The social-media ban will be a disaster | Last Orders

World News Updates
7 followers
Maxwell Marlow, director of public affairs at the Adam Smith Institute, joins Chris Snowdon and Tom Slater for the latest episode of Last Orders. They discuss the ban on social media for under-16s, the late David Hockney’s war on the anti-smoking bores, and why pubs are being squeezed by the government yet again.
#Gjwnews #WorldNewsUpdates #Neutral #worldnews
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe *Last Orders* podcast panel critiques the UK government's \"nanny-state\" tendencies, specifically targeting proposed social media bans for under-16s and smoking restrictions. The speakers argue that such policies are performative, technically impractical, and infringe upon parental rights, while also discussing the decline of British pubs and various social pet peeves.
We've become more right-wing, essentially, I think.
Yeah, miserable right-wing prohibitionists.
They keep talking about bloody youth clubs, you know, for young people.
And there's nothing more social than the pub, I think, for adults at least.
There's two things that politicians across the divide want to destroy.
It's the internet and pubs, in my opinion.
Do not drink wine and walk in the middle of the road.
Because apparently that happens all the time.
I think we've got our title for this episode now.
Hello and welcome back to Last Orders.
I'm Tom Slater, editor of Spiked.
Joined, as I am, in every single episode by Chris Noden from the IA.
How are you doing, Chris?
Very well, thanks.
I've got a book out.
I'm just going to get that in there straight away.
I've got a book out.
I forgot to bring it with me.
So the log rolling is going very well already.
Quite poor promotion.
It's called Inside the Sausage Factory.
It's a story of my secret life in Brighton on the nightclub scene.
It's pretty racy stuff.
No, it's not.
If only it was.
It's about policymaking in the UK.
It's got a terrific book cover as well, which we should flash up on screen.
Yeah.
Have a look at that, folks.
AI's still got a way to go, if you ask me.
I like it.
I'm also delighted to be joined by Maxwell Marlow from the Adam Smith Institute,
the Director of Public Affairs over there.
How are you doing, Maxwell?
Very well, thank you, Tom.
Very well indeed.
Great to have you.
We've got plenty to talk about.
We're going to discuss the social media ban.
We're going to pay tribute to the late David Hockney, who was talking about the never-ending
war on pubs.
Before we do that, though, I just want to remind you all about our very special Brexit
anniversary offer.
We've made up these beautiful 10 years of Brexit pint glasses, but you can only get
your hands on one if you donate to Spite.
A donation of £40 or more will allow you to get your hands on one of these and also
support our brilliant work on this podcast and across the site.
Go to spite-online.com forward slash support to get one while stocks last.
Do you know what else happened 10 years ago, Tom?
What happened 10 years ago?
We started this podcast.
Has it actually been that long?
Just over 10 years ago.
May 2016.
That makes me feel very, very old.
Very old.
And unbelievable that we've been dragging this podcast so long.
Talking about essentially the same thing every two weeks.
Well, you say that.
It has morphed over the years.
We've moved into the let-be area.
Moved into the let-be area.
There's obviously the COVID period, which took up a lot of time.
Also, the fact that we've gone from being a libertarian podcast to the most band-happy
podcast that exists.
It's the aging process in microcosm.
I think so, yeah.
We've become more right-wing, essentially, I think.
Yeah.
Miserable right-wing prohibitionists.
Exactly.
It's been a hell of a journey, Chris.
I hope you've enjoyed it.
It's been emotional.
Shall we start with the social media band Maxwell?
Because this is something that the Labour government were toying with for a while, but
now they've come out pretty firmly in favour of it and going even further than what seems
to be done in Australia.
Do you want to talk us through a little bit about what scant details we have and what
you think about it?
They're calling it Australia Plus, which we seem to get all of our horrible, nanny-style
ideas from Australia, and we just lump it in over here.
Obviously, it goes as planned, which is terribly.
They've basically been under pressure from Mumsnet and the Conservative Party.
For some reason, the Conservative Party came out when it was announced and said,
this is a big victory for us.
They thought, you don't really want to put your branding on a big turd like that, to
be honest.
So that's where we are with it.
But yes, they've said they're going to ban all under-16s from accessing most end-to-end
user social media, which is stuff like Instagram, Snapchat, ex-formerly Twitter, Reddit, but
not Discord, which I think is fascinating, given the sort of stuff that goes on Discord.
It's not great.
What is Discord?
Discord is basically a big chat where you basically have all these channels you can
join, a whole global community.
A lot of grooming happens on there.
It's quite famous for it.
So they're keeping that nice and empty.
Except for that one, that's great.
Obviously, Blue Sky has been included after a lot of bashing on Twitter, which is good.
But yes, they're doing that.
Are there a lot of 14-year-olds desperate to go on Blue Sky?
I don't know.
That's the concern.
They're going very left-wing nowadays.
