BMW X3 vs. Genesis GV70: Which Is the Better Compact Luxury SUV?

SUV review
33 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares the Genesis GV70 and the 2025 BMW X3, weighing the GV70's superior interior luxury and value against the X3's dominant driving dynamics and performance. While the Genesis offers a more opulent cabin and better standard features, the BMW provides a more precise driving experience and a more powerful engine lineup.
The Genesis is better. At least, that's what I would have told you a year ago. But things have changed.
Remember when the Genesis was the underdog? I sure do. But now it's one of our favorite compact
luxury crossovers. It's quiet, comfortable, beautifully made. It's everything you want.
The X3, however, is the old dog. But for 2025, it's got some new tricks. And it looks like that.
This is actually the X3 we bought for our one-year road test fleet. And almost everything is new.
Today, we are going to go through everything tech, interior, luxury stuff, plus cargo space,
and of course, what they are like to drive. And everything else you might miss on a quick
dealership drive. You ready? We're Edmunds, and we test hundreds of cars each year on the road
and at our private track. So you get the most trusted reviews. If you want to know which car,
truck, or SUV is the best, then stick with us. Bentley interior, BMW price tag. Seriously,
the inside of this thing is world-class. But as a package, the Genesis isn't perfect.
The biggest change from last year is the addition of this huge 27-inch OLED panel.
The screen used to be up here, but they've brought it down into one continuous piece of glass.
There's some pretty neat tech in here too, like a way to prepay at gas stations and a
killer Bang & Olufsen sound system that's standard on the V6 cars, but optional on the
higher trims of the four-cylinder cars. There's also some tech that's not so useful in here,
like this 3D setup menu. It's basically another version of other menus, but instead of diving
through screens, you can flip your car around, which is cool, I guess. Also, I'm not the biggest
fan of the design of Genesis infotainment setup. It just looks like a bunch of iPhone icons tacked
on together. It doesn't really have any identity or personality, but at least it's functional.
It works. Another thing I wanted to point out is while one continuous screen looks cool,
there's really no practical advantage to it here. Genesis hasn't taken advantage of using the entire
screen all of the time. CarPlay, for example, has this fake border that's put in between the
instrument display and the infotainment panel, and I just think that they could have taken
better advantage of using all of the screen all at once. As a centerpiece though, it's pretty cool.
Design is a really strong point throughout the Genesis. Subtle design tweaks on the outside
sharpen what was already a pretty handsome look, but I really dig this interior. Take the ambient
lighting, for example. It's hidden underneath here, so it reflects off of this metallic strip
that goes from door to dash to the other door. It's really clever, really neat touch. There's
this oval motif across the doors and the dash that really brings the cabin together. It's
really cohesive. Plus, there's leather on the dash, the upper part of the doors, the grab handles,
pretty much everywhere. It is super nice in here. Plus, you get heated and cooled seats on higher
trims of the GV70. Also, the Sport Prestige models, they get massaging. That's nice.
One design choice that I really like on the inside is the use of real metal here in the center
console, but it is very fingerprint hungry. Have you ever tried to keep fingerprints off of your
stainless steel fridge? Yeah, not great. Speaking of fingerprints, there's also quite a bit of
piano black in here, and it happens to be where your hands will go, like on the steering wheel
buttons and this row of controls right here, so you might want to keep a rag handy. One thing I
do really like, however, is the use of carbon fiber in the center console and on the doors.
There's a lot of it. It looks really well done, and I think, honestly, it belongs in a car like
this. I'm always going to prefer physical buttons and knobs for the HVAC, but at least the screen
is dedicated, and you're never more than one tap away from what you're trying to do. Also,
you have a physical knob for the temperature up and down control, which we appreciate.
Interior storage in the GV70 is pretty good. You have a sunglasses holder up here, which is nice.
That's slowly disappearing from modern cars. I like the center console. It isn't very long,
but it is quite deep, and there is a wireless charging pad right in front of it. Cup holders.
