Early Spay Neuter May Raise Your Dog’s ACL Risk

Pet stuff
361 followers
23 Video Views·Jun 27, 2026
pet, pet stuff, pet lover
The video explains the link between early spaying/neutering in dogs and an increased risk of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries, while suggesting alternative methods, such as hormone-sparing sterilization, to ensure long-term health for dogs.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedRecent research indicates that early spaying and neutering significantly increase the risk of ACL injuries and certain cancers in dogs. To ensure proper musculoskeletal development and joint stability, experts recommend delaying these procedures until the dog is fully developed or opting for hormone-sparing alternatives to maintain essential sex hormones.
Comments are disabled for this video.
When should you be spaying or neutering your dog to lower the risk of ACL injury?
The recommendations have dramatically changed. Find out exactly what you need to know in this video.
Are you looking to learn more about natural pet health and wellness? You've come to the right
place. Click the link to subscribe to Veterinary Secrets. I want to first thank Dr. Karen Becker
of Proactive Paws for posting this brand new study. So they looked at a large number of dogs,
over 20,000 dogs, and the results were somewhat interesting. This was a study involving over
20,000 dogs. So these are really valid results. And the study conclusions found that spaying a
female dog before the age of three, like it's a lot much longer than we previously thought,
neutering a male dog before the age of two, dramatically increased the risk of ACL injury.
ACL stands for anterior cruciate ligament. It's the primary ligament responsible for stability
in the knee. So Angus is now here, happy to be our model dog. First, he's going to show you
where his knee is. So the big bone here, here's his hip, big bone here, here's his femur,
and the bone below that, the tibia and a little one just adjacent behind it called the fibula.
Tibia is the main one below the knee. So the ACL or that cruciate ligament,
it's attaching from this big bone called the femur down across, crossing the knee,
almost the center of it, to a smaller bone called the tibia attaching on the tibial plateau.
So once again, this, the big bone here, this is his femur, right? Starting off with the ball of
femur, which goes into form the hip and the hip socket. Another big bone that we're palpating
is the tibia, right? If I grab this joint down here, his hop joint here, I move it up and down,
you can see me bending his knee, flexing it back and forth. Angus' ACL is a happy dog's ACL,
runs from the outside here, the lateral part of the knee, and there's two bumps on the end
of the femur called condyles. So it attaches on the inside part of the lateral femoral condyle,
running cranially before, that's why it's called the anterior cruciate ligament or
also known as the cranial cruciate ligament, running forward, attaching onto the tibial plateau,
right? So from the femur towards the tibia, right? And it's responsible for the primarily
stability of that knee, right? So if you flex and extend it, Angus' knee is pretty solid.
One of the big tests to see if a dog is injured is ACL, called the cranial drawer sign,
let's show them how you do that Angus, where you firmly hang on to the upper and lower part of the
and you see if there's cranial motion of that knee, right? Where the tibia, the lower bone is
moving cranially in relation, right? To the femur and there should be no cranial motion. If there is
forward motion, right? Then we've got it. No, wait, don't lick me. Yes. No, I've got a dog
that has an ACL rupture and his is really solid. You have no evidence of any type of ACL injury.
Yay. Good boy. Right? Also in exam often I flex and extend dogs with their knee and I'd feel
sometimes an audible click that may also mean there's also potential meniscal injury,
but yours is nice and solid, which is great because he is a lab and they're definitely
higher risk for ACL tears. Good boy. Angus' pet parents are obviously doing stuff, right?