So who knows if they're going to get their normie opinions from somewhere.
So they're going to do that.
But obviously, learning from Australia, where 60% of under-16s are still using their old
accounts.
Well, using some accounts.
I'm assuming they're all the ones.
Well, this is the other thing.
So they're also using VPNs, right?
So now this Kendall came out and said, oh, we're going to look at banning VPNs, which
puts us up there with North Korea, China, Russia, Iran, and Djibouti, or something like that.
There's an element of the old lady who swallows a fly as well, isn't there?
It's like, well, we banned that.
Everyone's using that.
We better ban that.
Yeah, exactly.
So it keeps going.
And there's a really great clip out on LBC where other radio shows are available.
But basically, a producer was sat there, asked by Nick Ferrari, can you show us how easy
it is to get on a VPN?
And he just goes, done.
And there's Kendall sat there going, oh, I didn't know that.
Firefox has it installed now in the browser.
You just click it.
I didn't know you were a Firefox user, though.
I'm a Firefox man, yeah.
Oh my god, yeah.
Or you can use Braille.
Is that bad?
Is that not cool?
It's quite retro.
It doesn't work with a lot of podcasting software, I find, including the one we use.
Yes, exactly.
I don't know why.
And we keep trying to tell you to switch it out.
But, you know.
I've refused it.
You're brand loyal to it.
I've got all my ball marks.
I can't give a Firefox no.
But yeah, that's where we are.
It's going to be an absolute disaster.
It's going to be really, really terrible.
Especially because they won't be able to ban the VPNs, I don't think.
They've got it in them.
You know, M in MI6 will have to find another way of hacking into other softwares.
But yeah, that's where we are, unfortunately.
What do you make of this, Chris?
I know you write a piece for The Critic about this.
Yeah.
Talking about your own experiences of trying to come down to your own daughter's social
online experiences.
But they are quite valid in this instance.
Because I do have a 14-year-old daughter who uses social media all the time.
And so do all her friends.
And honestly, I share the concerns of parents about kids being on the internet in general.
Smartphones, all this.
We don't know how it's going to end.
We're in uncharted territory.
Of course, you don't want to see your child constantly glued to the screen.
But then you just go, well, what was I doing when I was that age?
I was just glued to the TV.
And older people would go, isn't it terrible that kids are always watching TV or playing
the Sega Mega Drive?
We used to spend the entire summer holidays just playing computer games.
People would go, you should go outside.
I said, no, I'm playing Sonic.
Surely, a large element of this is people being worried about the next generation and
new technology.
And these things tend to work out fine.
And I would say, honestly, on balance, there's obviously pros and cons of social media.
But they're a net benefit to me personally.
And I think they've been a net benefit to my daughter and her generation.
Kids are never bored now because of it.
And I know there's some curmudgeons who think that's a bad thing.
And you need to use imagination.
And maybe a bit of boredom can be useful in life.
I think that's quite a hard sell to kids, to be honest with you.
It forces them to be bored when they don't need to be.
But as one of these wonderful kids said on the BBC on Monday morning, this is my window
to the world.
This is how I connect with my friends and family.
It's just how we do things now.
You can't put the genie back in the bowl or turn the clocks back.
So I don't think social media generally has been a bad thing.
I think it's actually made kids at my daughter's age very tech savvy, for one, which means
they're going to be able to run rings around these legislators.
But also actually quite cynical about the internet.
It's the old people who fall for the internet scams.
That's very true.
It's not kids.
Fall for very obvious janky AI videos and things.
Yeah.
And also, she will happily put her phone away as soon as she has a chance to do something
else.
A chance to play football or play something or see her friends.
They don't have the phones on them.
So I don't think it has retarded their development in any way.
I think it's been generally a good thing.
I agree with everything Max has said about the dangers of this.
But it's interesting it's not just libertarians pointing these dangers out.
It's the NSPCC.
It's UNICEF.
It's Save the Children.
All of whom are against this thing.
All of whom are saying there are serious unintended consequences.
They're not being thought through.
We're ignoring what's happening in Australia.
Just as we did with tobacco.
Exactly the same situation.
They were a world leader in Australian plain packaging and tobacco control.
World leader.
They were a world leader in social media.
They were all saying this to politicians.
They've not been a world leader in Australia.
I don't know why they bother.
Because no one pays attention to anything that goes on there apparently.
Why being a world leader if the world doesn't care?
But yeah, I honestly think it could really get quite nasty.
Because you just don't have the safeguards.
I can, on my phone right now, I could turn my daughter's phone off.
Should we do it?
From here, yeah.
I can also turn my central heating on and all sorts of things.
Open your Firefox, you can do everything.
You've got to use Safari on this unfortunately.
Which is why I use it when we have to do the podcast remotely.
But no, I can turn off TikTok.
I can set the times, how many hours you can use it for.
