Hillary Clinton Surprisingly Says She Is Not Ready to Label Israel s Actions in Gaza a Genocide

Hillary Clinton
2 followers
#HillaryClinton #Israel #Gaza
Join this channel to get access to perks:
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker discusses the current impossibility of a two-state solution and suggests that Trump's 20-point plan for Gaza offers a viable, albeit contested, pathway toward security and reconstruction. The conversation also examines the Biden administration's role, the trauma of October 7th, and the immense tactical difficulties Israel faced regarding Hamas's tunnel networks.
Let's stay in the same region for a moment.
I know that you're for a two-state solution and see it as the only
outcome that any kind of peace can exist.
But if I look at the Israeli polity, they don't want a two-state solution,
certainly not now. And if you look at the Palestinian
polity, which is an even more complicated set of
geographies and population,
two-state solution is not anywhere near the offing
there. So other than, you know, some constituents,
now it's diminishing, in the West and elsewhere,
a two-state solution, which was fought for so hard but began going
out the window many years ago, seems impossible. Am I
wrong? You might be, but you might not be. And
I'm going to say something positive about Trump.
So hold on. Okay. I've got a grip on my chair right now.
Trump's 20-point plan for Gaza is
actually a pathway to security for Israel,
reconstruction for Gaza, and the possibility of
self-determination, however defined, for the Palestinians.
There are a lot of people who, you know, reject it because Trump did it,
but it's the only game in town. There's nothing else.
And I've engaged in some, you know, kind of track two diplomacy with
Israelis, not in the current government, former governments,
military, intelligence, political officials,
Palestinians, Arabs. So it's a very, you know, it's a very
painful discussion because, you know, these are experienced
people with lots of scars to show for their efforts over many years, not
just on peace but on security, particularly for Israel.
But I really believe if we took this 20-point plan,
which starts with, you know, the disarmament of Hamas,
a huge, important step yet to be accomplished,
but took all of the 20 points so that it wasn't just disarm Hamas and,
you know, maybe do some reconstruction and, you know, build some
resorts on the coast. But if you really took the whole
approach that is embodied in that 20-point plan,
and I know there are people who are working
to try to move forward on that, there is a glimmer of a possible
path forward. Now, having said that, you are dealing with
two peoples that are even more traumatized than
perhaps has happened in the past. I think you had Rachel Goldberg-Pollan
on your podcast last week and, you know, I met her
during the time when I was trying to help and support
families who were advocating to get the hostages back.
And it's, you know, she writes this very moving,
profoundly sad book about her son, Hirsch. And we've had
Mohamed Mawish and Mossad Abu Toh who lost multiple members of their family.
And I've met with them as well. And did the Biden administration
fail to push hard against the Netanyahu government? Did it give
too free a rein to the Israeli government?
You know, I think it's a very, very hard question to answer for this
reason. As I said, October 7th was a mass
trauma event. Clearly, the people who were murdered,
the families who lost loved ones, the hostages,
250 plus who were taken into Gaza. It was a long,
terrible trauma. And what I said to my class at Columbia after
October 7th is, you have to keep competing thoughts in your head.
A hundred percent. But Biden came to Israel. And the
wisest thing, it seems to me, that he said was,
I feel your pain. I understand how horrible this is.
We support you. But at the same time, do not
repeat our mistakes and act out of prolonged vengeance. He was obviously
referring to Afghanistan and even more so to Iraq,
the misadventures there, to say the least, and the damage they did and the lives
lost there. And I think a lot of people would say
that is exactly what Israel went ahead and did by such a
prolonged war and that the United States and the Biden administration and later
the Trump administration did very little
to put a pause to it. You know, I think
that, and again, I wasn't there. I don't know what the
internal discussions were. But every time, what I would hear, every
time, especially while the hostages were
still being held, every time there was a push
against Israel to change tactics, to avoid certain targets, you know, the
response would be, we know that there are tunnels.
We know there are something like 350 miles of tunnels. We know that they
can be entered through a lot of these sites.
And, you know, it's very difficult to refute that
because we know that there were tunnels and we know that
numbers of them entered into hospitals and
schools and all kinds of civilian places. Could and should the Israelis
have been more careful with civilian casualties?
Absolutely. There's no doubt about that. But did they have a response to,
you know, what they were trying to accomplish, rescuing hostages,
you know, getting access to Hamas leadership and fighters in these
tunnels? They did. And trying to walk that line
in the middle of a war is very hard. So I try to imagine myself, I'm sitting,
you know, in CENTCOM and talking to the Israeli
military. I'm sitting, you know, at the CIA and talking to
Mossad. And they are coming back not with,
you know, totally unbelievable claims. They're coming back with,
here's what our intelligence tells us. Here's, you know, we think if we can get
there, get there. Maybe we can, you know, get Sinwar.
Maybe we can, you know, rescue hostages. And the fog of
war was, like, totally overwhelming. So
in retrospect, could they, should they have done more?
You can always say yes and you can always hope so.
