Thanks to Storyblocks for sponsoring this video. Get a limited-time discount, only available through this link: http://storyblocks.com/jonlaw
Most productivity advice is complete BS, and in this video I break down exactly why. Instead of handing you another list of morning routines, apps, and discipline hacks that 99% of people quit within a few months, I walk through the two things that actually drive your output: circumstance and identity. I lay out the framework with a simple prison and 1,000-calorie thought experiment, explain why controlling your environment beats grinding on willpower, and dig into how your identity and self-perception quietly shape how productive you are without you ever noticing. If you've ever followed every productivity tip out there and still felt stuck, this is a completely different way to think about getting more done and actually changing your life. Big thanks to Storyblocks for sponsoring this one. If you want a stock media library where every clip, track, and template is 100% human-made with zero AI-generated footage, check the link below for 15% off an annual plan.
CHAPTERS: 0:00 Why Most Productivity Advice Is BS 0:16 What This Video Is Actually About 0:32 Sponsor: Storyblocks 100% Human-Made Stock Media 2:00 Productivity Comes Down to Circumstance or Identity 2:24 The Prison and 1,000-Calorie Thought Experiment 2:56 Controlling Inputs When Outputs Aren't Guaranteed 3:28 Why Circumstance Is a Powerful Productivity Frame 3:44 The "Work 14 Hours or Else" Example 4:20 How Money and Survival Drive Real Output 4:51 Circumstance as the Biggest Driver of Productivity 5:23 How Identity Quietly Shapes Your Behavior 5:54 Why Self-Perception Controls How Much You Do 6:42 The Feedback Loop Between Identity and Circumstance 6:58 Why Productivity Hacks and Self-Help Books Fail 7:13 The 99% Failure Rate of Productivity Tips 7:30 A Better Way to Actually Change Your Output 7:46 The Big Life Decisions That Change Who You Are 8:18 Final Thoughts
------------------- Clips channel @jonlawclips
I do NOT sell any products of my own. Watch out for scams.
The speaker argues that most conventional productivity advice is ineffective. Instead of relying on small hacks or discipline mantras, he proposes that productivity is primarily driven by two powerful forces: circumstance and identity. By focusing on these fundamental drivers rather than marginal habits, individuals can more effectively alter their output and life outcomes.
I think just about all productivity content is complete BS. I want to spend the next 10 minutes
explaining why and my observation about, number one, both the vastly superior frame for productivity
and, number two, a descriptive explanation for the world at large and behavior. Let me know if
you disagree. You might. That's fine. This will be a little bit of a different video. Again,
we're just here to talk about productivity, how to live your life, and how to do better
as a professional or a business owner. That's going to be the video. Let's hear a word from
our sponsor, and then we'll jump into it. Now, I spend most of my time on this channel talking
about AI, so it might surprise you that today's sponsor is built on the opposite idea, and that's
because my take is that there are some things where you should use AI all the time, and there
are some things where you just don't have to. Case in point is Storyblocks. They're a stock media
library where every single asset is 100% human made, so you have no AI-generated footage or music.
Every single clip, track, and template comes from a real filmmaker, artist, musician, or creative,
and you have millions of these assets that span just about everything you could possibly need.
And so you avoid any risk associated with AI footage in your videos, and you support real
creators, and over 150,000 content creators currently are using Storyblocks in their
video production workflows. So it's extremely easy to whitelist your channel so you can use
these assets and stay monetized. There's unlimited downloads, a plugin that lives inside of Premiere
Pro, and customizable templates to help you not only with footage but also with actual editing.
And Storyblocks say they save members on average about three and a half hours a week in that track,
so you can stay monetized, save time, and find better video assets. They also have this cool AI
toolkit that helps you edit better and also find footage. So if you want access to one of the
leading stock media libraries for content creators, you can go to this link on the screen or in the
description, and you will get 15% off an annual plan. That is 15% off and this link on the screen.
And that in mind, let's get back to the video. So the elevator pitch for this concept, or what I
observe about productivity and other people and to myself, is that nearly all of it, in terms of
output, comes down to one of two things. Number one, circumstance, or number two, identity. And
those tend to converge over time to one and the same. Depending on where you're at in your life,
they might be kind of different and they affect each other cyclically. But let's break down a
little bit what exactly that means, and I'm sure you can already start to think how that contrasts
with the standard frame of productivity. So the example that I've used before is if you were locked
in a prison, right, and someone comes in every day with 1,000 calories of food and slid you that plate
and closed the door and you ate it, and that is all the food you had per day, you would lose weight.