I can switch it off at 10.30 at night, whatever I want to do.
Admittedly, I don't use many of those controls anymore.
Because she's not actually that bad at it.
But I have used them in the past.
I had TikTok completely cut off until she was 13.
I don't like TikTok.
If there was one that I would ban, it would be TikTok.
Because in my opinion, it sounds a bit conspiratorial.
But it is run by the Chinese government to demoralise the West.
And you thought 13 was the right age to loose that on her?
Well, she wanted it when she was like 10, 11.
I said, no, you can have it when you're 13.
Because that is the age at which actually you're supposed to be allowed on TikTok.
So you're quite deferent to the rules of the CCP in some sense.
No, I don't want to make promises I can't keep to my daughter.
When she gets off 13, I was like, can we make it 14?
Because I still think it's toxic.
And she's like, no, you promised me two years ago.
Counting down the days.
Yeah, she really was.
They bloody loved TikTok.
So the point is, if you're a parent with an Android or iPhone or anything.
Well, I mean, basically that's all the phones, isn't it?
You can do all this stuff already.
And I know the nanny status will go, well, some parents don't.
Well, I'm sorry, that's not my problem.
It's the parent's responsibility to look after the kids.
And if they're not looking after their online safety,
they're probably not looking after the safety in general.
And they've got bigger things to worry about.
I heard somebody say, because I did a few interviews about this.
An argument made in favour of it was, well, if it's illegal,
then that gives you as a parent a bit more authority to do it.
I do sort of see that a little bit.
But at the same time, you have the authority.
You can just turn it off on your own phone.
You don't need to say, oh, well, Keir Starmer agrees with me.
You have to wield the profound moral authority.
Exactly.
Why should that be an argument?
And Keir, it's not just me who thinks this.
It's also the government.
I also heard someone say that, well, the next generation,
it's not about the current generation of teenagers.
The next generation, because it's already banned,
they'll never get into social media in the first place.
Very similar to the generational smoking ban thing,
where, well, if they're not allowed to smoke by this age,
they'll never start smoking.
But there's an element of sort of, it's very utopian,
or dystopian, actually, because there's an element of,
we can create a whole new breed of man, isn't there?
It's kind of like communism.
It's like, well, if you take all the profit motive away,
then people will just grow up not expecting it,
and they won't be greedy.
They won't be self-interested.
And of course, that doesn't work.
And in actual fact, if the smoking age was 40,
and it was genuinely somehow enforced,
you would still find masses of 40-year-olds
suddenly start smoking.
Absolutely.
And would you make, Maxwell, of the claims on the other side?
Because notwithstanding concerns about child safeguarding
or what have you, which are going to exist
with any technology, I suppose,
it has focused very much on mental health.
There's a lot of best-selling books
which have been written about how this has been
uniquely deleterious to young people's mental health
in general, but young girls' mental health in particular.
Do you think there's anything in that?
Or is it just kind of parents projecting
their own anxieties onto these devices?
I think there are.
I mean, a lot of the data doesn't hold up to peer review,
I'd say.
So Jonathan Haidt's books, famously,
I mean, there's a few really good studies looking at it,
saying, you know, the evidence is quite sparse, actually,
if you look at it.
So it's like with anything public either way.
There are concentrated harms.
But in general, it's not so good.
I think one of the things that comes up
is sleep deterioration.
And the South Koreans tried this
when they banned gaming, for example.
And then they did a big study looking at...
They banned gaming?
Yeah, they banned gaming for young kids
after they kind of put a curfew in.
And they found out that they only had
an extra one minute and six seconds worth of sleep.
Wow.
So great, well done.
That's fantastic.
And massively harmed the chances
in esports going forward doing that.
So that's really good policy.
So there's that.
It's also, I think, interesting when we look at...
You know, so they're talking about, like,
TikTok, as you're saying, Chris, or Snapchat.
I think Snapchat is actually...
You know, it's not a great platform, actually.
There's a lot of bullying that goes on
because the message is self-delete afterwards.
So there's...
But when has there not been bullying in schools, right?
So it's just on a different platform now.
It's all to do with people.
I think the really concerning part of the ban
is YouTube, which I think...
Which has really, really got to me
because I am a very boring, you know,
early-stage professional,
and I will sit...
I will actually go to bed every evening
and listen to a podcast or a documentary on YouTube
as background music or background noise.
And I actually think it's a really fantastic medium.
So my mum is a schoolteacher,
and she tells me she uses YouTube
to teach some of her subjects
because they've got, like,
amazing subject-matter experts
turning these, you know, grain sites
into really, obviously,
entertaining but informative content.
My dad watches math lectures on YouTube.
Then all of a sudden, if you're under 16,
you can't access that anymore
with this ban.
So it's completely mad.
They're going to say,
oh, yes, well, YouTube Kids is OK.
