Rye Barcott, co-founder and CEO of With Honor, veteran of the U.S. Marine Corps, and author of Courage Can Save Us, joins School of War to discuss the meaning of courage, the enduring value of service, and the challenge of bridging America’s growing political divides. What separates courage from bravery? Can military service help heal a polarized America? And what does principled leadership look like in an age of distrust? #Gjwnews#WorldNewsUpdates#Neutral#worldnews
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Rye Barcott, a Marine veteran and CEO of \"With Honor,\" explores the distinction between instinctive bravery and conscious courage. He discusses his military career, the psychological toll of war, and his mission to combat affective polarization in U.S. politics by leveraging the unique, cross-partisan leadership qualities of veterans to foster bipartisanship and selfless public service.
It's not easy to find someone these days who thinks that the future of American politics
might be bipartisanship and selfless service.
But my guest today, Rye Barcott, gives us an optimistic case.
Let's get into it.
It is the 54th war this block invasion has plagued.
December 7, 1941, a date which will live in infamy.
The bloody experience of Vietnam is to end in a state of panic.
We continue to face a threat of a new war.
Hi, I'm Aaron McLean, thanks for joining School of War.
I am delighted to welcome to the show today, Rye Barcott.
He is the co-founder and CEO of With Honor, a political nonprofit that fights polarization
in Congress with principled veteran leadership.
I'm reading that from your materials there, Rye.
You're a Marine, Semper Fi, author now of two books, most recently and the one we're
really going to discuss today, Courage Can Save Us, 10 Extraordinary Americans in the
Fight for Our Future, and before that, a memoir of your own service, It Happened on the Way
to War.
Rye, thank you so much for joining School of War.
Thanks.
Great to be on.
I am, if I'm moving slow for the folks on video, I completed a Murph yesterday and I'm
feeling it.
Tell the folks at home what a Murph is.
A Murph is named after the late Navy SEAL Lieutenant Murphy, who was killed in action
in Afghanistan, and it is a routine, often done on Memorial Day, of two one-mile runs,
a hundred pull-ups, 200 push-ups, and 300 squats.
And if you want extra credit, you run it, I actually have it right here, you run it
with your flak jacket.
This one actually has the old sappy plates.
Don't tell me how I acquired my old sappy plates.
There's a SIF staffer Marine back there, and I don't remember if you were Lejeune or Pendleton,
but somewhere.
He's still looking for those, dude.
Think of the pain.
Oh, no, I think they charged me for them.
It was like, you know.
Yeah, because we had the new, the better body armor was coming out at the, you know, I was
getting out in 2005, the better part, or at 06, rather, the better stuff was coming out.
So they were like, all right, Marines, you can buy them for, you know, 50 bucks or something.
There you go.
And I, you know, never use them except for one day a year, Memorial Day, go for my run.
So I want to talk to you about this new book, which opens with a really arresting story
of essentially how you came to think about serving one day.
And like so many of us, it was a story of a close family member.
In your case, your father, who served as a Marine in Vietnam.
There's an extraordinary anecdote involving you finally finding out about what a scar
in his cheek, what caused it.
Let's start by just you telling us that story, because it was quite arresting and remarkable,
right?
Yeah.
I mean, like both of us, my father served.
He did not make it a career, but he was sort of in the Vietnam generation, and he volunteered
for Vietnam with Phil Caputo, who we just lost another great writer a couple of weeks
ago.
And they were, they were friends in 1965, 1966.
And he was a Marine recon officer, and he had this scar on his face that reminded some
of my friends when I was, you know, around 10 years old of Barnes in platoon.
The he's got this scar on his face because my father was shot in the face and miraculously
survived on an, on an ambush.
Well, one of the other rounds during that ambush was heading for his heart and was intercepted
by a smoke grenade.
I actually had the smoke grenade.
It's right back there.
It's just like a, it's encased in a wax.
Is it sorry.
Sorry.
Is it, is it in the, it's in the white, like the white thing over your shoulder there?
We're on video.
Oh, and we see your teammate there too.
That's a, that's impressive.
There we go.
Yeah.
I got my, I got my wingman here.
Yeah.
Show it.
I'm actually want to see this.
Yeah.
This is, it's it.
Well, I remember feeling like almost a mystical force touching this, like truly for the first
time, but that's the smoke grenade.
