Tour the Historic (and haunted?) Vaile Mansion

Timeless Architecture
14 followers
1 Video View·Jun 19, 2026
The Vaile Mansion in Independence, Missouri, is a gem of an historic site with an impressive history. In this video tour, our volunteers take you through the home's most interesting rooms, pointing out details along the way and telling the story of Harvey and Sophia Vaile.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video provides a guided tour of the Vail Mansion in Independence, a restored 1881 Victorian estate. It explores the opulent lifestyle and personal tragedies of Harvey and Sevilla Vail, the home's advanced 19th-century architectural innovations, and its transition from a private residence to a nursing home and eventually a city-owned museum and botanical site.
Good morning and welcome to the Vail Mansion. What you're going to see today is as close as
we could restore it back to what it was when the Vails moved in in 1881. Harvey Vail and his wife
Sevilla originally were from back east, New York in fact, and Mr. Vail made most of his money because
he had the mail contract with the U.S. government. He delivered mail to all points west of St. Louis,
including the Santa Fe Trail, the Oregon, and the California Trail. He didn't just make his money
that way. He was a lawyer, had taught school, had been a newspaper man. He also invested in cattle
ranches in Oklahoma and Texas. When they moved in in 1881, Mrs. Vail was 47 years old. Mr. Vail was
four years older than her. Tragically, she died just 18 months later of an overdose of laudanum.
Mr. Vail never remarried. He remained a widower until his own death in 1894. There was quite a
fight over his will. However, by 1910, the mansion was a nursing home and remained a nursing home for
71 years. The very last owner of the house, Mrs. Mildred DeWitt, who unfortunately never got to
live in the mansion, she gave the house to the city of Independence when she died in 1983.
The restorations were paid for by government grants in the late 1980s and the 1990s. However,
that all dried up by the turn of the century. And so now one of our main goals is the Vail
Victorian Society. We take care, we maintain the inside of the house, and the city of Independence
takes care of the structural integrity. So let's go on in and take a look. We're going to start
our tour in the ladies' parlor. This is the largest room of 31 rooms in this mansion. I want
to point out to you the tête-à-tête. This is a pink velvet tête-à-tête. It was very important
for us to get this because after Mr. Vail's death, the discussion over his will, they had a big
auction in 1901 and items were sold. Probate Court had inventoried the house room by room,
and we have a copy of that. And there actually was a pink velvet tête-à-tête listed
in the inventory. Now in Victorian times, young separate men and women were never allowed to sit
on the same piece of furniture. Only married couples. So leave it to the French to invent
a chair for lovers. And so this became very popular. Above the tête-à-tête, you see the
chandelier. This is one of three original chandeliers that we have in the mansion. It is
a twin to the one that you will see later in the gentlemen's parlor. The story goes that Mr. Vail
was able to secure these two chandeliers from the White House. They had been intended for the White
House and because of some flaw, which we've never been privy to, they were refused. And so he bought
them while he was in Washington, D.C. Originally, these were gasoliers. Mr. Vail actually had his
own gas well. In fact, the gas well was used up until the 1940s, after it had even become a
nursing home. Everything was converted to electricity sometime between 1920 and 1930.
The drapes. Our restoration committee worked very hard to make sure that these were authentic
and the very top of the line, because of course the Vails would have had some. I particularly
want to mention the tiebacks. They are made of paisley. Now paisley was something that was
reserved actually almost just for royalty when it was first discovered. Paisley had been imported
from Kashmir, but actually the design goes clear back to the Persian days. Paisley Scotland had
some smart young person figured out a loom that could weave the paisley design. And after that,
it became more affordable. Not cheap, but more affordable. And so that was what most wealthy
people in the 1880s and 1890s, that's what everybody wanted to have.
Now we're going to move and look at our white Carrara marble fireplace.