But if you look at what's on YouTube Kids,
it's Bluey, Brain Rot, and Cocomelon,
and Peppa Pig.
So it's completely infantilising
to, I think, a generation which,
because they've grown up on the internet,
are actually quite intelligent
and quite inquisitive about the world.
There's also the case, fundamentally,
that, you know, they're bringing in
the Santa 16s ban, you know.
And because they want to...
Obviously, if you're 15 years
and 364 days old,
the day before the next general election,
you're expected to go out
and vote for whichever party,
you know, you want to,
on zero information.
So they haven't thought
any of this through.
In contrast to this thing,
it's, you know, to plug Chris's book,
this is pure sausage
because this is just a load of,
you know, het up interest groups
badgering, badgering,
and badgering policymakers
if they've got kids.
And they'll go,
oh, yes, well, my kids
have the same problem, whatever.
And therefore, you should act
and ban the whole thing.
It's complete nonsense.
Yeah.
And the way in which Starmer
has changed his position on this
has also been quite interesting
because originally he came out
against it, I believe,
because he talked to his kids
and they said they didn't like
the sound of it.
Yeah, as far as it went.
But now it does seem, Chris,
like our old friend,
a legacy has come back.
Like, he really thinks,
in the same way that Rishi Sunak
thought that banning smoking
would be the thing
that they would build statues
to him for.
Keir Starmer thinks, you know,
trying and failing
to stop kids getting on Instagram
will be the reason
that it will be inked
in the pages of history.
I think so.
The timing is suspicious, isn't it?
But let's not forget
this is yet another
Rishi Sunak policy.
Yes, he actually is.
This is what it is.
He came up with it originally.
Everything goes back
to Rishi Sunak.
The man was an absolute menace,
only in charge for two years.
We are still pushing through
Sunak policies.
I saw some Labour MP,
admittedly with Alan Cairns,
Alan Cairns?
Al Cairns, yeah.
Who used to be in the army.
He was saying,
we need to bring back
National Service.
But Rishi Sunak
basically didn't even
lose that election.
Might as well still be
pinned down next week.
Just doing all this stuff.
It's unbelievable.
And the guy has a nerve
to write a column
in the Sunday Times
every week.
Lucy donates his fee,
which is the little
thing at the end.
It's like, oh yes,
I've donated it
to my own foundation.
It's fantastic.
His own foundation?
God's sake.
Oh, what a
worst Prime Minister ever.
Theresa May or Rishi Sunak?
Who's the worst
Prime Minister ever?
Sunak.
Yeah.
But it's one of the two,
isn't it?
I mean,
Theresa May was so,
just milk toast,
I guess.
Because nothing
happened the entire time.
But we're still doing
a lot of her policies too.
Net zero.
Extended producer
responsibility and all
the net zero stuff.
But I just think that
was like a continuation
of Blair, basically.
And it was just milk toast.
Nothing really interesting
happened.
Then you got to Sunak
and it was like
mandatory maths day level,
you know,
chess clubs,
smoking ban,
National Service.
Compulsory cricket.
I'm not a cricket guy.
You know, football's on
at the moment.
It's much more exciting.
No, I agree.
Could you imagine
Keir Starmer coming out
and saying,
oh, we're going to do
a bank holiday
if, you know,
we win the Ashes?
Never.
No, definitely for
World Cup.
No, but the Ashes,
to be fair,
wouldn't finish at
two o'clock in the morning.
Or it might do,
I suppose,
if it was Australia.
Of course it would do.
Good point.
So we talked about
one of the great
villains of this podcast,
which is Rishi Sunak.
Should we talk about
one of the great heroes
of this podcast
and your work, Chris,
which is David Hockney,
the famed
anti-nanny state campaigner
and also I understand
quite a good painter
as well.
He painted, didn't he?
He did.
I found that out this week.
You wrote a
brilliant tribute to
the great man
on spikes this week.
Do you want to
remind us a little bit
about his
lonely but very
passionate fight
against crackdowns
on smoking in particular
that you mounted
over the years?
Yeah, it was only when
I wrote the piece
and did the research
and basically
started looking
at particles.
This is how
the sausage is made.
I realised how
relentless he was
in his,
let's call it
pro-smoking.
It wasn't just
about smoking,
it was actively
pro-smoking.
You should do it.
And pretty much
every interview
he did
for the last 20 years
of his life,
either he would
be asked about it
or more often than not
he would just
bring it up himself
about how much
he hates the
anti-smoking lobby
and how it makes
life miserable.
And what I liked
about him
was firstly
he was kind of
untouchable
because he was
a living legend,
arguably Britain's
greatest living
artist when he
was alive
and very,
very cool.
He was all part
of the
swinging 60s.
So the Guardian
in particular
couldn't really,
didn't know what
to do with him
and he would
be there,
he would always
write his letters
to the Guardian
and it kind of
reminded them
that they
had betrayed,
suddenly the 60s
generation reminded
them that they
had betrayed
all their
sort of libertine
values essentially,
liberal values
even.