It will fit your big dumb cup, but it won't fit your even bigger dumb cup. Another thing is the
door bins. They're quite small. You're only going to fit a venti latte in there. While space in the
is good, the backseat feels positively cavernous. I really enjoy being back here. There's tons of
foot room underneath the seat. There's tons of knee room. I got lots of headroom. It's huge,
and also the material choice back here is just as good as it is up front. Automakers tend to
cheap out in the backseat and put hard plastics in places, and it's a lot more obvious where they've
cut costs, but there's no such thing here in the Genesis. I would be more than happy to sit
back here for a couple-hour car ride. Every GV70 gets a couple of USB-C ports back here,
and this one has a household outlet for charging up something bigger like a laptop. Also, on higher
trims, you get completely separate control of your climate compared to the front seats, so you can
adjust the temperature up and down here, and you even get heated seats on the outboard. This is
huge. Super luxury touch. If your passengers are small enough that they need a car seat,
you'll be happy to hear that the doors open nice and wide, but the ISOFIX tethers are a little bit
of a pain in the neck to get to, so you might want to consider that if you're going to put a
car seat back here. Genesis includes a nice auto tailgate feature on every single Genesis. Just
walk up to it with the key, and voila, it's open. The cargo area itself is pretty good. It's nice
and wide. The load floor is nice and low, so it's going to be easy to get your stuff in here,
but overall, it's not as big as some of the class leaders because of the way the roof is rigged.
Other SUVs are more square, so they just have more square footage to play with.
If you need a little more space, you can fold the seats down from here super easily. A couple
of extra things worth mentioning, you do get a 12-volt outlet back here and a full-size spare.
That's not so common these days, but you do not buy one of these to just load up cargo,
admire some orange stitching, and look at a big screen, so let's go for a drive.
Okay, on the road with the GV70N, the first thing you're going to notice is that it's actually
really quiet in here. All of the V6 cars come with acoustic glass, so it's actually going to
be a little bit quieter in here than it would be in the four-cylinder model. Another thing you're
going to notice is the ride. It's actually really nice, but sometimes over little bumps and
imperfections in the road, you get just a little bit of jittering that sort of upsets the rest of
the car. It's just a little bit more shaky and not as settled as the BMW. It's easy to drive
smoothly too, but you have to be a little bit careful with the throttle pedal. If you dig in
too much, you're going to get a downshift and a huge surge, so the powertrain can be just a little
bit too difficult to modulate perfectly, but as long as you drive with a gentle foot, you're going
to be just fine. What is super smooth is the brakes. They give good feel, good bite, and the
pedal is progressive all the way into the ABS. You're not always going to be doing panic stops
in your luxury SUV, but it's good to know that the brakes are going to respond well to your input.
The ride in the GV70 is super well controlled almost all of the time. It's only when you're
going over small bumps or road imperfections that you notice a little bit of a wobble. It's sprung
just a little bit too stiffly, but it rides really well and is really quiet and comfortable,
especially for something on such big 21-inch wheels. My biggest complaint with the GV70 on
the road is the steering. It just feels so artificially heavy, and it doesn't matter what
mode you're in, comfort, sport, sport plus, whatever. The point is, it's heavy for being
heavy's sake. It doesn't feel accurate or sharp in the way the BMW does, and I'm not saying that
BMW has all of a sudden become an expert on steering tuning. It still has its problems,
but the Genesis has a lot of work to do in that particular area. If you want to reduce fatigue
on a longer drive, the Genesis has you covered. There are a ton of standard safety features here.
The adaptive cruise control with the lane centering works, and it even does automatic
lane changes, and they're executed with more authority than they were in the pre-refreshed
GV70. Also, when you pop on a turn signal, you get a fun little blind spot camera in the
instrument cluster, and that's super helpful. The view out of the front is good, and the side
windows are large, but the view out of the back is pretty compromised. You have two pillars that go
across the very far back of the car with a small sliver of glass to look through, so your natural
visibility isn't that good. Luckily, all the camera views will typically have you covered.
When it comes to powertrains, you've got two options here. You have either a turbocharged
four-cylinder or a twin-turbo V6. We recommend sticking with the four-cylinder. The V6 is fine,
but the four-cylinder is more than competitive enough in the class. It's got plenty of power
and torque for passing and merging with confidence. It's not going to be a problem.
This V6 is just a little bit disappointing. When we strapped our testing gear to it,
it was less than half a second quicker than the four-cylinder, and the power isn't always there
when you need it. There's just a little bit of lag in that throttle response. Now,
there's another caveat, which is that the four-cylinder is actually super inefficient,
which means the V6 pays a very small MPG penalty. However, we don't think it's worth the $8,000
upgrade. The Genesis is a strong pick if you're looking for something that's comfortable and
relatively sporty, but that part I already knew. What I'm more curious about is what's
up with that new BMW? This is the new BMW X3. I want to take one second to talk about the way it
looks. Not great. Okay. Is it actually a good luxury SUV or is it just cashing in on BMW's
reputation? Let's find out. Check out the ambient light in here. BMW first debuted this setup in
the 7 Series, and it's nice to see it trickle down to the X3. Plus, all the colors have fun
names like citrine, azure, and emerald, so you can feel like a sophisticated, even though deep
down you know you're really not. On the tech front, BMW has a digital instrument cluster and
an infotainment screen underneath the same piece of slightly curved glass. The screens are just as
clear and as crispy as they are in the Genesis, so it's a bit of a tie there. It's two separate
displays, not just one, and the infotainment itself isn't as intuitive as it is in the Genesis. The
icons are a lot smaller, and it's basically like scrolling through a big apps drawer, but once you
get used to it, you'll find your way around in no time. The best way to control it, at least while
you're on the road, is this little glass rotary knob. It's similar to what's in the Genesis,
but BMW has been doing that for a lot longer, but if you prefer, you can just touch the screen too.
