6 Learn Corporate Finance Principles in 1 Hour: Rate of Return and Financial Leverage

Finance Guru
9 followers
AI GeneratedยทMay contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis lesson explores the relationship between the required rate of return, capital structure, and financial leverage. It explains how companies balance debt and equity to minimize their cost of capital, while investors seek to maximize returns based on risk. The core focus is on using debt as a tool to amplify returns on equity through strategic leverage.
Welcome back again. In this lesson we're going to better understand the required rate of return
and how this can be optimized using debt. Returning to a conceptual model of this course,
in this lesson we will look at the various financing and investment instruments. Companies
issue these instruments to investors to raise capital to grow their business. Companies have
the objective of minimizing their cost of capital and they do so by optimizing their capital
structure. Capital structure refers to the mix of debt and equity instruments they issue. Investors
on the other hand buy these securities looking to maximize their returns but in doing so assume
different levels of risk depending on the securities they invest in. There's an infinite
world of investment and financing possibilities which all boil down to two and a half categories,
debt, equity, and hybrid instruments, which is an instrument that has characteristics of both
debt and equity, which I count as a half a category by my reckoning. These hybrid instruments also
happen to be beyond the scope of this course. All of these investment options come in the form
of what are called securities. Securities are little pieces of paper that entitle you to
something. As we discussed during the course introduction, debt always ranks before equity
in a liquidation scenario and for this reason debt always carries less risk than the associated
equity. Lower risk comes with a lower return expectation. However, don't walk away thinking
that all debt is cheap financing. Risk is relative and can vary considerably. At the low
end of the risk range you have a debt security that may be well secured or backed directly or
indirectly by various levels of government. At the high end of the range you may have debt securities
which are unsecured and have no such guarantees. You may have heard of the colloquial term
junk bond, which refers to a low grade debt security with a high risk of default. For
argument's sake let's just put some ballpark numbers on the spectrum of returns one might
expect from debt securities. At the low end the floor is set by government T-bills and at the high
end the rate of return might be 10% or more for unsecured loans. Debt securities pay interest to
the investor. The interest paid divided by the investor's cost base is called yield. While it's
the investor who is the buyer of a debt security to hold it as an investment, the company is the
seller or the issuer who is looking to raise cash proceeds to reinvest into their business.
Both parties get what they want if all goes according to plan. Let's talk about equity
securities for a moment. An equity security entitles the holder to a residual interest in
the business. If you've got a crappy business this isn't a fun place to be and there's a more than
fair probability that you'll likely lose all of your investment. On the other hand if you've
invested in a fabulous business the upside is all yours. This advantage compares to the biggest
disadvantage of a debt security which is that you can never make more than the interest promised.
There are various types of finance theories that attempt to mathematically devise the expectation
of return for the shareholders. These theories only have limited application and vary widely
in practice but they all boil down to something along the lines of a risk-free rate plus some
equity risk premium. This equity risk premium can and does vary for dozens of reasons. So here I
present you with a sort of spectrum of required rates of returns on equity for various sorts of
business. At the low end you have relatively safer types of businesses such as those that
are rate regulated like electric utilities and gas pipelines. As you move up the scale you have
other large public companies followed by private companies. Both may be established businesses but
by being both large and publicly traded helps investors mitigate what is called liquidity risk
and that is the risk that they can't sell their investment position and for this benefit investors
expect a lower required rate of return for the company who has their shares freely traded.
As you get further to the right of the spectrum you start getting into businesses that are smaller
and perhaps in startup or trying to develop a business in a new market. As the risk of failure
is significantly higher so too is the required rate of return. If you plot this spectrum on a
chart it gives you another perspective of how the required rate of return impacts value of any
investment security. Small rates of return create much higher valuations than large rates of return.
The value of a $10 cash flow stream at 10% is $100 where the same cash flow stream valued at
40% is just $25. Secondly the smaller the discount rate the more sensitive it is to any change.
In this chart I have varied the rate of return by just 1% one way or another.
At the 10% cost of equity level you see that this made a huge difference in value almost $10
one way or the other whereas at the 40% rate of return the difference in value was only a dollar.
The dilemma often confronting investors and companies alike is that the rates of return
aren't high enough to meet expectations. The solution to this dilemma is to just add debt.
Wait a minute isn't debt bad? Why is this a solution? Debt isn't bad in the finance world.
Debt is a tool of arbitrage. That is to say by replacing or supplementing more expensive equity
with lower cost debt you can increase the return generated on the equity investment.