And they just
didn't know what
to do with him
because he would
just point out
they'd all become
so bloody pretty
and they knew
it was true
and so
what can you
do about it?
But he did his,
he conducted
his activism
with kind of
a combination
of humour
and a light touch
but then
just like this
abuse.
It's like
just abusing
people,
calling them
dreary,
boring,
all the,
every politician
used to say
oh they're dreary,
they've got no vision,
they're artistic.
It was pretty much
about the love of life,
that was his thing.
It wasn't in a way
even about smoking per se,
it was just that
smoking was the thing
that was being
constantly targeted
and he saw smoking
as being an element
of bohemia.
I remember hearing
on a radio show
years ago
and I couldn't
find it again
to mention it
in the article
but I remember
I was driving along
and I heard him
say something
to the effect of
you know,
I grew up in
bohemia
and I think
it's sad
that young people
can't grow up
in bohemia
as well
but then he says
but the young people
don't really seem
to mind
so I suppose
what's the point?
And of course
smoking in itself
is not bohemian,
a billion people
smoke
and most of them
are not in any way
bohemian
but I guess
just the fact
that you can't smoke
is a symbol
well it's not even
a symbol
it's a part
of not being able
to live the
bohemian life
that he felt
he lived.
And it's kind of
attitude to life
as well.
It's an attitude, yeah.
There's one quote
of his I dug out
which was
longevity shouldn't
be an aim in life
that to me
seems to be
life denying
and I think
that's kind of
the nub of it
is that not
everything is about
like those crazy
rich guys
who are trying
to live forever
it's actually
about enjoying
yourself.
Basically that was
his point
because I like
smoking
it has my life
I'm never going
to stop smoking
I don't care
if I die young
or younger
and they didn't
have to say
anything more
than that
because I'm an
artist
artists enjoy life
they appreciate
beauty
you are making
the world more
ugly and more
miserable and that's
all I really
need to say
and that's more
or less all he
really did say
he never sort of
challenged the
statistics or the
evidence or said
oh this might
have unintended
consequences
he didn't care
about any of that
at all
so this is just
miserable behaviour
and I detest it
and you know
good on him
RIP
the fact that he
lived to the age
of 88
is the icing
on the cake
but it's not the
point right
if he would have
died at the age
of 68
I don't think
he would have
said oh god
I wish I
hadn't smoked
he said that
20 years ago
he said I
could die
tomorrow
it's none of
your business
and that's my
lookout
it's great that
the only smoking
people never got
the chance to
say I told
you so didn't
they
no absolutely
what do you
think
especially
because
Hockney
himself
also that
attitude
that he
embodied
which seems
to have
completely
disappeared
in British
public
life now
I mean
there's
social
reverence
for him
I mean
I remember
reading some
of the
bits and
facts
Madison
Peary
our founder
at the
Aboriginal
Institute
there was a
great story
about how
he went
to a
talk with
him
and they
said oh
no we're
going to
turn off
the fire
alarms
for 10
minutes now
because
David
Hockney
wants to
have a
smoke
inside
so they
turned
off the
fire
this is
absolutely
fine
even though
there were
some pretty
white knuckle
people in there
going oh
we can't
possibly do
that
no people
let them
do it
I think
it's
fantastic
but that's
the issue
now most
people don't
you know
they don't
look on
smoking
the same
way
I think
we all
have other
inhibitions
nowadays
but I'd
love to
see
Asher's
reaction
to
David
Hockney
because
they always
say oh
yes the
cost of
smoking
the cost
of
productivity
how much
does
David
Hockney's
paintings
he's
got an
enormous
amount of
money
that's
all I
assume
somewhat
a conduit
from big
tobacco
this is
the
joys
our
product
can
create
he's
an
amazing
legend
he's
gone
he
is
Bradford
is
know you know is Bohemia I'm like what the hell's happened there it's a whole
another story. He was in Brillington when he was still going on about being Bohemian in his 80s
saying I live in Bohemia and in a way he did. He did his own thing didn't he. We also moved down to France
didn't he and he you know had a I think he enjoyed the French you know quite
laissez-faire attitudes towards the sort of stuff you know cheap wine cheap
cigarettes and they all seem to be much happier than we are even though they're
striking all the time so it's. He would move house purely based on smoking
regulations. Absolutely. That's how absolutely committed to it he was. He put his money where his mouth was.
He was in California for a long time. He went to California in the 60s and then of course they
more or less invented the smoking van but he said he didn't really bother him because
it's really sunny out there so I'm just outside I couldn't care less and then
moved back to England and I was like look yeah I went to France for ages and then
came back to England I guess he more or less said look I don't really go out
but he would like emigrate purely as a protest to the anti-smoking legislation
you can't get much sounder than that. RIP. Also RIP there's so many pubs these days I mean
it's was I believe this week Maxwell was it National Pub Day? National Beer Day. Beer Day.