And so the round went in right here and then like basically blew out the back of it.
Wow.
And you know, saved his life and enabled mine because I definitely, that was a, that was
a close call for dad.
And you know, I I, I became very fascinated by the idea of courage from that moment.
And my father never, of course, referred to it as courage.
You wouldn't be such a, you know, such a, such a guy.
But but clearly it was.
And I think the courage moment, as I came to understand, it was not how he responded
in the moment.
But it was that he continued to serve afterwards.
So he was given a chance to go, you know, go in the rear with the gear, but he chose
to continue to serve as a recon platoon commander for six months and carry out his, his tour.
And that is really how I think about courage, that courage, whoops.
Courage is, is distinct from bravery in so far as bravery can be, both are noble.
Bravery can be instinctive.
It can be, it's can, it can be in the moment.
It can be not deliberate.
You know, you, we develop our muscle memory and our training to respond hopefully in moments
when so called.
And the other, but courage, on the other hand, is a, it's, it's a decision.
It is actually weighing the risks and making a conscious choice.
And it's making a choice that is serving something larger than yourself.
Bravery can serve the self-interest or it can be, you know, more selfless, but courage
is always serving something that's larger than yourself.
In this case for, for dad, you know, it was most for, you know, foremost the Marines in
his platoon.
And so that was the first moment that, that, that I started really getting interested in
it and thinking honestly about service myself.
And my father's reaction to the Marine Corps service was one, he was, he was certainly
proud.
He was not encouraging though, necessarily of the service because he fought in a war
that he believed was just filled with bad decisions.
And at times if not lies, you know, misinformation and misleading statements you know, HR McMaster
writes his famous book about dereliction of duty and so on and so forth.
But the, you know, my father's example and going through that really planted in my mind
both an interest in courage, which becomes the topic of this book, and then a commitment
to trying to do, you know, live my life in a way that it has a service as a part of it.
And you know, ended up applying for ROTC from, from that point on.
So we'll come back to the story here in a second, but just to linger on your distinction
between bravery and courage, which is, I don't think I've heard that distinction made before,
at least as, as, as cleanly or unintentionally as you've just made it.
And it, you know, puts me when I just, I'm embarrassed to say I only for the very first
time this past weekend, watched the movie First to Fight.
Have you seen this movie, Rye?
Here's a good Marine Corps test for you.
Yeah.
Well, I would have failed until last week anyway.
Are you, are you familiar with it?
It's one of Gene Hackman's first movies about Marines in the Pacific.
First on Guadalcanal and then later in the Island Happening campaign.
It's, it's magnificent.
And it's loosely, and emphasis on loosely here for reasons that will become obvious
in a moment, based on the career of John Basilone in the sense that the lead actor who I'd never
seen in anything before, Chad Everett, and this movie's from the 60s, it's a 1967 movie.
And I think already has shades of like Vietnam kind of coloring it, even, even though the
Marine Corps obviously sort of robustly supports it.
But the main character, you know, we meet him on Guadalcanal.
He and his buddies repulse a Japanese assault.
And it is basically the John Basilone story.
He's like last man standing, you know, lifting the machine gun out of the position, you know,
firing it from the standing, the final protective fires and receives the Medal of Honor and heads
back to the United States and tours around, meets a nice girl, falls in love, gets married,
and then is sent back to the Pacific.
So up till now, this is all the John Basilone story.
And of course, as many listeners may know, Basilone then goes back into action on Iwo
Jima.
Iwo Jima is killed in action, highly decorated again, I think he gets the Navy Cross the
second time around, if I'm not mistaken.
Well, in the movie, things diverge.
And it's very interesting that the character basically suffers from a breakdown on the
battlefield when he goes back into it.
Has real combat stress, can't make to see.
He got a battlefield commission, by the way, so he's a platoon commander now and basically
breaks down in combat.
And there are these riveting scenes where Gene Hackman, who plays the salty sergeant,
who's the platoon sergeant, has to deal with the platoon that has this like famous, nationally
famous war hero as their platoon commander, who obviously can't hack it.
Hackman is the guy who like has to hold it together.
It's sort of dark.
It's complicated.
Hackman kind of saves the main character in the end, he kind of bucks him up and the main
character, you know, it's a Hollywood movie, so the main character, you know, it saves
the day in the end and re-unlocks his heroism.
