course, supposed to be a source of financial protection.
That in many cases, even when people are uninsured, they still end up,
they have emergencies, they access care in other ways,
and they're facing very large bills out of pocket.
And so I think the other thing we do have quite a bit of evidence of is that,
you know, health insurance does quite a lot to improve financial security,
because it means that, you know, people are able to meet their other needs,
their other financial needs, even when they do end up experiencing a large health impact.
So here in late 2025, as the premium subsidies are set to expire,
what are you in the Center on Health Policy looking at
going forward in terms of health care for 2026 and beyond?
I'll say I don't think the issues we've been talking about this year are going away.
I think even if the expanded subsidies do expire on schedule,
I think we'll see future democratic efforts to reinstate them.
And, you know, likewise, I think implementing this year's reconciliation legislation
is going to be a multi-year process.
And I think there's going to be a very active debate about,
should we be delaying some of these changes?
Should we be modifying them in some way?
Should we be reversing them entirely?
So I think in some sense, I think what's coming down the pike,
at least in this slice of the health policy world,
there's a lot of continuity with what we're talking about right now.
And I honestly, you know, on the theme of continuity,
I think there's a sense in which current debates are just the next stage in the debate
over the Affordable Care Act that we've been having since 2010.
You know, the expanded subsidies were basically a democratic effort
to build on the policy framework that was established in the ACA
to make further progress in reducing uninsurance.
And I think we've seen sort of predictable Republican opposition to that.
Likewise, I think, you know, the health components of the beautiful bill
mostly target the ACA's Medicaid expansion and its marketplaces.
And I think we can, you know, think about them as a Republican effort
to make progress in paring back the ACA
without necessarily taking on all the baggage associated with ACA repeal as such.
That basic push and pull is pretty likely to continue.
I think we're likely to see Democrats continue to try to sort of
use the policy framework established in the ACA
to make more progress toward universal coverage
with a sort of long-term goal of really getting everyone covered.
And I think we're likely to see Republicans look for more ideas
like the ones that made it across the finish line in the reconciliation bill this year
that can allow them to make sort of progress towards ACA repeal
without necessarily, you know, undertaking a full frontal assault on the law.
Matt, we have to leave it there.
I want to thank you for sharing your time and expertise
to help us understand some of this today.
Thanks for having me.
You can learn more about Matt Fiedler and his research on our website, brookings.edu.
