A New Fra Angelico in the Prado Carl Brandon Strehike V O English

Fra Angelico
4 followers
119 Video Views·Jun 23, 2026
A New Fra Angelico in the Prado Carl Brandon Strehike V O English
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe Prado Museum has expanded its collection of works by Renaissance master Fra Angelico, acquiring pieces from the Alba family. The presentation analyzes these works within the context of the early 15th-century Florentine Renaissance, exploring the artist's transition from Gothic traditions to the linear perspective and sculptural realism pioneered by Brunelleschi and Masaccio.
We are delighted to have him with us today. Thank you very much. You have the floor, sir.
Thank you very much for the generous presentation.
Unfortunately, I cannot continue in Catalan, but I'm very pleased to be here this evening.
It is a very rare occasion that a museum can present two new works of art by a Renaissance master,
Fra Angelico, that also come from the same source, the Alba family.
Congratulations to the Prado, the Amigos del Prado that helped with the purchase of the Madonna della Granada.
Also to the excellent Duke of Alba who generously donated in full the small predella panel of the funeral of St. Anthony Abbott,
a painting that was not known and is a new Fra Angelico.
I have been a museum curator for 35 years and I've never been witness to such an event.
I'm jealous, in fact. In my institution, the Philadelphia Museum of Art, there are two paintings by Fra Angelico,
but not three like the Prado.
Three because the Prado already possessed an important altarpiece from the artist's convent of San Domenico in Fiesole
that came to Spain, that's his convent, that came to Spain after 1611.
On February 28th of that year, Mario Farnese bought it for 1,500 ducats,
a smaller price than the Prado paid for the Madonna, as a gift for the Duke of Lerma,
Philip III's favorite, Francisco Gomez de Sandoval y Rojas,
who donated it to the Dominican Church of San Pablo in Valladolid.
It was later in the nunnery of the Descalzas Reales in Madrid and came from there to the Prado in 1861.
The Duke of Lerma would have known that San Pablo was a church of Juan de Torcamada,
who had also been a patron of Fra Angelico and had been portrayed by him here at the foot of the cross
of this painting now in Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Possibly that painting was also in San Pablo.
The Spanish artist Berruguete, active in the late 1400s,
was certainly aware of the typology of Angelico's crucifixes.
The remarkable fact of all three Fra Angelico paintings in the Prado,
as well as the one other Angelico in Spain, in the Museo Thyssen,
is that they date to relatively early in the career of that artist,
who began to paint in Florence in the mid-1400s, mid-14-teens, excuse me,
continuing until his death in 1455 in Rome in the convent of the Minerva,
where his tomb can still be visited today.
The Prado pictures all date to the mid-1420s,
a period that is the most magical for all of the Florentine Renaissance.
The energy of new discovery, possibly a new age, is palpable.
Also in Angelico's paintings in the Prado, all of which are cutting edge.
On Easter Sunday, 19 April, 1424, Lorenzo Ghiberti's gilt-bronze doors
of the Stories of Christ were installed in the Baptistry,
an encyclopedia of images for Florentine artists.
They faced the cathedral, where a team of artisans was at work
on the construction of the cupola, designed by Filippo Brunelleschi,
which would not be completed until 1434.
Brunelleschi, an architect who had studied the ancient buildings of Rome
and had introduced a classicizing vocabulary to the designs of his edifices,
had also invented a system for drawing buildings
in an illusionistic perspectival space
that was immediately adopted by artists who understood
its revolutionary possibilities for the design of painted compositions.
Masaccio was Brunelleschi's cohort and closest disciple
that the fresco of the Trinity in Santa Maria Novella
might be seen as a collaboration between the two.
But Fra Angelico was no less important.
His Annunciation Altarpiece, here in the Prado,
is the first altarpiece painted according to Brunelleschi's norms,
and one of the first in which the Brunelleschian architectural vocabulary
appears, that ancient type of capital.
The great wealth of Florence, coming from its luxury textile industry
and international banking network,
supported the many public art commissions of the early 1400s,
like the Statuary of Orsa Michele, the Cathedral,
and Ghiberti's Bronze Doors for the Baptistry.
These projects were overseen by appointed committees
that were made up of a wide swath of the male population,
who were members of the guilds that served as the gears
of the oligarchic government of Florence.
The system encouraged a wide participation in decision-making,
including choices about artistic matters.
The upper reaches of the oligarchy supported the humanistic pursuits
that looked to the Latin and Greek literary past
for models of eloquence in language,
and subsequently also in the visual arts.
Just as a humanist, like Poggio Bracciolini,
would pursue an unknown ancient manuscript,
a Cicero or Lucretius, in a remote Swiss or German monastery,
Brunelleschi, on hearing from Donatello
about an ancient sarcophagus in Cortona,
some 120 kilometers away,
walked there immediately without bringing a change of clothing.
He was so desired to see this work of art.
It is precisely this type of sarcophagus
from which artists, including Angelico,
got their repertory of figures, poses, and narrative sequences,
as you can see in this slide.
Smaller-scale marbles, cameos, and intaglios,
dug out of the ground, would be passed around at dinner parties,
either elegant ones in some wealthy man's palace,
or in a tavern where the male coterie of artists,
humanists, and merchants would congregate
for drink and companionship.