But it's a pretty gritty movie.
The combat scenes, even if they don't look like Saving Private Ryan exactly, like in
terms of the way the characters react, like they're clearly written and made by people
who know what real combat is.
It's a pretty good movie, truth be told.
And so, sorry, that was a long summary.
But the reason I cite it is because in the Guadalcanal scenes, the protagonist, he's
reactive.
Now, he reacts in a way that's incredibly brave, indeed, unusually and conspicuously
brave.
But then he carries, you know, the guilt from, you know, sort of survivor's guilt from it
as well.
And then when he's back in the action, now with a wife, now with something at home to,
you know, to really reflect on and a lot of time to reflect about what's coming and the
new responsibility of being an officer and all the eyes on him before he was in the ranks
and no one paid a great deal of attention to him before he did this incredible thing.
And, you know, he struggles.
He struggles with his courage dramatically.
It's a good flick.
And it's funny that you give that distinction because the movie seems to me to illustrate
something like it.
Yeah.
And it's interesting.
I'm right.
My son is 13 years old and he's a big history buff now, which I'm thrilled about.
And we're in the middle of, we're about to finish Laura Hildebrand's amazing book, Unbroken.
And we're in a spot where the protagonist, the real life protagonist, Louis, is going
through the trauma of reintegration.
And so he comes out of this incredible, this unbelievable journey in World War II where
he's a Japanese prisoner of war, Japan, and he kind of holds it together for a while.
And then it comes rushing back at him.
And I think, you know, for me, as I think about courage and my distinction is a little
bit of a distinct, you know, it's a unique distinction, but it comes from the Stoics
and some of the Greek writing originally.
Courage can, you aspire to it, but, you know, you hope that you meet the moment when the
moment comes.
Just because you had it at one point doesn't necessarily mean that you can continue to
rise to the occasion when it presents itself.
But I view it as a rare occurrence for most humans, you know.
Now if you're serving in a combat scenario as you did in Marjah, I believe that almost
every moment that you are serving requires a degree of courage.
Why?
Because you have made a choice to be there.
You are in harm's way.
So there's a level of courage for just being in the service.
But then there are also these, you know, moments in time.
And that's what I've tried to do with these profiles is say, okay, what were the key moments
of both physical courage and moral courage?
And, you know, occasionally you'll see the fusion of the two.
Well, let's talk about Fallujah, which if I'm not mistaken, was kind of the capstone
of your time in the infantry.
So we'll go back to your joining up.
This is the last thought, but certainly any Marines listening should check out First to
Fight.
I just love Gene Hackman too.
And of course, as you know, he was a Marine in real life.
And so his performance, you know, he doesn't really look like a movie star even as a young
guy.
And his performance is just phenomenal.
I mean, it's like, oh, this is the real thing.
This is actually exactly what it would look like for an NCO to find himself in this unenviable
set of circumstances.
Well, I'm definitely going to go watch it.
And I'm thinking about With the Old Breed right now, which is one of the few books that
I've read, you know, more than once.
Also a chronicle of that point in time.
Don't let it on that Marines can read, right?
It's unsettling to the people.
So there you are, you decide to join.
What year did you go in?
What were you anticipating from your Marine service?
Because you joined a little before 9-11, right?
I did.
Yeah.
I was, well, I was ROTC and I was, just a point of correction, I was a CI human guy
in the Marines, not an infantry officer, but went in ROTC at UNC Chapel Hill.
And I signed up in 1998 and then ended up going into the fleet and was at the basic
school when September 11th happened.
And so I was expecting a very different type of service, you know, at that time we were
preparing for peacekeeping missions, you know, interventions of ethnic strife.
That was, that was the, that was the, this was the age of, you know, Francis Fukuyama
writing about the end of history, you know, so much for that, right?
I remember taking in college, a class on nationalism.
It was a seminar on nationalism.
There were only about 20 folks.
I ended up meeting my wife there of all, of all places.
But as we were sitting there taking the class, most of us were thinking, you know, is this
relevant for our lives?
And really no, no vantage point of kind of what was to come.
But yeah, I was at the basic school when September 11th happened.
Remember being, we were getting ready to go out into the field.
We were still in the barracks at the time and, and, you know, froze and started watching,
watching what was transpiring.