He's got a nice strong ACL and there has literally been an epidemic of dogs rupturing their ACL
to the point that many people were sort of retrospectively looking back like,
how can this be? Like, why are we seeing so many dogs with ACL injuries amongst other concerning
diseases? Nevermind things such as cancer. And just looking at some of the current conventional
veterinary practices and kind of wondering like, well, maybe some of the things we've had have
advised have played a role in this. Turns out one of the biggest things has been early spay and
neuter. ACL injury itself can be pretty darn difficult to manage and treat, require surgery,
you know, costing now in excess of easily can be $10,000 in some cases and some of the more
advanced procedures and often now in many cases only done a referral practice, right? So it really
costs prohibitive for so many people and we should not be seeing so many animals with so many ligament
injuries. Like clearly something's not right. And it's not just the cost of the surgery. It's, you
know, once you tear your ACL and I'm sure you as the YouTube viewer may have experienced this
yourself or know people who have, even though you get surgery doesn't mean you're going to have a
fully functioning knee, right? You're much more prone to early degenerative joint disease. And
then you have these dogs that are laying much earlier than they should be in spite of even
having ACL surgery. Some cases it's a hundred percent works great, but that's not always the
case. So if we can do something, especially early on having a puppy, you can maybe modify some of
the veterinary suggestions, i.e. the age of what your dog is spayed or neutered and or alternative
methods of sterilizing that could ultimately decrease the risk of injuring their ACL. That
is something you want to do. A study done in 2024 at the university of Wisconsin and Madison
found that dogs neutered prior to the age of 12 months had a marked increase in the risk of ACL
injury. Even for those dogs that had no prior genetic predisposition in terms of it wasn't
sort of a breed or a line of dog that was regularly injuring their ACL. You know, the
single biggest environmental trigger there in terms of external factor, that dog was spayed or neutered
early. There was a study done in February, 2024 at Ohio state. They studied over 4,000 agility dogs
and they found that early span neuter of all of these 4,000 dogs strongly increased the risk of
stifle or knee injury. And over half of those knee injuries, they were ACL tears. And there's
been early Evans, a study I discussed done in 2022 in UC Davis. And they found that spayed
female dogs had a marked increased risk of ACL injuries as opposed to non-spayed females. And
they also studied a whole bunch of other different things in particular risk of cancer and some of
among some of the different dog breeds. And just more than anything, the big conclusion was
the benefits of delaying the age of what your dog is spayed or neutered. If they're spayed or neutered
at all, many pet parents are sort of wondering, well, what is it? Why removing some of these sex
hormones early on, how is that affecting our dogs? Why are we seeing more ACL injuries? When part,
those hormones are pretty key for bone and muscle development. So if you can imagine, if you've got
a dog that right, their bones are growing at the rate they should, but the muscles don't develop
the same way. All of a sudden you've got a dog instead of this normal confirmation, that's got a
moderate flex to his rear leg. You're very straight legged, right? He doesn't have adequate soft
tissue supporting that whole joint. I, the knee is not properly supported because we remove those sex
hormones. Like what's happening. All of a sudden we've got an unstable knee and you mean, it's been
well studied. Like these sex hormones are really important for normal growth and development.
Yet in veterinary medicine, we've just thought like the biggest thing, let's just decrease unwanted
pregnancies. The last thing we want to do is contribute to pet overpopulation. So let's just
make a blanket rule. We'll spay and neuter at the age of six months, which if not earlier, which I
did with thousands of animals. I mean, I'm especially being involved with an animal shelter.
I mean, we were pretty aggressive at early spay and neuter. We didn't want more puppies. We didn't
want more kittens. Fair enough and made huge sense, especially in a shelter setting. But at the same
time, there wasn't a whole lot of thought put into like, okay, how is this affecting all these
different other health parameters in our animals? And you know, if you sit back there and think
about it, well, it's pretty key, right? And it makes huge sense that the sex hormones are more,
they're not just there for reproduction. They impact secondarily all these different body
systems. And clearly they're impacting how our animals grow. So if we have an animal that is,
you know, some part of his skeletal system is growing too rapidly. You've got bones developing
at one rate, muscle and soft tissue developing at a slower rate. You have these joints not
adequately supported. Yeah, that makes sense. That's why we see what seemed to be this epidemic
of ACL tears. And then, which is not part of today's video, but obviously as concerning,
is how some of these sex hormones have protective effects and perhaps are modifying the immune
system, aiding the immune system, or at least ensuring normal cell growth. As our population
grows and we domesticate more animals, they become more key parts of our hosts.
We just make these blanket statements. Let's just stay new there at six months.
Yeah. Will there be any health problems? Probably not. Turns out, you know, maybe
in hindsight, that wasn't probably the best blanket advice to give future veterinarians.
So you can see how maybe the intention started strongly. Like we want to prevent
pet overpopulation makes sense. But when we make this blanket statement, early spay and neuter,
this is it. Now we're dealing with some of the consequences. So what are the options now for our
dogs? Other one, you delay the age of which your dog is spayed or neutered. It's like closer to
three years for majority of the female dogs, upwards of two years for some of the male dogs.