We have to imagine, even for Angelico,
a Dominican friar at these gatherings,
perhaps at Palastrozzi's, then the richest man in Florence.
In the late 1420s, Angelico painted
the deposition of Christ for Strozzi and his son Lorenzo.
Pala, the father, is seen holding the crown of Florence,
and Lorenzo kneeling at the foot of the cross.
Angelico's convent was buried,
barrels of wine for the pitcher,
which adorned the Strozzi Palace in Santa Trinita,
a church in Florence.
Angelico's altarpiece was the second one in the chapel.
The other, finished in 1423,
was Gentile da Fabriano's Adoration of the Magi,
in the luxurious late international Gothic style
in which Strozzi also appears.
These men like to have disguised portraits
of themselves in these paintings.
Angelico was not the first person
to be commissioned for the other altarpiece.
As is obvious, the pergola and pinnacles
were scenes of the resurrection,
Noli me Tangere, and The Three Marys at the Tomb
are by Lorenzo Monaco.
This artist, a Camodolese monk,
had died in 1425 and probably had left the work unfinished.
Lorenzo Monaco was Angelico's master,
and, like Angelico, an artist who made
a career outside the system.
Lorenzo, a monk, and Angelico, a Dominican friar,
did not have to work within the rules of the guild.
Angelico learned the advantages of this
during his years of apprenticeship.
The latter's monastery, Lorenzo Monaco's,
was Santa Maria delle Angeli,
a famous scriptorian that provided
illuminated liturgical books.
Lorenzo Monaco started off there,
but soon, becoming a successful painter of altarpieces
and small-scale devotional panels,
he found the confines of the monastery
too restricting and established a studio
outside of its walls.
The demand for his work was great.
Sometimes, as in this small panel
with the Alberti family coats of arms,
the Alberti were an important family of Florence,
it is difficult to distinguish his hand
from that of his assistants,
in this case, Angelico.
Now, I say Angelico even though
Friar Angelico would have never known that name,
which came to him posthumously
when theologians of his Dominican order
compared him to St. Thomas Aquinas,
who was called the Doctor Angelicus.
Angelico's real name was Guido di Pietro.
Little is known of his early years
except that he was born in the countryside
outside of Florence.
During his apprenticeship with Lorenzo Monaco,
he would have been known as Guido.
The first document for Guido
dates to 1417 or 1418
when he joined a religious confraternity in Florence.
The enrollment papers call him a dipintore,
a painter,
indicating that he was already an independent professional.
The next years are obscure,
but in 1424 he is called Fra Giovanni
in a document for a painting of a lost cross
for which he was not paid
but his convent
of the observant or reformed Dominicans
on the hill going up towards Fiesole from Florence.
San Domenico was a new convent.
It had only been founded in 1406,
but in 1409 the friars were forced into exile
until the election of the new pope,
Martin V in 1418,
1417,
putting an end to the schism in the church.
With the church now unified,
the Dominican friars, just numbering six,
came back to Fiesole
where they were able,
with the help of the general of the Dominican order,
Leonardo Dati,
whose tomb is by Ghiberti here in Florence,
that he helped them raise money
from the Florentine patrician Bernardo d'Ali
to build a convent that could house 30 friars.
Friars had to be recruited
and Angelico's decision to become one
was certainly heartfelt.
Not to doubt his religious conviction,
but he probably also saw career opportunities.
He could imitate what his master Lorenzo Monaco did
and set up his own independent workshop.
Later counter-reformation sources,
16th century sources,
affirm that Angelico prayed
before he took up the brush
to paint an image of the Virgin or Christ.
This is an imaginary portrait of him
by the Italian baroque painter Carlo Dolci.
This is a typical,
but that story I just told you
is a typical pious story of the era.
The same was told of Palomino,
by Palomino,
of the great Spanish sculptor Gregorio Fernandez.
Fernandez supposedly
For Angelico,
entering into the convent
of San Domenico in Fiesole
meant that he had a pick of commissions
from the convent itself
and the Dominican community of Florence,
as well as control
over the development of his own art.
As a friar,
the first work of art
Angelico produced
for San Domenico
was the high altarpiece.
It is no longer
in its original position or format.
A traditional polyptych
made up of separate sections
with gilt backgrounds,
it was transformed
into a single panel
with unifying architecture and background
by Lorenzo Credi in 1501.
Many Gothic-style altarpieces
underwent similar modernization
in the early 16th century.
Angelico's must have looked
something like this.
It had pilasters on the side,
pinnacles in a second tier,
and a predella,
or a historiated base.
Now in the National Gallery in London,
the predella shows a heavenly vision
in which the Dominican saints
and blessed find
a particularly special place.
The pinnacles of the Annunciation,
which were in the top part of the altarpiece,
have just been recently founded
and they are now
in a London dealer.
Angelico was not yet
fully on his own
when he painted that altarpiece.
The style is infused
with his master's influence
as a comparison with Lorenzo Monaco
is clearly evident.
You can see the Lorenzo Monaco
here on the right,
which is in the Thyssen collection.
The brilliant colors of the angels
are the palette developed by Lorenzo.
However, Angelico also
looks at new happenings.
Saint Barnaba
here is a combination of sources,
most particularly Ghiberti's
and Donatello's statues
at Orsa Michele.