And then we were, we were all quite envious of the IOC guys, the, the folks in infantry
officer course, you know, down the hall because they were mobilized to go provide a first
response at the, at the Pentagon.
Oh, fascinating.
I didn't know that that had happened.
I was still a junior in college.
And I just remember the Marines bringing out, the Marines still guarded the Naval Academy
at that time.
I was across the street at the Hippie Liberal Arts College, St. John's also in downtown
Annapolis.
And the Marines brought out all the, you know, the, the medium machine guns and stuff to
guard the gates at the Academy.
And I remember thinking to myself that it seemed unlikely to me that Al-Qaeda was going
to take a swing in Annapolis.
I mean, you never know, anything could happen, but they were certainly taking it very seriously.
I didn't know that IOC went to the Pentagon.
Yeah.
It was again, we were all thinking, oh man, we're going to miss the war.
Of course, of course we're thinking we're going to miss the war, you know, and little
did we know.
Little did you know.
I'm not going to say every Marine that's come on this show is a former CI human officer,
but it is definitely like an overrepresented constituency because now it's you, it's Matt
Pottinger, it's Mike Gallagher.
I mean, you are an overrepresented constituency.
Thanks for coming on and dealing with that.
Those are two great guys.
And just as an aside, Mike Gallagher helped us set up with honor, the organization that
I lead now.
And Matt Pottinger really kind of helped us put into tradition something that we just
completed last week for the eighth time, and that was the cleaning of the Vietnam wall.
So we gathered the vets in Congress and cleaned the wall before Memorial Day, and this time
we did it with the three surviving Vietnam vets.
But Pottinger was aware of that from when he was deputy national security advisor and
went to Australia because there is a remembrance day in Australia and that is part of their
tradition is that their elected officials go out and humble themselves and clean the
memorials to their sacred war dead.
So help me understand the shape of your active duty service.
So you had some non-Iraq Afghanistan deployments.
Was the deployment to Fallujah at the end the only Iraq one or just to walk me through
what happened?
Yeah, it was, you know, CIHUMA was such a unique kind of MOS, we were deployed all around
the world.
We still had guys in Marines in Bosnia and the Horn of Africa.
And so for my first two deployments, the first one was in Bosnia, right when the invasion
was happening in Iraq.
And we were essentially going after war criminals.
And then there was a bit of a counterterrorism element there.
And so that was a deployment for six months as a second lieutenant.
And then came back and went to the Horn of Africa where we had our base, we still have
our base in Djibouti.
And that was, we were mostly doing missions, also kind of counterterrorism focused along
the Somali border and in Yemen.
And that was 2004, 2005.
And then in 2005, you know, a lot of people forget that we had a stop loss in the Marines.
We basically didn't have enough Marines.
And I was very, very eager to get to the front lines after having these two deployments.
So I deployed as our company executive officer initially and attached to regimental combat
team five and eight with two CIHUMA teams.
And the fifth or the eighth Marines at the time was led by then Colonel Dave Berger,
who would later become commandant.
And then Colonel Larry Nicholson took over RCT five.
Fallujah, this was after the battle, still very active in terms of the counterinsurgency
efforts.
We were essentially trying to stand up, you know, a Fallujah city council.
And that was a perilous job in and of itself.
I think most of the council members were getting kind of picked off every few months.
And we were still going after Zarqawi at the time.
So that was it.
That was my final assignment.
And then left active duty after five year period of time.
Well, General Nicholson, of course, was my brigade commander in Afghanistan.
And then General Berger, I never met him until I was out and he was commandant.
And I was a congressional staffer, still sort of dealing with the vertigo, the disorientation
of having been an officer and a company grade officer that only relatively recently to,
you know, working for a Senator on the Armed Services Committee and being treated accordingly
by officers who previously would not have treated me that way.
Not that they would treat me badly, but you know what I mean.
I would have been seen and not heard at best.
And I distinctly, to illustrate this, I distinctly remember that Marines are very
good at congressional relations, as we both know.
And one element of that is the commandant always hosts a holiday party just for congressional
staffers, not for the members, which is kind of genius when you think about it.
And so in we go to his house.
And I think he's the only server.
I believe he's the only one that, anyways.
All I know is I didn't get invited to any others just for staffers.
I certainly staffed at other events.
But to be, you know, to be actually the guest was unique.