There are nine marble fireplaces in the house. They're all original
and they're all different. None of them are exactly the same. This is the white Carrara
Italian marble and it's probably the most detailed of all of the fireplaces in the house.
The panel that you see underneath the mantle and then the pillars are made of pink onyx.
And supposedly when there was a fire going, they would glow with the pink glow. There are three
different wine motifs that are carved into the marble here. And particularly I want to call your
attention to on either of the corners, you will see two little hands. Each hand is holding a
champagne glass and they are toasting each other. And just in case you don't know for sure, there's
a bubble. They are drinking champagne. And you're going to see the rest of the fireplaces
and they're all different. I think you'll enjoy it. Welcome to the gentleman's parlor,
also the green parlor. This was the parlor where the men would gather when the women,
and the women would go to the pink parlor. They could shut these pocket doors and smoke and talk
politics, which you did not do in front of the ladies. The fireplace here is original.
There's nine of them in the house. This one is chocolate model marble from either Georgia or
Missouri. It has onyx pillars. It's a coal fireplace, not a wood fireplace, which means
the box is smaller and has a metal plate in front of it. Above it, you see a picture of by painting
by William Holbrook Baird, who was famous in the 1800s for pictures of animals acting like people.
This one's called the Dancing Bears. Painted this supposedly something to do with Wall Street,
but it inspired a song called If You Go Down the Woods Today, You Better Not Go Alone. It's lovely
down the woods today, but safer to stay at home. The walls here in this parlor are green. During
the nursing home years, they papered the walls. Well, they took the paper down and found the
original walls were painted. And this green was the original color. And this was supposedly Mr.
Vale's favorite color. The shutters on the windows are original. They're made of cypress,
which their cypress is resistant to rot and insects. The nursing home took the shutters
down and put them up in the attic. And when the city went to replace them, they found that the
windows aren't all the same size. And so it become a big puzzle what shutters went where. There's
still some windows in the house. They couldn't figure out what shutters went there. So there's
some up in the attic. The mirrors on the wall here were made in France in the late 1700s,
and they came up the Mississippi and Missouri River to a mansion in Lexington, Missouri.
They are made by a process called diamond dustback. It's nothing to do with diamond dust.
It's because it looks like that on the backside. But it's silver, and silver doesn't spread evenly,
so they mixed it with mercury to make it spread. That's highly toxic, so you don't do that anymore.
But after all these years, they're still very clear. We have two other mirrors in
the house made by the same process. If you put an object up against the mirror,
there'll be a gap between the reflection and the object, and that's how you can tell that
it's diamond dustback. Imagine being invited to dinner in this beautiful mansion and then
entertained in this room afterwards. This is the music room of the Victorian Vale Mansion.
In this room, we have a beautiful square grand chicory piano. These were only made during the
Victorian era, from about 1860 to 1901, and then they were discontinued after that time.
They were beautiful instruments to look at, but terrible instruments to play because of the
mechanism inside. They had to be tuned quite often. In this room, we also have a dulcimer.
We have a violin, and we have a beautiful Victorian music box. Now, young Victorian
ladies were not taught so much science, math, or history. That wasn't considered important,
but what was important was that they learned etiquette and the fine arts because that would
turn them into a refined lady, a suitable wife, and worthy of a home such as this.
This beautiful Brazilian rosewood chicory square grand piano was donated to the Vale
Mansion in 2019 by a very generous benefactor. Now, the chicory was sort of the precursor to
the Steinway Grand. There was a concert at Carnegie Hall in New York, and Mr. Steinway
happened to be there, and he was working on this new design for a piano. He didn't come to hear
the opera singer. He came to see the piano that was on stage, which was a chicory grand at that
time, and it's said that after the concert was over, he nearly rushed the stage and examined
every square inch of the chicory, and it is today what we know as the Steinway Grand.
In this corner of the music room, we have this wonderful pump organ. It is German in origin.
