Eco India: Why plastic producers must partner with informal waste pickers for a circular economy

Nature conservation
234 followers
10 Video Views·Jun 26, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video highlights the critical yet unrecognized role of India's informal waste pickers in the plastic recycling chain. While these workers collect the majority of recycled waste, they are excluded from official government policies like Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR). The film advocates for a \"just transition\" that integrates informal workers to effectively tackle problematic plastics.
Days start at 6.30 am for Kavitha, when she goes door to door picking out dry waste from
neighborhood garbage bins.
By 9, she has usually collected about 40 kilos of plastic waste within a 5-kilometer radius.
Every piece of plastic has its own recycled value, Kavitha explains.
Listening to her, it is difficult to gauge that she has had no formal training in waste
management.
India's informal workforce of waste pickers collects nearly 70% of all recycled waste
in the country.
Historically, they have been an invaluable part of our waste management system.
But despite the significance in the value chain, their contribution is neither tracked
nor accounted for officially by the government.
35-year-old Kavitha Nanavare has been doing this for the last 20 years in Mumbai, earning
about 500 rupees a day after selling this waste to a scrap dealer.
From there, the waste is further sold to a recycler.
But for all practical purposes, Kavitha remains an invisible cog in the wheel.
Sushila Sable leads Parisar Bhaagni Vikas Sangh, a Mumbai-based co-operative of women
waste pickers that helps mitigate nearly 1,200 tons of dry waste every day.
A former waste picker herself, Sushila tells us that there are close to 30,000 informal
workers in the city, all largely unorganized and unrecognized.
India, as a country, currently recycles a mere 13% of the plastic waste it generated.
Today we happen to be the third largest consumer of plastic in the world.
And at 10 million tons of plastic waste generated annually, we have come to become one of the
biggest plastic polluters globally.
The biggest and most relevant policy today with regards to plastic waste in India is
the Extended Producer Responsibility, or EPR, based on the Polluter Pays Principle.
EPR seeks to hold the producers of waste accountable and responsible for the end of life of their
products, stipulating mandatory targets like recycling plastic packaging, reusing rigid
plastic packaging, and using recycled plastic content.
But the EPR guidelines currently requires producers to collect credits only from recyclers,
a system that then leaves out the informal sector completely from the picture.
The way that EPR is structured, it is essentially concerning only the producers of plastic and
the recyclers of plastic.
It doesn't mention the other actors in the recycling chain.
See, the government of India also acknowledges that around 60% of plastics in India are recycled
and a very large part of that is happening because of activity of waste pickers, scrap
dealers, aggregators, most of whom are operating informally.
So unfortunately, EPR does not consider this scrap trade at all, it doesn't mention the
existing scrap trade.
Leaving the informal sector out means leaving out close to 1.5 million workers from the
sector.
Experts tell us how this exclusion is a big policy gap that will continue to increase
the burden of plastic waste in our ecosystems.
In one of our studies back in 2021, we found that it is actually the informal space that
feeds the formal recycling value chain.
The formal recycling value chain does not have the bandwidth to collect, to process,
does not have the expertise in terms of identifying different kinds of items and falls back on
the expertise and the strength and the bandwidth of the informal sector in order to have access
to these materials.
Recognizing this deeply flawed system, waste picker cooperatives today are advocating strongly
for the inclusion of informal workers in the EPR system.
In Pune, for example, the waste picker cooperative, SWACH, along with the private corporation
ITC, has been trying to create a viable model for tackling the most difficult plastic waste
of all, multilayered plastics.
Multilayered plastics or MLPs are harder to recycle due to the difficulty in separating
the layers.
Because it is also lightweight, collecting it remains unviable for waste pickers.
A report by the Centre for Science and Environment in 2022 pointed out how Indian plastic producers
were mostly manufacturing materials that could not be recycled easily, like multilayered
plastic, which alarmingly accounts for 35% of all plastic waste in India.