There are two USB-C ports down here, a 12-volt charging port in here, and wireless Android Auto
and Apple CarPlay are standard. There's also a surprisingly reliable wireless phone charger.
The software behind the screen is super snappy and responsive. My biggest complaint is that the
vast majority of the climate controls are hidden in a separate menu that you have to go through the
screen to manipulate. Buttons are just better, and I've said that I don't know how many times,
but we're just going to have to live with it. A couple other things to note about the front of
the X3. I like the design. It feels very fresh and modern in here. I also like the seats. I like the
way they hug you in the side bolsters, and I like the adjustable under-thigh support you get here,
but it's worth noting that you can't get cooled seats in the four-cylinder X3 like you can in the
four-cylinder GV70. If you want cooled seats, you're going to have to step up to the M50,
and that's a lot more money. After sitting in them back-to-back, there is definitely better
small item storage in the X3. You get this big bin here in front of the center console,
which you don't get in the GV70, and the center console is a little bit deeper and a little bit
longer. You don't get a place to put your sunglasses, however. As for cup holders,
your big dumb cup will fit in here, in either of them, no problem. And also, you can fit a giant
water bottle in the door bin. That was definitely not going to happen in the GV70. But by far and
away, my biggest complaint with the X3's interior is the material choice and quality of it. This is
hard plastic. This is hard plastic. It just doesn't feel very nice to the touch. In the Genesis,
you are bathed in metal and leather and nice stitching, and you don't get any of that in here,
at least not to the same degree. It really feels like BMW cheaped out.
The two things that really bother me the most, though, are the window switches, which are the
same across the entire BMW lineup, and they feel super cheap. But this weird touch panel really
takes the cake. It's one solid piece of plastic, and it is so flimsy and cheap, and you can
accidentally activate your seat memory at any point. It is so ridiculous. I cannot stand it.
It's unacceptable. Actually, and I can't even believe I forgot about this, one more thing I
can't stand are these dinky little vent control knob things. They don't stick out from the vent
anymore. They're hidden away in here. They're just stupid. There's no reason to reinvent
something that was so easy before, and I don't see why BMW felt the need to do this. In the Genesis,
it's much easier to just manipulate the fan where you wanted to. Here, you have to go fishing for
it. I just can't with this. I can't. In the back of the X3, there is literally one inch less leg
room here, but I still have plenty of space for my knees, and BMW mounted the front seat nice and
high, so I got space for my feet. I also have a bunch of headroom back here. The seats feel a
little bit firmer, not quite as soft as they are in the Genesis, and like in the front, the material
choice isn't quite as nice. Luckily, the door bins are nice and big. They're still going to fit that
same huge water bottle, and you get two USB-C ports here. You don't get the independent vent
controls unless you pay for that as an option, and it's just not on this car, but you can't have it.
You just got to spend more money. One thing you'll want to know if you're trying to put a car seat
back here, the door opening is a little tight, and the door handle you have to reach underneath of
to open, so it might be difficult if you have a car seat in hand. However, the ISOFIX points are
a lot easier to get to in the BMW. What you give up in that little bit of rear legroom, you gain
in cargo space. The X3 has a bit more space with the seats folded up and up to 10 cubic feet more
with the seats folded down. Despite the fact that you get a few more cubic feet of space because
the opening is a bit more square, the back of the X3 does have a few more weird quirks about it.
There is a hook here, but not directly across over here. The other one is over this way on the inside.
You get a cargo space with a net on this side, but no net here. And you do get a spare tire,
but unlike in the Genesis, it is a space saver. But the most offensive thing by far is the fact
that there's no way to fold down the rear seats from the cargo area. You have to go back around
to the back doors and open them up and then fold the seats down yourself. It's a crime.