But then the other option is just doing everything slightly differently. This hormone
i.e. not ovarial hysterectomy. How about just hysterectomy? Just removing the uterus itself,
leaving the ovaries intact. So for the male dogs, not leaving the testicles there,
but removing the vas deferens, doing vasectomy. The Parsimus Foundation has a great resource
for you as a pet parent, also for veterinarians, and actually even have it provide a resource for
veterinarians that are doing some of this like ovarian sparing, as well as performing vasectomies.
And even some of those are actually doing hormone restoration therapy. It's kind of like hormone
replacement therapy that's done in people that's now happening for some dogs. It is a new procedure
for veterinarians to learn. Something new that I would have to learn if I were to be back into
But there has been thousands of vasectomies, thousands of hysterectomies, where the ovaries
are left intact, the testicles are left intact. So there's still testosterone being produced.
There's still ovarian sex hormones being produced. You're not removing those hormones.
As far as the challenge of the procedure or not, many people ask about what about just tubal
people. Well, the risk here with our dogs especially is the risk of palmitra, which can
be really high, upwards of 25%. So if it were my dog, I would do a hysterectomy in terms of
not doing something like a tubal ligation, where you're leaving the ovaries intact.
I would remove the entire uterus, including the cervix. You want to make sure that you don't leave
part of that cervix or the lower part of the uterus, because then
that can result in palmitra. Because we still have all those sex hormones being produced.
And while they're there, then that can result in palmitra. But that's a great option,
just a hysterectomy itself. As far as a vasectomy, that would be a new one for me to learn.
But you know, you're isolating the vas deferens, very much the same thing that has
happened to human males. I think the big thing is you're just retracting the testicles,
so you can clearly isolate the vas deferens. First, what about the risk of mammary tumors?
And that was one of the things I always discussed for the benefits of spaying a dog, right?
Turns out the risk is still actually quite low. And the benefits of keeping those intact sex
hormones markedly lowers the risk of a whole bunch of other conditions, i.e. ACL injury,
i.e. some of the cancers. A vasectomy for our male dogs? I mean, the one concern there would be if
you've got a dog who's somewhat aggressive, well, you still got to source a testosterone.
I think there you have to, more than anything, you have to look at behavior period and adequate
training, etc., etc., etc., as opposed to, okay, I'll just take away any of your source of
testosterone. Like, think of the well-developed muscles. And I mean, I think any person who sort
of dealt with declining levels of testosterone can see all of a sudden, like, where'd my muscles go,
right? There's a big benefit to having these sex hormones. Because the ovaries are still present,
our dogs still will experience heat cycles. But because the uterus is no longer intact,
there shouldn't be any espress bleeding. But it just may attract attention from other dogs.
I mean, it's going to happen a couple of times a year, which is pretty traditional for these dogs
coming in heat. But if that's all you have to manage, and it's going to mean your dogs
be much healthier in the long term, lower risk of ACL injury, lower risk of other serious diseases
such as cancer, I think it's worth it. And this is something I wish I knew 15 or 20 years ago.
Yeah, because I sure did a lot of spaying and neutering. And sure, it would have been nice to
have been aware of that and not be responsible for a number of dogs having ACL tears and
probably some early cancers, which I never would have thought possible. But yeah,
I guess that's the whole point of research and also learning from past mistakes. But fortunately,
you're in a position now to know like, what your options are. A big part of today's video is,
you know, doing what you can and in particular, not having your dog spayed or neutered early,
putting them at increased risk of ACL injury. Oh my goodness. And Angus, as you can see,
is quite happy to be on video. So long as he's not on the exam, people. Oh yes. Good boy.
It's like a little vacation. You get far too many treats and all this individual attention. Yes,
you're a good boy. Oh yes. Yes. Oh, apparently he likes being on camera. Oh yes. Oh, what a nice
doggy. All right. Oh, my doggy Angus. Thanks so much for watching this edition of Entry Secrets,
the update on ACL injury, the correlation with early spay and neuter, the age at which,
all right, we should then be spaying or neutering our dogs or just not doing that at all anymore.
And just looking at hysterectomies, looking at vasectomies. Click up there to subscribe,
hit the bell to sign up for notifications. Then when you click that link directly in the box below,
I can send you a copy of my free book. Apparently he likes being on camera. Okay. Yes. Oh, what a
nice doggy. All right. Oh, my doggy Angus.