And again, a kind of illustration of the Marines' cleverness.
And I just remember walking in the door of the commandant's residence and, you know,
there's General Berger in a sweater with his wife.
And he's like, hey, I'm Dave.
And I think I even joked with him at the time.
It's good we're having this conversation now and not 10 years earlier, because I don't
know, I don't think I would have handled it quite as well 10 years earlier.
But I remember he was such a great commander.
And we were actually in a Humvee that they got hit by a 155.
Everybody was fine with it.
But he immediately, immediately turned to the Marine in the turret and, you know, started
basically providing first aid to him.
And he was a great commandant, too.
He actually makes an appearance in this book in one of the chapters because he took a real
interest in what some of the vets were doing in Congress to help create the 988 National
Mental Health Hotline, suicide hotline initially for vets, and now it's, you know, national.
And Berger came and said to me during an interview, he said, you know,
it's important for people to know that this exists, and it's hard to ask for help.
So when it came out, I wrote to the vets that were involved with it.
Gallagher was involved with it, a few others, and said, this thing matters.
I'm going to put out an ALMAR and let Marines know about it.
And so within about a week, the Marines knew that this thing existed and, you know, their
commandant said that it was fine to use it, you know, get over the stigma.
I'll also go as far as saying that his highly controversial actions with force design
back when he was commandant, based on what's going on in the Persian Gulf
now and in the Black Sea, and you sort of see how warfare is evolving through the 2020s.
I don't know.
It's hard to go back and mount a, I think, effective criticism, at least of the direction
he was taking.
I mean, it was complicated, and there are lots of elements, and anyone can quibble with
the details, but the notion that the Marine Corps was going to stay relevant by, you know,
essentially doing sea denial from really austere places where life might get super unpleasant,
and that's what we should be prepared for.
I don't know.
Seems like a pretty decent thesis, really.
Yeah.
Well, if you think about, like, moments of courage, there's some courage in that.
Again, you know, regardless of where you come down on this, that Marine General took on
the industrial complex and the K Street lobby, and that is not an easy battle always, you
know, and he was doing it for, he was trying to find the truth, you know?
And so, yeah, I think it was commendable, both the ideas behind it as well as the fact
that he put on the hard hat and went after it, but especially with regard to this incident
in particular.
You know, he's a Marine General.
He cares about the 18- and 19-year-old Marines that make up the majority of the Marine Corps.
So tell me about your day-to-day in Fallujah.
What was the target set like?
What were your Marines doing?
What was the actual work there?
Yeah, CIHUMINT guys were basically, we had teams attached to every infantry battalion.
My team was attached to the recon battalion, and we were essentially rolling out with our
units.
Most of the activity was happening at night.
It was typically, you know, raiding houses and then try to collect information about
where the enemy location was and neutralize threats and, of course, going after target
number one, which was Zarqawi at the time.
We made some headway on him, but he was killed a few months after my particular deployment
ended.
There was a lot of uncertainty in that environment.
It didn't really matter what your MOS was.
The IED's threat was pretty robust at that point in time.
I remember leaving the deployment, and Iraq was, I mean, front and center in the news.
This was right before the surge, but every day it was right up there in the headlines,
in part because we were losing so many Americans.
I remember thinking to myself, how the hell do we get out of this thing?
I'm in a field that is focused on intelligence and understanding what was going on, and I
basically felt like we had a real lack of clarity on how we could figure out an end
state here.
I was basically incorrupt.
It was a captain, so there are many layers above me, but what I had not really put together
was just the sectarian violence and how, essentially, that could be addressed by
factors outside of our control.
Well, not necessarily outside of our control, but what we ended up seeing with the Sunni
awakening, where you had, essentially, a group of tribal elders decided to turn on
the terrorist elements instead of wage war against both of us.
So, let's talk about everything that's come since.
The organization with honor, the political work that you've done, the book, of course,
which is a profile of some of the prominent veterans who have passed through with honor.
Put it to you this way, and I'm curious your response to this.
I mean, this is an organization that's devoted to, I don't think you use the word
bipartisan, do you?
Is it trans-partisan?
Yeah, cross-partisan.
And basically, the reason why we say that is that we'll support third-party
independents if they're viable.
Obviously, these days, most is done within the two-party framework.
So, cross-partisan about a vibrant middle, sort of.