No artist in early 15th century Florence
could get out from under
the shadow of these masters.
The obviously sculptural quality
of the figure of Saint Barnabas
in the Angelico
is an omen of a change in his style
and engagement with artists
consciously seeking a new style.
And in this we come,
you didn't think I would get there,
to the Madonna della Granada
and the Annunciation in the Prado.
Let's look at the Madonna,
the Prado's latest proud acquisition.
It came to Spain in the early 19th century.
It is said to have been
bought in Florence
in 1817
by the 14th Duke of Alba,
Carlos Miguel Fitz James Stuart e Silva.
The Duke was then 23 years old
when he bought the painting.
He was living in Florence,
a city that he did not like.
He wrote,
Florencia me di gusto cal sempre
in Palazzo Corsi
on the Via Tornabone
with his new wife,
mother and half sister.
Here they are.
They had come to Italy
at the end of the wars of independence
with a suite that included
their French art advisor,
Benoit Guillaume Ange Publot.
I show the unfinished portrait here
by Fabre of the Duke
painted several years previously
before he bought the painting.
Fabre, the artist,
was the lover of Alba's great aunt,
Caroline, Countess of Albany.
Widow of the last claimant
to the Stuart throne of Great Britain,
she lived around the corner
from the Duke in Florence.
This is unfinished
because he departed Florence for Rome
in 1818
after the death of his mother in Florence
in April of that year.
Over the years,
he had been in and out of Rome
where he had often encountered
the exiled Manuel Godoy,
another collector,
and the exiled kings
Carlos IV and Queen Maria Luisa
who were then living in Palazzo Barberini
in Rome.
Most importantly,
there was the French painter Ingres
who had made a drawing
of his mother and sister,
Alba's mother and sister,
here on the screen.
Ingres also gave his sister
a drawing of St. Helen
in a self...
Excuse me.
From him,
the Duke had commissioned
several important historical works
about the Alba family.
I'm showing you a drawing
for one of them
which is in the fog art
of the Getty Museum in Los Angeles.
He, Ingres,
also gave Alba's sister
a drawing of St. Helen
in a self-consciously early style.
I bring up the artist Ingres
because he was also a collector
of early Italian paintings
which had long been ignored.
They were coming back in popularity
in the early 1800s.
And Ingres owned a small panel
called Pasolino
by an artist
also associated with Angelico.
Appreciation of this period of art
was undergoing a revival then
in the early 19th century.
The Duke,
who had lived in Paris as a youth,
would have been well aware
of the Italian primitives
that had come to the Louvre
thanks to the depredations
of Napoleon in Italy,
largely through the agency
of Dominique Vivant de Nome
in 1812.
And here you can see
a view of the Louvre in 1810,
actually all of which
shows Italian masterpieces
that Napoleon stole from Italy.
In 1812, however,
Dominique Vivant de Nome,
who was Napoleon's agent,
brought Angelico's Perugia
altarpiece to Paris
and also the Coronation
of the Virgin,
which is from San Domenico in Fiesole,
just like the Prado Annunciation.
For himself,
Vivant de Nome
got the panels of the Annunciation,
which are now in Detroit.
In Rome in 1818-19,
the Duke of Alba's curiosity
about the arts
would have made him alert
to new happenings
and perhaps also
of a group called the Nazarenes,
a group of German artists,
who although they did not
directly copy Angelico,
were much engaged
with 15th century Italian art
as can be seen
in Johann Friedrich Oberbeck's frescoes
for the Casa Bertoldi
on the Pincio Hill
and also for the Casino Massimo
near San Giovanni Latorano.
These were new works of art
which would have been
just available in 1818-19
when the Duke went to Rome.
A visit to the Pantheon
was obviously an obligatory stop
for anyone on the Grand Tour.
The Duke lived not far from it
in the Palazzo Braschi.
The visit to the Pantheon
was not just to admire
the ancient monument
but also the tomb of Raphael.
Since the early 1800s though,
a series of commemorative busts
were being installed in the Pantheon
providing a quick guide
to Italy's great artists.
In 1814,
Canova personally paid
the sculptor Leandro Bilioschi
to do one of Angelico.
In that same year,
Basso Massaccio and
Ghiberti by Carlo Finelli,
another Canova associate,
were also placed in the Pantheon.
The Quattrocento was back,
in other words,
and it was now living on its own terms.
Just a few years before,
in 1795,
the curator of the Uffizi,
Luigi Lanzi,
in his very influential
Storia Pictorica dell'Italia
had defined for Angelico
as the Guido Reni of his time.
No longer was a comparison
with a much-loved Baroque painter needed.
If anything,
the Duke of Alba's purchase
of the Madonna della Granada
was the sign of the Duke's
modern horizons at that time.
I mentioned the busts of Massaccio
and Ghiberti joined Angelico
in the Pantheon.
As the Duke could have gone
around the Pantheon in 1819,
he would have also seen busts
of two other major Florentine
artists of that period,
all paid for by the neoclassical
sculptor Canova.
And those are busts of
Brunelleschi and Donatello.
And it is with these artists,
Massaccio, Ghiberti, Donatello,
and Brunelleschi,
that we can begin to explore
the culture of surrounding
the Madonna della Granada.
Paintings of Madonnas
seem so diffuse
that it is difficult
to look at them in detail.
