Neer Claim (USA v Mexico) (Protection for foreign nationals)

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Jun 26, 2026
In this international law case, the widow and daughter of a man killed in Mexico sued the Mexican government for failing to bring his killers to justice. The Arbitrator found that in order to fall short of the required standard, the host nation had to fall clearly and dramatically short.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Paul Nier was the superintendent of a mine in Mexico in 1924.
One evening in November of that year he was out riding with his wife when he was surrounded
by a group of Mexican nationals who started shooting and killed him.
His wife got away.
Nier's wife and daughter alleged that following this incident the Mexican authorities did
not do enough to identify the murderers and bring them to justice.
The family claimed to have suffered damages of $100,000 due to the loss of Paul Nier and
they sought this money from the Mexican government.
Essentially the argument was that Mexico had not met even the minimum standards of justice
in relation to the Niers as foreign nationals.
And as a result Mexico had not provided the legal protections which international law
requires each nation to extend to foreign nationals.
Now there are some difficulties here.
Different nations have extremely different conceptions of what justice means and different
nations have extremely different systems of justice and different amounts of resources
that can be allocated to justice.
So there really is no one size fits all standard of justice which can be applied everywhere.
What then is the requirement of international law?
The commissioners in this matter expressed the requirement in these terms which have
become a classical statement of the law repeated many times over.
They said the propriety of governmental acts should be put to the test of international
The treatment of an alien in order to constitute an international delinquency should amount
to an outrage, to bad faith, to willful neglect of duty, or to an insufficiency of government
action so far short of international standards that every reasonable and impartial man would
readily recognize its insufficiency.
Whether the insufficiency proceeds from the deficient execution of a reasonable law or
from the fact that the laws of the country do not empower the authorities to measure
up to international standards is immaterial.
In other words, to amount to a denial of justice, the conduct of a nation must be so poor that
every reasonable person would think that it amounted to a denial of justice.
Unfortunately in this case, when that standard was applied, they found that while Mexico
had not met the standards which the NIAS had expected, the Mexican response was also
not so poor that it failed to reach the minimum required standard.