I mean, these are my words, so reject any that you see fit, as you see fit, obviously.
And combating polarization.
Seems like a pretty tough row to hoe here in 2026, right?
What do you think?
Yeah, we've clearly not hit our mission accomplished yet because we've been at this
thing for like nine years, you know.
It is tough work.
But one of the things that I find encouraging is that there is a group of vets that,
again, they don't necessarily agree on much from the policy perspective, but they're still
able to have trust and talk about serious subjects and get some things moving in an
environment that's pretty corrosive.
And we really need that, especially as we see the threats that we're in right now with
the pace of technological change, our rising adversaries, we have to be able to at least
have some spaces where we can trust one another and have serious conversations and not worry
about the guy or lady that is a member next to you going out and tweeting what you just
said or weaponizing what you just said in a closed-door session where you're trying
to get to the truth.
Yeah.
I'm curious, given that your mission really is to fight polarization, and you're doing
so through the means of supporting veterans who to you seem to represent something that
pushes back against it.
You know, why are where we are?
It would be hard to find anyone who disagreed with the notion that our politics are polarized.
I think you might find people who roll their eyes at it, not because they necessarily reject
the characterization, but because in their view, it's entirely the fault of the other
side, if that makes sense.
What is your account for why we are where we are?
Yeah, I mean, I think that's a really important piece to it first is that the polarization
that we see is the most problematic of it is the affective polarization, what's called
affective, A-F-F, affective.
And what that is speaking to is how Americans increasingly view the others as the enemy,
as opposed to ideological polarization, which is about really the underlying ideas or policies.
Don't get me wrong, both exist, you know, affective and ideological, but the affective
is really tough to break through.
And when you look at the numbers, I mean, the estimates now are as high as like 80%
of registered Republicans and Democrats viewing the other side as the enemy.
You know, just pause for a moment and kind of let that sink in, right?
Yeah, now if we think about, you know, who registers, about 40% of Americans don't register
either way, are pretty checked out.
Some of those are pretty checked out.
Some are more partisan, but they're not registered.
Among those that are registered, you got a third and a third.
And, you know, that is the environment and the context that we're living in, in part,
based on how we, you know, consume information.
So, the problem is around identity, in part, not just ideas and rational thinking, right?
And I think that this is one area where, and I believe, and part of the reasons why I give
my best hours to this, I wrote this book, is that the common experience of service,
particularly military service, forces every American to work with individuals that do not
think like they do on a common mission that matters for the country.
And that is fundamentally a good thing.
And it also happens to be an 80-20 issue.
I mean, maybe even higher than an 80-20 issue.
Most Americans, irrespective of their tribe, believe that service, particularly military
service, at a young age is formative, does make a difference in terms of not only living better,
healthier lives, but also helping to unify the country.
So, that's part of the reason why this organization came about and said,
all right, you know, veterans in Congress used to be about 70% back in the era of our fathers.
That is now right around 20%.
It's still higher than the population in the United States,
but it's lower.
But that group is one of the few groups that not only understand how to work with individuals from
different viewpoints, but also happens to be one of the only groups that's still left in
the United States that has trust across party lines.
And we measure this each year with Gallup.
It's not the highest trust.
The highest trust belongs to our nurses, actually, as a group.
But it is one of the few groups in America that, again, has that trust across party lines.
That's a sacred thing.
I remember when we were first starting the organization, the late Senator John Warner
was part of our group in his 90s, World War II and career war vet.
And he said that he recalled to us, and he recalled to the vets that were in Congress
and that are part of this organization, there were about 20 at the time, we had a little
conference.
And he said, hey, guys, just don't take it for granted.
When I came back from the Korean War, the country was in a very different place.
I wasn't wearing my uniform when I've traveled across country in the train.
And what you have right now is a sacred level of respect.
Albeit a lot of Americans are disconnected more and more from the military, but you have a level
of respect and don't take that for granted and use that as an asset to actually make
this place a better place.
The service element is kind of our North Star.
It's remarkable that the military has maintained this position, given the pressure politically
that it's under.
And I can kind of both sides this, and I'm curious your response to this.
I mean, from the left, in popular memory, it really is sort of a function and sort of
peaks during Vietnam, but the simmer is always there.
That there's something inherently conservative, inherently suspicious about the military.
