In this wine collecting video, John Jackson DipWSET a/k/a Attorney Somm discusses Second Growth Bordeaux producer Chateau Montrose in detail. Attorney Somm then discusses Chateau Montrose's grape growing and wine making philosophy and the different wines produced by Chateau Montrose (including its second wine, which is an excellent cellar defender). Finally, Attorney Somm discusses wine collecting and wine buying strategies, as well as his favorite vi
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video explores the Saint-Estèphe appellation in Bordeaux, focusing on its unique terroir and the prestigious estate Château Monrose. It details the region's clay-heavy soils, Monrose's extensive modernization efforts, its rigorous production methods, and a comparison between its top wine and second wine, La Dame de Monrose.
It's located past Poya. It's the coolest of the major Appalachians, and it's generally the last
to harvest. There tends to be a higher percentage of clay in the soils, and so there's a larger
amount of merlot planted in San Este than in Appalachians such as Poya. It's worth keeping
in mind that clay soils tend to retain water a little bit better than gravelly soils, and so
the wine producers in San Este typically fare well in very warm vintages, and so you can have
some extremely strong wines in vintages like 2003 and 2009. San Este has two producers that are
classified as second gross in the 1855 classification of Bordeaux, Costa Stornel and Monrose.
Monrose is definitely the youngest producer in the 1855 classification of Bordeaux. In fact,
the first vintage for Monrose is 1815, so it was only around for about 40 vintages at the time of
the 1855 classification. Monrose gets its name from the fact that when Heather was in bloom,
the hillsides in the area turned pink, and so sailors referred to it as Monrose. Interestingly,
the current owners of Monrose purchased it because they were so impressed with the 1989 vintage
that they said that if they ever got the opportunity to purchase this producer,
they would do so. They finally got their chance in 2006. Immediately after acquiring Monrose,
they embarked on an ambitious renovation program and spent a whopping 55 million euros investing
it in the winemaking facilities and modernizing and overhauling all aspects of this estate.
The results were extremely impressive, and they absolutely have a state-of-the-art winemaking
facility and definitely one of the most impressive barrel rooms that I saw when I was in Bordeaux.
Among other things, they purchase 59 stainless steel tanks that have temperature control
that they use for plot-by-plot vinification. Monrose does metalactic fermentation in the
stainless steel tanks and does frequent pump overs, much more in the way of pump over than
some other producers, and so the wines tend to be a bit more extracted than some of their
competitors. Monrose generally matures the top wine in 60% New French oak for around 18 months or so.
Monrose has 95 hectares of vines that are planted to 60% Cabernet Sauvignon,
32% Merlot, 6% Cabernet Franc, and 2% Petit Verdot. These vines average around 40 years of age,
but they are undergoing a replanting program, and they're increasing the percentage of Cabernet
Sauvignon. So these percentages will change a little bit, and also the average age of the
vines will come down a little bit as some of these newer vines come online. Most of the Monrose
vineyards are farmed organically, and their goal is to become 100% organic in the near future.
Monrose uses a very strict selection of fruit for the top wine, so only about 35 to 40% of
harvest makes it into the top wine. Beginning with the 2023 vintage, for example, they're only
going to use the fruit from Terrace 4, which is largely the vineyard that's right next to the
Chateau, and closest to the Gironde River, in their top wine. Chateau Monrose is definitely an
extremely age-worthy wine. Among other things, that means that it can be a challenge to drink
it when it's young. For example, when I visited the winery, I tasted the 2017 vintage. While this
vintage is certainly very promising and a high-quality wine, it's definitely one that's
going to need another decade or so of aging before it shows its best. But on the bright side, this
extreme age-worthiness also means that if you can find back vintages of Monrose with good provenance,
you may want to take a flyer on them, and there's a good chance that they'll still be very enjoyable.
Some of my favorite vintages of Monrose include 1989, 1990, 1996, 2000, 2003, and 2009 and 10.
And certainly after the renovations to the winery were completed, the vintages from 2014 to the
present are all quite strong. And in fact, during that era, the Monrose wines are almost at the same
quality level as Costas Dornel. If you're wondering about a comparison between Monrose and
Costas Dornel, I tend to find Costas Dornel to be a little bit more ripe and also to include some
flavors and aromas of exotic spices, whereas Monrose can be a little bit more powerful,
dense, and structured. Monrose also has a second wine that's called Le Dame de Monrose.
They'll typically use about 40 to 45 percent of the harvest for this second wine. Oftentimes,
they will mature this wine in 30% New French oak for about 12 months before it's bottled.
This wine often consists of around 70% Merlot and 25% Cabernet Sauvignon, and they also include
some Thibodeaux and Cabernet Franc. In 2022, this wine was extremely highly acclaimed,
yet sells for only around $45 per bottle, so it's definitely a very compelling value.
While the second wine also benefits from some additional aging after release, it doesn't
require nearly as much aging as the top wine. The 2017 I enjoyed at the winery was definitely
quite enjoyable, even though there's still no rush to drink that one. That portion of the harvest
that does not make it into the top wine or the second wine is either sold off or in some vintages
they make a third wine that's sold primarily to restaurants. If you enjoyed this video,
I've published dozens of other videos about Bordeaux.
If you'd like to learn more, please be sure to check out the playlist that's linked above.