Here, the Virgin balances
Jesus on her lap.
Her left arm with its limp hand
is there to make sure
that he does not fall backwards.
It is a beautifully delicate gesture.
With her right hand,
she offers Jesus the pomegranate,
the Granada,
that gives its name to the painting.
It has been cut in half
so that he can pick out
a few seeds.
And with fruit in hand,
it seems completely normal.
But even in this respect,
Angelico's depiction
is innovative.
The pomegranate in Botticelli's
much later Tondo of the Madonna
in the Uffizi
is just slightly peeled open
and the red seeds are about to burst.
In that case,
it is a clear reference
to the Passion of Christ.
In the Angelico,
the emphasis is to show
that the seeds are packed
in the round fruit,
suggesting also another meaning
often associated with the pomegranate,
the universality
and the unity of the Church.
This was a major concern
for 15th century Christians.
After years of schism in the Church,
multiple papacies,
occasionally several popes
at the same time,
heresies raging,
Protestant heresies raging
in northern and eastern Europe
and also the division
of the Catholic and Orthodox churches.
Some of these questions
were discussed
at the recent Church Council in Siena,
south of Florence,
that would have well been on the minds
of the preachers and friars
of Angelico's Dominican order.
The Council's decrees
were published on 8 November 1423
and the Council disbanded
in February 1424.
The painting probably dates
maybe even some months
or a year within that time.
In other words,
it's painted at a time
in which people are really thinking
about the issue of the universality
of the Christian Church,
following its unification
in the West
with the papacy
of Martin V.
However, let's look again.
Pomegranate is not
the only fruit in this picture.
In his left hand,
the baby holds another piece of fruit,
which is harder to identify,
but which I believe,
I think I believe,
I went back to look at the painting today
and I'm not so sure,
that for its color
and its small size,
remember it looks big
in the baby's tiny hand,
it might be what we call
in English a loquat,
a nespero in Italian,
in Spanish,
and I took these from the tree
in my garden in Italy
to show it to you.
The loquat has multiple seeds
and therefore the meaning
would have been the same
as the pomegranate.
In other words,
the unity of the Church all in one.
We are so used to paintings of the Virgin
to have names like the Madonna della Granada
as in the Angelico
or Botticelli
or something like the Madonna of the Pear
as in Bellini
or in Dürer,
that we probably are not aware
that this is mostly a quattrocento phenomenon.
And I think the Angelico
must be one of the earliest
Madonnas painted with a piece of fruit.
Close in date
to the Prado painting
is the painting now in London
from Masaccio's early,
from Masaccio's piece,
in which the Christ Child
eats grapes.
In this case,
a patent reference to the Passion
and the Eucharist.
Florentine trecento Madonnas
instead depicted the Christ Child
usually holding a bird
such as you can see in this one
by Bernardo Dadi.
Bird usually being a goldfinch,
another symbol of his crucifixion
or a flower
usually associated with the purity
of the Virgin.
There are also Florentine Madonnas
and not a single one
has them painted with a fruit.
Now I won't say Angelico's
is the first because I'll
immediately find one
that's earlier than that.
But it is a very unusual
and new type of representation.
The Virgin in the Madonna della Granada
is enthroned
but the throne is not visible.
It was probably what we call
a falstool or a querelle seat
in English.
It's similar to this
because it is covered
with a beautifully brocaded cloth
that the angels are holding up
behind the Madonna.
In another picture by Angelico
he painted the seat more visible
in which you can see
the lion's heads
at the top of the folding legs
which relate it to the iconography
of the throne of Solomon
and therefore in the case of the Virgin
as the sedes sapientiae,
the seat of wisdom.
There are two angels
but the cloth extends up.
We will discuss this
what might be missing shortly.
The cloth is made of gold thread
and has an unusual pattern
of lobed circular shapes
intersected by lines
with little three petal flowers
at each end.
The pattern does not correspond
to any surviving textiles
of the period
and seems to be Angelico's invention.
In other paintings
he uses circular fabric
like the curtain
and the Anatolian rug
in the San Marco altarpiece
but sometimes as in the Madonna
he prefers striking patterns
in gold threaded cloth.
This is the painting
in its present frame.
Out of its frame
this is what the panel looks like.
It is cut at the top.
It would have had
been an arch shape.
The dark spandrels
there are two angels
holding the cloth of honor
at the sides
but we need another angel
at the top to hold it up.
The two angels here
they can't reach that far
in fact they just hold
a little bit of it.
In a later painting
by a follower of Angelico
Andre Di Giusto
there are only two angels
holding the curtain
but their arms reach up
to the top.
Somewhere in the Alba Madonna
there is a missing angel.
What would have it looked like?
We have a good idea
because we know that the painting
that Angelico was looking at
when he made the composition
for this one.
It is the painting of Saint Anne
the Virgin and Christ
in the Uffizi.
It is from Sant'Ambrogio
in Florence
and it is generally called
the Sant'Anna Materza
showing the descent of Christ
through the female line.
Saint Anne was one of the patron
saints of Florence
and therefore images like this
were popular there.
It is generally dated
around 1424.
The painting here
was a collaboration.
Massaccio is credited
with the Virgin and Child
and Masolino
with the Saint Anne.
They shared the work
on the angels.