It's an 1883 Etsy Grand Salon pump organ, so you have to play it while pumping it. The bellows are
in wonderful condition. It has been completely restored, and it sounds just wonderful and airy
during our Victorian funeral customs event that we hold each October. This is a lovely Victorian
music box. We have a lot of discs for this music box. I'll point one out here. They're flat on the
top, but if you turn them over, they're quite sharp because the mechanism in this actually
plucks them like a music box would. So to entertain your guests, you would simply wind it,
and then you would turn it on. Now that, of course, is the beautiful Blue Danube Waltz.
As I said, we have quite a large collection. There is one disc in here called
I Don't Want No Chief Man, which I think is very apropos for this home.
I'd like to point out the beautiful chandelier here in the music room of the Vale.
It is original to the home, which means it's been here since 1881. It was originally a gasolier
because there was a natural gas well on the property. You can still see the original keys,
which adjusted the amount of gas coming to the fixture. Over here, we have this beautiful blue
gray Vermont marble fireplace. It does have the grape cluster in the corner because six of the
fireplaces in this house have some reference to wine on them. Above the fireplace is a portrait
of a young girl. We know from the signature that he was a traveling artist in the area.
Now, these traveling artists would spend the long, cold winters in their studios,
and they would paint just bodies. And when the weather broke, he would load all these canvases
that he had painted all winter long into his cart, and he would hit up all the affluent
neighborhoods in the area. And he would ask mom or dad, would you like your child's portrait
painted? By just having to paint on the head at each location, the artist could save time and
move from home to home, make more money so that he could feed himself during the winter.
Welcome to the dining room of the Vale Mansion. This is the first place in the mansion where you
see the transition of wood in the mansion. There are many different varieties of wood represented
in the home. In actuality, they are all soft pine, which are faux painted. Now, the Vales were very
proud of that fact because, after all, who else could afford to hire the artisans to come over
from Europe and faux paint the wood in your home? Now, in the first four parlors, you see the very
dark walnut. In this room, we see light feathered maple. The dinner parties that were held here were
no doubt very elegant. And the Vales had no children, so they didn't need a huge dining room.
Mostly, they entertained dignitaries because this home was a stopover for representatives and
ambassadors and senators who were traveling to Washington, D.C. or traveling back home from
Washington, D.C. The ceiling in this beautiful room is an actual representation of the estate.
To this end were the beautiful greenhouses that the Vales were quite famous for. We have the
lake, which had a little island in the middle that the Vales could actually row out to for a
picnic. Mr. Vale's love of wine is echoed in this ceiling. He has the grape leaves and the grape
bunches, but also the Latin phrase, in vino veritas, which translates to, in wine there is truth.
He also gave homage to the natural springs that are on the property with the phrase, in aqua sanitas,
which means, in water there is health. It was Mrs. Vale's wildest desire to be a member of high
society when she moved to independence. Unfortunately, that did not happen for her.
In the 18 short months that she lived in this home before her death, records show that she was never
invited to the other ladies' homes and never had the other ladies come into her home. There were a
very staunch abolitionists living in a slave state, and the second reason was probably that
they were very wealthy, and they were building the largest home in the county,
and people may have been a little jealous of their money.
This is the grand hall of the mansion. For anyone visiting in the Vales time, or even today,
this is the first impression you would receive when you walked through the front doors of the house.
Now, as you've heard, all of the wood in the house is white pine that has been painted to look like
other wood grains. The one exception is this staircase. The staircase is actually made out
of black walnut, which is a much stronger wood and much more appropriate for a staircase. Now,
we're going to move down the hall and talk about the various owners of the mansion over the years.
We'll start with the Vales, the people who built the mansion. Here we have Sophia Vale. The
paintings are contemporary, but we think that the photo it's based on was taken by Matthew Brady,
who was a famous Civil War photographer. He had studios in Washington, D.C. and New York City.