A lot of what gets rolled out is, I haven't done a lot of Civ Mil, civil military relations
episodes for a variety of reasons.
One of them is I'm a little suspicious of the Civ Mil literature, which seems to me to sometimes
amount to like, oh my gosh, have you heard that they're kind of conservative in the military?
That's kind of a problem.
So that's, you know, the left has a sort of wary eye on the military for that reason.
And then from the right, as very vividly demonstrated by, I think, the current Secretary
of War, I mean, these are words he would say himself.
I mean, in his estimate, the military is certainly a noble place full of good people,
but it's been sort of glommed onto or captured in his critique by an officer corps that has
been captured by liberal elite society.
And so it's very clear that Secretary Hegseth sees, you know, part of his job as to dismantle
that.
So those are two pretty powerful forces to be trapped between.
The left wing critique that this whole thing is a little fishy.
Don't you guys like war a little bit too much?
There's something just kind of off about this whole thing, and certainly anyone who would
choose to do this.
And then on the other side, like, yeah, all that stuff's true and we like it.
And by the way, we should stop sending, you know, colonels to Harvard so that they come
back and screw it up.
You know, that's a powerful couple of forces to be trapped between.
Yeah.
And what's happened since I started the organization in 2018 was the cycle with another
Marine I had served with and a late mentor of both of ours.
And the military at that time was pulling, you know, around national sentiment was like
maybe 70% supporting, you know, broadly the institution of the military.
It was one of the few public institutions that had that broad level of support.
And that's declined pretty significantly.
Because, you know, the military has been pulled into, and I think that this is not
exclusive to any one party, truly, but it's been pulled into, you know, various culture
wars.
In some cases, it's jumped into the culture wars itself.
Although I think that oftentimes it has been brought in by the civilian leadership as
opposed to the military and the brass leadership.
But that has worn on the institution in terms of its level of trust across party lines.
And so you do have a chipping away at it.
The civil military relations piece is something that's always interested me.
I did my honors thesis at UNC Chapel Hill with a fellow named Dr. Richard Cohn, K-O-H-N,
who was H.R. McMaster's disputation advisor way back when.
He was a Air Force, former chief historian of the Air Force.
And he partnered with a professor of political sciences who maybe was on the show, Peter
Feaver from Duke.
Anyways, they have led together some of the landmark studies on the, you know, the civil
military gap.
And however you view the issue, it is certainly a gap that is increasing in American society,
right?
Fewer and fewer Americans have, not only are fewer serving, less than a percent of young
Americans now serve within the military, but fewer have any really connection to military
families and military service.
I've had Peter on the show, Peter Feaver, and he's great and he's a friend.
And I have given him a hard time precisely along the lines that I was just sort of describing
my own attitude towards civil scholarship to you.
And he handled it well, as you might imagine.
Okay, so another one I want to toss you just to see how you respond.
So the book is, you know, a profile, you've got five Republicans, five Democrats, all
of whom With Honor has supported, none of whom I think it's fair to say certainly self-describes
or is broadly perceived as a radical, like no one from their party is far right or far
left.
Even if, you know, you or I could probably go through, I won't put words in your mouth,
I could probably go through a few of their decisions and quibble.
That said, I'll just put it bluntly, right, a book about courage and politicians, another
tough row to hoe.
What's your response to that?
Yeah, it's like the last place that anybody looks to for courage.
And like, let's face it, I mean, you know, it's interesting, Americans, I think, value
courage, but generally also have a view of not seeing much of it, both obviously in our
public life as well as maybe privately, and perhaps this book can help change a bit of
a perspective to this.
Public office, while filled with individuals that are flawed, still is a calling that should
be noble.
In our country, it should be noble.
And it takes a degree of guts, if not courage, to even put your name on the ballot.
I've never done it.
I've just worked with folks that have.
But in this environment, not only as toxic as it is, but also with the level of political
violence that exists these days, it takes some guts to rise to that occasion.
It is especially difficult to actually go against the herd, go against the tribe, do
things that might ostracize you, these moments of moral courage where you might lose friendships,
you might lose your reputation.
God forbid you might lose your career as an elected official.
You might actually not get reelected.
And most people will follow their incentives.
I get that.
What this book tries to do is say there are moments when some of these individuals, none
of whom are perfect, everyone of whom you can find flaws with, have taken some tougher
positions at moments, when it actually costs them, in order to do what they see as the
right thing to advance a common good that is not necessarily aligned with their self-interest.
