Coffee vs Tea: Which is Healthier? The Answer May Surprise You

Health Benefits of Tea
24 followers
1 Video ViewยทJun 18, 2026
AI GeneratedยทMay contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedBoth coffee and tea offer significant health benefits due to their high polyphenol and antioxidant content, which support heart health and brain function. While coffee generally has a slight edge in nutrient concentration and cognitive protection, both are excellent choices for gut health and immunity when consumed without dairy or harmful sweeteners.
Well, coffee and tea,
studies show they both have health benefits,
yet one of them does have a slight advantage.
Medical reporter Lori Johnson tells us
which one is the most healthy and why.
If we're going to reach for a hot cup of something,
which is healthier, coffee or tea?
Both, they're actually both incredibly good for you.
That's because they're both loaded with polyphenols,
Hippocrates, 2,500 years ago, the father of medicine,
said, all disease begins in the gut.
And quite frankly, I believe that all disease
begins and ends in the gut.
Polyphenols have been shown to improve heart health
and increase energy.
Coffee contains the most polyphenols,
particularly light and medium roast.
One very large national brand,
because of their dark roasting,
virtually has no polyphenols in their coffee.
And I won't mention the name.
After coffee, for the most part,
the highest polyphenol concentration
is found in green tea followed by black tea.
It's generally healthier if you don't add anything to them.
If you put any milk-based product,
like half and half, like plain old milk,
it completely binds with the polyphenols
in both tea and coffee
and makes them pretty worthless for you.
If you have to lighten them,
Dr. Gundry recommends non-dairy creamers
like coconut milk.
Sweeteners, both natural and artificial,
can cause health problems,
with the exception of non-GMO allulose.
Allulose is actually a prebiotic fiber
that actually lowers your blood sugar.
In addition to polyphenols,
both coffee and tea are chock full
of cancer-fighting antioxidants.
But coffee has more.
Coffee also contains more caffeine,
which, believe it or not,
is generally considered healthy,
especially for the brain.
Coffee drinkers, for instance,
have much lower dementia and Parkinson's disease
than non-coffee drinkers.
Too much caffeine, however,
can interfere with a good night's sleep.
So depending on the time of day,
sometimes tea is the better choice.
Black tea has more caffeine than green.
I have three cups of coffee in the morning
and then I switch over to tea
and I have about five cups of tea.
Two of the healthiest, Puerh and matcha.
You gotta make sure your matcha tea
does not come from China.
Most matcha tea does come from China,
so buyer beware, it is loaded with heavy metals
and other chemicals that you don't want.
So in the coffee versus tea smackdown,
coffee has the edge.
But really, they're both winners.
Okay, Laurie Johnson is here with more
and we've got a whole array of tea in front of us
and you left the coffee behind.
I thought coffee was really good.
It is very good, but tea is a little bit more confusing,
especially because there are these newcomers
on the market and this new sweetener.
Well, I can't say they're newcomers.
They've been around for 1,000 years.
It's true, they have.
They're sort of new to the United States.
Okay, talk about the Chinese one
and this is puree?
It's actually called Puerh.
Puerh.
Rhymes with Puber.
That's how I remember it, Puerh tea.
So this Puerh tea is special because it's fermented
and a lot of people will, you know,
a light bulb goes off when you say the word fermented
because we know that fermented foods
are generally very good for our gut
because they have those wonderful probiotics,
the good bacteria, and we know that a healthy gut
is directly related to strong immunity,
especially this time of year.
We're all thinking about ways to strengthen our immunity
and by the way, Gordon, as you know
and many of our viewers know,
we have a whole booklet about how to build a better gut.
It's called Build a Better Gut
and you can go to our website, CBN.com,
to learn how to get a free one.
Because it's fermented, it's got probiotics in it.
That's the big selling point.
Another really good thing about Puerh tea
is that it's been shown to lower cholesterol
more than other teas
and some people call Puerh tea nature statin.
Well, I can't pronounce it, but I have had it.
It is an unusual taste.
I like it.
I drink it without anything in it.
I actually make a pot, put it in the refrigerator
and drink a cup of Puerh tea with my vitamins
in the morning.
Oh, so you have it chilled.
Yeah, and then this I have usually right around
one o'clock in the afternoon because it does contain caffeine
and I'm sensitive so I can't drink it much.
That one says chocolate on it.
Yeah, that's why I like it.
It's chocolate Puerh tea.
Yeah, so that's good.
Okay, green tea.
Now, I've actually had a Japanese tea ceremony
with a brush and they create a slurry out of it
and it's old.
The samurai used to use it every day
as a strengthener for warfare.
So, tell us about why we should,
you've got this.
Matcha tea.
Well, that's because I'm a cheapskate, Gordon.
So, what you want to do is get the nice bamboo whisk
that they have at the wonderful Japanese restaurants
and I know I've seen that before too.
It's really fun.
But I've got this at the dollar store.
But what makes matcha tea so special,
unlike other green teas,
is you're actually drinking the whole leaf.
Other green teas, you steep it in hot water
and then you throw the leaves away.
This is actually the whole leaf
that is ground up into a powder
that you mix with water.
Okay, and it's almost like a soup.
It is and it's actually a lot more concentrated
and so those wonderful health benefits
that are in green tea are even concentrated here
because you're having all the whole leaf.
And it's also such a beautiful color, isn't it?
Interestingly, about a month before harvesting,
the growers cover it and so that's what gives it
this beautiful, bright green color,
whereas other green teas are sort of like a brownish green.
Okay, I'm kind of a tea snob.
So I get tea from India and Darjeeling
and Single Estate, not blends.
Why should I change to these?
Well, Dr. Gundry recommends these two particular brands.
Actually, before I interviewed him,
I drank Pu-erh tea and matcha tea from a different company.
But he, I said, tell me which ones you drink.
And he says, these are the ones that I drink every day.
And they both come from Japan
and he has some issues with tea from China,
specifically matcha tea from China.
He said that can be problematic.
So these two brands come from Japan.
Well, I've gotten tea from China, too.
It's really good and particularly Hunan province
is phenomenal tea.
So not every tea has this, but it's the green tea.
His main concern was matcha tea from China.
But I'm like you, too.
I also drink matcha tea that's organic from China.
So that's just his preference.
What about the ones from Taiwan?
I know we're getting deep in the weeds.
I don't know about Taiwan, yeah.
But I would think that any tea is better than no tea.
Okay, and what you're doing is you're building your gut.
Absolutely, these polyphenols.
And the green tea doesn't have as much caffeine,
so in the afternoon, take that.
What about the fermented tea?
This has a little bit more caffeine, still less than coffee.
And what you really wanna watch out for,
when you're talking about caffeine,
problems with caffeine, espresso,
and also some of these energy drinks.
Caffeine, you do.
In the morning.
Right, so.
I'm now no coffee after 9 a.m.
Oh, after 9 a.m., okay.
My cutoff is like one.
So tea in the afternoon, coffee in the morning.
And you get the best of both worlds.
Yeah, that's right.
All right, Lori, thanks for the info.
And if you want to get that Protect Your Gut,
all you have to do is go to cbnnews.com
and there'll be a place you can order.
You can also go to cbn.com.