We also have Mr. Vale over here, Harvey. They look like they have a tremendous age difference
between them, but in actuality, they were only four years apart. When they got married, she was
27 and he was 31. We just don't have a photo of him from that time. So he's about 62 in this image.
It was painted by a local painter who included some of the details we talked about in the ladies
parlor, the fireplace, the clock on the mantle. So she included those details in the background.
This is Carrie Mae Carroll. She actually married one of the relatives of Mr. Vale, and she was in
charge of the house when it was run as a sanitarium and nursing home, which it was for the majority of
its existence. She actually lived on the property for almost 50 years. When Carrie Mae Carroll passed
away, she and her husband hadn't had any children either. So again, the house was left without anyone
to inherit it. In 1962, there was threat that it might be demolished. This couple, Roger and Mary
Mildred DeWitt, saved the house from demolition. They bought it at an auction for $60,000 cash.
Their plan was to let it continue to be a nursing home while they restored the exterior of the house.
Then when they were finished with the exterior, they would move in. It would cease being a nursing
home and they could work on restoring the interior. However, Mr. DeWitt died unexpectedly, so they were
never able to do that, and Mrs. DeWitt never lived on the premises either. They did do extensive
restoration to the outside of the house, including the slate roof and chimney caps, and shortly
before her death in 1983, Mrs. DeWitt willed the house to the City of Independence.
This room was originally Sophia's sitting room. It was designed so she could sit at the windows,
view the lake that was at the north end of the property, while enjoying a nice warm glow from
the Carrara marble fireplace. We know for certain that this was Sophia's by looking at the ceiling.
Now, this is one of the most detailed ceilings in the mansion, and it has some very distinctive
Victorian symbolism in it. It has peacock feathers, which symbolized loyalty and longevity. It had the
cherubs, which were traditional for joy and love. The interesting thing about these three cherubs
is one of them was painted over shortly after Harvey Vale passed away. It was not discovered
again until there was some unfortunate water damage to the ceiling, and when that damage was
repaired, the third cherub was found without wings, which is very unusual for a Victorian cherub.
These wardrobes had a beautiful security function in that behind the side trim, if you open it up,
you could unlock all the drawers or lock them to make it a more secure place to store your
belongings. Some of these today that we find are lined with felt and were used to store the family
silver. Now, since we're talking about dressers and clothing, I'm going to bring you over here
to the closet. Now, the Vales were very innovative in their housing design. This is a summer winter
closet, and these were put in the upstairs rooms rather than using the traditional freestanding
wardrobes. What makes it a summer winter closet is it has two levels, so when the seasons changed,
you could switch the clothes out and put the clothes that were more readily needed for this
season in the bottom where they were more easily accessible. One of the things I love about this
closet is the original hooks are actually still in it, and you can actually see the little
intricate detail of the acorns that were cast into the hooks when they were originally made.
We are now in actually the most technologically advanced room in the house. To give you a little
bit of history, the Vales moved into this house in 1881. Public works departments didn't exist.
In fact, they didn't even have a water department anywhere in this region until 1884, and they
didn't have sewage systems in the city until 1895. So this house that was designed in 1870
was designed with not one but two full and sweet bathrooms on the second floor, which was a very
big deal for several reasons. One was they had to get water here. So the Vales were very lucky
on this count. The Vale estate had multiple springs on the land. To the south of the house,
there was a spring that used a windmill to carry the water into a water tower that was two stories
tall and inside the house. It was two stories tall to provide the water pressure needed
to take a bath on the second floor without carrying water up and down the stairs.
The second issue you have is, where does it go when it moves the bathroom? We believe they built
a septic system on the property, and that would make it one of the first in the United States.
Now once you have the water and the septic taken care of, you need the fixtures.
Here we have a beautiful copper bath, which was opulent and we know made to be shown off for
several reasons. One, if you had a copper bath such as this with the seams, you had to have
servants to clean it and keep it from turning that green patina and protect it and dry it from the
Missouri weather. Also, this bathroom has two doors, the one that you see here and the one
you're looking through. That meant from the hallway guests could view this beautiful bathroom.
