tatus Coup reporter JT Cestkowski breaks down why New York Magazine seems so eager to shut down theories that Jeffrey Epstein may have been murdered — and why some journalists are pushing back. JT examines the magazine's arguments, brings in reporting from investigative journalist Julie K. Brown, and explores the unanswered questions that continue to fuel skepticism surrounding Epstein's death.
Status Coup is the leading INDEPENDENT ON-THE-GROUND reporting outlet in America that covers what the corporate media COVERS UP. We are FUNDED BY THE PEOPLE FOR THE PEOPLE—and need your support to help us stay ON-THE-GROUND. Join us as a paying member for as low as $5 bucks a month: https://www.statuscoup.com/join
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
J.T. Suskowski critiques New York Magazine for definitively claiming Jeffrey Epstein committed suicide. He argues that the magazine's conclusion is a leap of logic, as the New York Times investigation it references actually suggests the truth remains unknowable due to extreme negligence and a mishandled crime scene.
Bombshell Jeffrey Epstein did kill himself.
Extremely unlikely anyone would have been able to sneak into Epstein's unit,
despite the Times' investigation didn't even know how to tie a noose.
Covering what the corporate media covers up.
Hey, it's J.T. Suskowski with Status Q.
Well, that didn't take long.
There is already a media institution, in this case it's New York Magazine,
that is rushing to the defense of the global elite in the wake of a
bombshell New York Times investigation into the death of Jeffrey Epstein.
And New York Magazine is trying to claim that Jeffrey Epstein, don't worry,
did commit suicide despite the Times' investigation, deliberately concluding
that you cannot say for certain what happened to Jeffrey Epstein.
And walking back the New York Times' earlier assertions that Jeffrey Epstein did kill himself.
Let's get right into it.
This is the story from New York Magazine titled,
Jeffrey Epstein did kill himself.
It doesn't get more definitive than that.
We're actually going to start at the very bottom of this story, which reads,
in the end, based on the Times Magazine reporting,
it seems clear that Epstein's death could and should have been prevented.
But there is still no evidence to suggest that the incompetence and negligence of MCC staff
was intentional or part of some attempts to ensure Epstein's death and other inmates
did not notice any signs of foul play.
Apparently what New York Magazine is trying to assert here is that because there is not
affirmative evidence of murder, therefore, we have to conclude that it was a suicide,
which is, of course, not how evidence or arguments or burden of proof work.
And certainly not in this country.
And they actually go at length to quote from this story here,
which is the Times investigation titled, The Untold Story of Jeffrey Epstein's Death.
Notice that the Times, who actually did this investigation, did not title it
The Untold Story of Jeffrey Epstein's Suicide.
They deliberately title it Death because, as is quoted in New York Magazine, they say,
Some important questions about Epstein's death remain unanswered and likely unanswerable,
meaning we cannot know and do not know.
The Times does go on to note, however, that Epstein did show a clear pattern
of behavior in the weeks before his death, suggesting an intent to kill himself.
But intent does not mean that he did it.
The incomparable Julie K. Brown from The Miami Herald,
who broke open the Jeffrey Epstein story anew back in 2018,
said the story may have proven he was suicidal, but that doesn't mean he killed himself.
I've covered prison deaths for a good deal of my career.
Plenty of inmates are suicidal and consider suicide.
They don't end up dead like this.
Epstein didn't even know how to tie a noose.
That is the eminent journalist on all things Jeffrey Epstein.
She has been covering him for, at this point now, getting close to a decade, if not longer.
And it is, I take her word at face value.
I take what Julie K. Brown says with a great deal of seriousness.
I say this as someone who believes Jeffrey Epstein killed himself.
I still think that what New York Magazine is doing here is journalistic malpractice.
You cannot, in your headline, just definitively declare that Jeffrey Epstein killed himself
if you're not prepared to present evidence to that effect.
And they do have an article here that goes through, you know, what they would like to
call evidence, but all of their evidence has to be heavily caveated like this.
In this sentence, it is extremely unlikely that anyone would have been able to sneak
into Epstein's unit to kill him.
Note the extremely unlikely caveat there.
Not saying that it was impossible.
I mean, just that it was unlikely.
Unlikely does not mean that it could not have happened.
And it is irresponsible for a journalistic institution to just make the cognitive leap
and go right there.
Process of journalism should be in presenting facts, not merely conjecture.
And you've got to be able to back up what you say with facts.
Another one of their points that they use here is the physical evidence for homicide
is shaky, meaning non-existent.
There is some.
It's just not as solid, which is why no one is also concluding that Jeffrey Epstein certainly
killed himself, at least no institution with the ability to say so is.
So the physical evidence for homicide is shaky, and the scene of Epstein's death was mishandled.
This is almost a contradictory sentence.
The physical evidence for homicide is shaky and fully there.
And the scene of Epstein's death was mishandled.
Do you not see the contradiction there?
There could have been evidence that suggested murder, but because the scene was mishandled,
we have no way of knowing that.
Just like there could have been more definitive evidence of suicide, but the scene was mishandled.
You cannot use the fact that the scene was mishandled to say that therefore he could
not have killed himself, as if in all homicides, the scene is always going to be exactly correctly
handled.
Come on, New York Magazine, you have to be better than that.
You have to recognize you have to have some standards here, and your argument at least
has to make logical sense.
Coming back here to the article, MCC officials and guards were indeed shockingly negligent.
Again, that is a statement that could go either way towards bolstering the case for suicide
or homicide.
As the reporting indicates, the now closed Manhattan Correctional Center already had
a notorious reputation, and Epstein's incarceration was egregiously mismanaged.
Then they go on to quote at length from the Times story, but Epstein's incarceration
was egregiously mismanaged, meaning that he was not under 24-7 surveillance where someone
was keeping an eye on him at all times.
Yeah, that's the problem.
That's the problem.
That's why a lot of this is unknowable.
But that's what also, while it creates an opportunity for Epstein to have killed himself
because he is not being directly observed by somebody, that is what also allows people
to draw the same conclusion about Epstein was murdered because he's not being watched
24-7 to be able to say beyond a shadow of a doubt that he wasn't.
So you can't take the set of facts that New York Magazine is presenting out of the Times
investigation and present it as just blanket truth.
You just can't.
It's journalistically irresponsible.
In the same way that I carefully caveat everything I say, I let you know what my personal feelings
are.
I personally believe Jeffrey Epstein killed himself on the balance of what we know.
But I'm also not going to come out here and say that that is God's honest truth, like
that is the only thing that is possible here.
And any journalist who does tell you that is yanking you around.
For what reason?
For some kind of incentive structure that we can't see, that we can't know.
Or maybe they're just being irresponsible with the truth.
Jordan and I did a long live where we broke this down at length.
We will link it here in this video for you to follow through and click.
If you click up in the corner, you'll be able to get to that video.
And I should say that doing this kind of accountability journalism on the people who call
themselves journalists, it's expensive work.
And we're only able to do it with the support of our members.
If you want to be one of those members and help sustain the work that we do here at Status
Coup, go to statuscoup.com slash join for as low as $5 a month.
You go to keep us editorially independent and focused on the stories that matter to
real everyday people.