The Angelico
must date shortly
so this is the painting
by itself
but the Angelico
must date shortly
after it was made.
Therefore,
towards late 1424
or 1425.
Some people date
our painting
around 1426
but I have a feeling
it might be even
a little bit earlier.
The Massaccio-Masolino
gives us
not only the model
for the missing top angel
but the Madonna
is clearly derived
from the Massaccio
in the three-dimensional
sculptural quality
of her body.
The fall of the blue mantle
around her legs
and the distant forward
looking expression
of her face.
Angelico developed
the theme further
in a Madonna of humility
seated on the ground
rather than enthroned
in the Thyssen collection
where the third angel
at the top
has survived.
The three-dimensionality
of Madonnas
by Massaccio
and Angelico
and the interaction
of the Christ child
and the Virgin
in them
is the result
of a continuing dialogue
not only between
the painters themselves
but their closest colleagues.
The main sculptors
who investigated
the themes
in a stunning series
of polychrome
terracotta Madonnas.
This is what appears
on a Google
search page
when one types in
Ghiberti Madonna.
They are not all by Ghiberti
but you can see
the ubiquity of the theme
the varieties of poses
and also the ability
in terracotta
to make repeated copies.
These Madonnas
filled Florentine houses.
More than painters
sculptors
were able to play
with a dynamic
interchange
between the Madonna
mother and child
and the dramatic
possibilities
of the veils
and drapery
of the Madonna.
The Madonnas
by Angelico
are more composed
but the baby
reaching for the
pomegranate seed
in the album Madonna
or his lifted foot
in the Thyssen painting
rival what was
possible in sculpture.
Whereas the sculptures
rarely ever bothered
with extraneous objects
symbolic or not
like the vase of roses
lilies
or pieces of fruit.
Many of the sculptures
are polychrome
and the coloring
of those sculptures
was done by painters.
In the case of the Donatello
here on the screen
my colleague
Lawrence Cantor
has suggested the name
of Masaccio.
The latter's workshop
is documented
as painting objects
like candlesticks
so a sculpture
would have been
well within the range
of the type of jobs
that he would have accepted.
We have information
about these painter
sculpture collaborations
in Siena
at this period
and at a later date
for Florence.
I once attributed
the polychromy
of this bust
to Angelico
comparing it
to the figure
of Paolo Strozzi
in the
Strozzi deposition.
There is much
discussion now though
whether the bust
dates to the 1430s
and is by Donatello
or whether it is
much later
and by Desiderio
da Settignano
in which case
Angelico would not
have colored it.
However,
a recent attribution
to the workshop
of Donatello
is this sculpture
of St. Peter Martyr
from San Domenico
in Fabriano.
The Dominican provenance
might argue
for the polychromy
of which is now
being restored
to have been
by Angelico
and his workshop.
Getting back
to the Madonna
della Granada
the present frame
is modern
and neo-gothic
in style
and the arch
has been filled in.
Like it,
the original one
would have had a base
probably with the
coats of arms
of the owner
at either end
and inscription
and columns
running down the sides.
It is less sure
that it had
a recess around
the arch
with a starlit
blue sky.
In Florentine inventories
of this period
these small
and medium scale
framed images
of the Madonna
were called
colmi.
A colmo
was often found
in the bedroom
of a house
and used as an image
for private devotion.
According to the inventory
of Lorenzo de' Medici
property
drawing up
after his death
in 1492
he displayed
a colmo
of the Virgin
by Angelico
in his family palace.
The two coats of arms
at the bottom
of such paintings
like this one
by the master
of the Castello
and activity
for Lorenzo de' Medici's
parents
was most often
of a married couple
with the woman's
crest on the right
or distaff side
and the man's
crest on the left.
I think this might
yeah
so these
they're not
visible anymore
they've been regilded
but
these are where
the crests
would have been
with the family arms
and even though
this frame
is not original
it would have had
originally been similar
and had crests
with the identity
of who commissioned
the painting.
The presence
of two arms
husband and wife
is often
an indication
that such
Madonnas
were commissioned
on occasion
of a marriage
or a birth
of a child.
The founder
of Angelico's convent
of San Domenico
and Fiesole
Giovanni Domenici
actually wrote a book
about this
recommending
that parents
show young children
images of the
Virgin Mary
and baby Jesus
so that they
can learn
their religion.
Here are two
Colmi
by
Angelo Gadi
and Starnina
that are
in their
original state.
They date
around the
turn of the century
from about 15
to 25 years
before the
Angelico.
It is rare
to find one
still surviving
in its frame.
This is one
this is how one
looks like
when the frame
moldings have been
taken off.
The moldings
were attached
by glue
and nails
to the wood panel.
One of the best
preserved
contemporary
Colmi
to the Angelico
is by
Masolino
that artist
I mentioned
before
who was
collected by
the painter
Ang.
This one
shows the
arms of
the Boni
and Castellani
families.
Two families
of Florence.
An inscription
at the bottom
a recessed
arch and
a series of
columns on
the sides
and above
what we
call a
mixed
linear
arch
tympanum
with an
image of
Christ
Redeemer.
The arch shape
was an
early feature
of Quattrocento
Florentine
architecture
and can be
seen
such as
in this
niche by
Aghiberti
for
Orsa
Michele.
