Chamizal Arbitration (USA v Mexico) (River Borders)

Global Affairs Academy
6 followers
Jun 26, 2026
In this international law case, the Arbitrator considered the nature of river borders, and the ability for parties who have fixed their border by reference to a river, to decide what happens to the border if the river changes course.
AI Generated·May contain errors
In the 1840s, the USA and Mexico fought a border war, which was ended by treaty in 1848.
Under that treaty, part of the border between the two nations would be along the Rio Grande,
which is Spanish for Big River. Rivers are commonly used for borders. In Australia,
the river Murray separates much of Victoria and New South Wales. However, rivers are problematic
as boundaries, because even though it might seem that rivers remain stationary, they actually move
over time. Sometimes they change gradually due to silt or erosion. This is called accretion.
Sometimes they change due to human intervention such as dredging, and sometimes they change due
to sudden geographical impacts such as floods. Boundary treaties take various different
approaches to this issue. Sometimes they fix the boundary by the river's position on a given day,
then keep the border there forever. Sometimes they allow the border to move with the river.
In this case, an area called the Chamazal tract started out as Mexican land, but then the river
moved, making the land American. The nearby US city of El Paso expanded into the newly American
area. Most of the river movement was due to accretion, but some of it, particularly around
1864, was due to a flood, which suddenly and permanently changed the river's course.
Mexico claimed that the Chamazal tract remained Mexican. The USA claimed that it was now American.
The countries tried for decades to negotiate a solution, and ultimately agreed to arbitrate.
The arbitrators said,
On the whole, it appears to be impossible to come to any other conclusion than that the two nations
have, by their subsequent treaties and their consistent course of conduct, put such an
authoritative interpretation upon the language of the treaties as to preclude them from now
contending that the river portion of the boundary created by those treaties is a fixed line boundary.
However, even though they agreed that the boundary moved with the river,
they said that the boundary only moved with accretion.
Geographic events such as the flood of 1864 did not change the boundary. As a result,
some of the land went to Mexico, and some to the USA. The US arbitrator dissented,
and the US government ignored the outcome because powerful countries can just ignore international
law. The boundary dispute remained a cause of friction between the two countries,
and wasn't ultimately settled until the 1960s.