So at a time when 99.9% of people in this part of the country were bathing in a wash basin
on the kitchen floor with water carried in, the Vales were bathing in copper tubs
with hot and cold running water out of silver taps, which is kind of amazing for the time.
The other amazing thing in this bathroom is the toilet. I know it doesn't sound fancy and most
people don't want to talk about toilets, but it really was a sanitary marvel at the time.
The particular toilet that's in this house is called the National. It was created in 1879,
which was two years before the Vales moved into the house. So if it was created two years before,
why is it amazing that it's in this house? Well, the construction of the house started in 1871,
and for this particular toilet you needed to have water running to it,
waste running away from it, and a vent. You needed a vent because at the time there was the risk of
gas building up and your toilet exploding, and theirs did not. This entire bathroom was actually
restored in the 90s, and just like the trim in the rest of the house, you can see the wainscoting in
this room is stained two different colors to make it look like it was two different woods.
It was a lot of work, and we're very grateful to the folks that did it for us.
Now as you can see, this house was a marvel of the intellect. Not only was it exquisitely
beautiful, but it was one of the most technologically advanced homes in the whole country.
Welcome to the master bedroom. Like the gentleman's parlor downstairs, the room is green,
which was Colonel Vales' favorite color. Once again, we have a white Carrara marble fireplace,
and I'd like to point out the bed on the other side of the room. Our Victorian bed is an actual
full-size double bed. It looks small, but that's because of the headboard, although I'm sure the
bed might have been small for Colonel Vale, who I understand stood over six feet tall.
Above the bed, we have a painting named Innocence Awakening. She was originally naked from the waist
up in 1881. A newspaper reporter came out and reported on this magnificent home in Northern
Independence, and he mentioned the naked picture of Mrs. Vale on the ceiling in the master bedroom.
That is not Sophie. It nearly ruined her reputation with the local society. She
insisted that Harvey get the original Italian artist back to cover her up. Well, she's almost
covered. Sadly, Sophie suffered from stomach cancer. She was also extremely worried about
Harvey, who in 1882 was accused of stealing money from the government on his many mail routes. They
were called back to Washington D.C. and put on trial for mail fraud. Sophie was left alone,
and while Harvey was in D.C. on Valentine's Day in 1883, she took six milligrams of laudanum.
That was a mixture of morphine, opium, and alcohol, and she died the next morning. We do not
know if it was an accidental overdose of her prescribed medicine, or if she was actually
committing suicide because she was afraid of being left alone in the house. Harvey was notified,
and was allowed to come home for one month for the funeral, but he had to go back to D.C. He was
still on trial, and it wasn't until April or May that he was found innocent of all charges,
and allowed to come home. But he came home to an empty house. He never remarried, and 11 years
later, on June 4th, 1894, Harvey passed away in this room after suffering a series of strokes.
Thank you for visiting the Master Bedroom, and enjoy the rest of your tour.
This room is pretty unique. It was called Nature's Bower back in the Vales Day. It has stars on a
blue ceiling still. It would have had a green carpeting at their time to represent heaven and
earth, and supposedly was Mr. Vale's favorite room in the mansion. As you've heard already, most of the
mansion is painted in faux bois, the fake woodgrain painting technique. In this room, they take that
to a new level. Mr. Vale actually decided, while having the woodgrain painted, that his artist
should paint little faces in the room. We have animals as well as people represented. At one
point, someone actually counted the number of faces, and it was over 350 faces that were depicted
in this room. The story goes that Mr. Vale would invite his business associates to come up here,
and they would sit in this room, and they'd have a glass of wine, maybe a couple glasses of wine,
and then his hope was that the associate would start to see things in the woodwork. We also have,
in addition to all of the faces, the artist painted his signature above the window, and it's
dated with the date of October 12, 1881, which is right around the time that Harvey and Sophia moved
into the mansion. Welcome to the library. This is the room in which Colonel Vale conducted his
business, as well as attended to the affairs of his estate. This room, like others throughout the mansion,
has the beautifully hand-painted woodgraining appearing here in silver oak and bird's-eye maple.