And so if we think about that through the lens of behavior, you didn't choose to change your
behavior, which prompted, for a lot of people, a goal like losing weight. Your circumstance changed,
and that regulated or drove the outcome. Now once we jump from motivation or things like that into
something like productivity, where you can control your input but the output is not guaranteed,
there is no 1,000 calorie equivalent, that becomes a bit murkier. But assuming we can control the
inputs, that logic, in theory, is the same. If you want to maximize the probability, maybe not
guarantee it, but maximize the probability of a given outcome in any situation, if we regulate
the circumstance or the environment. And so circumstance can be a powerful frame for productivity.
And so as a material example in that context, where we shift from the more prison-like
motivation frame into productivity, is if someone said, you have to work 14 hours a day,
otherwise something bad will happen to your family, you're probably going to do so. And what
a lot of people want out of their career or working is money. So what we're trying to maximize the
probability of getting the input is work. So by changing the circumstance or something exterior
to that individual, we are making them productive, each maximizing the chance that they'll make
money by controlling for that input, which is working more through that external frame of
circumstance of an exterior force, like someone saying, something bad will happen if you don't
do this. So that's the extreme, just to illustrate the concept. And if we think about that more
normally, right, generally, what we see is, if you have no money, you are more incentivized to
make money. And what is that? That is your circumstance. So the food you can afford to
eat, the number of vacations you can go on, stable housing, providing for your family,
the people you care about, that is your circumstance. And that more than anything,
I would argue, is going to drive how much people do in terms of work or their productivity in that
context. So to take that down a notch, if I look at the world, there's two things we mentioned
there. There's circumstance and there's identity. But I think circumstance is maybe the predominant
determinant of productivity. The external factors in your life, which push you in one way
or another, are going to regulate your productivity more than, at least the way I see it.
Anything, any little hack, any strategy, any setting alarms in the morning or buying this tool
or reading this book or personal mantra going to affect your life and regulate the outcome
or the set of outcomes that you are driving toward. That's what I mean by circumstance.
And then if we shift to identity, that ties more so into that frame of behavior. And part of what
I'm saying here is, hey, maybe it's less about behavior and more that your behavior is shaped
by your environment. But there's something so fundamental about identity, whether neurologically,
psychologically, I don't know what it is. But if I look at myself and the people around me,
and I ask, why are they as productive or not productive as they are? And I'm not saying
that's good or bad. They just, they are or they aren't within that frame of productivity,
of personal productivity. And then I strip out circumstance from it. Generally, what I see is
how they think of themselves, how they've internalized who they are as a person,
how other people see them, and what makes them valuable as a person is going to also, at a very
fundamental level, alter how they live their life and how, quote unquote, productive they are.
Does that mean that's a good thing in one way or another? No, that is a whole separate,
much longer discussion than the one presented in this video. But it's the same thing there.
If you want to change how productive you are, and I'm not saying you should,
change your identity, change your circumstances, change your identity. And maybe your circumstances
are what regulates your identity, right? You can start to see that feedback loop there.
But one way or another, that is a completely different frame than if you go on YouTube,
you type how to be more productive, or you read a self-help book, and you get this list of mantras
and things to do and how to have more discipline. The reality with all of those things is either
they are marginal, they're barely going to change things one way or another, or the probability of
failure is extremely high. If you look at a subset of 100 people who apply those things, 99% of them
are going to fail over the course of a month or six months or a year. If you want to fundamentally
affect any given outcome, you want to be more productive in that endeavor, whatever it is,
my observation is those two things and playing with those, and I've made other videos on how
materially to do that, is going to be a much better way to achieve the outcome. Whether you
want that outcome, again, is a whole different question. And that's about you. That's about your,
you know, religious beliefs. That's about how you view the world. That's about a lot of things
that we are obviously not going to cover here. And I think we do have more control over those
two things than we realize, just in a different way than we realize. It's less so about the small
things and more so the big thing, the city we choose to live in, the first job we take, or the
business we start. We have control over those things. We can change our life in very big or
very small ways. And the very big ones are the ones which are going to change you as a person,
and therefore the outcomes of that new person. That's my little spiel on productivity. Maybe
you disagree. Maybe you agree. Either way, I hope you found it interesting, maybe useful for you.
I appreciate your time and being here, and I will see you in the next one. Cheers.