The reasoning comes back to the fact that equity is always more expensive than debt.
By using other people's money not the shareholders and generating a return that exceeds the interest
cost that excess return all gets added to the shareholders return without having them invest
any more money. So your next question might be if debt's so damn good let's just add more.
There are limits imposed by lenders and other limits that are imposed by financial theory
which I think are integral to understanding this concept of financial leverage. Financial leverage
is the degree to which your operations are financed with debt. Let's plot this along the
x-axis at zero percent you're entirely financed with equity at a hundred percent you're entirely
financed with debt. On the y-axis let's put the cost of capital. These are the rates of return
we just discussed for debt and equity instruments. Now we need to plot two curves that represent the
cost of equity and the cost of debt at different levels of financial leverage. The cost of equity
is generally an upward sloping curve because as the degree of financial leverage increases
the risk of default on debt increases and the equity investors will be more sensitive to the
risk and demand a higher rate of return. Let's look at the cost of debt curve. Debt is generally
a cheaper source of financing when the company has strong security to offer. So as we replace
equity with debt or add debt incrementally into our capital structure the cost of debt
stays constant until the company runs out of good assets to provide as collateral.
Then debt starts getting expensive and quickly because it's largely unsecured at that point.
When we plot a composite of these two curves we create a curve that calculates the weighted
average cost of capital or WACC. This is a u-shaped curve. At a hundred percent equity
your WACC is the same as your cost of equity. As cheap debt replaces expensive equity this is a
downward sloping curve. As debt gets increasingly more expensive though the curve turns and becomes
upward sloping. The lowest point on the curve represents the optimal capital structure for a
firm. Said another way it represents the ideal amount of debt that a firm should incorporate
into its mix of financing instruments. WACC is an important calculation in both theory and practice
because it represents the true discount factor that should be applied when you're doing present
value analysis. So previously when we left Bob we recognized that he needed a 15 percent return
on his money to achieve his 1 million dollar investment goal. Let's say however that the
best he's able to do with his risk return appetite is identify an opportunity that is expected to
yield a nine percent return over the next five years. Let's cash flow this out and look at the
future value. Sadly and not unexpectedly this is not enough but what if Bob was able to leverage
this investment using some debt. Let's say that the bank has offered him two to one leverage
which is probably more than most banks would offer him today but when you consider that banks
themselves operate at ten to one leverage then it's not exactly stretching the concept.
The downside of high financial leverage is that any losses get magnified by the same degree of
leverage as we see profits getting magnified. So let's build a model for this two to one leverage.
In other words the bank has now given us a million dollars at a cost of four percent
to invest alongside our own five hundred thousand dollars with the expectation that we're going to
repay the million dollar loan at the end of five years. Our investment opportunity still yields nine
percent but because our investment has tripled in size so has our income. However not all that income
attributes to us because we need to pay the bank on the loan at four percent. That spread between
the nine percent return and the four percent interest accrues or attributes to the investor
as the holder of the residual interest. Lo and behold we have a pool of funds of one million
sixty eight thousand five hundred and forty eight dollars at the end of year five after
repaying the bank loan. Mission accomplished. In fact using ratio analysis we can now prove
the effect leverage had on our returns by calculating return on equity which is calculated
as our net income divided by our shareholders equity. As you can see the ROE in the first year
is 19 percent 17 percent and so on down the line. Here's a question to test your understanding.
Why is the return on equity decreasing? The answer is because the capital structure
is slowly getting thicker with equity while the balance of debt remains the same. In other words
the firm is deleveraging even though it's not paying back any of the debt until the end of
year five. In this lesson we learned about the tools of investing and financing which are just
opposites of one another depending on your perspective as either an investor or an issuer.
Investors buy securities issued by companies to give them financing for their business.
You need to keep in mind that first equity of a firm is always going to be more expensive than
its debt because it has greater risks. Each debt and equity instrument has their own required rate
of return based on various underlying characteristics of the instrument and of the issuer.
Secondly we talked about capital structure and how the introduction of debt can reduce
the cost of capital which is also the discount factor we use in present value analysis.
And finally we talked about financial leverage and how it can be used to augment our return
on equity. Keep in mind however that in the same way returns get magnified losses will as well.
Setting capital structure is an imprecise science at best and many entrepreneurs will weigh the
decision by asking themselves do I feel better sleeping at night with a pillow of equity or the
double-edged sword of leverage. It boils down to an individually determined level of risk tolerance.
That's all for this lesson so until next time I'm Blair Cook.