On either side of the east-facing window are two original bookshelves reaching from the floor
to the ceiling. We know from auction records that the Vales had an extensive library, ranging
from classic literature to history and even to cattle breeding. On the opposite side of the room
sits the fireplace. This fireplace features American chocolate malted marble. To the left of
the fireplace, we have a wall niche, which was quite popular in Victorian homes. In the Vales' day,
we believe this particular one to have housed the Venus de Milo, because the Vales were such lovers
of art. This room is among my favorites, because of the celebration of education, knowledge, and Mr.
Bell's love of winemaking, as seen in the leaf motifs around the room, including the fireplace,
as well as the ceiling. The hand-painted leaves on the ceiling create a border around the room,
joining together in the south bay window, in an education-inspired motif. Here we find
an artist's palette and brushes in celebration of art, a book in celebration of knowledge,
a globe in celebration of travel, a triangle in celebration of architecture, and a harp
representing music. Hi, welcome to the Vale landscape. I want to share with you the history
and the present day jobs that we are working on at the Vale. Originally, the house sat on over
600 acres, and of that 600 acres, 10 of the acres were made into formal gardens. There was a
greenhouse. Beyond that was the spring house, which fed a lot of the fountains that were on the grounds.
There was a pond that was several acres in size on the north side of the house, and to that pond,
there was a double row of sugar maples, so that you could be in the shade as you went to the lake.
Around the lake, there was a boathouse, and there was a gazebo. Middle of the lake was a small
island that had a weeping willow on it, and that was used through Mr. Vale's life, and also
the first several years of the sanitarium. There were barns, there was a pergola,
there was also a couple cottages for some of the hired help that worked on the grounds.
Currently, the house is maintained by volunteers, and we also have volunteers that maintain the
grounds. Several years ago, we decided to re-reinstall the pond that we thought was a
reflecting pool, but turned out to be a fountain, and for two weeks, we had the help of the Kansas
City Archaeological Society. The very last day, we got to the very bottom and found that there was
an overflow and a fill, and we were able to identify a tiered fountain that was in place
rather than just the reflecting pool. We replanted the double row of sugar maples that would have
gone down to the lake. We also have a state champion smoke tree. We have three other trees
that are Kansas City area champions. We are fortunate to have a few of the original sugar
maples from the double row, but other than that, we have just tried to bring back plants that would
have been here during his lifetime, using plants that were popular in the 1880s, 1890s. We are
always looking for experienced help, if possible, so come visit the Vale, enjoy the grounds, and thank you.
It's time to say goodbye. We hope you've enjoyed this tour. You've seen most of what we have in
the house, but if you come in person, there's a lot of more details that you'll be able to see.
We are open at various hours, and you can always check our website.
The days that we are open, we're open from 10 to 4 on weekdays and Saturday, and then we're open
1 to 4 on Sundays. Also want to mention that at Christmas time, we open the day after Thanksgiving,
and we are just, it's beautiful, so you need to come and see that. I'm glad you've joined us today,
and I'll say goodbye. You want to be singing now? Yeah. If you go down in the woods today,
you better not go alone. It's lovely down in the woods today, but safer to stay at home.
For every bear that ever there was, will gather there for certain, because today's the day the
teddy bears have their picnic. Picnic time for teddy bears, the little teddy bears are having
a lovely time today. Watch them, catch them unaware, and see them picnic on their holiday.
See them gaily get about. They love to play and shout. They're having a lovely time.
At six o'clock, their mommies and daddies will take them home to bed, because they're tired little
teddy bears.