A panel
at
Villi Tatti
by
Andrea
Di Giusto
follower
of Beato
Angelico
shows a
frame that
is similar
to the
Neo-Gothic
one on
the Alba
Madonna.
But
originally that
frame must
have been
different
because of
the
spandrels
on the
sides.
However,
these would
have been
something
at the
top of
the frame
in the
frame.
Like the
Andrea Di
Giusto
a dove
of the
Holy Spirit
or perhaps
an image
of God
the Father
or the
Redeemer.
Other
paintings,
such as
the much
repainted
Masaccio
in
Washington
D.C.
or the
Masolino
in Munich
show
within the
main body
of the
picture,
not above
in the
frame,
either the
dove of
the Holy
Spirit
or God
the Father
and the
dove of
the Holy
Spirit.
This type
of Madonna
with the
God the
Father,
the Redeemer
or the
dove of
the Holy
Spirit
became popular
in Florentine
Madonnas
of the
1420s
and 1430s
because there
was a
specific
interest
in the
Creed,
the Credo,
and in
particular in
the Trinity,
as can be
seen in
Masaccio's
fresco of
the subject.
One of the
articles of
the faith
asserted in
the Western
Roman Catholic
Church was
that the
Filioque was
the Filioque
or the
descent of
the Holy
Spirit
through both
God the
Father
and the
Son.
This was not
part of the
Creed in
the Greek
Orthodox
Church.
This was a
Latin addition
to the
Creed from
the early
Christian
times and
over the
centuries a
matter of
difference
between the
Eastern and
Western
Churches
that was
coming to
a head in
the early
15th century.
It would
be a
subject of
much discussion
at the
Council of
Florence in
1439,
at which
there were
representatives
from
Constantinople
including the
Patriarch.
However,
in the
decades before
that meeting,
at which
time the
two churches
briefly came
to an
agreement,
one can
see the
concept of
the
Filioque being
asserted
visually in
Florentine
Madonnas.
In the
Linaiole
Altarpiece by
Angelico,
he includes
an angel
at the
top,
a dove
of the
Holy Spirit.
Originally,
the
pinnacle
of the
frame of
the
Madonna della
Granata
probably would
have had a
dove of
the Holy Spirit
or God
the Father
like that.
So,
here we have
to imagine
again,
this came
up to an
arch at
the top,
in which
there was
another
angel holding
up that
curtain,
and then
it was in
a frame
like I
showed you
before,
with a
tip of
them at
the top,
in which
there was
a roundel
or some
such shape
in which
you could
see a
dove of
the Holy
Spirit
or maybe
Christ
Redeemer.
So,
it created,
it finished
off the
whole religious
meaning of
the painting.
So,
this painting
of the
Madonna
with the
fruit,
and
imagining
what it
was like
originally
when it
had its
frame,
had a
whole series
of significant
meanings,
all of
which were
of major
concern to
Florentines
and to
Christians in
the West
during the
1420s.
As I
said,
the Madonna
dates sometime
after 1424,
probably around
1425,
maybe 1426,
when all of
these issues
were being
discussed.
This is
somewhat
before,
the Prado's
Annunciation,
and
probably not
too far
from that of
the New
Predella
panel,
and in
the time
remaining,
I'll look
at these
two pictures.
The
altarpiece
consists of
the main
scene of
the Annunciation
with Gabriel
arriving at
the Virgin's
house.
The dove
of the Holy
Spirit
arrives on
a stream
of golden
rays.
To the left,
the angel
is ordering
Adam and
Eve out
of paradise.
They are
already dressed
for a
life of
work.
However,
they are
still in
paradise,
as indicated
by the
flowering
garden.
Below is
the Predella,
the Italian
word for
the base
of an
altarpiece,
where often
narratives would
be painted.
Here we have
the birth and
marriage of
the Virgin,
the visitation,
adoration of
the Magi,
presentation of
the Virgin,
and the
presentation of
Christ,
sorry,
presentation of
Christ,
and the
Dormition
of the
Virgin.
On the
sides,
there would
have been
pilasters with
small scale
figures of
saints.
These do
not survive,
but an
interesting black
and white
photograph,
found by
Miguel
Falomir
Faust,
shows a
copy of
the
altarpiece
in a
house in
Madrid,
with pilasters
on either
side.
The pilasters
look like
they might
be original.
As I
mentioned at
the beginning
of the
lecture,
the
annunciation
came to
the
Prado
from the
1861.
Could it
be that
before that
happened,
the
pilasters
were
separated
from it
and put
together
with a
copy of
the
original?
Another
altogether,
the Prado
annunciation
altarpiece
is what the
architect
Brunelleschi
would have
defined in
Latin as
the
pala
quadrata
et
sine
civoribus
picta
honorabiliter.
This is
how, in
1434,
he described
that the
altarpiece
should be
for the
new church
of San
Lorenzo,
in which
he wanted
clean
architectural
lines and
frames that
did not
have
Gothic-style
arches and
pinnacles,
dudads,
or
civoribus
for
Brunelleschi.
The
Prado
angelico
is earlier
than
1434,
when
Brunelleschi
made this
prescription.
The
painting
with its
predella
is square,
although
by
quadrata
Brunelleschi
did not
necessarily
mean a
square,
but a
rectangular
panel,
one without
arches.