I mean it comes around quicker every year doesn't it? I'm sure we all celebrate
every day is National Beer Day on this podcast but I thought this would be a
good point to talk about what's going on with pubs because we've been talking
for more than 10 years about how they've been closing at a rate of knots because
of various different policies but it does feel like the squeeze is on once
again with various things that the government is doing. Do you want to fill us in?
I think it's really interesting from the government's perspective because they
keep talking about bloody youth clubs you know for young people and there's
nothing more social than the pub I think for adults at least and there's this
great divergence I think it's a Baptist obsession about under 16 smoking ban you
know the general smoking ban, the under 16 social media ban whatever else and you
know now they need to have these community hubs. I really hate that word
absolutely terrible word. Is that a good ban actually? Ban the word hub? That could be that later actually who knows but
but this is the thing right and then you get to the pub which is the absolute
cornerstone of so many social issues back in back in the 80s in the city it's
where all the deals were made you know up and down the country it's an amazing
amazing institution and the government absolutely despise it I just can't work
out why. I think I know is the Resolution Foundation had this paper out when
Torsten Bell was still running the place saying that hospitality is so low
productivity that we need to have kind of targeted policy in order to kill off
hospitality to transfer all those workers. It's amazing but when you read it and you go
right okay that's really interesting I don't think from a think-tank
perspective you should ever say we want to crack down on specific kind of legal
sector because we don't like where it's going of course Resolution Foundation
did but now that's coming to come into action so yeah they're really up
the creep shall we say. It's like a combination of mainly is energy bills
and fashion assurance and whatever else. The hospitality sector though the kind
of industry association want to cut VAT for pubs and then Dan Needle who's
obviously you know the bald-headed magician of tax policy who's very well
respected I guess in government even in the government and has turned around and
said well this should just be a huge you know tax bun to McDonald's and Hilton
whatever else just from the numbers so that's not gonna work and I'm a
bit worried that they're gonna go off down this trail of VAT and ignore the
national insurance the minimum wage you know those things that really hit
hospitality the hardest and there's also beer duty of course and that's been
absolutely whacked the bottom line for most of these pubs so our local in
about 8 pounds 20 pence for a pint of Asahi other beers are available but you
know that's completely absurd so you know it does affect young people who are
on rubbish wages it also means the pubs can't stay open. Yeah absolutely. Chris
anything you want to add in to this? I know you've said it all but is
there anything that's kind of new about this? By coincidence we're
mentioning in the same episode social media bans and the state of the pubs
there's two things that politicians across the divide want to destroy it's
the internet and pubs in my opinion everything they do seems aimed at
internet censorship and closing down the pubs and they claim to believe in free
speech they always claim to be pro-pub but everything they do contradicts that
and Max is right it's mostly about the wages these days you know the national
insurance and in a way this is very difficult obviously these pubs are
surviving yet at the same time spoons is still there selling two pound pints. I don't know how
do I mean we should should be Lord Martin I'd put them in the Treasury. Toss the
bell should I say we'll go and get Tim Martin to take over all the other pubs
rather than close them now we'll just get Tim Martin to take over. Because that thing is running like a
well-oiled machine you know. I mean we'll create a monopoly which possibly you know
Well we did nationalise the pubs if you remember. In Carlisle. Yeah yeah I don't think that went
very well but you know it's interesting it's also we had nationalised
restaurants too and then we see we've seen these suggestions they want to
bring back nationalised restaurants. I think they are bringing them back aren't they?