That's a real moment.
They're pretty damn rare.
Will we be better off if we recognize those and in some ways celebrate or at least seek
more of it in our public leadership?
I think so.
I am pretty realistic that I don't, at least at this stage now after eight years of this,
I don't think this alone is going to be the solution.
I do believe strongly in it.
It's why I give it my best hours.
I'm giving all the author proceeds from the book to the organization.
I mean, I truly believe in this.
And it's heartening to see a group of individuals that are still able to have adult conversations
and trust each other and try to work in this difficult environment.
But I'm not suggesting that this is a silver bullet or that these individuals always meet
the moment.
They don't, especially in the political orbit.
You are constantly tested and are making trade-offs.
Before we go, let's find a moment or two here in which you've profiled where someone
does meet the moment, as you put it.
And one thing as a character, I think it's all or certainly almost all of the folks you
profile join the military after 9-11, which is an interesting fact and sort of speaks
to the youth, relative youth of the group.
Pick someone, pick a couple who you want to highlight for listeners and how their military
service in a meaningful way, not in a, you know, any veteran running for office can slap
up an ad with a picture of them in uniform.
But you and I, Rye, we're old cynics and we know that the military is a big organization.
It's full of good people and bad people, usually between the 40-yard lines on both fronts.
And, you know, the fact that you wore your uniform means you served your country.
But somebody whose story that really, you know, their service resonates with their political
career in a way that really is meaningful.
Well, since we're both Marines, I'll pick two Marines.
And the first is Gerard Golden.
The book ends on Gerard Golden.
And Gerard Golden's story is a little bit of a warning, actually, about what kind of
where we are as a country, but also, I think, a point of optimism with regard to his character.
So he was a Marine infantryman, enlisted infantryman.
The chapter with Gerard opens when he was responding on a QRF in Afghanistan and unfortunately
had two of his fellow Marines killed in action.
He was about 20 years old at the time.
Gerard is a member of Congress from rural Maine.
And there was a really tragic shooting incident that occurred in rural Maine at Lewiston.
It was not far from his home.
And the laws at the time were what we call yellow flag laws.
And essentially, the shooter, unfortunately, was somebody that was serving in the National
Guard and had a history of mental illness, but for a variety of kind of bureaucratic
reasons wasn't able to be apprehended.
At any rate, he was on the loose for quite some, for hours.
And Gerard's home's about three minutes away.
And the episode for him made him rethink his position on an issue that was
particularly important one in his district.
And so he changed his position on assault weapons bans.
And that is an issue for him that almost cost the next election he won by like 0.3%.
But he did that without calling anybody, as he recalls it.
He just said, this is a personal issue now for me.
I went up and visited him and spent a little bit of time with his family.
He has decided not to run for re-election, in part given that he's kind of done his part,
his time.
He's now coming up on the eight-year mark.
He's done his service.
He's going to go on and in his 40s have another career, but also in part just due to the level,
frankly, of threats and the grind of the job as a parent with a young kid.
Very honorable person.
And the book concludes on Gerard.
Another Marine that's in the book is Senator Todd Young.
He's actually one of the few vets that came in prior to 9-11.
And he's described by one journalist as the senator,
one of the more impactful senators that you've never heard of.
And what Young really focuses on is doing the work and building the relationships
across the party lines.
One of his signature bills was the Chips and Science Act.
It took some heat for partnering with Democrats on that.
He's a Republican.
In fact, the lead on that side was the Democratic leader, Chuck Schumer.
So you can imagine the level of comfort being, as you know, working in that building,
being a Republican senator that's got to partner with the Democratic lead on a major bill.
But they worked it for a number of years and ended up getting it through.
And I think it's an important piece of legislation for our overall national security.
Each of those episodes, we go into more depth in terms of what actually happened
and some of the trade-offs and how they fought through the examples.
But I think both at their core are motivated by the pursuit of public service as something
that is benefiting society and the country more so than necessarily your own narrow self-interest.
Rye Barcott, the book is called Courage Can Save Us,
10 Extraordinary Americans in the Fight for Our Future.
I really appreciate your time.
Thanks for coming on School of War, Rye.
Thanks, Aaron.
Great to be here.