Today, a lot more products are packaged in plastics, moreover, a lot more products are
packaged in materials, plastic materials which are non-recyclable in nature, they are problematic
in nature, which means that even if they get collected, there is very less likelihood that
it will end up in a recycling facility, because either it is very difficult to recycle, either
it is very expensive to recycle, or recycling technologies simply do not exist for those
materials.
Every day, Sarika Gaikwad, who works with the waste picker cooperative SWACH in Pune,
is out on her rounds collecting waste.
But now, she picks up multilayered plastic as well, because the SWACH model has made
it viable.
A problem with waste in India that continues to persist, and that which makes the role
of waste pickers even more crucial, is the near absence of households segregating their waste.
Since waste pickers recover multilayered plastics from source-segregated dry waste,
it is cleaner and relatively free of contamination. This value addition allows MLPs to be channeled
for purposes beyond end of life.
The SWACH model also facilitates buying MLPs directly from waste pickers, either at designated
feeder points or through its own scrap dealers.
The purchased material is then sent to two satellite sheds, where it is stored until
finally transported to sorting and baling centers. From here, mechanical recyclers go
on to make pellets, boards and benches from the recycled material.
Sarika makes about Rs. 700 in a month for collecting and selling multilayered plastic,
which is sold at Rs. 5 a kg under this model, a higher rate than the market price. Her work
is helping tackle one-fourth of the city's MLP waste.
Lubna Anantakrishnan, who works with the SWACH cooperative, explains how the whole enterprise
has been made viable through ITC's support. A brand and producer of plastics themselves,
currently running this model on a voluntary basis.
Recycling MLP, even where there is a system to do it, is prohibitively expensive. This
is because the cost of buying, collecting, transporting, aggregating, getting MLP to
the recycler and then recycling it is very high, much higher than the value you get for
the recycled product. If you look at the system in Pune, the cost of actually buying
the MLP and bringing it up to the recycler works out to around Rs. 20 and the rate that
recyclers are willing to pay for MLP is only Rs. 4, which means that in a natural system
this is running at a loss of Rs. 16. That is where ITC comes in and ITC pays what is
called the viability gap to make this operation viable. Now a part of this goes towards purchasing
the material from waste pickers and so waste pickers for many years were getting Rs. 4
a kilo and now are getting Rs. 5 per kilogram for multi-layered plastics. So this is a direct
earning for waste pickers.
Swachh has been able to collect and support the recycling of 1200 tonnes of MLP plastic
annually, reducing emissions by close to 13,500 tonnes of CO2 equivalent. 700 waste pickers
in Pune are part of this model. Despite such initiatives, the fact remains that the challenge
of multi-layered plastics ending up in waste-to-energy plants or cement kilns will prevail until
solutions to reduce its production are in place. As for companies like ITC, which is
a major plastic polluter and producer of MLP waste, this kind of an initiative is a drop
in the ocean until the same model is scaled to match their production capacities of around
50,000 tonnes per annum.
So what we really found is that currently for a problematic fraction of plastic packaging
such as multi-layer packaging, companies today are only paying 10% of the actual cost that
is required for recycling problematic fractions like multi-layer packaging. So for instance,
if the cost of recycling, and when I say recycling, I mean the cost of collection, the cost of
storage, the cost of transportation, the cost of preprocessing, the cost of labour that
is involved, the cost of fuel, the cost of maybe logistics, vehicles, etc., etc., all
of that, let's say, works out to 10 rupees a kg. But what we found is brands today are
only paying 1 rupee for every kilogram of multi-layer packaging that they put out on
the Indian market. The remaining 9 rupees out of this 10 rupee cost is externalized,
which means that either end consumers are paying, or the local governments are paying,
or it is the state government and the national government that is paying the cost for management
of this plastic. Today, EPR has several loopholes through which producers escape responsibility.
But its biggest flaw is the exclusion of the informal workforce. The hope is, being relatively
new to India, EPR still has potential to model its framework on similar initiatives like
Swachh for a robust system aiming for a just and green transition.