They are aren't they? Yeah. The kind of Soviet dining experience you can get. That's the
plan is to bring them back and that fella in New York Mandami is state-owned
grocery stores, bodegas yeah. That will go well I'm sure. So yes yeah nationalisation is the
answer. What is the answer? Less regulation, lower tax. Also I would say
pubs aren't doing many favours if they're banning vaping because I will
tend to avoid them there's no need to ban vaping. Yeah. So Green King and
Nicholson's can both sold off as far as I'm concerned. That's been really
interesting because when you do speak to the pub coach and you go well if you
look at for example the smoking ban and how they're just coming down the track
and unfortunately I think the tobacco industry for a long time kind of lay
there and kind of said there's not much we can do about it unfortunately you know
and then you go and speak to the gambling industry you can speak to the
you know the pub coach and they go oh no they're not going to touch us
definitely not going to touch us we're fine and then comes knocking Rachel Reeves
and formerly West Street and now James Murray going oh yeah no we're coming for
you now and it it's it's been really interesting to see and then you know
when the when the tobacco and vapes bill was going through you know I did sit
down with your friends of mine who work in in these big corps and I'm going you
guys can stand up for your customers who want to smoke and vape no don't want to
side with big tobacco and then now there are rumours going around quite well
substantive rumours actually that they're gonna the government will be
moving to put plain packaging on the front of beer pumps you know and as
well as calorie counts so that's currently being worked up in the end on
Victoria Street at the moment I expect to see that probably by the end of this
Parliament as a suggestion I can see that cancer warnings as well yeah yeah
on the balls gonna be a consultation on that later this year well I will say
though the South Africans do this the best if you see if you don't you ever
bought a bottle of wine from South Africa but they've got this great warning
label the back say it's not about cancer it's do not drink wine and walk in the
middle of the road because apparently that happens all the time all right
that's a that's a that's a better label that's that's telling me not have too
good a time but it's not discouraging me completely I think that we've got our
title for this episode now that's absolutely perfect
should we turn to the final two questions that we put to all of our
guests Maxwell starting off with the theories round I've got a theory so do
you have a theory I do actually wrote it down I think the obesity epidemic is the
cause of big gym and kind of if food influences and the reason I think that
is because all of these regulations keep coming into place I remember when I was
going to school they have to eat healthy mascots whatever else we had turkey
twizzlers were banned while still at school it was absolutely terrible and
all these regulations keep in place sugar tax whatever else but you know the
ban on the ban on fast food on the tube you name it
yet people kept getting fatter and fatter butter so who would benefit from
that of course pure gym the gym companies the the influencers online who
would keep hawking their health products whatever else master crying obesity and
obviously people get kept getting bigger and bigger or or at least people you
know people weren't getting smaller until Novo Nordisk came along with glp
ones these mpix and that actually broke the cycle so my theory is that you know
these big kind of health the health companies fundamentally were profiting
off terrible policy and getting people fatter and we can see that's been broken
because Weight Watchers famously basically exploded overnight when they
brought in those mpix so that's that's long gone and that's what happens when
there you know their little Ponzi scheme of fatness ends up going under I'm glad
we're finally having a pop at gyms as well because I've been I think we talked
about it before the mystified by the seeming compulsory nature of gym
membership now amongst people just a bit younger than me or I suppose my
they do in London yeah you don't go no no never once once in my life someone
took me long as I visited me but yeah I think I didn't talk about like it's a
normal thing yeah because it has become that really unsettles me I think is
spread out of the element of just narcissism and I don't know I have never
even seen a gym in a hotel even though every time I check into a hotel they
tell me where the gym is and I was I don't even accidentally walked into one
I mean I've seen that be your first question but if you check in somewhere
where is the gym where's the gym is the barns on the top yeah yeah excellent
rooftop bar thanks I mean what my club in London has one and whenever I walk
past it completely empty so it's also you know they're struggling because pure
gym for example have basically automated the front door so I don't I don't have a
go whenever I walk past I see on see on Twitter people complaining that there's
no receptionist at the gym anymore now they've got these like weird things you
see in pond when you're going in it's like weird sort of Star Trek II doors
that rotate so when you go in they've just got rid of all their staff
basically because they'd really struggling now that everyone's on the
Zempik yeah yeah yeah yeah so I don't quite understand what your theory is
that they they benefited from people being fast basically yeah and that's
true yeah and they keep pushing this sort of stuff not that they caused the
I think they pushed government policy in that way I would say make them bring in
useless policies basically yeah and then they say oh well don't worry because if
you remember you know during Covid for example they're always encouraging people
to go out and exercise as soon as lockdowns were lifted all the big deals
came in you come and join the gym one pound for a month etc so I think they
basically privatized the you know they financialized the outcome of like
terrible government policy and they really ride on the coattails of it okay
well I mean I guess that's true that's my theorem yeah paper forthcoming let's
turn now to think many people's favorite part of this podcast Lucy let me call
Rick we've got a lot of questions to give out there go for the babies one by
one if you had to have one plan Maxwell what would it be and why I'd ban slow
walking people and no one's ever done the maths on this and I really want I
really want to do it myself I just don't have the time what is the cost to
society the economy my own mental health of people who walk incessantly slowly
through crowded public spaces so it whether that is people who for example
includes people who stand on the wrong side of the escalators I think should be
immediately vaporized by some like big space laser beam absolutely terrible but
but like walking through Westminster is as Chris and I do you just get whores