The
architecture
of the
Virgin's
House
shows us
how open
Angelico
was to
Brunelleschi's
ideas.
This is
probably
the
earliest
example
of
representing
architecture
in
perspective.
The
perspective
of the
building is
perfect,
as if
for the
first time
Angelico
feels at
home
working
with
orthogonals,
vanishing
points,
and
horizon
lines.
However,
it gives
the good
idea of
a
very
good
student
who
makes
it
top
grade
in
class.
In
other
paintings,
executed
soon after,
such as
The Last
Judgment,
the
ascension
of the
tombs
augments
the terror
of the
rising
of the
dead,
where
the
low
point
of view
in the
coronation
of the
virgin
makes the
heavenly
court
more
majestic.
In
the
Prado
Annunciation,
besides
that
new
perspective
he
employs,
there are
also
other
novelties.
Our
they do
not have
the same
desperation
of Adam
and Eve
in
Masaccio's
fresco
in the
Brancacci
Chapel
of Santa
Maria del
Carmine,
their
poses are
clearly an
homage to
Masaccio's
representation.
In
Angelico,
Adam and
Eve do
not have
to be
as
distressed
because they
are in
the presence
of their
salvation.
Knowingly,
Eve casts
a furtive
glance
towards
Mary,
the new
Eve.
While Angelico
does not
paint
nudity,
even his
baby in
the
Madonna
della
Granada
is fully
clothed
unlike
Masaccio's
in the
Sant'Anna
Materza,
but Adam's
torso and
muscular legs
come directly
from
Masaccio.
The sorry
in his
life of
Masaccio
puts
Angelico as
a first
among the
many artists
who went
to study
in that
chapel.
The Prado
of Adam
is the
first
example
in
Florentine
painting of
this
influence.
The inclusion
of Adam
and Eve
in the
Annunciation
recurs in
two other
altarpieces
by Angelico
in the
Cortona
and
San Giovanni
Valdarno,
but in
both of
those,
the first
couple is
shown already
outside the
gates of
paradise,
not here
in the
garden that
serves
as both
the garden
of Eve
and the
garden to
the
Virgin's
house.
The new
Renaissance
innovations
did not
mean
Angelico
threw away
everything
that smacked
of the
Gothic.
Gothic
decoration
survives in
the
pastilla
framing
of the
predella
that is
subdivided
into scenes
with polygonal
not rectangular
formats.
The
surfeit of
plants,
fruit,
trees,
and flowers
that grow in
the garden
of paradise
would have
scared any
farmer.
The
flora is
described
with a
botanist's
eye that
recalls
medieval
Lombard
herbals.
The
precise
detailing is
contrary to
the new
language of
Masaccio,
who in
the late
15th century
literature is
defined as
senza
ornato,
an artist
who works
with the
essentials.
In the
same
text,
Angelico
is called
ornato
molto.
In
truth,
however,
Angelico,
after 1424,
usually
follows Masaccio
in the
essentiality of
his pictorial
language.
However,
in the Prado
Annunciation,
he seems
to have
taken a
pause,
almost as
if he
desired to
see what
else might
be happening.
Perhaps the
guilty party
is the
adoration of
the
magi
by
Gentile
da
Fabriano,
finished
in May
1423.
In
its love
of sumptuous
detail,
it blinded
for a
moment the
eyes of
even the
most progressive
Florentine
painters.
No less,
it was for
one of the
richest men
in Florence,
Pala
Strozzi.
But we
might say
that Gentile
was more
of a
florist
than a
farmer
or a
green
grocer.
Delicately
paints all
those flowers
in the
frame of
his
altarpiece.
The
excessive
attention
for detail
in Angelico
seems
almost
Netherlandish.
Even the
play of
light and
shade
that one
can see
in the
little room
beyond the
door in
the
Virgin's
House
resembles
certain effects
that ten
years later
a painter
like
Filippo
Lippi
would
experiment
with.
After
having come
in contact
with
Netherlandish
painting,
and in
particular
with
Jan van
Eyck,
you can
see the
light
streaming
in through
the
window.
This
type of
flickering
light will
become a
hallmark
to
Angelico
and can
be seen
with fine
effect
in his
frescoes
for the
cells of
Saint
Marco
in
Florence.
We will
look at
three scenes
of the
perdella.
The
temple
in the
presentation
of the
Virgin is a
round building
set in the
middle of
Florentine Street
with two
children.
The scene
is a direct
derivation
from the
one in
Gentile da
Fabriano's
perdella
for the
Strozzi
Altarpiece.
The
visitation
is a
subject
that begins
to be
represented
by more
or less
in the
early
Quattro
Cento.
The
Virgin,
her hand
made,
trailing
her,
is seen
having
just reached
the top
of the
hill to
embrace
Elizabeth.
Elizabeth's
house has
a portico
at the
front.
The
setting and
the
architecture
appears
to be
that of
San
Domenico
in Fiesole,
itself on
top of
the hill
overlooking
the
valley of
Florence.
Angelico
makes an
adjustment
in the
landscape
of the
similarly
depicted
visitation
in his
Cortona
Madonna,
Cortona
Annunciation,
where there
is a
bottom
of the
valley,
which
corresponds
to the
actual lake
Trasimena,
which you
can see
from certain
points in
Cortona.