First thing I notice here is the steering. It's nice and light. It's far more precise than what
you get in the Genesis. The X3 handles corners with a little bit of body roll, but a ton of
control. So you're going to be able to handle corners in this thing with plenty of confidence.
The view out of the X3 is just as nice as it is in the Genesis, and you get a smaller blind spot.
There are no blind spot monitoring cameras here in the instrument cluster, but you have big mirrors
and you also get blind spot monitoring. I also like that you sit lower in the X3. You feel
slightly more cocooned in here and you feel like you have a more direct line of sight outward.
It's just better for driving, handling, visibility, all of that stuff. The ride is
just as compliant and controlled over most services as it is in the Genesis here in the X3,
with one small exception. Small imperfections in the road don't seem to upset the whole car as much
here as they do in the Genesis. It's got just slightly better control of its overall platform.
Like the Genesis, there are two engine options here, a four-cylinder turbo and a six-cylinder
turbo, but the gap here is much wider. The four-cylinder in the X3 is fine. It's powerful
enough. It's a little bit behind the Genesis, but there's more than enough power and torque
for poodling around town or merging onto highways. Also, one more thing is the response from this
transmission is just a little bit snappier and more immediate than it is in the Genesis also.
That said, the BMW's four-cylinder is way more efficient. The straight six in the X3 M50 though,
that thing is a monster. Our test team clocked it at 4.4 seconds from zero to 60 miles an hour.
That's like proper sports car territory we're talking about in an SUV. From a performance
and handling perspective, the straight six BMW is in a different league to the V6 GV70.
If you're going for a light performance SUV, then the X3 is just going to be the one to get.
When it comes to driver aids, BMW includes automatic emergency braking,
blind spot monitoring, and lane keep assist as standard.
If you want adaptive cruise control with stop and go control like you get in the GV70 as standard,
you're going to have to drop an extra $3,400 on the premium package. But if you do go for the
premium package, you also get a heated steering wheel, a head-up display, a panoramic sunroof,
and better parking cameras. It's every bit as capable and confident as the system in the GV70,
you'll just have to change lanes yourself. Another couple of differences to the Genesis,
the brake pedal in the X3 is far more immediate. It's a little bit harder to be smooth,
but you're getting a lot more stopping power right at the top of the pedal.
Another thing I like is the powertrain in this is just so much more smooth and linear. You don't
feel that lurching or that surging that you get in the GV70. So the BMW, it feels a little cheap
in places, but there's a lot of space and it drives great, especially if you want to go big
on performance. Genesis made its name on value, but these days, yeah, it costs the same as a BMW.
But there's a catch. The Genesis comes with stuff like adaptive cruise control as standard that you
have to pay extra for on the BMW. That said, even if you pay a little bit more for the Beamer up
front, you might break even. Remember the big MPG difference I mentioned earlier? The EPA says that
a driver doing about 15,000 miles a year is going to save way, way more on gas when you're in the
Beamer, regardless of what engine you pick. So the money you'll spend is more or less a wash,
but what about value? You'd be wise to consider the Genesis's incredible warranty. The powertrain
warranty alone is almost double that of the BMWs. As for the dealership experience, there are 350
BMW dealerships across the country, only 70 dedicated Genesis dealerships across the country,
and they're centered around Florida, Texas, Illinois, and California. Genesis, I know,
is working on bringing more bespoke dealerships, but that's just the way things are right now.
You'll probably have a nicer experience at a dedicated Genesis dealership,
but that's only if you live close to one. If you don't, you'll have a decidedly
un-luxurious experience at one of the 200 Genesis-certified Hyundai dealerships across
the country. So which one takes home the gold? That is a little complicated. You see,
when we put them both up against our rating criteria, both cars won. There's no tie here,
it's just that they both excel in completely different areas. Here's how it shakes out.
This is the first nice thing you buy yourself when you've got the big job and you're making
a little bit more money. If you want something that feels truly luxurious all of the time,
get a fully loaded up four-cylinder GV70. It'll feel nice, it's got great materials,
you'll be perfectly happy. But if you want something with real performance credential,
get the B58 straight six in the X3 M50, because it is truly sports car fast and you're going to
have a blast behind the wheel. To me, the Genesis better sells that luxury experience, that feeling
for most people. Those high quality materials, that excellent build quality, it well supersedes
any shortcomings in terms of cargo space and fuel economy. If you want something with a traditional
luxury badge and you have a little bit more coin to spend, then the BMW is a solid choice too.
Just beware that the inside isn't quite as nice and might not be exactly what you're expecting.
As for me, I'd have the Genesis, but I'm not going to fault anyone for taking the BMW.