and whores of tourists walking so suddenly I've been late to meetings
with like with donors or with clients whatever else and it's like oh my god oh
you turn up late to a meeting with a minister for example sorry and it's not
really excuse because everyone was really used to it but I just think it's
absolutely terrible and I avoid places I know they might be full of slow walkers
currently helping a Westminster but where I live in West London I don't go
near the Kings Road don't touch that with a barge pole I haven't meet Oxford
Street in years does it just it genuinely drives my cortisol up I can't
do it I think Simon Clarke who runs onward like speedwalks everywhere because
he knows that it's you know he's only got a certain amount of time on the
planet and even when I'm abroad I don't think it's excuse being a tourist even
when I'm abroad I walk at pace everywhere because I just try and put
myself in other people's shoes and go god bloody hell it's a tourist walking
slowly jamming up really really horrible I hate it well I couldn't agree more
how they were didn't Julia Hardy Brewer suggest vaporizing slow walking
you want to vaporize somebody just you want to vaporize them or pick them off
with a sniper or something I don't know what it was there was some sort of pretty harsh
punishment it was something to do with I mean basically every band we have is to
with people being held up yeah walking or getting around London somewhere isn't
it exactly it seems to be recurring or not just London to be fair I mean let's
not be too London centric about this slow walkers are all over the place do
you find Max as I do that the speed of walking slows down even more in London
the weekend oh definitely yeah because I think it's bad enough in the weekdays
but on the odd occasion where for some reason we're forced to be in London on a
Saturday it's just unbearably bad awful yeah get out of my way all these people
cause of carrying wheelie suitcases it never should be the slows me down God
ever since you start talking about this I see them everywhere and it seems to
be getting bigger and bigger and bigger you think unless you're moving house why
do you need this that is the only time it's horrible if you're gonna get on a
one-way ticket to Australia I will tore it your massive back but that's it but
you get an uber or some form of transport other than walking it's absurd
I love to see people walking three abreast on streets that's a true yeah do
you see to see the story about the that banker who pushed someone as he was
jogging on the bridge I was like that's obviously like a cold case isn't it
yeah they found his ex-wife so he was him I think he went over confess he just
the police rocked up they arrested him for that and then they found cocaine and
marijuana and it's properties has been done again on his on secondary charges
but thing is is you know that was clearly psychopathic and insane yeah
let's defend people pushing does go through yeah it's not legal to say
intrusive force intrusive thoughts of like three abreast the other extreme one
thing I would also ban is people jogging on the pavement in central London you
often see this where and again was getting slightly pissed off that even
though I'm walking a perfectly acceptable pace that can get a bit
testy in the trunk sort of cut you up it's like just go to a ******* park but
why do you need to be jogging around go to the gym like everybody else well
exactly it's got a running machine like a normal piece do you think that there's
a case with banning beards I've been thinking about this recently because um
it sounds like a fairly draconian thing to do obviously and one of the stands I
famously bands beards and people hold this up as an example of how insane the
dictator of Tajikistan is and to be fair he's a bit of a mad lad but actually the
reason that they ban beards in Tajikistan is to suppress like jihadist
is to stop the Islamic fundamentalism growing because their neck of the woods
it's a danger it's actually more practice method in the madness but also
I think there's a lot of young people hipsters or whatever they call themselves
these days who are wasting their best years of life when they're never gonna
look better by growing a great big beard which immediately makes you look about
60 and I think it's for their own good that they can't be allowed to grow a
beard but I would ban quite genuinely I would ban facial tattoos right because
if you have a facial to do the chances you ever get a job are very small it's
an inherently mental thing to do I think so some things are so irrational that I
think you can say that you know objectively that doesn't make any sense
like the cost and benefits of it you you made a decision to do something you're
almost only gonna regret it so facial to think like a big spider web over your
face the only people you see with facial tattoos are homeless people and that's
because they no one will employ them so I would ban that but on a similar basis
I would ban beards because you will regret it later in life you go God I'm
all old and wrinkly now this is the time to have a beard
shout out to Stephen behind the camera shave that thing off son the homeless
people aren't getting the tattoos when the homeless there are they so there's
good cause and effects there basically they go out for you know a binge before
they become homeless when they're normal people and they for a bet get a facial
to do they then lose their wife they lose their job and they end up on the
streets we have to pay for that saw some you sounded like piece of the great
though did he bump it he very famously banned beard why was that so he thought
they were too scruffy for his cause because he was trying to stop playing I
think they look scruffy yeah he's trying trying to make the same pieces bows it
was but then more you know more European and Europeans famously never really had
beards unless you're in the Nordics so it's actually a bit of a foreign import
to have it I'll be honest I don't think Caucasian people are that are that good
are that good at growing beards unless they're hipsters or homeless so all
they're in the army or something so it's a very specific phenotype of people who
do it you know I'm actually with you on that one I would get rid of them
completely and they're terrible where we go you're always very clinching no
exactly it was inability to properly grow one so it would look like sour grapes
you know it's a blessing no paper go there there we go gotta make use this
place while still got it so ban beards get yourself a brexit beer glass we'll
see you in two weeks I hope you enjoyed that episode of last orders if you're
watching this on YouTube make sure you subscribe and click the bell so that you
never miss another spiked video if you're listening to this on your podcast
app make sure you subscribe there and leave us a glowing 5-star review and if
you'd like to get in touch with your questions or band suggestions email us
at lastorders at spiked-online.com