So Angelico
is also
very much
a realistic
painter,
taking
account of
the
surroundings.
Finally,
the Adoration
of the
Magi.
In this
depiction,
the first
two of
the three
Magi have
already
adored Christ
and are
standing to
the right
discussing
something
between
themselves,
usually in
adorations,
as in the
one by
Angelico
at San
Giovanni
Valdano
or
Cortona,
the first
or the
second
Magus is
shown
kneeling
at Christ's
feet.
In the Prado
altarpiece,
we have a
young man
with blonde
hair touching
the babe's
foot.
Could this
have a
particular
significance?
The
altarpiece was
in San
Domenico
in Fiesole,
which was
Angelico's
convent,
but he did
not just
paint it
out of the
goodness of
his heart.
It would
have been
on an
altar in
a chapel
that was
paid for
by a
private
patron.
The
patron would
have
underwritten
the
construction,
the
decoration,
including
the
altarpiece,
and also
maintenance,
paying for
priests to
say Mass
there.
Who
could
this
have
been?
The
interior of
San
Domenico
was
renovated
in 1488,
so the
original aspect
is no
longer there.
But at
the time of
this
renovation,
one
Tadeo
Gaudi,
a direct
descendant
of the
Trecento
painter
Tadeo
Gaudi,
underwrote
two new
chapels for
the church.
And in
those two
new
chapels,
two paintings
by
Angelico
were
transported
to the
altars,
the
Prado
Annunciation
and the
Louvre
Coronation.
This
would not
have
occurred
if the
family
did not
already
own
the
patronage
rights,
the
just
patronato
to
the
chapels
where
those
paintings
had come
from.
The
father of
the
Tadeo
who
paid for
the
renovations
in
1488
was
named
Angelo
Gaudi,
angel,
like the
angel in
the
Annunciation.
He already
owned a
Fra Angelico,
the
Saint Jerome,
now in
Princeton.
It bears
his and
his wife's
coats of
arms.
This
Angelo
Gaudi
had an
interest in
the growth
of the
community
of San
Domenico.
He owned
most of
the
land
around
it.
His
relationship
with the
Dominican
order was
close.
His
maternal
uncle had
been
invested
as a
friar
by
Giovanni
Domenici,
founder
of
San
Domenico.
Gaudi's
mother
was one
of
Domenici's
first
female
clique.
She
owned
Domenici's
manuscripts
and copied
one of
them in
her own
hand.
Angelo
made
donations
to
Santa
Maria
Novella
and paid
for the
family
supplicant
there.
His
mother
and his
brother
Luigi
made
large
bequests
to
San
Domenico
and
a
bequest
by
Luigi
paid
for the
coronation
in the
Louvre.
It is
very likely
that
Angelo
Gaudi
paid
for the
Prado
altarpiece.
The
Quattrocento
Gaudi
family
was
justly proud
of their
family's
artistic
heritage.
They
descended
from three
Quattrocento
artists.
This
painting
that comes
from
Angelico's
shop
depicting
those
three
artists
is an
indication
of how
close
the
family
was to
Guido
di
Pietro.
We
looked
at the
predella
of the
Annunciation
altarpiece.
It
consisted of
one long
panel in
which there
are painted
five stories.
Often when
altarpieces
were broken
up in the
18th and
19th
centuries,
predellas
would be
cut apart.
This is
what happened
to the new
Angelico
panel in
the Prado
showing the
funeral of
Saint Anthony
Abbott.
He is
showing on
his beer
in a
square
surrounded
by mourners
from his
own order.
In the
center at
the top,
his soul
rises to
heaven,
seemingly
observed by
no one
except
possibly
the man
and forth
from the
back.
The
composition
depends on
a picture
showing the
funeral of
Saint Francis
of Assisi
when a
doctor kneels
at Saint
Francis'
beer to
certify his
stigmata
in the
side.
Here the
man kneeling
at Anthony's
body seems
to touch
his hands
whereas another
at the end
bends to
kiss his
feet,
just as in
the other
representations
showing Saint
Francis.
It is not
known from
what altarpiece
this is from.
There is a
perdella painting
often attributed
to Frangelico
in the
Houston Museum
of Art
showing another
scene from
the legend
of Saint
Anthony,
the saint
fleeing from
a false
pot of
gold.
That picture
has about
the same
dimensions
as the
Prado panel
but seems to
be later
than it is
and by a
follower of
Angelico,
possibly
Zanobi
Strozzi,
but this
is still
to be
investigated
and I
would be
also in
favor of
reconsidering
the
Angelico
patrimony
of the
painting in
Houston
and maybe
an X-ray
of these two
panels could
certify
whether they
came from
the same
altarpiece.
I hope
that in
today's
lecture
has shown
how Spain
was attuned
to the
artistic
language
of Angelico
from
Torquemada
to
Lerma
and then
to
Alba.
The
exciting
part of
the new
paintings
from the
House of
Alba
now at
the
Prado
means that
there can
be here
in Madrid
new
focused
research
on this
remarkable
painter of
the
Renaissance,
of the
Florentine
Renaissance,
Guido
Di Pietro,
Fra Giovanni
da Fiesole,
Beato
Angelico.
Take your
pick.
He is all
three of
those names.
Thank you.
